← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/9494/2020allowed

Virender Kumar v. Additional Registrar Cooperative Societies (Credit), Haryana And ORS

2024-05-07Mr. Justice Jasgurpreet Singh Puri22 pages

           



 !"#$!%&'&"()*+* ,&-!($!-./0- ***! & &"(!- ,!-'/'

$$& &"(1!2&' --3""4!- &5!6"%&! &!' -!$& 3 -7(($" 8!-' ***!'4"($!( '

 )  9 : *666 

   

      

    !" 

 #$$ 

 % &'

(((( 66 3* -1 ;;

) 

*    +*   % &  &-. &-'

/

+

0+*   % &  &-.  &-'1 *## , 

&(%'!

.

)  *   &&2-&&3  4  5          .& &7.9:

 .3; *  

 % .,+*+*1 % & <'

6 

  7= 7.

.9=.

     1+

+     +          && .& .9='  + + * 

        +       *   4   $

% .279-.99>$?% .&>'= &7.3 /   *+   *  @.=A

% /1  -&<   )                    +  B  +    

      $      1   &'

7'

.932  "    .2 .933        +  *

  1 "  +*  4 $

 * + &.

7> .939 #  *1

C7= 7.

.9=.     &-& +*DD+ * +

   + 

**  .'777- C*     + ++ +  +&3 ..

.9=.

"    

  +

*



 &3 .7 .9='

"      

 6 * 6       #  

  ) 

   

   6       +         && .& .9='

 )   

; '7 .& .9='

     

  

  6

++E6 C



 )E6 C

     :

  >;&& 7'

.9=8 C*  6     + +.7 .& .9=8   

+         

   +'.

.9=>   +

    +

#         *    4  4     78 .99&  )   1  

 # +

)

4  

 &.

7.

.99> )

 # + * 

4  *  $

 $ % .279 .99>* 4 

) $ * * 4   4   .7'

..

&7.2 5*

  

   

  +

*  6  +      4         4    

   # + "F*$

+4 # +

* 

4 &.

7.

.99>+ *1        +  1

  + 6

  ,+ )4 $ 

*+*   + +

     1

    *       ,+

'

)  1# + * 4  $ * $ ?*  "F*$

+ 4       +       '    7'

&7.3  "F* $

+4 *  *

"4 , , 1   +6  +  



     

 

)  6       + 6

5

  6  E6 C

    *

  46 

72 &7.3  +  .8 )   

% '7..& &7.=* 4 4    4    6      +     .2*  

*    + 

 5  .9=8 +    

   

   1 1++  #+   *  1

 +

+ >

)  * 4    4 &9 ..

&7.= )   



 

   ) 

1

*  4 $:4;"   .3 .& &7.9 

+*16

 ) 4 $**   *   +  

   +

   *  1   6  +*  5

* 1   1  6              .3 7= &7.3     

+     7> &7.372 &7.3 5 1



    +  ,+ *   ,  *+*   $

4++ 5+

  * + *  )  6   *

  1 + )        *  4   $  "       ,      +      +*1 +6      ) + * 4  )  1   +   +

* 4  4 ++ .& &7.9*   

=

      

   7& .7 &7&&  

 )?   )       + +  &' 

6/>0&''&"(' >7  1!-(!$%"/('!1#"-4! & &"(!- 

           

    *    

 *+       + .932 +8=  "    1 +     

    +

  .9='           

    +          " 

&7&&  *   1*

 + *  

=

?      *+             7= 7.

.9=.   1  6 +*  +*          1 

                  +         *               1          #   " *+ ++ ++4   ++*1E6 C

       #  +  .9=.* 8' *

   1     * *     1  *     

*      # +  8'  +   

*   +

" *++ +  +

+      +  *   

? 

 *+

+ * 4 $  .3       # + +*1E6 C

 " *+ 

*   4 $ *  

+ .& &7.9 *+

  *  + *   1 

++6 1  *     " *+

   * 4 * 

 4 $,+ +*1+ * 4  +*  1   



6 *  + &7.9 1 

 6 ++7& .7 &7&&   " *+   * 

?

    4   $    .& &7.9     + +  +   

.7

? 

 *+  6 *   6 *    

   *

+

  * 

+  + +  + 6   +   * *  

6 *   " *+     ?  * *    

  &= 7& &7.&  + + .9=.           +    &= 7& &7.&        

  *  *      "   *+ + +  *  $  +  *  +*  *?  " *+  * *     

     * 

 + 

+* *   1  +  * *  *  +*

  4  +* *      #    1 " *+   F 1F

      " # +

"F*$

+4   

          !     +  1         F 1F



" 

  *      *#, 

"F*$

+4   # +  ,   +  *     *  

   D*1  *  

  D    F 1F 



6/>0&''&"(' >7  1!-(!$%"/('!1#"--!'4"($!(  (@) ..

 #$$ 

*     1 *+ *  4 $  

,      +* " *+ : ;+*DD+   .'777-  .9=.   +  +

+ +*1*   +          ,  +             

" *+ 

 *  + +  *  (17'&'"#'/>0&''&"(') .&

5   

.'

 

      1  + 

*  5 *    +    

+ .9=.  +* ++ *16  )     

     

*+** 4   *1   #    +

 

    5 

    *1   +  *   +*1 6 

 &7&& )4    *#1*   1 *  # % + *#**  

  1+*

.8

4++   

 *    +7= 7.

.9=.   +87

 "*1+     #  )

 +      +   +        *      

+*DD+ *  .'777- +++ *1*  -4  / ++ +*1+*    *



   &3 .7 .9='          +     

    #  )  + +*1* 4   4 $ 

 .7'

..

&7.2 )      # +     

  

  

    

   

    

   

 

  

       

  

  !       "

   





!  

 #

     

  

   $"

 % &    

   

     

   

  

 

       

  

 

  %   

   

'   

         %"

!  

'  "



    !

 

 !

 

  !     

      

%  

 !

 

    

    (  

   



!  

    



  

!  ) &

  

  "  #  $%   &!

' !

 ()  *+

,   $   !

 &! - $  .   # , /$")  &0 0 01!

%"

 ) &   * * *+



   , 

   



 

       

    



        

   

    



 

 



  

  %  

 

 ! 

  





 

  

     



    

 

  #





   !         



 

 

 

.>

    ** * 4    *  

     +     6  +* "F*$

+ 4  )# +*  1* $?* $

+ 4   7'

&7.3 $ 

  

 

   

 "



   



    #

    

    

   

 -    





  

  

         

 

    .   "

 

  

  







          /    

 

    !         "

  !   

     !    

   !  "

    !

 

  

 

$  ! 

 "

 / 0  1





 1

  "

  "





 2 .2

)  +   +++*1* 4  $  .3    #  *  1 )      .3    

; 2 $    33))  ),4

,))) $5   6    5) ,)33  /$  )$ 3 3 6/4   3  4  $) , $ 3

7  $33))   3  4 6   

/5  63/  7  $33))  3 "







*4 56 5*7   )

  &

"









*7 56 5*7 





   



5+ 5 5*7 

 



54 57 5*7     % 

 !

        



  

   

  

!      

 !



!  '  

 3  "

  

        8 ! 









 

 !  



   %  

  

   

 

 

  





3  

    

 !

  .  

 

        "





  

   





  

9      !   %"

      

    ! 

  

 %



  



+ 5: 5* 



 



* 5; 5* %  !  

  

  !      

!  2

3   33)

.3

    **

 4 $*   *   +  

   +   + *    1               6   +  *  

 5

*  1   1   6  

   ++ *1E6 C

 5   4  $1    1  )  1 * 

+*    + , +*1

  

.=

  .& &7.9   *   1     .'

7'

&7&7 )+ * 4   +*  1  6 

   *  4 $  .3 "  1 

+1 6

5 + 1      7& .7 &7&&  

.9

)   + +*1  + + 87   7= 7.

.9=.

 +*DD+ *  .'777-       + ,*  *  1  *   4  $    -

+  1  * 6  $  

6 *  *  +*   ) 

+ ,  *   +87



 + * +          

 #     # 

4 $1   1  

&7

5   11  

4   *   1       #   + 6 6 #   G+   &7&&6 + + 

)4  *+++ #  1 1#    

 # ++*1 6

 1     #     *              5           1

&.

)*#*   #   #  + #  ) 

  *  

+ )   #    *  * $ 

++ 6  #   +

 * + 6  ) +     #  1  ) 3   *+ 

= &&

5    +     ).& &7.9:

  .3;,* +*+*1*

      

6 *  

&'

$            

+      

  *  *    

  &= 7& &7.& )  1  *    @2A  +

&8

           + ++ $  + 1 *   )    1        1 

      ++1  * +*+   +        *  6     +         )  + *    + +

&>

$    

     * 

  +*1   6   1 +

#  1   + 

*   6 

 *  +&& .& .9='      

  &= 7& &7.& ) +  *   + +

"*  + /   +  *    

   * 4 

 .+*#  ?  *   +  



1     '''8 # +

$

+4 8 5 

3     ::

%

 

!  

 

        

    

    "

 

           



 

 





    %

"

  "

! 

 

  

   "

 

 



 

    '





    '"

 



   %   "

   '  !



  

  

        

 

! "

 

 !

 

 

3      !

 

 '!  



3       

%   



  '  !

   







 "

  

 !

 

 

  !  % "

   "

    

 ! 

 



  ! 





 !



 

 

  

  

       



 

-! 

 ! 

  "





 !  

 ! < =   



         

 

    

 



?  '  

 '   

 

:;

$    

   

!      "

    



 8 

 "

  "

   

"



"

      

   

 

  

   

 

% "

  

"

 

  



 



!

  

  

  



  % 



   "

     

 !     8   

  "

"



 !  



 

! 

 







       !  

!  

!    



 

   

!  "

  

  

 

  

!

    

!  ) &     -  !

 

   % !

  

    # "

"



 !  

 ! '

&2

)   F 1F

  

  # + "F*$

+4    

    

3

#  $ %   9  

&!!& &! .    #  $ %  

&0 &1 ''0*   *     +#**   ** 4 *  4 $*      #  6 

+    *    1    F 1F

   )  +   * +

 *++* 6  + 

&3

4*1   + 

+87  *  

 .9=.

+    4  +  ) *1 6  +1

*

 $

+4 " 4 +   

 4  $*  +E6 C

 + 87  )  

+ +  * 

/+ .9=.

  ,  + *

   * 4 $

  .

)    +  + )4 1# D 

 +   +   +  +87  

6   + + + *   * D

 +

   )   1

 +  * 4 $*  4   4   .$ *  +   ++ + 1     #  ) *1

     #  +

   ++ +++*1 + 87 +     1 5,+    * *  

  1  +87 

 + +   5    + *  

 E +

+

 *  * C 

 1*+ 

&=

4   "F*$

+4  :)))   4/ 53) 3   

&! 0 ' 010     

&. 4  5 )   *1 *  1     &.*  % 

      '77      4     5      *   %  &.* 6  *  * 6  +   

&9

5    +4 +    + ,+  

  1  .777777- :)?;

) *    6     

 + +

)4     6  + * 4   +   ,+  *   +

 * *+ 

  + *  5 

   1*     

     + + # + "F* $

+4  "    $;  ) &!! & 1& * +    

'&&&2 4  5 *

/ +   &. ,  4  

*#     

,* 

* $   

*   / + D 5 

*4 *

   D* 4     ,    4    1 5  

 *     +    # +    + 

    

++     * +   * + / +   D* 

*$  *  '7

5       ++*  

'.

)  1**  , * 



:;* 

   

   , * +  

+

:;

"(%1/'&"() '&

)                   :;

).& &7.9:

 .3;, * +*+*16    % &&

:;

)  *

*   

 

  &= 7& &7.&   1            +                    @  2A    +  % &'&8 :;

)  *

                      1     6 *  +&& .& .9='&= 7& &7.&   % &>&2 :;

 )    1           

 .777777-  :)  ?;             

6     % &9'.

? + 

 .'

&7&8

66 *+*   .  0 1-  H-% 0 *  H-%