High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-A/632/2024disposed of

Harvinder Singh v. Daljit Singh

2025-07-22Mrs. Justice Manjari Nehru Kaul4 pages

!"#$!%&'&"()*+, ($- . /0&($!/1&(23 4444455+&%( 655!++( 7!/'*'

+8& 1&(23 44444!'5"($!( ' ) ) ) ) 9:141;:

9:141;:

9:141;: /!'!( ) /44141&$3*-$0"% ! #"/ 3!55+&%( 4 ;:-4 ;:-4 ;:-4 ;:-4 4 3!55+&%( 3'#&+!$ 3!5/!'!( 55+&% &"('!!<&(22/( "#+!0! "55!+2&(' 3!8*$2=!( "#%>*& +5''!$&(%"=5+&( %'!&(' & * !$*($!/1!% &"(?"# 3!!2" &@+!(' /*=!( '% -??

3!/!&(# !//!#!//!$ "'-A% B-C3!/!@, 3!%"=5+&( #&+!$@, 3! 55+&%( C'$&'=&''!$($ 3!%%*'!$C'%>*& !$4 4 3!+&=& !$>*!' &"(/&'&(2#"/%"('&$!/ &"(&( 3!5/!'!( 5/"%!!$&(2'&'C3! 3!/(55!+2&(' ("/$!/"#%>*& +5''!$&( %"=5+&( %'!*($!/1!% &"(?"# 3!% %(@!!( !/ &(!$*($!/ 3! 5/"0&'" " 1!% &"( D "# 3! /444 3! &(' (%! "# 3! %"=5+&(( E 4 3! &''*! &' (" +"(2!/ /!' &( !2/4 ( A6' !+!' &*= A6' !+!' &*= A6' !+!' &*= A6' !+!' &*= &((%&+ 7'4 4 (('!</( %4 . 1 ?

) .

&((%&+ 7'4 4 (('!</( %4 . 1 ?

) .

&((%&+ 7'4 4 (('!</( %4 . 1 ?

) .

&((%&+ 7'4 4 (('!</( %4 . 1 ?

) .

/&=&(+ ?B

/&=&(+ ?B- 3!"(9@+!1*5/!=!"*/ * 3"/& &0!+,3!+$ 3 %"=5+&(( &(5/"'!%* &"(*($!/1!% &"(?"# 3!% ->*+&#&!' 'A0&% &=B*($!/1!% &"( C"# 3!/444-@!&(2 3!5!/'"(C3"

'*##!/'#&((%&++"''$*! " 3!$&'3"("*/"#%3!>*!4"('!>*!( +,- '*%3%"=5+&(( &'!( & +!$ "5*/'*!(55!+2&(' %>*& +*($!/ 3! 5/"0&'" " 1!% &"( D "# 3! /444- C& 3"* 3! /!>*&/!=!( "# '!!<&(2'5!%&++!0!*($!/1!% &"(D?

"# 3!/444

4 C"*+$ @! 55"'& ! " /!5/"$*%! 3! /!+!0( !F /% "# 3! #"/!=!( &"(!$8*$2=!( -C3&%3&''! "* @!+"C) GD4 FFFFFFF 1!%"($+,- 3!/&23 "#0&% &="#%/&=!=*' @!5+%!$"( 5/ C& 3 3! /&23 "# ( %%*'!$ C3" 3' '*##!/!$ %"(0&% &"(-C3"-'= !/"#/&23 %(5/!#!/(55!+ *($!/ 1!% &"( D "# 3! /4 5!/'"( %"(0&% !$ "# %/&=!3' 3!/&23 "5/!#!/(55!+*($!/1!% &"(D ' = !/"#/&23 ($(" @!&(2'*@8!% !$ "(,%"($& &"('4 1&=&+/+,-0&% &="#%/&=!-C3 !0!/@! 3!( */!"# 3! %/&=!-*(%"($& &"(++,=*' 30!/&23 "5/!#!/(55!+4 3&/$+,-& &'#"/ 3&'/!'"( 3 3!/+&=!( 3"*23 & #& "&('!/ 3!5/"0&'" "'*@'!% &"(D C& 3"* =($ &(2 (,%"($& &"(5/!%!$!( "@!#*+#&++!$@, 3!0&% &="#( "##!(%!- C3&%3 !F5/!''&"( +'" &(%+*$!' 3! +!2+ /!5/!'!( &0!' "# $!%!'!$ 0&% &= C3" %( 5/!#!/ ( 55!+4

( 3!%"( //,-'2&(' ("/$!/"#%>*& +- 3!1 !- 3/"*23 3!*@+&%/"'!%* "/%(5/!#!/(55!+!0!(&# 3!%"=5+&(( $"!'(" 5/!#!/'*%3(55!+- 3"*23"# %"*/'! '*%3 ( 55!+ &' C& 3 3! +!0! "# 3! %"*/ 4 "C!0!/- & &' (" +C,' (!%!''/, #"/ 3! 1 ! "/ %"=5+&(( " 5/!#!/ ( 55!+4 * C3!( & %"=!' " 0&% &=9'/&23 "5/!#!/(55!+- 3!&('&' !(%!"('!!<&(2 '5!%&++!0! "55!+#/"= 3!&23"*/ *($!/1!% &"( D?

"# 3! / C"*+$ @! %"( //, " C3 3' @!!( &( !($!$ @, 3! /+&=!( @, &('!/ &"( "# 3! 5/"0&'" " 1!% &"(D "# 3!/444 "*/ 3+,- 3! /+&=!( 3' (" =!($!$ 1!% &"( D? " %&/%*='%/&@! 3!0&% &=9'/&23 "5/!#!/(55!+8*' '& 3'C& 3/!2/$ "%"=5+&(( "/ 3!1 !#&+&(2(55!+4

( 3!" 3!/3($- 3!/+&=!( 3'&('!/ !$ 3!5/"0&'" " 1!% &"(D '"' "!(0&'2!'*5!/&"//&23 #"/ 3!0&% &= "#("##!(%! "5/!#!/(55!+"( 3!2/"*($'=!( &"(!$ 3!/!&('%"=5/!$ "%"=5+&(( 4 &# 3+,- 3!&(0"+0!=!( "# 3!1 !&(/!'5!% "#("##!(%!

*($!/1!% &"(?"# 3!% &'%"('5&%*"*'@,& '@'!(%!4 3&'&'@!%*'! 3!%"=5+&( #&+!$*($!/ 3 5/"0&'&"(&'&( 3!( */!"#5/&0 !%"=5+&( '5!/1!% &"(

"# 3! /444($1!% &"( "# 3!% @,(!F5/!''&( !( &"( &(%"/5"/ !' 3!5/"0&'&"('"# 3!/444&( 3!= !/"# /&+"#'*%3$!!=!$"##!(%! /&!$'%/&=&(+"##!(%!4 3!/!#"/!- 3!%"=5+&(( -C3"&' 3!0&% &="#$&'3"("*/ "#%3!>*!=*' @!%"(' /*!$ "@!0&% &=&( !/='"# 3! 5/"0&'" " 1!% &"( D /!$ C& 3 3! $!#&(& &"( "# 0&% &= *($!/1!% &"( C"# 3!/444 FFFFFFFFF 4 ' +/!$, (" !$- 3! 5/"0&'" " 1!% &"( D "# 3! /444C'&('!/ !$&( 3!' * !@""<"(+,C& 3!##!% #/"= 4 4

43!"@8!% ($/!'"(#"/'*%3&('!/ &"(=*' @!/!+&'!$($=*' @!2&0!(& '#*++!##!% "@,%"*/ 4( 0&!C"# 3!#"/!'&$$&'%*''&"(-C!3"+$ 3 3!0&% &="# ("##!(%!3' 3!/&23 "5/!#!/(55!+*($!/ 3!5/"0&'" "1!% &"(D "# 3!/444-&//!'5!% &0!"#C3! 3!/3!&' %"=5+&(( "/(" 40!(&# 3!0&% &="#("##!(%!&' %"=5+&(( - 3! %( ' &++ 5/"%!!$ *($!/ 3! 5/"0&'" " 1!% &"(D ($(!!$(" $0!/ "'*@'!% &"(

"#1!% &"( D?"# 3!/444H .4 3*'-C3 #+"C'#/"= 3!@"0!"@'!/0 &"('&' 3 3! "(9@+!1*5/!=!"*/ -# !/(!F3*' &0!!F=&( &"("# 3!' * "/, #/=!C"/<($5/!0&"*'8*$&%&+5/"("*(%!=!( '&(%+*$&(2A++&</8*( A++&</8*( A++&</8*( A++&</8*( ;"$2+&7'41 !"#;/( <" 3!/'B 1D.

;"$2+&7'41 !"#;/( <" 3!/'B 1D.

;"$2+&7'41 !"#;/( <" 3!/'B 1D. -%+/&#&!$ 3 3!/&23 "#55!+%"(#!//!$*5"( 3!A0&% &=B*($!/ 3!5/"0&'" " 1!% &"(D "# 3!/444&'&($!5!($!( ($'*@' ( &0!&(( */!-(" %"( /"++!$ @, 3! 5/"%!$*/+ /!2&' / &"( *($!/ 1!% &"( D?

"# 3! /444 4 $"5 &(2 5/2= &% ($ 8*' &%!"/&!( !$ 55/"%3 ($ 2*&$!$@, 3!5/&(%&5+! 3 5/"%!$*/+/*+!=*' '!/0!($(" "@' /*% 3!%"*/'!"#8*' &%!- 3&'"*/ $!!='& 55/"5/& ! "$&/!% 3 3! 5/!'!( 55!+ @! /! !$ ' "(! * 3"/& &0!+, &(' & * !$ *($!/ 3!

5/"0&'" "1!% &"(D "# 3!/444 D4 ( 0&!C "# 3! * 3"/& &0! 5/"("*(%!=!( &( 6'!+!' &*=&((%&+9'%'! '*5/ 6'!+!' &*=&((%&+9'%'! '*5/ 6'!+!' &*=&((%&+9'%'! '*5/ 6'!+!' &*=&((%&+9'%'! '*5/($ 3!0&!C <!(@, 3&'"*/ +'"&(1 5+1&(23041 !"#*(8@(/4

$&'5"'!$"##"( 4 D4 .- 3!5/!'!( 55+&% &"(&'$&'5"'!$"#C& 3 $&/!% &"( 3 3!+!/(!$1!''&"('*$2!%"(%!/(!$'3++ /! 3!5/!'!( 55!+'(55!+#&+!$*($!/ 3!5/"0&'" "1!% &"(D "# 3!/444 ($''&2( 3!'=! "(55/"5/& !"*/ #"/$&'5"'+"(=!/& '-&( %%"/$(%!C& 3+C4 ?4 3!%"(%!/(!$55!++ !"*/ '3++5/"%!!$ "$!%&$! 3! 55!+!F5!$& &"*'+,-C& 3"* @!&(2&=5!$!$@,(,$!+,&(#&+&(2 3! 55!+- &( 0&!C "# 3! +!2+ 5"'& &"( ("C %+/&#&!$ @, 3! "(9@+! 5!F"*/ 4

4 3!!2&' /,&'$&/!% !$ " /('=& 3&'"/$!/+"(2C& 3 %"5, "# 3! %"=5+! ! 55!/ @""< ($ /! */( 3! /&+ "*/ /!%"/$- &#/!%!&0!$- " 3!+!/(!$1!''&"('*$2!4 4

&'5"'!$"#%%"/$&(2+,4 *+, *+, *+, *+, ($ ($ ($ ($- .

- .

;: *(!! I3! 3!/'5!<&(26/!'"(!$ )

!'6" I3! 3!//!5"/ @+! )

!'6"