Shanti Devi Deceased Through Lrs. And ORS. v. Roopmati And ORS.
!
!
!
!
' ()* #+ #
#+ #
#+ #
#+ #
,,--./
,,--./
,,--./
,,--./ + # # + # # + # # + # #
) #
) #
) #
) #
,/
,/
,/
,/
#$%0& %0& %0& %0&$
' ()* ++
++
++
++ '##*
1 # '##*
1 # '##*
1 # '##*
1 #
,,--./ ,,--./ ,,--./ ,,--./ + # # + # # + # # + # #
)
)
)
) #
#
#
#
,/
,/
,/
,/ ) ) ) ) 21)# #
3
4 21)# #
3
4 21)# #
3
4 21)# #
3
4
/ ) .566.7#8!./98/6 ) #.68-6.7!./:/6.,,--./ 8 #
&:
) 3).-6/.7!./7 :/6.,,--./8 #
) 36. ./.,#8;67!./ :/6,/ "8</6!.
3
47
3
47
3
47
3
47 ) ) ) )$=00 (=000 =00 (=000 =00 (=000 =00 (=000$$ 8
8
8
8 #$%0& %0& %0& %0&$
,,-8!./8:,,>/:/6>.8.,,.-.9--.)$ =$$ 58;/.?:/6@! /8,!8;7968!68:8@:
89 : /6 .>/ >. 8 /6 .,,-8!./87 .> . .--9./6>.8.,,.-.9--./6.,,-8!./8:/.?:@! /8 ,!8;./.5./.?8/-:
$ $ 48/6 /6 !/ : /6 ,./8 . 8 /6 8// : A /8!7 !!/ #
#
#
#
7777968!68,8;:
78.-/.5 ./.?8/-:
).8!. ).8!. ).8!. ).8!. /6/6 ; -.#!,,.-6.<:8-:..8-8; /6!!/:/6A ;>/.!./"
"&7,.<?/6
8/,,--./ / ,6-8;/6A ;>/.!./"
%
"&7 ,.<?/6/8.- /. !67</6/6 ; -.#!,,.-.:.8 6.--<!8<?/68!>>
6 ; -.
; -.
; -.
; -.#!,,.- #!,,.- #!,,.- #!,,.-
&:
&:
&:
&: 6.<:8-<? /6,-.8/8::$.,,--./'68.:/:/./6.,,--./*.;;8 .;.8//68>8.-:/688-# 8/:8-<?/6>.968!66.<: /6 ,6-<?/6 8/,,--./ /
" 46.7 ; -.#!,,.-
; -.#!,,.-
; -.#!,,.-
; -.#!,,.- 6.<:8- <? /6 .,,--./$:./ 0B+8A.?8 #8;6 '68.:/ : / . C.,,--./$+8A.?8/6 ;61 D*<8;.-.;;8.;.8//6!! / 8>8.-:/6 8/:8-<?/6,-.8/8:: 6:--98; 8;/.<-:-!//6-./868,8//6 ,./8$ Ram Singh s/o Jhabar (Owner) died on 05.04.2012 Roopmati Shanti Devi Birmati Mdahumati Satbir Singh daughter Widow daugher daughter son since deceased (defendant No.1) (Plaintiff No.1) (Plaintiff No.3) (Plaintiff No.4) claiming Registered Gift deed dated 19.03.2012 Vijayvir Iswati Rajbir Vikram Singh since deceased Widow died (Plaintiff No.2) (defendant No.3) (defendant No.2) Issueless appellant in RSA No.368 of 2019 Monish Hema minor son Widow {defendant No.3(ii)} (defendant No.3(i)
$%$ 1./ .> #8;6 B 6.<.7 !$8$8// 9. /6 98,8: "% EB 76.;9.-?788- .7
6/.5'68.:/:/./6C 8/,,/?D*7968!6/6,/ "B:./ "8!-.8>8;6968,/6<.8:/6;8:/ <.8; %= ./"
%
':6/7C/68:/D* 6-;.-8/? :/6.8;8:/6.<!6.--;<?/6,-.8/8::$.,,--./.. !-../86.< ;6//6.//6.88:/88--;.-7 --.8
, /6 <8: :.!/ /$ , <? /6 ,-.8/8::$.,,--./7 .> #8;6 9. 9$8$,8 : /6 8/ ,,/? @,8 E
. .:/ 68 ./67 /6 8/ ,,/? .-; 98/6 /6 /6 ,,/89<?.8 .>#8;69.868/<?/6,-.8/8::<8;68 -;.- 68 6 ,-.8/8:: !.> / 59 .< / /6 8:/ .--;-? @! / <? .> #8;6 8 :. : :./ "7 968!6 6. < !6.--;8/6 8/:8-<?/6>/6; /6././/6/8>:@! /8 :/6.--;8:/7 .>#8;69.>/6. ?.:.;.6 9./8 8,8;>87<8;<$8 68:// <.8;./ ./6 ><$8>,8: .>#8;6 69.8--;.--? ,! <?:./ "8!-- 898/6/6!8<./698/ 6,,!8,/8:/6 8/,,/?8/>/88/68! /6 >< 6. < 98// . " "B 8/ ./ 8 +8A.? .;.7 96.!!/!8,/8:/6 8/,,/?8 "% EB 78/ ./ 86.;9.-?788- .7 6/.5
" 6,/$:./ "!///6 8/<?:8-8;/6 98///./>/! ,-98/6/6! /$!-.8> 6-./868,8/ /6,./89..>8// 6968,:/6 8/,,/?9.!-.8> /6<.8:;8/8:/6.8;<@! /<?6:./67 .> #8;6 /8: /6!//6./,8/@! /8:/68:/7
$E$ /6:./6::./ "6.@! /.;8/48--./
"" .9--8:. ::./ /8!//6./,-.8/8::9/ 6.8;!8.--./868,98/6 .>#8;6. //6.8.769. -88;98/668. ;6/$:./ ".6<F ./6/6,,/?86 :. 88/8.--?<?@! /8;.48--./6.:/7<?@! /8;.;8/ 8:/86:. /8,!8:8!.--?!//6./,-.8/8:: "> ..,,-8!./8<:/6# <888.-).;8/./'#)*7 6/.5.;.8/ /66 <.::./ " #!/8 =:/6:8>8.-
! 7"
=%':6/7C/6
D* /6<.8:/6.8.,,-8!./87 /./>/: .>#8;6'9!.*9.!8/6 /:#)
6/.5
&796868:>/6#)/6./6888;98/6 :./ ".66 <.98/668:!/./6?.8;68> 9-- /6! /$!-.8>7/6-8::,89. ;6/.--;8;/6./ :./ "89$8$,8:/6 8/,,/?/6<.8: ;8/8:/.9--./6<.8:/6;8/48--
6 -;.- ,/./8 : .,,--./$+8A.?8 :8- ,../ 98///./>/.>8//8;/6!-.8>:/6,-.8/8::./6?.->.. ,.?/6.//68:/<!-. --(8
%
> /6 ,-.8; : /6 ,./87 /6 :--98; 8 9 :.>$
46/6/6,-.8/8::./8/-/.!:!-../8/6; .,.?:G
:8 "8,796/6/6,-.8/8::./8/-:.!: ,>./8A !/8/6; .,.?:G
46/6/6 8/8/>.8/.8.<-8/6,/:>G
46/6/6,-.8/8::6.-! /.8/:8-/6,/ 8/G
-8:
$ $
E 6 /8.- / 8>8 /6 8/ :8- <? /6 ,-.8/8:: . .--9/6! /$!-.8>:8-<?:./ "7!-.8;/6./:./ "8/8/-//6,8:/6 8/,,/?7697:./ 9.-/.8:>.-8./8;/6 8/,,/?
6 8/,,--./ />8:8/6A ;>/.!<? 9.? : .--98; /6 ! /$!-.8> :8- <? :./ " . !-.8; :./ "/</69: "% EB 6.;9.-?788-
.7 6/.5 6,-.8/8::98!//6.,8:/6 8/ ,,/?/:./ "98/68.,8:%>/6 1.! -:/6.,,--./$,-.8/8:: <>8///6.//6 8:/.--;/6.<@! /<?/6,!$ .>#8;68 >-?.,.,/..!/8.69. ::8;:> .58D8..
/./.!H69. ?.:.;H69./8. 8,8;>8 /8: /6,8/ //6./).6.8#8;6 -8.79686 <.:/6 <:8!8.?78..///8;98/:/67968!6!-.-?88!.//6./6 6.</.8/6.8! >/<? 8;688:- ! /8: /6.--; /6.//6,,!8,/8:/6 8/,,/?8/>/88/6 !67/6!,.<?/6 8/,,--./ /8-8.<-/< / .8 / 8 .- ,8/ / /6./ /6 . . >/8 : @!- 8;/6./ .-68:/6 /8!//6.//6@! /8: > -/8,-! >/!-.-?88!./>.-.:8/6,./:/6:./ 6.7.48--8.--;/6.<@! /<?/6
""78 !6!8! >/.!7/69.:@! /8:.8:/ <?/6!. --/6! >/9;/,,.<?:./ "<? 8;68:- !7. !67/68:/8-8.<-/</.8 8/386.)6.3 -+ ./8>.).8/?7 % # ,> /E% "H 386.)6.3 -+ ./8>.).8/?7 % # ,> /E% "H 386.)6.3 -+ ./8>.).8/?7 % # ,> /E% "H 386.)6.3 -+ ./8>.).8/?7 % # ,> /E% "H +5./.!6.-. ?;. + 68>>.A.>>. . /67 "
+5./.!6.-. ?;. + 68>>.A.>>. . /67 "
+5./.!6.-. ?;. + 68>>.A.>>. . /67 "
+5./.!6.-. ?;. + 68>>.A.>>. . /67 "
$0$ # ,> /EE%H#8 ).66+ #.;.>./67 # ,> # ,> /EE%H#8 ).66+ #.;.>./67 # ,> # ,> /EE%H#8 ).66+ #.;.>./67 # ,> # ,> /EE%H#8 ).66+ #.;.>./67 # ,> /E /E /E /E H.3 1.@>..+ 655.?8- .>88./67 1.@>..+ 655.?8- .>88./67 1.@>..+ 655.?8- .>88./67 1.@>..+ 655.?8- .>88./67 # ,> /
# ,> /
# ,> /
# ,> / = 1.! -.,,.8;<6.-::/6-;.-,/./8 : .,,--./$+8A.?8 .8 8>8-. .; >/ . .8 <6.-: : /6 .,,--./
!/.7-.! -.,,.8;<6.-::,/ "7:8;//6.!<?/6/8.- /.9--.<?/6 8/ ,,--./ /7 !/ /6./ /6 8/ 6. < 8;6/-? ! . /6 ,/.,,.-88:.?>8/
6. !8 /6 .:.8 <>88 . , /6 ,.,$<5 " /8/8, //6.//6 8/,,/?9.-:$.!F 8,,/? : .>#8;67968!69., !6.<?68>8.-./E = '@
I* </7/6.,,--././6-.-;.-68:!.$ .> #8;67697/6<:8!8.?:/68:/8.-:/6./ .- 68$. ;6/:/6!. 6!6.--;//6@! /8:/68:/6.<>. ,8>.8-?/6; /6.//6@! /./9.-H69./: 8,8; >8H 6 9. /6 8:- ! : /6 <:8!8.?H 6 9. ::8; :> .;$-./ .8->/H . /6 ./ .- 68 6. < @!- 98/6 //6<8;.!8/.-8/6 " 6.8!6.--;:.--:-./968-!88;/6! >/.? 8!<?9.?:.,,-8!./8:8-<?/698::/6@! /./ 8;/6 -8:/8>:/6@! /./ #!/8 =
./6/./>/>.<? /6@! /./<:/6#)7 6/.5 ,@ %7#6./8898:: /6@! /./:8-..,,-8!./88/6 /:#)F /8;:8 .!
$=$ :.!69../:66 <.$@! /./:/6798/6/6:--98; .--;./8$ J
6.//6.!! 6.9;-?!:8/66 <.:!>,-.8./ .>-? .>#8;6 69..//686 8/ ././ &!/ % ;. 66 <.:/6!>,-.8./9.!:8.;.8/6898-- .986 6.//66 <.:/6!>,-.8./8.;.< /&B& ?.- .686./,./8/..-,./8/:<-, 7./68. .,,688/6>8:!>,-.8./7/6.//6.!! ,>.?58-- /66 <.:/6!>,-.8./7<!. /66 <.:!>,-.8./9. 6.8;.!.6.> /: " -.! 6.//6!>,-.8./888;8/6..: -8!#/./888- 187 6/.5.,-8!:88-18 6/.56.A 88!/8/.!6 66 <..8!/8>.?<8 //6!!,-8!/./8 K
/6<.8:/6.:.8.,,-8!./87 .>#8;6'@! /./ :/6*7>.././>/
&<:#)7 6/.5'@ %*7 9686/.//6./6888;.-;98/66. ;6/$<:8!8.?: /68:/.$8$-.9.,68:$98--.6: /6@,68 8 / !/8 -? -8 98/6 68 . ;6/ . $8$-.97 96 9 8;68>9-- 6;-86/.-./8:/6.8/./>/8. $ J#/./>/:# <.'?
1/ .>#8;6*$$$$$ #/.//6./.>-88;98/6>?$8$-.9).6.8#8;6 -8.. . ;6/ ,>./886 &7#!/ %7 ;.>.,>?:$ 98--.66.;//6>98/668!/ /-?.>-88;98/6 /6>.,68:$98-- 9.//-898/6>?$8$-.9.. ;6/ /8--/6:>?-8: 6?.8;>9-- 8-->?-./<./679./ /-898/6>?$8$-.9).6.8#8;6 -8... ;6/ ,>./8 /9.//;98/6>?98:8!69.//.,,,8./>?,,/? .:/;//8;>58--
& #B$ # <888.-).;8/./7 6/.5K
$&$
/68;.7/6//8>?:- ).6.8#8;6 -8.'4$
*7968$8$-.9:/6@! /./.:/6.///8;98/78 .->./8.- 6.//8:8/6.//6@! /./:/69.6 >8-8./ .6..<?/6,-.8/8::.<?68/6-./8$:./
(% 9./ /:686 ./ 6/.58/6?. & 9.-5 .:/<?68$8$-.9.. ;6/$ ,>./8/8--68./6 /6!$ @.>8./87/698/6.//8:8/6./68:./6$8$-.97 .>#8;679. ::8;:>!68/8H69.,./: /./8/6?. "./ .;.-H.;.8769.,./:>#8.;. .>,8/.-8/6?.
" 9. .- ::8; :> .58D 8. . 9. >8!./8:> /8,8/.-.#8.;. .>,8/.- "% 6 //8>? : /6 .///8; 98/ . /6 .:.8 /./>/:/6@! /./.9--./6.,,-8!./8;8<?/698::/6 @! /./!-.-?88!.//6.//6@! /./9./-88;98/6/6,-.8/8:: 8;68-8:/8> 9.6.8;>8!.-8 -.//-.; 9. <8;/./98/6>8!.-6-,.9.<8;-5.:/<?/6<:8!8.? .66 <. 6@! /./68>-:6.69688/!/8 -88; 98/6 : 68 . ;6/ ,8/ 68 98: <8; .-8 -- !6 !8! >/.!;8/;88!./8/6.//6@! /./9./;8-. .::!/8.9.8--/./<?6898:.9--.<?68/6!68- "E 6.
--; ,8!8 !8! >/.!.< //6. /6/8!8/?: /68:/78 .;:/6@! /./7@!- 8;/6/6./ .-68:> /6<:8/:/6,,/?8F /8.-.;>8!.-8 ./;-? 8,--<?/6! >/.?8!78 /6@! /./68>-:@, 68 8 / -8 98/6 /6 <:8!8.? . <8; 6.,,? 98/6 /6 8! <?/6<:8!8.?7 8;68-8:/8>7/6.//<:.. /68/?7 # <888.-).;8/.
$ $ 6.:.8:.!/. ,,->/98/6./6.,!//6./ ,8/@! /8;/68:/7/6@! /./6.@! /.;8/ 48-- 8 :. : /6 <:8!8.?
6 @! /./ 9. -88; 98/6 /6 <:8!8.?
/6/68:/.9--./648--.;8/! >/7 968!688!.//6.//6@! /./6..,,.<:/6# < ;8/.: ;8/./8 : !6 ! >/ . <? >.58; . >/ !6 ! >/7/6# < ;8/.6.;8. /6/8!8/?.< //6.,,..!: /6@! /./<:68>.!:8>8;/6@! /8: !6! >/ "0 89:.:.8,! -8.:.!/(!8! >/.!:/68!.7 /6<A!/8.8<?/6.,,--.//6./:/6.///8;98/8/6 6 <. : /6 <:8!8.? /6./ /6 @! /./ 9. - /6./ /6 8 .<! : . : @!- 8; /6 /6 ./ .- 687 ,.- 8/ 88;8:8!.! "= 6!88-8 ,<?-.! -:/6.,,--./ 8386.)6.3 -' ,.*7 +5./.!6.-.?;.' ,.*7#8 ).
66 ' ,.*.3 1.@>..' ,.*..-8/8; 86.<-:.!/ "& F /-?7/6.>8/8/6,/.,,.-.. !67</6/6 ; -.#!,,.-/.8>8H/6:88;! <?/6 8/,,--./ /..::8> !<.9.!!8;-?
8;.,,-8!./8'*78:.?76.--.-/.8,:
#.,.?.- #.,.?.- #.,.?.- #.,.?.-B./ - B./ - B./ - B./ - '
3
4* '
3
4* '
3
4* '
3
4* 46/6,.58;B. 46/6 ,/.<-