High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/21721/2015allowed

Charan Singh And ORS v. State Of Punjab & ORS

2015-10-15Mr Justice Rakesh Kumar Jain4 pages

!"! #$ %& '

!"! #$ %& ' ( #)!#*( (&"

,,,,,,,, ! #&"

-&"."

)

.#/ % (&"

,,,,,,"0 #+# $ $ $ $ 12),)) 12),)) 12),)) 12),)) &"#

&"#

&"# $ &, (.3)( &4 '+5

& ! #&", &,,),)!+(.'.#/ %, &,,),)!4%3'+5

&&"0 #+# " , , 6666 )', )', )', )', ! #&"( 5 !3+ (!"0 ! #.#+&) 7

( + &!4!# 3& +.&'89 &:.

,9+

+7, , '.#+&) ! #"9 '99' 7' 8

(#+!

## 3 +'7;

<11 &"( & =<) ! #9;

+++3

& #='&*!"

3! )

! #) + & &# #'

&# # 33 #":.# 30& +!#*" &!"!#*

& 4' # (% "!" 40& 4!", &#+ .#"3 & ( 0 ! #&" " >33 &#+ .#"3 &&"0 #+# " , ( 5".%4!

!" " 5&"! # #+ & ""5&"! #, >5&'# >0 !"

5 4!

%3?"

3+ (!&+!"0.

, -!+ &+& +

+ 7, , ' &!

3 .& @33 :

*!"

> "+!& + & &+ ("

4# " !"

#+ "#+ !

" &0 & >!

( &* &+ *#.!##"" 40& 4!"

+% ># !",

#0.&".

# ("

!+ &+&' ( *!"

& &+!#* ("

4# " "&0 & +

40& 4!"

+ % ># ( 0 !" > " >!

( .

' & ! # &.#+.!# 3.# , " 0& ( .33 # ( /.+*4# (!" .& !# A.3>!#+&)!#*( (&"5",)

.#/ %'

<9= A.3>!#+&)!#*( (&"5",)

.#/ %'

<9= A.3>!#+&)!#*( (&"5",)

.#/ %'

<9= A.3>!#+&)!#*( (&"5",)

.#/ %'

<9= <&!4!# 3=

<&!4!# 3=

' !*( .& ( " 0 >& .#+& ) ! # 7 &,,, 33 > ( 40 .#+!#* # # 40 .#+ %3

#+:.

"( (0& " .

! #>(& (!*( .&

4> "&:.!&+ 0&5# ( %." (0& "" #?

.& & (&>!"" .& (#+" /."

! ,(!"0 >&

"(!#*!"# # !#+ 4

&!4 #!

3+!"0.

" 3 #, #1%3 (0B .& !# ( " !

#)!#*(5", !

#)!#*(5", )

.#/ % # (& )

.#/ % # (& < =<&3,=

< =<&3,=

9'( "(3+

".#+&$ , ( 0 "!

! #

4&*" & 4 % 5 +!" .""! # #%".44 &!"+ (."$ (0 >& !*( .& !#:.

30& +!#* & & 403 !# !#B& !" !

"!#(&# /.&!"+!

! #!"

+!"

!# #+ +!

&# & 4 ( 0 >& *!5#

&!4!# 3 .& & 40 .#+!#* (

# ".#+& ) ! #9 ( +,#(&# 0 >&!" >!+ 03#!

.+>!

(# "

&?3!4!

! #%.

( " % B& !"+!# &+>!

( (*.!+3!##*&

+!# ". (0 >&5!DE<!= " .& (#+" /."

! &<!!=

0&5# %." (0& "" #? .& ,#>(

"" 0 >& :.

"( ( &!4!# 3 0& +!#* & !# & ,, 4 ? % B& !"+ >(&

#+& #+5!

!4( 5"

3+ (!&+!"0.

> .3+ +0#+ # (

" #+ !& .4"

# " (

#+#

* &? #%0&" &!%+, >5&'% B& !" ". (0 >&' (!*( .& 4."

(

9 +.&* &+ (#

.& #+*& 5!

? ( &!4, !# ." #+"&! ."

# " 4#

3+0& 5!

? &

# "3!F4.&+&'& 0'+ ?' , ## %

!#*3?:.

"(+5# ( .*( (5!

!4 &5!

!4G"

4!3? #+

#+& ( 5 "

3+ ( +!"0.

, ). (

# " &# 0&!5

!##

.& #+( "&! ."!40

#" !

?,)!4!3 &3?' #? 40& 4!"

% ># (5!

#+&!#&3

# " .#+& "0 !

3 "

" 3!F &5# ! #

&&.0 ! # & (

# " 44!

+%?0.%3!

"&5 # ">(!3> &F!#*!#

? E ##

0& 5!+ & #? % "!" & :.

"(!#* &!4!# 0& +!#*"!#5 35!#*". (

# ",.

( &!4!#

""( 5!#* 5&>(34!#*3? #+0&+ 4!#

!#*3?

!5!3 5 .& "

#+ # +!

!#* & 0.&0 "" :.

"(!#*' 0 ! .3 &3?

# "

&!"!#* & 4 44& !

3' !# # !

3'4& # !3' !5!3'

#&"(!0 &". (3!F #"

! #" & (

# "

&!"!#* .

&!4 #?&3

!#* + >&?' , &

4!3? +!"0.

" >(& ( >& #* !" % "!

33?

0&!5

&0&" # 3!##

.& &" 35+ (!& # !& +!"0.

, # (!"

* &?

""'!*( .& 4 ?:.

"( &!4!# 30& +!#*"!

!#!

"5!>'% ." ( 40& 4!"% >#

#+& #+5!

!4' (0 ""!%!3!

? #5!

! #!"

&4 #+%3 F #+ # !#.

3 > .3+0.

."+ *&

00&""! # #+0&/.+!

#+B &4!#/."

! > .3+% ."+ (!4%?#

( &!4!# 3 "+"0!

.33 #+ 403

34# #+ 40& 4!">!

( (5!

!4,# > &+"' ( !*( .& 4."

#"!+& >( (& !

> .3+%.#

!& & # &? (!# &"

/."

# !#. >!

( ( &!4!# 3 0& +!#* & # !#.

! # ( &!4!# 3 0& +!#* > .3+

4 .# %." 0& "" 3 > +"0!

34# #+ 40& 4!"% ># (5!

!4 #+ >& #*+ & #+>( (& " .& (#+" /."

! '

!" 00& 0&!

3 "!"0.

##+

#+ !

#">& % 5 :."

! #<"= !" !#

!&4

!5' (!*( .& "( 33%>33>!

(!#!

/.&!"+!

"( ( &!4!# 30& +!#*,H )!# 5 &&!5+

40& 4!" #+ 5 + !++ 3!5 !# 0 ' # ."

.3 0.&0 " > .3+ % "&5+!# 33 >!#* ( &!4!# 30& +!#*" # !#., &+!#*3?' (!" 0 ! # !" 33 >+, ,9 +

+ 7, , ' .#+& ) ! #" 9 ' 99' 7' 8 <) ! #9; +++3

& #='

3! )

! #) + & &# #' !"

&# # #+ 33 ( #":.# 0& +!#*"' &!"!#* & 4' &:.

"(+, <)= <)= <)= <)= %& '

%& '

%& ' 5!&