Chaman Lal v. State Of Punjab

 



       




! "#$    % &'!( ( ! ) 



 
 
   










 " 





*!"+'

! "#$ 
 " 
   










 " 






+*,)

! "#$  #

$ 
   










 "

# & #-./01 (23
1435
-61
-44
00 

%
&'(

")
*"+)


!   

 % , - %
(

$)
*"+)


!   

 % .-/0 - %
1

$
"2)
*"+)


!   

 % /.3 -

  



' )
**&)



%
!4
'

)
*"+)


! 
55555 435
-61
-44
0072  
6
"

"




+
 "

!  




 
 



78
2
!   

)
 "
 "
#

$)
+
!!"

 

4 $
$ 

   !9
 

 !


 
$ "

$



+ "
78
1)
""
.-)
$ "

 

 
  )
  
: ")

 

./
 "
.
 8
  
0

6+


$  
*  6
78
2
$ "



 

(

$
2

$"


"
"







2
 $
")

2 


! "



 
2 


+
$ 
2
 "
"

! 

;9!

<

8

$"



"

! 


24 !

2

<
#

$
2
 
! "
9 " ""
! <


!
 "





3)=
2  2
$ +
9

! )
2
2
! 
 $
2 


!2
 9)

  "


 "
#

$


,
8

$"


 

  )

  "
!

""
+

!9

 

;9!

<


! "

" ""
 





3

2 
2
 
$ +
9
 ! 





"

(2+)

2


"






2


! 
2
$"
 "


! 4"

)

#

$
 "

")
$ 
 

 9

9
" "

 



"


"


9
2 "
"

! 

;


* <

2 
 2 "
+

!9





0,
 

8

$"
 



"

-,
 ""
+

 

;

 * <
 "
" ""





0,
 "


"

9 2 "
 
 $

 4
2 
0 .
"9 

6
! )


3-,
$+





3




 "
#

$)

 
!

> 9)


 $




")
 ! )

,-,
 ""
+
 





-)= 
#

$

8

$"





$ !!"

$ 
2

2
$"

9
2 "
$
 ! 

! 


;


* <
 "
2 "
 $
  

0
9
 
  

"

9
2 "
 






.3



! 

6
! 
$"





"
2+)
" "

"

" 
 "


"

 






.3
 0 1 


  "
!  

2

"

 .  "





!   ?

@


 "

9
+  9

! "


! 
 
 "


+ " 

  




)

 "


78
"

""

 ""
+
9

! 




 3  "




!   
 "
?

 % .-/0 -@


 "



+
!

$ 

+"


78 )

2
 "


"
+
"
 ! 


! "

9
 


"
 ! 
2 

! "

$ +




3 


! "

"9
"
+  $  / A!!

$

!  

)
 "






 "


+ 2




!  
$ 
$ 



+"


78 )

 

$ 

 

"
  , (+ $


""
 +



""

"


 
 "

 $

 "

 

$ 

)


 9

 
2  2 "
> 
$ 

!  9
> 


"



 "
#

$

*


!    
 "

  ")

 
 9
"
+  $  

 
"


! 
2 

! "

! "





3  )
2 


" "
9

! 

 "


 "

$"
/
9 

8
+ 2


  "
! )
2  
 "






  "

" +
  


 )


2
!  

 "








$

9
"



-   
 $
1 % .-/0 -)
 "





 "
 "

!"
  
"  

"
+ "
"
""

,-

"
  




 "  

!   
 "

!!


+  $  "
2

"


"

 "
!
2 

8 +  $ $
A 
 "




 "
9

 "  

!+ ""

 
.0-
?@     

 "







$

 % , -
 "
 % /.3 -

9
"



 8
)
2+)
  "




 + 

"
+



4



B!


 



  8

  7 ! ) 435
-61
-44
00 

 23641










C
!4 $
= "

D
=
1 C
! D
=
1