(O&M)Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Gurminder Kaur And Others
! " #$ #%& ' $( ' "$
) *+,-./011.
2,345
:;
<9=>?>:@ BCD 0D0B0E
,F>9@87G H@?IF7@=9 J:KL7@M N>K>89<
DDDDD+LL9GG7@8
O9F?I?
PIFK>@<9F Q7IF 7@< 7@:8R9F
DDDDD S9?L:@<9@8?
*+,-1BE11.
2,345
PIFK>@<9F Q7IF
DDDDD+LL9GG7@8
O9F?I?
Q7T> S7K U7@?7G 7@< 7@:8R9F
DDDDD S9?L:@<9@8?
$ V&W! $ %#X ! #'$( YF9?9@8A
4FD 6DYD PIL87Z +<T:=789Z
;:F 8R9 7LL9GG7@8-H@?IF7@=9 J:KL7@M >@ *+,-./011.
7@<
;:F F9?L:@<9@8 [:D0-H@?IF7@=9 J:KL7@M >@ *+,-1BE11.D
[:@9 ;:F 8R9 F9?L:@<9@8?
>@ *+,-./011.
7@<
;:F 8R9 7LL9GG7@8 >@ *+,-1BE11.D
\\\\\
#'$(] %
^R9
7;:F9?7><
7LL97G?
7F9
_9>@`
<9=><9<
8:`98R9FZ
7F>?>@`
:I8
:;
8R9 ?7K9 7a7F<D
0D
H8
R7?
_99@
?8789<
>@
8R9
`F:I@<?
:;
7LL97G
>@
*+,-1BE11.Z
<9=97?9<
PIFLF998
b>@`R
c
d:GGM
7@<
+K7F<99L
Q7IF
c
JR7@<@>
a9F9
;78R9F
7@<
K:8R9F
:;
7LL9GG7@8-PIFK>@<9F
Q7IFD
69=97?9<-+K7F<99L
Q7IF
!
"# $%&'
%&
()#
*+!%&#!!
,-
!+..$/
,-
#$#0(1%0
*+$*!2
3)#
0,4.#&! (%,&
!!#!!#"
*/
()#
31%*+& $
%!
,&
()#
$, #1
!%"#5
*/
1,&'$/
..$/%&'
()#
4+$(%.$%#1
,-
%&!(# "
,-
!)#
*#%&'
/# 1!2
:(
) !
$!,
*##&
;#11#"
() (
<+1%&"#1
= $
<%&')
= $$%
!
"1%;%&'
()#
0 1
(
()#
(%4#
,-
00%"#&(5
)%0)
%!
.1,;#"
-1,4
()#
#;%"#&0#
$#"
*/
()#
0$ %4 &(5
"#!.%(#
() (
()#
31%*+& $
) !
1,&'$/
)#$"
&#'$%'#&0#
,&
()#
. 1(
,-
()#
"#0# !#"
>+1.1##(
<%&') ?
@,$$/ &"
"#&%#"
()# 0,4.#&! (%,&2
A&
()#
,()#1
) &"5
$# 1&#"
0,+&!#$
-,1
()#
:&!+1 &0#
B,4. &/5
!+*4%(!
() (
()#
31%*+& $
#11#"
%&
'1 &(%&'
()#
0,4.#&! (%,&
(,
()#
0$ %4 &(
%(),+(
..1#0% (%&'
()#
- 0(!
&"
#;%"#&0#
%&
()#
.1,.#1
4 &
&"
-%&"%&'
1#' 1"%&'
()#
! 4#
1#C+%1#!
(,
*#
1#;#1!#"2
3)#
0$ %4
,-
()#
"# ()
,-
>+1.1##(
<%&')
?
@,$$/5
!
1%')($/
1#D#0(#"5
!
()#
"#0# !#"5
),
)%4!#$-
!
"1%;%&'
()#
0 15
!
-,+&"
&#'$%'#&(2
3)+!5
)#
.1 /!
-,1
()#
"%!4%!! $
,-
()# ! %"
..# $2
E2
F# 1"
&"
.#1+!#"
()# . .#1 *,,G2
H2
I"4%((#"$/5
,&
829626JJH
%&
1, "!%"#
00%"#&(5
>+1.1##(
<%&')
?
@,$$/5
)%!
%-#
I4 1"##.
K +1
?
B) &"&%5
<+1%&"#1
= $
<%&')
= $$% &"
L,&%G ) "
"%#"2
M2
3)#
$# 1&#"
31%*+& $
)%$#
"#0%"%&'
()#
%!!+#
1#' 1"%&'
()#
&#'$%'#&0#5
"+#
(,
)%0)
()#
00%"#&(
) "
( G#&
.$ 0#5
) "
1#0,1"#"
!
+&"#1N
OJ2
PDD $
<%&')5
),
%!
()#
#/#
%(&#!!
,-
()#
00%"#&(5
)#&
!(#..#"
%&(,
()#
%(&#!!
*,Q
"#.,!#"
() (
,&
829626JJH5
)#
!
',%&'
%&
L ( ",1
-1,4
= (% $
(,
R#$)%5
(,
!##
,--
)%!
!%!(#1S!
!,&
& 4#$/5
<+1%&"#1. $
<%&')5
),
!
',%&'
(,
B & " 5
$,&'
%()
)%!
%-#T
() (
<+1%&"#1
= $
<%&')
&"
)%!
%-#
#1#
(1 ;#$$%&'
%&
&,()#1
0 1
*# 1%&'
1#'%!(1 (%,&
U,2=VW66RWX
)%0)
!
*#%&'
"1%;#&
*/
>+1.1##(
<%&')T
() (
%-#
,-
>+1.1##(
<%&')
!
$!,
(1 ;#$$%&'
%&
()#
! %"
0 1T
() (
>+1.1##(
<%&')
!
"1%;%&'
()#
! %"
0 1
(
;#1/
- !(
!!"#
$%
&
'!()
(& *
&%"
%!+,$+!%-
.&%%!(/
-*&-
0*!%
-*!)
(!&1*!"
%!&(
-*!
1&%&,
2($"+!
'$,,&+!
5&%"&
6*!($#
3%
7&-$&,&89&: ;(&
(3&"#
-*!
"($'!(
-*!
1&(
13;,"
%3-
13%-(3,
$-
&%"
-*!
1&(
4!,,
"30%
$%-3
-*!
1&%&,#
&
&
(! ;,-
0*$1*
&,,
-*!
43;(
311; &%-
-*!
1&(#
%&.!,)#
<;($%"!(
7&,
<$%+*
7&,,$#
*$
0$4!
&%"
5;( (!!-
<$%+*
&%"
*$
0$4!#
"$!"=
>!
*&
4;(-*!(
"! 3 !"
-*&-
*!
$%43(.!"
-*!
3,$1!
&-
9&: ;(&#
&%"
-*!
3,$1!
32-&$%!"
*$
$+%&-;(! =
?113("$%+
-3
*$.
-*!
&11$"!%-
-33@
,&1!
";!
-3
-*!
(& *
&%"
%!+,$+!%-
"($'$%+
5;( (!!-
<$%+*=
A3 )
BB9
C3=DE
"&-!"
DE=FG=GHHI
7=<=
<&"&(#
9&: ;(&
*&
&, 3
2!!%
,&1!"
3%
(!13("#
0*$1*
&, 3
*30
-*&-
-*!
&$"
1&(
0&
2!$%+
"($'!%
2)
5;( (!!-
<$%+* &- -*!
-$.!
&11$"!%-=
GF=
J3
(!2;-
-*$
!'$"!%1!
-*!
1,&$.&%- #
-*!
(! 3%"!%-
"$"
%3-
,!&"
&%)
!'$"!%1!=
<3
4(3.
-*!
-&-!.!%-
K::&,
<$%+*#
?LD#
0*3
$
-*!
!)!
0$-%!
-*!
311;((!%1!#
$-
-&%"
! -&2,$ *!"
3%
(!13("
-*&-
-*!
344!%"$%+
1&(
0&
2!$%+
"($'!%
&-
-*!
-$.!
&11$"!%-
2)
5;( (!!-
<$%+*=
MN=?L O?
$
-*!
13 )
-*!
3 -
.3(-!.
(! 3(-
5;( (!!-
<$%+*=
MN=7P
$
-*!
13 )
3 - .3(-!.
(! 3(- A*&%"%$ &,$& ?.&("!!
6&;(=
GG=
>!%1!#
-*!
"$ 1; $3%
.&"!
&23'!
$
$%"$1&-$'!
-*!
4&1-
-*&-
$ ;!
C3=G
$%
&,,
-*!
1,&$.
!-$-$3%
-33"
(3'!"
0$-*
(!+&("
-3
-*!
"!&-*
-*!
"!1!& !"
'$Q=
<;($%"!(
7&,
<$%+*
7&,,)#
<.-=
R3%$@&#
5;( (!!-
<$%+*
&,$&
S3,,)
&%"
*$
0$4!
?.&("!!
6&;(
&,$&
A*&%"%$#
3%
&113;%-
(& *
&%"
%!+,$+!%-
"($'$%+
-*!
1&(
$%
T;! -$3%
2)
5;( (!!-
<$%+*=
J*$
$ ;!
$ #
-*!(!43(!#
&":;"$1&-!"
; 3% &113("$%+,)=U
V=
7!(; &,
-*!
&0&("
*30
-*&-
&
!(
BB9#
(!+$ -!(!"
2)
K::&,
<$%+*8?LD#
-*!
1&(
$%
T;! -$3%
0&
2!$%+
"($'!%
2)
5;( (!!-
<$%+*
W
S3,,)#
-3
0*$1*
$%
(!2;--&,
%3
!'$"!%1!
0&
,!"
2)
-*!
1,&$.&%-#
-*!(!43(!#
-*!(!
$
%3
!((3(
$%
-*!
4$%"$%+
-*!
J($2;%&,
"!1,$%$%+
-*!
1,&$.
3%
&113;%- -*!
"!&-* 5;( (!!- <$%+* W S3,,)=
X=
L$-*
(!+&("
-3
-*!
&(+;.!%-
-*&-
$%1!#
%&.!
-*!
311; &%-
-*!
1&(
0&
.!%-$3%!"
&
A*&%"%$#
-*;
-*!
1,&$.&%-
5;(.$%"!(
6&;(
"O3
?.&("!!
6&;(
1&%%3-
2!
*!,"
!%-$-,!"
-3
-*!
13. !% &-$3%#
$
%3-
-!%&2,!
3%
&113;%-
-*!
4&1-
-*&-
$%
$%
-*!
(!,$!4
1,&; !
-*!
1,&$.
!-$-$3%#
-*!
%&.!
*!(
.3-*!(
0&
.!%-$3%!"
&
&, 3
$%
'$!0
-*!
1&-!+3($1
4$%"$%+
(!13("!"
2)
-*!
J($2;%&,
$%
-*$
(!+&("
-*&-#
Y===Z;(-*!(
-*!(!
$
%3
(!2;--&,
-3
!"
#$%
$
&'()!*+,(
-$'(
!"
*.
+$'/ ,(
.#
0)$(+,,1
-$'(
.'/
,(
1$ ,(*! 2
+.,"
*.
" $*+
," $34!" ,+
$
$445
3'
,(,
!"
*.
(,3' $4
.
!"
#$%
.*
(,%.(+
$
0)$(+,,1
-$'(
6 .
+!,+
!*
,
). .(
7, !%'4$(
$%%!+,*
+!+
*.
/!7,
3!(
.
$*2
% !4+5
$"
*.
6(! ,*
" $ ,),*
6$"
#!4,+
,(
!*
,
+!7.(%,
1, ! !.*
%.* ($+!% !*/
,
$7,(),* "
)$+,
,
1, ! !.*,(
#.(
",,8!*/
,
+!7.(%,9
:.
$8!*/
$44
,",
#$% "
!* .
%.*"!+,($ !.*
;
%.),
.
!"
%.*%4'"!.*
$
&'()!*+,(
-$'(
%4$!)$*
!"
,* ! 4,+
.
%4$!)
%.)1,*"$ !.* 3,!*/ , +$'/ ,( .# 0)$(+,,1 -$'(5 *.6 +,%,$",+9<
=9
>7!+,* 425
,(,
6$"
*.
+.%'),* $(2
,7!+,*%,
1(.+'%,+
,
%4$!)$* ?$11,44$*
6!
(,/$(+
.
!*%.),
.#
,
+,%,$",+?0)$(+,,1
-$'(5
,(,#.(,5
,(
!*%.),
$8,*
,
@(!3'*$4
$"
A"9 BCD?
1,(
).*
%$**.
3,
#$'4 ,+
6! 9
E.6,7,(5
6!
(,/$(+
.
,
,* $*%,),*
.#
,
%.)1,*"$ !.*5
!"
F.'(
%$*
)$8,
$
1(.#! $34,
(,#,(,*%,
.
,
4$6
4$!+
+.6*
!* HI JKHL
MNKH O PKINQ RH
SHM HSH MQ
MNKHT
UCC=VWX
AFA
VF!7!4X
YY5 MQ
I Z [H
\K LS
] ^QLQMK O H
] GKMNQ
MNKH
UC_YV X
AFA
VF!7!4X
_CC=
$*+ `
a Q O ZZZ ^ LaH Z [H
\K ^M T
VUCUUX
_C
:FF
B_U
$*+
$%%.(+!*/42
,
$11,44$*
!"
,4+
,* ! 4,+
.
/($*
.#
#' '(,
1(."1,% "
.
,
,b ,*
.#
Cc5
,
+,%,$",+
3,!*/
",4#
,)14.2,+
$*+
$4".
#.(
%.)1,*"$ !.*
'*+,(
,
%.*7,* !.*$4
,$+"
!9,9
#'*,($4
,b1,*","
A"9_d5CCCD?e
4.""
.#
," $ ,
A"9_d5CCCD?e
#!4!$4
%.*".( !')
.
$11,44$*
3,!*/
+$'/ ,(
A"9 d5CCCD?9
E.6,7,(5
"!*%,
,
+,%,$",+?0)$(+,,1
-$'(
6$"
UU
2,$("5
,
)'4 !14,
.#
_d
$114!,+
,
@(!3'*$4 !"
%.((,% 9
_C9
0"
$
*,%,""$(2
%.(.44$(25
,
. $4
%.)1,*"$ !.*
%.),"
.
A"9U
T UC5CdCD?
V BCf Cc
V .6$(+"
#' '(,
1(."1,% '"X
b
_U
b
_d
V)'4 !14!,(X5
f
A"9d 5CCC
V%.*7,* !.*$4
,$+"X9
@ '"5
,
,* $*%,+
%.)1,*"$ !.*
.#
!"#"$#%$%&'#
()*+
,-.
,/()*
01*
,2(3-0
(4
!"#%5#%%%&'
,6+*,.7
,8,+.*.#
,6(-98:01
:-0*+* 0
,0
01*
+,0*
(4
;!
<
=*+
,--32
4+(2
01*
.,0*
(4
4:6:-9
(4
01*
=+* *-0
,==*,6#
0:66
:0
+*,6:>,0:(-
1,66
/*
=,:.
0(
01*
?6,:2,-0',==*66,-0
/7
01*
+* =(-.*-0 #
,
(+.*+*.
/7
01*
@+:/3-,6#
8:01:-
,
=*+:(.
(4
2(-01
4+(2
01*
.,0*
(4
+*?*:=0
(4
,
?*+0:4:*.
?(=7
(4
01:
A3.92*-0!
B,:6:-9
81:?1#
01* ,2(3-0 1,66 ,??+3* ,- :-0*+* 0 , ,8,+.*.
/7 01* @+:/3-,6!
""!
C(.:47:-9
01*
,8,+.
0(
01*
,4(+* ,:.
*D0*-0#
01*
,==*,6
:!*!
BEF'G%H'"GG;
:
.: =( *.
(4 ,-.
,==*,6 :!*!
BEF';$5'"GG;
:
.: 2: *.!
"5!
*9: 0+7
:
.:+*?0*.
0(
*-.
,
?(=7
(4
01*
A3.92*-0
0(
01*
?(-?*+-*.
@+:/3-,6 4(+ -*?* ,+7 ?(2=6:,-?*!
"H!
I1(0(?(=7
(4
01*
A3.92*-0
/*
=6,?*.
(-
01*
4:6*
(4
01*
?(--*?0*.
?, *!
%J!"5!5%5H
KLMN E-O3+
PKLQR S1*01*+ =*,O:-9&+*, (-*.
T
U*
&
V(
S1*01*+ +*=(+0,/6*
T
U*
&
V(