Vikram Malhotra v. State Of Punjab And ANR
!
" #$%$ & '
(
'
)* +
+,
!" #$%&'"(&!) & "*"""+# # *", !
"!"*"#$%&'"(&)&$ &- +, - .*/
! ) & $ ' & ./- &( ! 0&$ &( 0 "+ &'$ !",( +$(&1 "! &( &-23$"$-423-32.
$ $' &.5-#.-4#536#2./"$2.7&(!$ ""+ 0&$ 8(&!&9!09:#"&+ '" & % &;0< "0 = 8> ?2:"$"++'&1 "+)&'$ " !(& #&! ," &('& $"$3/23-3258> ?-:" %$",@ !)" $&$$"$2A3--324#!)" @$ '$&"))" ,(&!+"$ "+0& B++"1"" "#(& ! "
'&$$C"&! &(!'& '& )+ "'!&(# )&&( $ ' "+" " 0+"# "#$"$-732-32/#!" ,' %$#@! # !",& '$!"!)" !"%+$! $ ) "
'",+=@ !& "= $ (+ '#'&' &&) "$ &&(!"''
$!"%,$'+"$")&'+"
$&(($ ! + ""
#&,*' %"$ &"+&("+ "+= & '&' +!&' "+'&(+ '"@ 1 $&+=& !")&)+$& &!"%&( !@ !"'!&!* &)&'! !&)&)=# ! &+ ("$+ ,="$&! !'
$&! ,=!+ "+= ! ' % +$ ) "!'&(+ ',@@&)" #!"% +&%& (&!&' "+&$#&' "+!" &=&!&' =" '! '",&+ ($& %&!)" &+! $ ) ,='& #&( '& #'& @ !'" + "+'&1 '"@++ &@%# ! ' "+$ ) $&&'" += '! +%&&+=@&)" &!$ ) &(! '&)#'&1 '"$((' !' "+ "'$&'"! (('"$'&1 '% )&!&' =" +" !(&#!+"@)' ,) !
#%) !
"$ !> ) !
# '+ $ $"!)"+=(&' "+"' &@%# &&(!&!' % +$ ) & ? '&(+ ' &( @& )" "(& ! +% & ' "+ ")'
!(&#!+ "+= )+"= ) &&+%!'&(+ ',@@&
)" C@ !!"$$$"D&( !"!"$% )"'&($ ) "&' ="+" E$ ++!'& $" &&+%! '&(+ ',@@& $,=) & !(&#%!' "+ +"@ 1 $& %$ "$&!@ !&(!)" &$ ) '& E ! ) ' )+&+=#!$ "+ "+= "+&)&% $(& '& E ! '& ,@ @& $ &( " ' "+ $ ) ' &A-300 ">))&% & ! "$ ! ' && &+=)&% $(&'& )& $ $ ! "+#, ) '& )& $ %""))++"&% &"+" &@%,= %=" "$'&)# ' &A-300'"&,!&+)& &=C@! !'& & &"'& ,@!)" !"%C'" +=C&,'&( $ ! ' &+"&+=&!&((')' ,$ $!$ ""+0&$
!""+& &&((')' ,$& $0%&!&((' > !0@$ &""$$$(& & # "D ! > &(('&,+ !& "$%@ &$"+ &()&&( &(&(('", '& $ % @&('!&+& '"+"$%"'
! ' ""$1 !$(&+&&D ,=&$' &A-3 00&'& !'& ,@!)" &$ ) &
" " !"' =&(!)&'$ )' ,$(&' "+ "+C! "+ 0& '"&,) $&"%+,=&$!'&))' ,$ $!" )&'$ '!$(& %&D ' &./-00,=! !
0& # " &,%$ ",&%# ! @ ! &( &+= )" & ! ' "+$ ) @& +$&"+@"=, (( ' & ""' "+ "+ % @&(!)"#+"& ,+(('C! '&$ '@& +$!"%+( "!&' ="+" !(&!&(' '&
$,=)& %&+%$ &%"'&"$ " &(&"'1 &(( ' "+)&@& @! +>' &(( ')&@'"&,) $&,'& $ D@ # % ! &(' %&+% &+= @& ) %" )&# , (+' $)"% =&('!""'& %&+% '" &"++&&(+ ( &'"
&"++&&()&)=,=>$
!"&(+& &( + (C '"& , ) $ & , '& $ >') ! ",&%?
&$ "%&(('#! %="&!""++&!&((' !& +$,) $&,'& $,=!0& '!)&&(&( &((',(&!0& #" " @& +$ %&+%!'&$ '&(!)" & $ ) #!(& (!0& $&&) !"
&,'& $ !!)" @& +$$&)+"= 'D )&!0& & ! "'1 "+&("''
$,= ,% !"$ " &&(' "+* ' $ % ! &("$ " &&(' "+* '&(&' !' E&+""$"$&)! 'D$ $&,)+"=$ )&0& & ,%!* '= & @& +$"+@"=, ! &(* ' +(C!"!'& ,@!)" '& E$"$!' E
" &&$ "$ '&
$ & ! "+ &( ! = &( "$ " &&(* '#"+"#1 "!&&(('#@! '!! &( &' =$&&) &,'& $ &9,+ ! ) 0& !" "
)+= '+" ( $ ! + "+ )& &&'& E '& !'"&(
!""$!"&,%$"
$?
! "
#
$
%&'
(
"
)*+ ,
#
+
,
(
!("
( - "
-
(
(
.- -
(-
(
/
(
$
($
(-(
. 0
1
(
.
( *
(
2
(
(
-
(
- -
-
-
.
(
(-
(
(
( -
(
-
-
(
.
# "
#
(
-
(
#
(
#
-
+ ,
-
#
3
!)'"$&&("++ "=&&(!>') &% " $ ",&% '# % @&(!)&&( $ ' "+" " 0+"# "# $"$ -732-32/ "$ ) "' &( ! &$ $"$ 2A3--324)"$,=! 0& #!0& (+!"& ( +) )& @& +$,%$,=D) !)&'$ "+ %@ ++, ! &(* '# (!+ "'!$,@!)" "'')$ ''&$ +=#!)) & "++&@$ &-23$"$ -423-32. $ $' &.5-#.-4#536#2./"$2.7&(!0 "&+ '" & % &;0< "0 =8> ?2: "$"++ '&1 "+)&'$ " !(& #&!," &('& $"$3/23-3258> ?-:" %$",@!)" "!,= "!$1 "!)) & . +, / (
% F!!)"D B"&$G & F!!)&",+G &