← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/21764/2015allowed

Ritu Prabhakar And Another v. State Of Haryana Through Distt. Appropriate Authority Cum- Civil Hospital

2016-06-03Mr. Justice S.P. Bangarh30 pages



          !

"#$ $%&'&() *   + &#, +"-."/"+"(0"(#.$+ 

 1#"#$ "+2"(""(0"(#.$+ 

  ) 34  1151                     ! 

  

 " #### 1516 $ %&

 '    ()     () )     *   +,- * *  .  *'

/0102-0$1 31#"#$ + &#, +"-."/"+$#%45(($7,+$ 6   

   7

 7  % . 5 ( 8 6  $99+ '-00-5    3*:% 46; ''    090+-0$1          '        7    0+0/-0$15(($7,+$ 6    0+0<-0$15(($7,+$

*6& (       '   ( '

   ( .   -    () 7  -          () !



  &     

   *     =    *           () 7   $  

   "&  >         

%

 ' &      $9 *:

%     22  $20--00-             8 -/0<-0$<& &

    -<0$-0$15(($7,+$ *6

    (  

   2 %   '   &         ?  @ >5    A?

@A6 ' '

  3% %(B( *  4 

   (  ?C -0$2      *   (    *:%  '

  '' 0/0--0$25(($7,+$ 86

( *  

  

21000"7& .  '      ?

@*  $,0--0$25(($7,+$  6 + ? '     ?

@*  '

  &    

  

  '    -<0,-0$2   $1$0-0$2? 

 '  "''09$0-0$+ 5(($7,+$ 6& (   ?   ! @'  D       &             ?

@" % *  "*

 *:% $99+?&

    ?

@" %*  '   . (       * *     *

   E(  

  *:% %   *  & (   @ '@5  6 @ 'F&  &   *:%  &  $99/

  ? '   *   (     3  *

45     6 1 %      

   &  (  ' '

   * E  G

 %     * G

 !

"*  (  $9$--0$+     

             '   

       ?

@         & 

.  *:% &    * &  !& &  '             & ( '

 B    

&*   0-0$-0$15(($7,+$ 6        & 

& ( ( ' 8'

& '

&   3 8    4  ?   * ( ?

@ .   /       & ( 

& &    (  

 $-0$-0$1( &      '  -<0$-0$15(($7,+$

*6

( * '5* 6   

       22  () !

&    *:%      =  * =

 

  *:%           =    *        (       (      

    <   (* '*'

   *  5(($7,+$

6& (    

  5%67 '7* 

     

    256+1/$,$9---2-1-, :-9 *:%  & -00* *  ?

@* & (    '   &     *:% &  

 

  ?&

 * & (    3 8  4  

'  '

 ( 

% &     '                &        ?

@   

 * %     & ( ?

@  &    

  (   

   %    *:% &  ( & 

   ''   090+-0$1 , B  '  &

         7         *D7$       B      *  ;*D7-    * G

 *D72 ?  ) * 5(($7,+$'  #  

 6   0+0/-0$1   '     &  7   ' 

"

'(  C?* 5(($7,+$ 5   6 9       7 0+0/-0$1  (  (      7        

   

 



 

    

 

!

"#$ % " &  

!

 

 

   

    

 

'

!

"#$ % ' " & 



 

  

(  

)* 

    

 

+

!

"#$ % , - 



   

. /   0    



    

 

!

"#$ ) $0      '     7

0+0/-0$1    '&   '

         0+0<-0$1  5(($7,+$  *6 

  (    

 C !      +,-* *  .  *'

/0102-0$15 6  

  

      *  :  %   ;    ''      090+-0$1          '       &    7    0+0/-0$15 6    0+0<-0$15 *6& (              '       (   '

    

( .   $$ % * 0,0<-0$1

 &  7 " 

 

  



  2)34)3+) $ 



 

  5

     ) :

$- ? 

'     '   &8  &   -25-6 *:%      (      &

   0/0<-0$1

(     !  *  * * . 

 (  

  &

$10<-0$1   )     

 

 7 0+0/-0$15 6 =   

  

    & 

 ' '  $2  

 (  *8  &  2$$0-0$1            (($7,+$    5   6      '   %? & (   ( ?

@ *    '   '(        

  '     3  *

4 *:%  $+ =   

     $2$$-0$1 '  ?          '  (     (  )    

  (                  '  "

   2$2* * ?    ?

@  ' '

 '

(  HI  ' 'I  ' '( 

 (  '         ( '

%   . '8'    &    '  ?

@   &     

                  (       '    ?  

('?

@ . '    &'(    

'      8      

  ( *:% ? 

('  ? 09$0-0$+5(($7,+$

6       ?

@*   *:% 

'  &   ?

@* &

     ' '

   $1 E *           (&    ' (        '' 

     *:% ?       (   &'   

  '  '         (  ' &        (  

'

   &   '       ?   ( &    & &      ' (    



  '  ' (  

*    -$ * '      &   . '

     

'   5 6 '

 -25-6 *:%  ?  (  '

   

'       -, %  $/  *  *  ('& 

      & (  *        (       ' 

7       2$2  * *       8       ?    

  ( 

 '    .   & & *:

%  &   '   ?    

   *:% (  ?

@ * &(     ' '

  

    =  *    (  

 

'

       '             &     '3 8   . 4&    ' '

 '

AHA:AIA E    &   09$0-0$+5 6

( *   '    ?

@*  ' (  '

& '     ?

@* &    (  '

   $< ?  *         

 ()& 

       (

      (& $, B   &'  

( 

)    *:%  & '





   '&    7   

5



 

!

"#$  0

 0   0    &" #    $ (  

 

 

          (



 

 0 

         



&" #    $ (  

 

 

     *    

 &" #    $ (   

 

 

* 

 

 &" #    $ (    

          

  *      (

   

  

  

  



    



)

  

 33*

 

!

"#$  0

    

 

  



  7  

   5  



 )

$  0  "), 33'

80))) ,)3)33'

  

0



      

 9& 

       



  *      *   

       (

 

        



  

       

 

 

  



& . 

   

 

   

 

     % * 



 0  

   ) 

 :



  $9 '     - *:

%  5   ''  & $+0--0026 &       '            7 . .- In this Act, unless the context otherwise requires,- (ba) "conceptus" means any product of conception at any stage of development from fertilization;

8 ; <



 



   = 

    0.

8 &   %

   8 ; <







  

 

     0   = 

  

8 

0 

 



     % 8 ;>  

<



 *

 *   *



   *  0

* 0 

    &       ) ?:   )&   

 * ;>  

<



 * 0  

 



  

   (   

 

  (  0  

     

    

 

    *

 %@

8  ;&       <



        

  



 *  * .

   

   *      *    

   

*  0

  >   A  >  

     

 &      



 

      %

* 0 

    &       ) 8 ; 

<



        

  

   

    

   



  ;

 

-0    27  * : %      ( *   3 8  4&     7       

 

& "  *



   

 

 

  *

        

  

      *   

0





 



* *  *     

  

    ) @   / *:% ) ( (

  ' 3 84   (      &   

 7        

  

)& -



 

*B8

>  





  >   A  >  

      

* A 

* &       (

  *   

  % 8



       &

      (

     

  % 8



*  0



*   0     

      )

-$ ' 

 (     '?

@?

 @ > &   *:% 8 

 '   

( *   '  09$0-0$+5(($7,+$ 6?( 

  

  

 & '( *   '&(    % 

  %  5 6B7-0$05(($7,+$ ;6

 3 %B-0$04( '  ' '(  )   '     

   '(   (&     7

!"#$%!



  +  

 0 

 ) $

 



  

  

  

) $

 

   

 

 

 

  

) 7 

    

    *

  

   0   

0      ) 

  

    *  

  .

&

 ) C   

 

 

     *  2+  

   

 .

 

  *

 D

0

    







&

 8 



 

5 

8

) 

         * A 70

462*   (

    = 

 E > :0

 .

* 0

&.





  %

*

 *





   

  ) F

0   

  .



  *

      = 

      %   

   

 =  *   

 0 0     0  0

 

    

 ) $   

  (     



  

     

0  

       *

 *   ) $ 

 

 

   0

    

   (

(   

 =     *  



) "   

  

  '" ()

*  

         + $ 

 *

( 

 

  

  ) 

 0 *

 

 * 



    

  

   

     

 *

    

     ) $    



   



    

8   = 



 .

   =  

  *   0     

*

      

    * 0 

 

  

     

0 

 =  0.

 



   ) :



 

 

-- %        &           &       '

 %

 &  >  ()(   *    (    ---2-1-/ *:% $99+%    (  '           7       &     

 6   &

& 

78'  %&'  * * '      

    '   =) 

     ' '

       7    &          '( 

    ('  $<25-6* *&   '

  $/$* *5 ( &

6 '  %       7     

'  2$2* *             (    *      7    %   

       

(  *  (& (  ( >'   -2   '     

   * 

&        -+1-+/* *  *  8'      

 ( 

    % '  (    (  &  (   '    %        '

& (   *  '   '  ' &

 '          ''



  & (

  % 

  

 *       ''(  * 



 '   -+ %       

              ?    @ >5?

@6*    '      =    *       '

< %

,<$' 

( 

   . '

   ?

@*  *:% 8 (     09$0-0$+5(($7,+$ 6 

 '( *D72

?

@   &       '  '  .      

' & (   ?  '(  &

*:%   '    '

?

@!&     

   





 %  5 6B-0$0 (   ?

@*  ( '  (   '      

7 -1    --      %     &     &  (  

  '     7     '   8     

 '       7 )

 

    

   

      

  

     

+ 8 "  * 

  * >  





* >   A  >  

 

   

  



     

&  

 

    

* A*

    )

 

8 " 

 

 

               



    

&  

 

     >  





* >   A* >  

    ) 8'   

0 



&  

8  &  

8   

 0 



 

0 

   

0   0 

  

  ) :   )&&  



  * H H





 *  *  0    



     

 



  *  *

.   )< -/ %   +  '

 8' 8

 -- *:%  '   &

   ' '( 

"

'

  3   8(   4'  (  ?

@*  % '

    &     ?

@* 

  ?

@ (   (            -- *:% ;(     --&  

    ?

@*  '  (          '          .   ?           

   (  -- *:

%  (     *  

  &  '      -<     *  '    

 

-2 *:%   &  ?

@ * &    '   

   &  =  * *   $, *:%        

* *    E(     *

&   

 7 32)  

,

-

- ,

%  ,

-

) 8 " 

 

 >  





* >   A  >  

 

 

  



* A 



     5    

) 8 :   

   

  &  

8*

 

    

 



        

    ) 8' : >  





* >   A  >  

 *      *



   &       (

  

  

 

,*

  

 

*      

0 

 



 

 ) 8,

5 

 

1*  >  





* >   A  >  

 



   &       (

     

 

    (

 









 

  



* A 

 

     

 

  5        

  * 0 

 ) 8+ " >  





* >   A  >  

       

  

   

   



* A 



  

       *



 (   

    ) '    7'(=+">.2  *      &  

   '   &    ' 

*D7-    $9$--0$+ &=     &   * & &  >(   B G

 5*D726(      @ 'A@A 8

      '   ?

@    %         '      . '    ' ' &        7         8(      F &                                 (     ''



 % * 

 '   

  &  (  '  (   

  '



 (  '

  -2 *:% (' &  &

       7 . 

)& 8  

     *   *  

        

   0 0

>  





* >   A  >  

 





* A 

  





     

  

* A 

* 0

  

 0 * 0 

 



  

     

 0  * 44, !





 

0 

   

0   0 

  

 



 (    * 0 



0 

    

0   0 

      ) ) $

 

     

       

 F 

      .



  

  

  

 

       

 

  

   



 

        

         (  ) ')   

0

.

  >  





* >   A* >  

      

   

     *   *  

     

         

   

   &

      (

  0

 

 

   

&  

8

 

,*  *  

 0 



 

0 

   

0   0 

     

        (   0 



0 

    

0   0 

  .  ) ,)

    *

  * 

   

&  

8' 

  0

0 0

         (



   )     -25$6       

   *:%    '  '

'         

$0000"7 ('



( .  '

'' 8     ( '

 

10000"7  -25-6        .  '  5 6(  '

*     ' 

  (

    



 ( &      -25-6 ( 8 ( 

'

         

'   (

  0/0<-0$1 -, %  *   '    -1  *:%   .      '

& 

('B  &    

     -1 *:% &     7 /0+ 

  

  

  "

        

    



    + & C 

 



   

  *  0 

  



 0  



*   

 0 



 

0 

  



 0   * 0 

   

 0  

    

0 

     0 

      

    0 

   



   

       )

        & &

 



            &    '  /

 '

  

(     =  *    ('    = 5    ' 6    @ '3@4&  '   * (  1   '%

'

         ?

@&  ('   

  

  &  %

   &     '

    ,&          '(   &  >

     

        '  & ?

@ *  

 8 &&  

?

@@   (         

          

'

& ( &   &  ' 8 &   

   ( *:% G     ?

@     &(   

  

  &  (  %  

'   -1          

      '  

       '

. ( (' -9 %       -/ *:%  8'

 8 -/      7 /1+  .      + & 8 C   * 

   

 



   *  

0*    0

 0

 * 0

 

 *   

    

 *

0

 *                



  9   

  



&  

     

   

 *   

   0

 0  

.

0             

  ) 8 "0     

&  

8* 0    

   

 



   

    



 0 



  * 

  



 *   *

*       *   *

*                       



  ) :   ) &

  

  * & 8 ;  <



  



 

 

  

   * 8 ; *<

 

 



 

  :

     '

   

 



3    '43 '

 4%   (  &    -/ *:%  (  

   * .     (  

           '(   *    (  *  

  '   '    '  '  20 %  *        

          -0     '(  (    '' ' ( 

'

  '

 (       &   ( ? ( ' &   (' ''  (   %  '

         &      '      (  (     ' 

'

  '

 

     &     G ' 

   '

 &  7

  ( ( 

 C&  

& &             %!A( '*  &   3?$+','@"+"2"( "4      8!16& &     ?

 &    &&

(*   '  

  

 2$  '

  

 '   '

     (  %    $ 

'

            

            

  

 * '& ''( ;(     '

      ' (  (  *          &''(



      >  

 '

  %    -, 

  *:%  '

  (,+#'."<<#"/$%=(&A"(%$ "( 

$(%$,(0$+#.&'%#$7%$>#(#.$%B><"&(#B"0$-2#.$">>+>+&"#$ ",#.+&#2%(%$+($06+"(2

&%$+",#.+&A$0&(#.&'-$."< -2#.$$(#+"< C$+(B$(#+1#"#$C$+(B$(#     -,       7 8 "

  .  = 

    

 



  8 $      *      =



 

 >



 >

*



 *     %  8  

0 

 

 

 



 



   *    *    

  

. 

)< '     '&

      < '(  -0$2  8        

                    &  

' 7 36 *  * 6     '' '( 

 D'*  '  ' 6     '(  ?  '

&  ( * 

'(   

     

      )   /5E6   &  

   '   &   (  (  

* 

 '

 '(&    '    )  >  

(  &''( 

   F    (  

   ' '  /5E6      ' '

& '

7 

      *

       

  #)))  

 



 # 0 

.





0

 = 

    

)

 %   '

     (  



      '  ((    *      >   '

 

    &     -,  *:%   * .    &  '

    

           *   '       '      

'

   (  ? ) *  ' '

 (   

  5%67 '7*    &''(   '  '     & -, *:%       '

  '     -, *:%  .      (& !&  

 (8'( (  *  (&  

  '   

   '

     2- % ' (  

   

 .    &  ' *:%  & *   ' 09$0-0$+58 7$$6 

(&       

  '  (

   &    *:%  (

& (              ?

@  '  

  

( *   '9 G ( -0$+5(($,7+$ 6 F  &  '  (8' '&  

   &  (     *:%       2$7 *:% (  (

    '    7 '&)

  



)

8      

   

&  #    $ (

8E 

  

  * 33*

 >

*    

-   >=*

.

 



 0  

  

 



         )   

  

   

 

      





 &  #    $ (

8E 

  

   * 33) 8 : 

   

 

   *



  

*   /   :      2$7    (         ('   ( *   '  

  8         ' '' ' ''   -00-5$+ -0026$+0--002=

  9 (  -0$+  5 6     

  (                  '' -00- .  ' (  (

  &  8     &  (    *    '    

   2$7   '    *:

%       22 %  &        -05$6  *  ?5&      7???@'  6

 (    

 8    &  '  ''

     

 ( 

 

 '  (   ( 

    *:% '  (  

 & &     (  '

   2+ * .  *    9 (  -0$+58 7$$6

 ( *    '  

.  (     

  *:%  & & ( !A(  '* &

         .  ' (      (   21 ?& 

 ' (  '  (          (           

  

    *:% '  (   = * & &      ''

  ?

@  * .   

 



   ' 

         *:% (   ?

@*     ((   '   (.       &     2/ % (  

  *      &8  &   +,-* * &     '   

(  & & ( !A( '*   '  &   +,-* * (8 ( !*     (  

* "  &   

          ('  ' !A(  '*   1"#&'.$.+"?'1#"#$  $<.&(+  * ! +&B&("<;;*&    7 20) $ 0

         

     



/ 



    

  



E  

  *

 *    

       

 

0    



     

 



 

)    

0 

    



 

 5  

   0  

 

0) $

 

0  0

 0   

  



 = 



 / 

) $ 0*   *    

 

  

     

 

 

  

0 

  *

*  

   

 

      *

 

 ) /0* 

0 *  0 0     

     

          *

*  

 

 ) 

 0 (    

 0  

0 0  *   *

 

 

   

    





 



 .

*

   

  

       0   

 

  * 

 

 * 

*



* 

   

 +         ('&&( B 

       !A(   '  *    1#"#$    @"+("#"/"  ?'  4 ,(&'.D"B2 8 1! ;8& &   7 

*  

0 0* / 



  (   



 0   0 

 

   %

5   (      ( )

$  / 

I

 0 * 

   



 *

   

    0 

   

     

0



    )





  *   5      * 



 

0     



 . 0 5   / 



(  

 5  ) $

5      

*



0  5   

  

  0

  *  ) $ 



 

.

  

   0     

5  

0  .



 0

/ 

  5   0

 )

5 * 0 



   0  

   5    )  2< ?& (*'

/ 0102-0$1

31#"#$+ &#, +"-."/"+$#%45(($7,+$ 6   256 +1/$,$9---2-1-,-9  7  7   % . 5 ( 8 6 $99+ ' -00-5    3*:% 46; ''  090+-0$1    '    7 0+0/-0$15(($7,+$ 6     0+0<-0$15(($7,+$ *6& (        '   ( '

  ( . 

  151!

  ,($ *6