Rajbir Singh v. National Fertilizer Ltd. And Others






 
 

 

 


  



       





 

 !"#$%
&#'#&(#
)$

  *


 !"#$%
+&)$)$,#
)$

  *


 !"#$%
+-). #
)$



*
/ 0#%0#&
)+#&.%1(#
)&
2--
3 !"#$%

--

#-.5
1$
+&)$)$,#"#$%
)2
2--
3 !"#$%
.$
&#.')$'6
12
.$5



 7
 89:


; :
; ::

9
**** 

        !"# 

   $ %$  !"$

&  ' !"

 &  $ !"

   $(  !" 

 ) &*+ !"# 



 ;.$ ##+
) !1-6

&.5#&
,-.

% /" # 0/  !&/  "112 # 0 / #3  #/

$#"4/

   56 1515 ,

8/ 79. $ + #   #' -:

15-2  -;

15-<             # #

+'  # "&$ =   &   $ " '  # "

!      '

  #/  "   /

        +'      "' !      16 51515 ,

8/ 77.  +'  # "'

 # 1" $' /'' / '+  

- 2 -

.,%'

,1.

%         ""/  0&  -9 5< -<<5   '  ""/ ##" 515-:

3  122=15-- /  "  751=15-=9:1=717 30 $    "   3  )  >  $    $     

''#  "

+ 8+# '/  17 15--    ##"  "'

' $  "'

 +   "?

""/   %  $ /'+ " !" ! / '   -:

15-2 +    @/ > $  $ "  /   3 # # $  #  #  6555=?

  %  0 ?)?75<?)A?15-2

#+ # 0/ ' 

/ + 0/!75:

15-2,

8/-.

#   / '  # "   "    /  !5:=52 15-2,

8/1. $!$ /

+'  #  + / " $ "  $ "

 $    /4/ +   56 15-2  B! /+   $ "4/ +  )! A "

# 0/!/ ' 19 5< 15-2,

8/-<. //     #

 #        11 -5 15-< ,

8/ 15. $$ !"# $ # -:

15-2    ($!     "   #' -:

15-2 -;

15-< "   $& + #

  "+ "   !  + ,7.

( " $

- 3 - )$%#$%1)$'

,9.

  "/  #   /'     

"+   / 1<$ /76#   B'

+,0 /")"  

.//#+ ' '+  /  # "   # " / + /     !     8   + ' /'"  '"

" ' '+ "/     "  $ /  +  "   #   / +

 " /"   // 

""/' "   + " 7--,1. #   0 /  # 3  $ "

'           ' '!  /"    & 8" #

 #'# "

  !  

/ + #

/" + '8"  "!/ ! ,:.

( /'       #"   "

'#/-<,-.# 0 0! !",0#" 0 

./-<2: !  "$ "/,.#" ! "7--,1. !& "  +/ +'/

+' 

/# " /"$ "

" "$   8'

+  $    "     /'"+   ' ,2.

3 /  )! A "

# 0/!/ ' 19 5< 15-<,

8/-<. "4/     "?""/ #   "

   + "'

+ $

 /   #/    "

?) ' /

 "   '  "' "/  /+"4/   /       '      '  !" $  #/

- 4 - 4/   #  #  !   &  / # '

+' 

"/+$  " //+



" " &

 '  #'   !+ 

 (   /    "  #       

    #' -:

15-2  -;

15-<  C D + 

+

 "  # C  $& +D  "'

+ '" "!  '/"

    "  # C D "

   !&   '

+$ 

 $

$&  + 4/ / $ ' / #"+& /# !"+ + ,6.

 " 




    " ! $  # " C D +    "'   

+  + # + +"



C

D /$ #" '"   '

+ ( #/    



    ! "#$  80/'

  " " #C D  8"     "

  

    $

  / ! '

  "+$  ""/' " /#+'

+#

# ?$&

/"

"   E"  '/"



#

 !"

 #'/+  $& /+  '! ,;.

+   "/  #   8    ?/  !" '# "' +'

 $ 

 "

/0" + 

/ #     + # ' $  '+ /

- 5 - '

+ 

    " + $  $  " !"  "' " !   !" !  !$ '"" 4/ " (# -;

5;

15-6,

8/ 72. / +  # $  ' #   " !"  "/' 

'+A     A $ $$" / !  '   !! "& $  "

)$%#$%1)$
)$
<#0.-2
)2
%0#
&#'+)$ #$%'

,<.

F ' #+ $      !    " !"    "  # '

 ' + "' "/ "

 +   "

 G  $ ! #'$

 +"/#/"

"  ""/ # +  ' # "  +   ' '  ( /'    "   "'

"

 !  "4/ !+8  '8'/'   # +  

   

  4/  !"  #  "!+ /     "  /'" 

     "' $  #      /

"

 "/+"

  + /+ %  " #C $&

+D    "  + 

 + "/   ' /   '

+ ! '" "&$ # # ! #"4/ "/+$  +$  #  "" "

,-5.

3#/   /    #! "!  "'   #"$ +     " #   !+ "  # /   ' 

- 6 - /4/   '  #$ #'    ! '   "' " !"/ //+#$ 

" 00  ,00 . / $   !

 / $

     "4/  3     4/  # "& $  # "4/    "  #"#"

" "

4/ # "'

"   / !/ #/$ #   !

'/$+

  ,--.

    "/  ! ' + "    #

 "'   + "'



 $    '

+  '" "!  !+ "  + "  8'     $  #" 

/# ## " # +   '

 "

"' "

"/'  /"

" #



?"& +'+"/' '

+" !"  ##  "     ## +   ' # +  "& $       + !     ! "  " " +  "" $ &

"  +" ,-1.

( "/ #  / ' $& ! 17 5- $.-5'1'

,-7.

'+"   $ /

# 3+ #+ #      $ $ $?    '   /+#!" + '!" # /'"

"& $  * #"&$ '#" 8" #"#"

"   " #C $& +D" !+

- 7 -

$  +   !"/

!  + #/ ,-9.






% & '


% 

    () % **+  / '0/    $ $ !" '!#'!""

"'"&$ '+"/

 $ /4/ + "4/      /'"  '   "& $     " 4/  ' +  #  %  0/ 8         # !" #$ #'   '

+E $   !!'     "' " +"

$ # "/ # !

 ,"






  





 
 

 


  







 
 


  


 








 






  

 



 
   
- 




 
!  


"  
#  




$ 


 
 
 

 
  


% 


 


 



 
   









 


  
"
 





  

 



./

 

 !

0



1  2/

/ 3

5./



!

0



1  2/

/ 34

*66-** -7


 
 





 



 
" 
&'(
 
 
" 
&)
*



 
  

 
  









 

% 




 







 



 
 

 
 


 

  
 


 









 

 
 
 

+ 


 
  


 
 ,
-"


.')

&/
0&
1
  

 
  


  



  


 
 
 



 





  




 

  






 

  


    

 

 
 


  
 


  
 
   

 

  








 
 
 

- 8 - 

 



 



 
 
 




 2


 
!  


"  
#  
 

 





  

 


    

8$  5    

8$ +***9+ (*7


 
 









 
 





  






 


 
 ,
-"


3(&

)/
0)
1








 








  


 
 

  









 
 
 




 









 
 

 




 


















  

  


  
 
 








 







 


 
 

 

2
#
4


 

 


  

4 

    54 

   "#+9- ( "7
 

 
  

 


 
 

 

 


  


   
  







  


  




   
 
   









 
 


 
  


% 


 


  



 





  

  

 

 
 



2
,-:.

  "  E  " #' /+ $ -:

15-2 -;

15-<$ "/# "    "'  "   +     %   ? $  /'   

3 "/

"

%  # ' $ #/  +   /"

 "    8" #  '

+E $" "' "    '#      #  #  E "4/   

!+&  "!$+ 

' 

" /+

- 9 - # !"  / 

 !" "  )  # "& $  $  #

 #   '  

+

 C  $& +D "/+    '

+  '# #'  

 !" /    "" "

#/$  "/+ " #" ,-2.

% E  #"4/ '/ " '# "  #  ! '"

""   # !  "     / '0/ !/(

0/ !'

"&$  '#"//  #" &  / # "

  /  # ?'

+'  # " /  + $   +$ #&

+/#$& (  #""

 

 

 "' "     +  '  # "4/   % + '+ "    #? " "    /   ! !" 3 /"

""/' " / + #0

  >/' #"&$ #-:

15-2 -;

15-< "/  $  " /+ # !"    '  "

  +  % "





 !

 C D #!#' ,-6.

% $ ""

+' ,-;.

 

" ,.# +  #   *   ;.$ ##+
) !1-

 !#

1. Whether speaking/reasoned?

:

Yes/No

2. Whether reportable?

:

Yes/No