High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/7016/2020allowed

Santosh Sangwan v. Ch. Charan Singh Haryana Agricultural University Hisar And Another

2024-01-11Mr. Justice Jasgurpreet Singh Puri11 pages

!

"#$ %& $'()(%* ++ ,+-"*#%).

-"*/0"*

.+ .","* -(*/.

",1"*"

/,('23#2,"3 *(4$,)(#15 ()",

",1"*" "*6 "*%#.$,

78 +

-

- - ! "

# " $$$$

- -

+

,"3 % ! ''( ) * + ,

-.-.'-'- / 01 !2

"

34 " %1-5'-%- ! ,

%%-.'-'- / 06 !2

+ 2

" 2+ ! 4 ! + 2" 7 + " ' !

34 ! "

!2 08 2

!2 08 2 %1-5'-%-

# "&

+!2

"2 "! ) )97%6:6- '-%-+;

) #+"%5-6'-%5 + 2 0

& #+"

!2 +<+%5-6'-%5

!

/ 0%& -(-5'-%5 / 0'

08 2

"

+;

" "" & #+"

+;

!2 !2 + 0 ! ) = 7>:% '-%5&

%'-5'-%5 ! /2 / 0' "" -(-5'-%5 / 0%

" 2& %'-5'-%5 0

! "# $ $% . + 2 = .%->'-%: " 2 ++ 2

"

!2 3 "

0

8 2 ! "2! +

/ 0. 01 2 "2!

+ " 2 / " 2""!2 2

!

3?!#!3 23+ )

+ +=7>:% '-%5

2 2

!+2 " " "! ""! & "2 ! 0 & !'$ $$!$ ($ ) * $

!

+ ,-$

!

+ $ . $ $ !

/0+ 1!2+ / /(

! $$ $ ($ ( 31 4

!

!

!-$ $ + ( - $ !

+ $ .

$

-+

-+ $

-

( $-$

$ $ (- $

!

.

+ $ . $ ( $-$

$ + +! + $ +% 1 + "2! +

/ 01!2 !2 + =7>:% '-%5+! #! 3 23+ ) "2

! 8 2 2"2 " " &

+ 0 @, 56)& 7

5 9$

9(. 54 9! 9(

/ .$ .'( $ $$$ 1 $$ 5

/5:9

,-$ $- $ ;44 ( (

$!!

+ !' -

$

4 ( + 1!2+ < / /(

! ! !

.$

$ + ! ,-$ ,-$

- $

$

$

# $

($

,-$ .$ ! !4 -+ + ,-$

$ + +! $

4% 6 = 2 " + ! ;

) -1-5'-'- "

! " + ! " ; = ;

!"

0 "

3 " 2 + + +

!2 "" " ! * !

!2

2 2 !# !+ , 2 + "

34 "& -1-''-'- 0

9

-.

$ $!+$=! - $ > )7 >' 9 - $!+ $

-( + .'

$ $$$ 1 $$ /5>9#

# $ (.

$

+ $ ( (

$!! $ >"?"# $ . $

- + !

!!$

3

!$

,-$ $ $!$

$ $

! $ !$

$ +2 +( $$

$ !

!!$ .

!

$=!

,-$ ( $!

$ $

$ $

$$$ 1 $$ /5:9# !$! -$

-.

+-

$ . $ $$ $ !

!!$ $"

,-$ $

$ ! $$ $

2!( $$ + 9( @!( .

$ % ( = -1-''-'-3 2 08 2

"+ / 01-.-.'-'-!2 + " %1-5'-%-

& "+

/ 06%%-.'-'-

! +! " + "

-(-5'-%5 ! & ! " + 2 "+ 15..'.A0

" "+ (>5%:(A0+ B ;*4 "2! A + %62 ; /

0106

+!2 5 )

!" "+ / 01-.-.'-'- " 2+ 3 !" %1-5'-%- + -(-5'-%5 #+"

+;

) !

" "!

%'-5'-%5 -(-5'-%5

" 2 3 !" 2

" / "3 !" + 2 =

+ !2 2

+ " "

/

-.-.'-'- / 01 !

" !

! 2 2

!2

3 !" + !

+ " 8 2+ "2

!2

"

2 > ) !"

"+ %%-.'-'- / 06 "

!!

-(-5'-%5 2!2

"2 = ! " ! ""!2

= + 2

:2 ! ! " "

2 2 ! ! " ! =

+! 8 2 ! " ,

2 2 2 !

,2 "

+ ! + ;

3 !" 2 80 2 2 "2!

+ C

+ "2! ++ "2!

!/ !2 8 2 / 0. + ++

"

! ! 2

3+ )

+ =

!

+ !2

= 2

+2 3 !" "2 !

! + 2 2+ 3 !"

" +/ 01 2

/ 0106 2

:

+ !! ! " 2! + 2

" 2 ! !2

"

2 2 : C ! " + ! 08 2 !"

"+

" 2 =

"2! + = ;

2+ " "2! + ! , %- * %%

2

2 + ++ 2

" " "

+8!2

34

#

+!2" !2 2 #+" +;

) / 0% "

0

C !

#+" + ;

" !2 2

-(-5'-%53 =+ #+" +;

=

%'-5'-%5

!2 -(-5'-%5 2* -(-5'-%5

!2 "

"

= 2 / 0. + +" + 2 2

" " ! = ;

! 2 +

2

: 2 ! + ++ "2 ! + " 3 "2!

" 2 /

2! "2

2 #+" = " + #+" =

#+"+ 2! + 2 = "! " D " %'-5'-%5

!2 -(-5'-%5 2+" + = " =/ 0. "

! 2 + ! ! !

! !2 " & +" 2 =

+ +;

+ 2

" "

! "

=

" + " %'-5'-%5 !2 2 + !

2 2 2 %' +" 08 2

"2 ! +

" "+ ! " ! ++ "2!

" 2 / #+" " +

2

2! ! 2

#+"

#+"+ 2! +! " " " %'-5'-%5

" ! 2 2

+ ! 2 + + ! * !

) + + .-- ) * ! ) + !2 +

2

* 0 8 2 "

"

2

!

2

" "

+ " / 0(!2 2%(-.'-'- = %. * "

& "+ -.-.'-'- / 01

%%-.'-'- / 06 !2 ,

& 08 2 " + " + 2

"+ %1 " + 7

!! 2

08 2 "

"2 + 2

+ + + 7 / " + #+" ++

- - '$

+ E A7 ! E A7