← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/21940/2015allowed

Navdeep Singh And ANR. v. State Of Punjab And ANR.

2015-09-23Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal18 pages



      !"# #$%&%'()

!*+##,-%'./0 1%'$#!'+!'"/#1  #"%"%'#1& 2& -"!"# 3'4!5!'+!'"/#1  #&,'+#'"& (

    

              



       

       ! "#

$%  &'%(!)* + # %  )* ,

&'%(!) '

%#%-).-( *

 /

 "

#  $%&  ''

  ( )* ) +   ,)( ,-  , , +)* -. -' ,('

%/

  /0 1 2  /3

0

4   #  

 22

/ $%&

5 /20          8   9 

:

0 0   

 : 2 



 , 3      4" %:7% " 7  &  2    & 0 /4"

; 

* * +  0" 3

   4" 

  00

  

6

< 

 * 2    4    03 2 0     =   04  >    4

0   



2 4 " "

2    4    3 





2 4 

00

0 4



0

 

3 6 4

4

2

4



00





.?,) 3  03 2  2 9   

  

 

6

@

 2  "

 "3  

  0"



" 

20   2

0  4 32 3

A 0  2

0 @

 2 

 2



04 4 

4  



 3

4



 2

"

04 4  

"

   6 00 

 2      





20  

 2

2003 4 



0

 2

04  4     0  



0 0 4   2 

"

  4 

     @3

0 2 

0  40  4  "

 & ))))?5 2  A

"

" 6   A2

 

  00

 0

2 

0 4  4 

   2

0 4 

0 

& ))))?5 : 00   "



 6

"

00

  



   

 2

2  @     2 $  3

) + 

4 3   = 3  00

  $ # 

:  $ 2 

&  4



    22 /0  3  4   0 7  0     04 

 2 4

0  4

"

  2  

      <2    

 



0 00

@  3 4

2 

  4 2 :  

 "

   

   3 

 2  6 3  4

2  

  3

 

 2  "03

"

 0

9

   2 2 $%&  ,!

 $%& 20  

00  

 2 03  2

    

6

   "

 "3  0

  0"



"    2

0 





04   

 3 4 



"

04

"

   /20  00 

   

  

 2 4 



0

 2

04 0    20  00

 2

0 



2 & ))))?5 



00 



 -!

@  " 0   * )* ) + @ 

  4

 2 4     @ 20 

00   

    %   +

4 "   



 B5 3    4  % 4 0  20  @  2     00 2 ,)( %/

+!

1  0      

 20 

40 22

  

4  *!

@ C

4  4 6 -.

/  /   #  2   2

400



 22

4



2 2  #    0

@ 6A 0 C

     2 %'

-! "0

      / 123'!'42  & ) 0

   " )  )% / 11+'! '564

  7 )  8 0

  ')- $ !" )% /  122'!'431 22  3   '(-  

/ $ . - 0

  0&  )%' 9

 )'' )% /+66,:+;  :

;356:;

@ 0

 22 

  2 004 5    

              

             

 



     

             

     "  #  $ 

    "      %

    



  



 "    " " 

       

     !     "         



  "        

    "        

                 !      "

    "     

   

              ! 

  

  "%    





      "   !    &       



       

       '    "



  !     

              

         

    !

     !    "

   

                 (      %     

    #  )* 

+    

  (,    (                       #    )*     

 +                   

 #  -.!      

+        # "

, "

# !

/  0 1  

             " 

    !    !     

  "    "

                      



    !                             

 

          

  "

    "          

!    "

      '              !!!              

"

     

     '  

'     "  

 



"

 "

    2      

 

       "    !    ! !

      

            

     "   !            

"   

   

 

 



     "

    

+        

 

 

 !

   !  3 (!

$00 7  7'

$-)%-)( )%

      <')& #  )%  )/  +662:,;    :

;  6=+   4 -.

/  /  0  6 4 #   

  



  @ 4

 02 2 

0    4

02 64  4

C 3  

4 2

 @   3

 4

  4 6 -.

/  / @ 4 -.

/  / 

C





  .!

%

 & ) 0

   " )  )% / 11+

'!  '  564 4 6 -.

/  /  4 

6A 0 C 4   2

0 % 0   4 0

C  

 

3  4      

3 

 0 2 2 2 0 C  0  4  4 0

C 00 6A 0 C   

00  4  4 0

C 



 

0  

 

   7  8   

 !

     !

  !

    "   %    

            "       

   "       !

%        

  

    8    

          !

   !

 

  " !

"

 &9      :

   "

     

    #  7;<071       2    

   

#   7;;01  -  8     

 !

   &9!

      

  

   !     !!

  " 

!

%     

    )  8   

   &9 

 :

      5 :

       !

 

   

   2      !

   #  7;;01 

;  8    

   !

      &9   !

  

     



                    



    <  8     

  

   

"         0      

        1    

                  =  

                                                    

"

  8    

      !

  "

  

!

   =       

   

    !   %         

 



  !      

 3

'!

% C  4 -.

/  /  2 



#  4     03

#  4  402

2 03 0 0

  22 0   0 2 0

0  2  %

 0 4 4

     

   2

  22

% - )-)(0

  <')& # )% )+6+:4;

 :

;=4, 6A 0 2   3 2

 

  004 5

;      !  ! 

     !!

 >     '     

      &9    !

 

                 !     

!

           #    -?          

 

 

 

 "

       

  

    

  :@0 1      0

1

  

     "    

'  

  !

 &  9!

           !                         !                 "    

 

           !           "

     !                 ! 

  "  

% ! 

  "   

    "  '             !      !A  "                      #                

  " #

" "!

!

    

        

             

  

% +        !!

 

   %   

"

@          " 

    '    

              B    

          "     5!

 "   



                        '  

 

"    !!! 

 

  !        

 

    

%                    !

 !"

  "    "      



   

   

               "

   !

"' 

   



   !

!

     

  !  

"    !  

%

  

        

          !     

   ! "'   

   



  !

    !     !

!

 

     !                !    

     

 "            

    

        

     !

        

  

    !    !

!

        !       

         



  

          

 '  01   !

   

     '  

   3  )!

@ 6A 0 2   4 - )-)(0

  <')& # )% )+6+:4;  :

;

=4,/ .-!"'& &0

)-)-"'(%!-)-  /

/ )%-(  )% /+6+:5;3+1



   ,)( %/ @ 6A 0 C 40 03  - )-)(  D 0  

004 2    

52

0 

  

   2  40

2

  @ 

 0 

6A 0 C     4

  

0

2    5 2

0  0      - ) -)(  D @ 6A 0 C  #  2  

     40  2

 

 4    4

3 C2  3 

 3 @ 

  

004

2 

  

23

23

4  % 2  6  ,)( %/

004

2

$%&

0 4  #  4 #  @ #  2 

 ,)( %/ 2    0 

 6A 0 2  -)%-)( )% 0

  <')& # )% )/+64:+;  :

;43+     6A 0 C 2 0  2  ,)( %/  



 3

52

0

   6 40





#   2 02

4  C  4 -.

/  / $004 0 4  4 

,  25 -7  

   

   !



"  

 

            '   !    !   

        #    )*           

  !    '             

    ! 

     

 

  > 01 +         #   )*           ! 



 !

     #  -?  ,   #    )*                

   '  

           !



   

      !

   !                

  

 

   01 8    

             !   

'    

        

      > 1   

   

      "  8          ! 

   

 

      01 #                               ! 

  "  

% ! 

  "  #               

  "  #

"       

      

  !!

      

   

%   +                   !!

   "  +

  #    %    

"   '  !  "

!

!

     !     0C1 D         

          "     5!

 "   

   

 

"         !! 

              !





 "   

'     

            ! !   0C1 8             

       

"     !  

%    

                

            !  

          !  "    '     

   0C1 D   #  -?+  

      "                      

"  

 !  

  "  



  

           !     

!      #    -?  +     &9        !      

  

     

  #  -?+    %                 

            



     #  -?+ &            "    "

    

" 

  

=   



"  

   2 

 

       "   !   

     D 

     

"          

         

"

                     !  

%  !            !  '  

      

     

!



     

!

       

     !

  !   

       

 

"  "      !   

     !"  ! !

   



0C1 8                

     #    )*             ! 



            !        

!! 

"      

   !!

        !

  

        !

     !   '   

  =                          



          $ %

            ! 

      "        

  "     

         

"

        !      !  =!

 

!   

 D                   

!  !

                    !

      !  !

"             

  !

          #    )*          

 

       

"!    !              #    -?  +    !!

      #

"          

"   " 

  !

 

 

        !  !

!

   

 

           !     

' 

    

"    " 

         #  -?+   

"

     !      

'  

   "   ! 3

%     %"  < %  0

 . 8 )%  / +64:4;  :

;+6+ 6A 0 C

   ,)( %/





 3



 

  

4  4

0  4  -)%-)( )% 0

  <')& # )% /+64:+;  :

;43+ 4  

  - )-)(0

  <')& # )% )/ +6+:4;  :

;=4,

    % 

   4 C  -)%-)( )%  D

0046 " 4  

 2     ,!

% 00  

   4 2 <0 C  4 6 C 2 4  03 

0 "

   40 







40 0 03 9 ,)( %/  00  3  

 

  

  ?3



   2 2 6 40 

   203

   ,)( %/ 2 $%&    % 00 



4   ,)( %/

       "   $%& %

24 0"

  3  

2 4  3 0   

3  4   2 2 

       

2 0  





0     4  C 2

4    03     

0 "

2 %  #  2 

   ,)( %/ 004  

 3

 



0   5

DE <  40 2





 ?3  

06  4  

  03 4 

DE 0  4  "

0    003

C 

C 

 



3 DE     

   4



2

02 03

   4 0 ,)( %/

DE  2

3 2



4 

/  0  0 

0  2   4 0

03 

  



00 





 2     0 4   C   0 4 4  03 4 

 2 

0

  6   0 



 5 

0     ,)( %/

  2 

 22  -!

   20  %

 

2    

 +!

1    0   2 %

 9

2    

 

   +

4 "   

    4   @  2   

  0

03 ,)( %/  *!

% 4

    

  -.

/  / 

C 4

0  2  -)%-)( )%

 D  (!

/#03  

004 &0 03 $%&  ''

  ( )* ) +  ,)( ,-  , , +)* -. -' ,('

%/   /0 1 2  /3

0

4   # 

#  2 

,

) +

 -  %