Union Of India v. Ex 628765 G Wo Retd Bharath Singh Dhull
!
!"
##
$ %"&
%!
!"
#!!
$ %"
# %!
!"
#$# % &&
'
# # $ %'
# %!
!"
()($*+ ', '
*
( )*( + +( ++ )*( +,-++
- ./001
"230 4
0 /5 /67 8 /+0/01"230 197 :5+ ;(#;#(< 0 "
&.00771
0 /5 /1 97 :5+ ;(=;#(>5+ ;)#=#;#(< ?????
+( ++ . / *0 =
,@ 7 "
1 6 !! "! 9 5+ ;(#;#(1 ;(=;#(0"5+ ;)#=#;#(A@03.."
07 2/2 "7 6!
7 0.
+77 3 9/ 3 !0 0"97 0B 932 19030 80B 9.5+ ;(#;#(
:<
7 !
17 370// 8 7 .!8 ""
"0 "=$ #$ : C ;=<!0 " A@7 / " .
"3 'A0/1 80/ , 371 570"807 :7 09 " 0 D7 'A0/E<1A@673717 =70A
7 /"A "9 "0A/@ 9"0A/@!
F$#G0080#G9/9 0/8 677 0 0
"3 !/03 /03 !7 !97 0 "30/,0"9 =7/"70787 "0A/ 9
0" 702
9" =1A7 0""0A/ 702
7 /"A@ 0 "30/,0"A D 7 0A0A/ 088020 "A@ /0@ 7 107 .
9 0 173.! "0A/@ 600 "FG3.! 9/9 0"7 /"A 7 0A0A/ 088020 "A@./0@
17 809A 99"0A/@ !
0"7 99"99F$#G =A@7 'A0/2"
.!8 ""
"0 "=$ #$: C ;=<A@!/038 /03 !7 H"8.
9 59"0
(=9#"
3"
"#( = #/ "0
.3
+ 702 7 0"/ "3 0"702 8 7877 30 9/ 677 0A/ 003
$
7 30 1033 "90370 = 60 3 ".@$ = =)0"60"3708 "= = #= "
7 /6.
"30/30 8@ 3 1 =70 2 "90 !
"9. 70@ 017 "0A/ 9
0"
:< 6737702 33 ""87 "1702 A 0A "7 ./0@ 0"7 3/"A 0!A/@707 0.
60088020 ./0@ B
!82 67 20 !86737 =70 2 ""8@ 09 677 ;9"0 0/033 "9037007 .
7 =H "7 0.
"93
$ = =)17 60 "30//@ C0. "0"609"99 89.0@37" 0 1 A0967371 =60/.0 /@"3708 "9. = = #=09 3.!/ 8. 70@ 09
(
!
7 !3!/ "A@ 59"0
/!
# 0'+ #".
1 6737700/A
3"
'A0/7 .!8 ""
"0 =$ #$: C ;=<10@993 287 .
"3 167 70""
8 7 .
"30/ C0.007 .
97I7 30"
609"99 89.0@37" 0 070.
7 A09 67371 7 I7 70 A
"3708 " 9. 1 37 0 .!/@
"97 99! .!7I7 9020!
/ $0" 9D / 9500/@
0@60"1=E707 0"
"0A/@70A
303 .!/@
"87 30
0"
171 "97 99"0A/@!
'7 20!00
#0"97 H"8.
30 :!0<0 0"
-;
J# 7 30 "! "70 9 0@ " 0 70 A
3"
" 0 7 .
9 0!!
//0K 033 !03 9 ./0@
'7 702 90/ " A8 3" 0@ "3.
88 70 7 0!!
//0 60 "
0.
9370" 0 A@7 "0@7
:< 99 89.37" 0
0A 90@ 3"07 .
9033 !03 9H8 9 0!!
//0 60 3.A 7 !0 9 7 "30/,0"30//9 3"0"/B7 0.
9 3.80!707 " 0 3/"702
"
".
"30/ C0.0 ! 7 033 !03 9 ./0@ 1 A 787 3"88 700@37 3"6030// "9A@7 "30/,0"/B 0" 0702
3"
"68 3.
7 33/707 "0A/@" ./0@
9031;0!!/309."9 "30/ ,0" 0!!0 9. 5/0 :"< 9 !0080!797 !97 "30/,0"1 673709//6- J:"<7 30 90"0A/@"
57 A0"
7/"0 670 C03/@7 !7 30 9
0A/@ /0 "./ L
! 97 09 0"!217
038 7@ 90/ " 3 70 7 "30/,0"70"82 0@ 0!!9 !1!03/0/@67 7 937 " 0 "0A/@020/0A/ 7 3"9 0!!
//007 .
9033 !03 9./0@
+7887877 09 0"9037
0387@.
37030//@!0 .!8 ""
9 3A0 "7 !9 "30/ ,0"
!
/ $ 0" 9 K / 9500/@
0@60"1 =K17 0!!
//0 "9! .!0"
99! .!7902 0A 9 0@ 2"
3"76707 0!!
//060 99 89.M* 0/ " N :
!/ !@<L07 .
9033 !03 97 16//A .
:$< 707 0!!
//060"!7@30/0".
0/ 3" 0 7 .
9 8 7 0"
0 7 7 0/7 70 0B !/03 "
L )
7 10!
7 "!3!/ 9/06 "A@
59"052/!!
0/ =I#=
1!
#1+ 2+#'"#167 70A
7 /"
700.
"3 !
/ "A 80 "7 99 "89967 80""0A/@!
1 !
32 97 903707 60 20/"0 " 9 1 " 008 7 08 9 !
003.!/ 97 97 808 199" 99 89..
"0A/@67370A0A/ 088020 /0@
20!0097 H"8.
30 :!0<0 0"
-;
J ,@7 90!!
0/7 0!!
//0:< 0 7 O 167 10"2"0/167 70 "0087 08 9!
00 3.!/ 97 9 808 199"
A 99 8 9. .
"0A/@ 6737 0A0A/ 088020 ./0@ 1
"A 80 "7 99"8;999 "0A/@ !
'7 0!!
//0:< 7 6/"
3 " 701 7 A0 9 53/0
=:<I)I:
;5< @9 *2 .
9"01"0 "= ##=17 09 0"
9.0"
020/0A/ /@0.
"3
/6720/"0 "9 10" 0@ 7 30 8@ 9 .
" 3
"7 0A2
$ + 702 7 0"/ "3 !0
:(< 7 /
( + "
0@ 7 .!8 H"8.
:<0""
:<0"7 9 0//7 0!!
0/ 6737!
07 33 !9"8;9997 "0A/@!
0 ". "167"
0 3
) '7 ".0/97 .0 6//A 0B 9A@7 87506 //0A@7 'A0/ 8080!!!0 / 97 A 9 .190@1670 8 80 "7 "0A/@!
L
'7 59"0 H"8.
!0 52/!!
0/ ====9#$1"
3"
"#= # #$/ "0
!
707 809A 9 9"8997 "0A/@0!
30 :!0<70080A
!7 /"16737903708 ; A "07 70"97
"3 70A
0A/ "! 0"!!9/067028A
59"0
30 :!0<1 30 :!0< 0" !
30 :!0<
=#
&
!8 2 6 7 " !3!/ 9 /06 "
30 :!0<1 30 :!0<0" !
30 :!0<06 //07 9030"33.03 97 30 70 0 7 .
9 31 7 = 60 .
"30//@
C0. "0"609"90// !
30"60/@09 = "
" 9. 70@ 0677 ;17 609"A 99 89.09 0""0A/@0/8677 90370 38 2"
I.0 0/"
0/ ".
"30/ 3"70A
A87
:)< 3"7675707 "0A/@0A0A/ ./0@
'70A 817 0""0A/@70A 0A "7 ./0@ 0"7 !9 "30/,0"300B 060@7 879 =3/0.7 99"0A/@!
==
7 08.
70A
0
=
17 0A 90@!
2 @A 8! "7 .!8 " "
"0 " =$ #$: C ;=<5+ ;(#;#(4 = == #$: C ;=< 40"= # #$: C
;=<5+ ;)#=#;#(!0 'A0/ 7 7 A097 903 7 " !3!/ 9 /061 8" .0"
9 0@ 9 A@757 9030"33.03 97 30
=
33"8/@17 6!
0 ".
=
73!@97"
A !/03 "7 9/ 93 30 / +( ++0 /,-++
0 (34
.!
!"
+7 !
0B8I 0
+7 !0A/