← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/12117/2019allowed

Jayanat Davar v. The State

2023-01-06Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil12 pages

 

        

 !"!

#$%&&   

     

    

 ! "#

$ %

   $  '() & * )*)) ( ****

& '

!(   '

) $   '

(*   '

)(   

'



!    *#+

, -+.!/0&  

 

%  +$'"'",-,,."-/,0 +$'"'"

,123,"-/,0 +$'"'",1245"-/,0 +$'"'",1243"-/,0 +$'"'",1244" -/,0 +$'"'",1242"-/,0 +$'"'",1241"-/,0 +$'"'",122-"-/,0 +$'"'",1.01"-/,0+$'"'",11/-"-/,0+$'"'",11/2"-/,0+$'"'" ,1153"-/,0 +$'"'",115."-/,0 +$'"'",114,"-/,0 +$'"'",112," -/,0 +$'"'",112-"-/,0 +$'"'",111,"-/,0 +$'"'",10/-"-/,0 +$'"'",10/."-/,0+$'"'",10/0"-/,0+$'"'",10-."-/,0+$'"'" ,1053"-/,0 +$'"'",1050"-/,0 +$'"'",103/"-/,0 +$'"'",1034" -/,0 +$'"'",122,"-/,0 

) 6   (% 

 

 4/ 7

 8 + 9 ) $   :(% (  +   #,002  ,002# ; % %

+$'"'",-,,."-/,0





- 2 - 

) 6  ( (%  < +8'=1.

 -- /4 -/,1 

  > 

    * ? 

   4/   7

   8  +  9 )  $   :(% (  +   #,002%  +  +'!  ( @

,#*

 6

-- /4 -/,1 @

-#((

'=   ( '            A

# "  (% 



 

 +(%   ,042  

; ,031

 B  (  (B

%   (%* 

  -/,. 

-5 /0 -/,.B(

 +

%  ;  +    (  % %  

    



 B

(

:

% ; (-,

* 

   -/,2 % B

C

 '

 *



8% =

% :(%   

(

 

 

 5, ,/ -/,.



%  . ,0318% 

%B

 

  *



* )  %  *  

  -5 /- -/,1 B 

 

%) ' )  

  # !  ( D   (%    

 (%



  *   

 -2 /- -/,1 *

 ( **  ( 

   

#   (     * ( 

  ') (  ( % 

( (         *          = B (  '= (

< 33

- 3 - 5''  ! (*



7

 8 +  9 )  $     :(% (    +     #,002  ,022# 



*

( * *   ( 

  E   C   ( 

  B

 ( % *



* 

 

 * ) B

(   *)  

8   B   %    (%    



-2 /- -/,1 @

3#

4/5# ,002  (%

     %% -0 /5 -/,1 (% 

  -2 /3 -/,1  @

3"#  F G

% %% B

+

% ;  (

 % 

 B( 

 -2 /- -/,1 (% %    *  G

%

 F

 (%%%

B

+((

   

  +

 %  ;   

     

      % 

     

 

    ( B =   *

   B

(%

*B (% 8/5 /4 -/,1 +((

  (%

(%

*

B =  %

 % 

%  @

,#   

-, /4 -/,1 (%   

     B ( 



< 4

- 4 - ,0-3-.   F

(%    ( (% 

8 -.

,/ -/,1   (%       A



  

 -4 ,/ -/,1

(   +    +' !  (  

   (      ') (  ( 

% 

 (%*  

/, /5 -/,0    +

 %  ;      



     %   

%B

  

        %%   @

2# *   (



=  ( 

  B 

          

  

   +' !  (((

 

(%

-- /4 -/,1





B BH 

 (   %  % 

%

 *  (  (  =%  

% 

%

*

 F    

 %    

=%

( 

 B

*  %% H  ( 



   % 

   

 

   (      %    B (%

4/ ,002  (%  (B

   $

 % 

  CB

 %

 +  H (   !#1 2"&3"&#",

20-!/+!#.1#2&2!4!#/,, / &56





-, /0 -//.I

- 5 -    

   %  +    $   ; ("# 

 ,002    (   

 ( 

  J

+ ; 



%

 (%





45 K002 

    *      B

 



   (%

 

 

  '=   ( '   *  

 *

 5, ,/ -/,. 

 

 -5 /0 -/,. *   B(

    +

 % ; 

 

B

 

5, /4 -/,5'

 *



%    -/,2 

(

 ( %

 -/,.

 ( *   

  

%B

   (%  ( % '

 * %  



( 7

  $

   B

 % 

   

          (% B

(%



 B 

%

 ' 

  B  

 

   ,3,   < B

 (  8   

 

B(

  AB  +((    AB  %  !  (  % 

(  '= ( /5 /2 -/,4    

   B

    :6  $ (  ,0.2 %  



%

 B

(* 

- 6 - B G(

 G(  $ '  (%   *    * 

*  +

!%

8%  ' 

% 

 ( 



(% 

(  @

 $,#      

     @

-#

* 

( * B (% 

 (  

 +(% A

 

 

         %   (     *  (

   -/,2"-/ * *  (

  ( *( 



 (  

-/,2"-/-/  

 *    @

3"#  * 

-2 /- -/,1

B (  (%   BH *)   

 (%    

=  * 

 B

(%          B       

(% ( %  ; %

   A

 '=    * (   (  A

 

  %   (%       A

* ' +"+ (%   

    

 %%

     (' 

,002



 

% ; ( < -  @

3"# ' =    * (   ( 



-.

/5 -/,1*

%  '= (*

 -5 /- -/,1

(

 (%   

  '



B

  (*% 



- 7 -

 

 %  

  B   A

   *(  (

A 

( (%  



%    





(   

 B

 

 (% (B

*B   %    (%   (%  *    

6

 B (%

 (%%   +'!  (

 

  (( 

       =%  (% '=  (

(     (% 

B

@(



   

 !  ("

% 

(  '= (

,002 $



(



  5.  

533/ ,002 $

,/5,,4,,.  78+9$

-//4  33 ,002%  

 

B

%B

   

6 %  B

      * )   B ( 

  

 % 51 ,002 

6

  

+((

  %%



  B ( *





- 8 - %  ( % -# 

   B (  (    *

    -#  ,002



&" !"#



 

       

        



   

                      

 

    

     

  

      

                  

  



   

             

   

 

    

     

         

    

 





  

               

     

         



  

  #

+'" % #  CB

%

+ 

% 

  

   

$ %&' ( 30, *

 

"  7   

 

  *

+(%*

*

 

 B    +(%    *   B +(%

 @ 



&" "!

       

      

            "  #$  % 

&     '            

 

    "  (

       )  "

&  * #+,-        

      

  

   

- 9 -

    

                   

      

     

 

   

 

 

           .)    

                 



  &               &  

  / 

           

    

  

  

 ,  )   "

&  * .0   

                       "  #$

    

      

           .)              

  1  

    2 &  

  

  

 

 ,  )  "

&  *          &  . )     &     

         

. 0              &         



 &   ."             

 &   

 

 ,  ) 

"

&  *          

      3  :(%%%

#   CB

%

+  

   (%

B 

B B

I B

(

I

B



 B   (%   *   B (%

* 

&" 43'                          

         

       

       

 .0   4 

       

- 10 -   "     



 

 

 

                     

 

               5 

 

      

  .* 

       

       5           

 .)    

        

  

     

. 0    

     

 

    

 

 .    )*  + ,

-    % #   %%

 *

+

'

:@  

!

'   !

' <  ( * + %  (% *

 ( ((



43 ,002   

 *

B  

*(%B  (%

%   CB

%

+ 

&" 0  

 

               

     

  

     

  

  

    

 /      

. )   

     

        

     

   

 

  /     

            

 .   +(B)   

   



 * '=   (   (   B

 *   ( 

  > ?   '=  ( '   * B

  

  % (B -/,.  * (

 +

% ; -5 /0 -/,.

; 

   -/,2 ; ( < -,  * 

 ( 

  '

     

- 11 - % =% %     



  *  (%    A



*  

/, /5 -/,0 +

% ;    



 @    % =   

%B

 *

        * '

    * * 

    % =  %  *

%B

 

 *

* )     B

%

B > ?* (  -# ,002 8%  (% 

 ( ( %             ') $(  (   B

 (%

        

% 

    

=%      %   %  ; ("   

 A

 

  

     

%

B   



* F  * =%

( 



 (

 B   +

 %  ;    

 '

*  * (  ( 

*B   +

% ; *



       F



 *   

 #       * *    =%   

( %  :

 (%B

(%

% (

 $ %-  % # *



 

- 12 -     ,002  ( B   (% 

  

  

 B '  

 533/ ,002 $

,/5,,4,,.  78+9$

-//4 *

 (

 B   +(%   B      +(%   *    

B +(%

     

  

     +(% 

B "     ,002    

  B  

%B

B  (% 

 

     



(%

 (%(*

 (% 

  *

  * B +  (  *  (%  @

,#(B



%





()  B

 

   %   

*

I   (% 

-- /4 -/,1 @

,#*



-- /4 -/,1 @

#

 

/2 /, -/-5 6.6

7*#+

, -+.!/8 -+.

1. Whether speaking/reasoned?

Yes/No

2. Whether reportable?

Yes/No