The Haryana State Cooperative Supply And Marketingh Federation Limited v. State Of Haryana And Others
!"#!$%&%"'())
!"
###### $%% & % ######'% % ( *+
) ,,
,
%( #)% *"+ ,- .& #
#
/,)-0,#
#'## ,- .&% 1#2## ,
,
) - .
#
% %3& -.% 4 & %&5 &%%.&/ & & 6% " 2# # 7-8 9%% 3 -
& . 0", , )", 7% 1#9,%/% "
#
7-8 9 %% 3 -
' % 9,.%,,.
7% 1# 9, & & %%. & / & " "% . % 1#2:
; !" " " & %% " '%# ,,< 4 .% #
# ! .% 3 & & / 3&% &.%& .%,%3" ," !"
7- =)9,%.%. % .% -., ><# '% 1#2 " ; !" ,%%.%. % &% -.#
&?%% 3- =)&"%/
"3 % "%/" .
6% % / % 1#23 #
"% % /%6 3.
&& / && %&" & %& 6%#5 % & %.%
># #
%% ' %,.%,, -8 % . %& " &? . 2 #
< &&.& ' %,.%, , / % % &&.% & 0", :- =),-'@; . %%/%#5 % " ,/%% / .
6%% 3& 3 ,% 3. && :- =)3& & 5/%& % .3 %/ %..& %.
6%/ & % ,.%&&, %%3 & / 3&8 - =)4 / 3 . 3 3 ;%.
% -4 & &".& 6%# & %3" , %",3& &% .% . %& " , "/%
2 6 3. 3% 1#2:3 && / & %# 2# & %3" %.%.
6%/.
/ % && %, % % ".
%" .% & .% -., ><, / & 3 . %#
) ' %, .%, , # #
27-89,/ / ." .% & -.,3% % %% ." 3& ", " ""4) ' % 9,.%,/ &2 % )' %,.%,;
/3 "& """,% %"/ & %#5 %",3/& , "/%& """ )' %,.%, ;
/#
&, "", "% & ) ' % .%, ; /,
7-89,% .% &&.%& 3 , ."& :- =)" '%# #
% . 3 %#5/%& % & 3
.""% &" A %, 3 / % " B C " - =), %. & A % /% .% %3# <# ! .%& & %3" % " """% & %.% &
< " A %,% %3 BC"#%3"
%.& , /% "& '%# ,A ,AA243.. %BC"/ 6% /. 3 A %#/, "/%..
3 % %.. % /% % % #
&, & . 3& -
' %7 9,.%,,.
, % % .%#/, %"/% -
' % 7 9, .%, ,
#
7-8 9, 3 3% )%% " "",/ - =) %. , %& '%# ,A ,AA24 )' %,.% .%&8" %.% 3%%%
% 3/ / . %% &/ . . & . " .%# 5 /% & 3% /% &% % %% ) ' %, .% " "" . % %%& &% 3 . 3 & "# @ 3%% & % 3%%, -
' % . &#
& .
-
& . 0", ,)", ,/ %
2# # 7-8 9 %"%% .& / /%% 3# %3" %"
A % %3& .
/" %, "-8% # A# ! .%& %3" .. .% /% 3/&" 2 #
<, . %/ &
3. . %-8 , %.&%&&.% & 0", :- =) . %%, /%..%& )' %7 9, .%, &" .%,/ 3 /%%% 3 %. "/ & & %#& %3" &%"" %3
%. & . & " "", / /% .. %, %"/ " %.. % .%#%3" % " "&%&" &8&&
%&" %& 6% %"%33 .. 3% 1#2:3 # # @ , .%&% 1#2%
" 3 .%& %3"
%/ .. "%.&/ . %%#& %3" """, / /% )' %,.%,;
/
% .% %% %."33%
&&.%3 &. 3 ,%. 3 & && %#/,/%%%3% &
8. %A % %BC"% 33#
%3" 3%%& /
" """ )' %, .%,;
/, % %%# # & %3" / & . 3& -
' %7 9.%,, .
, %"/%"3% %%&/& & %.
.. "% .% & .%-., ><#%3" "% %% )' %.%.
3.
3/&%&"%%3 /3%.
%/%& #%3" & %%-
' % 9 .%, , .
,
#
-83% /%%& . "% .% & -.# & %3" %% / .
& 3& -
&.0", ,)", & "
%-8% .. ./ / % %%3 %"%% # ># ! .%%3" % % %.%#& %3" -8 %" . %&.3% %".
%% &.#
I have heard learned counsels for parties.
&.%%% 3 .%& %% %#
/%%% %.%# %% / . 8 D% .& % -. & %&5 &&."&-8 / % .% 3""/ 3 % &. %&/#. ,%/ %.
.%"33& -
' %7 9 .%, , .
& 3& -
&.0")", 3.% / %%% / % .
3& %% / &. % # # &% &%%%/ % %.%% .. ,%&-8 / % / /% .% / /% 3"".%% &%&&.%. &&., - =), % 3 .# /% .%/ /% "%% #1%&/ .%-., >< '% &.3 % & / . 3 3 % # 5 % / % . &%
-8 /%%% %%&/ %&.&.3 %# # -&" 3,%& / % / /%% . %3" / & % .%6.& %"/ %% % &&
> %" %%3& ."%3&8 #/%.
.%6. & % % 3 % &%
.%# / " / " "" """ )' %.% %./ % % 3.%& &&.& 3 & . %" / A % %BC%3 - =) .%6%" "/% / .. %#
& %%& .% / %&% 3%." . & / & " & -8 %.. %"%%%3/& &. %"%&.3 / %&. & &. -. & %&5 %/ # 2# &% %. %.%.. %&-8% / % / & "/% .% & .%-. ><3 ) ' %.% % % &%3& ' %.% -
& .0")"3& . 3%%&/ , %"/% -
' % 7 9 .%, , .
& .
3/&3& -
& .0",,)", , / /%% %"%% #
%& %&. "%% 3 .%&% 1#2 " %-8%
.. ./ /% . % 3& &"./"3#@ % %/ -8% .%%# <# 5/& &.% .."%.%, %%& .% / %% &" %"%
3 %"%%
,
,
)) % 4% (E%41 3 (E%41