Ravinder Singh Saundhiya v. State Of Haryana

  010<    

 
   

 
   

 
   

 
        

    

    

    

   

  
  
  
   0 

 

! "

!# B6%$$&

% )") $$% &'

# # B6%)+&

$% &'

$% &'

$% &'

$% &' %( %( %( %( $% &' +,& $% &' +,& $% &' +,& $% &' +,&
*
*
*
*  $*  $*  $*  $* )& * )& * )& * )& *  (! 1=  (! 1=  (! 1=  (! 1=/ 010 / 010 / 010 / 010< & * & * & * & *  (! 1=  (! 1=  (! 1=  (! 1=/ 010< / 010< / 010< / 010<

 4- 6 

 

 4- 6 

 

 4- 6 

 

 4- 6 

   -  -  -  -  6 "

, &);:/  &($% '

)6  # . 

!."

/ %

&  # 6 >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> - - - -/ 6 2-5 / 6 2-5 / 6 2-5 / 6 2-5          $ +%$$& !) 7%% ',% "

%($& 0 &' $!% ! $#

  . "

.)!  !$/ 010 0 2'& )!& $ 3 45 2% ,%

%($& 
6 6
65 '&

$ &'  # 7, $& $!% +%$$& /  ()% 7%  

&60 $% 616010/ % )$ $!% &''% (%) +"

)!7,% "

%($&

) =/ 0=/ 0? 

08 &' $!%   ($/ ?= 2%($& ) 0? 

08 &' $!%

 ($ 

,$% 5/ $ &,(% $$& )

!/ )$ ($ 9

,6

:% &' $!%    @"

"%)$& ) $!$ "+&

%(% )%( %$  :

:$& / $& $!% %''%($ $!$  :A$ $  !/  (&,,")& ;$! 

, , !/ ;) ) ):" , &  &)$ 2+&++# !

!").5 '

&:  !#  %)! 

%!(,% &6 =0?? $&;

) ,, % 

;,/ $!% ) %!(,% ;) (%+$%

%

)(,&)% !) :% )  :A$  ! 

$!% &$!%

&(("+ $ ) $ :  !6 "

)% (! &' $!% ) %!(,%/  +,)$( 7 ) 1 . &' &  &)$ ;% %(&% / ;$!&"$ ! # +% :$ ,(% (%6 "

/ $!% ((")%

:% C 

,  !/ ;) )"7)%@"% $,# 

%)$% 7)% )(,&)"

% &' '& %) (&((")% "

(")$& , 

/ ) 

,  !

)(,&)% $!$ $!% :

)"++,% ;) 

D  2+%$$& % 56   ;) (&

"($% $ !) %) (%/ !&;%% / !% (&",

&$ 7% ++ %!%

6 -%

(&"

)%, '& !)  "% $!$ $!% +%$$&

!) 7%% ',)%,# :+,($% $& $!%    6 -%

(&"

)%, !) "% $!$:

$& # + &)& ) &' $!%  ($ !% &$ )( "+",&"),# 7%% (&:+,% ;$! 

/ $!")/ $!% + &)%("$& ()% )"''% ) '

&: 

%'%($)6 -%

(&"

)%, !)  "% $!$ $!% +%$$& !) &$ 7%%

:%

  6 -%

(&"

)%, !) '"

"% $!$ $!% +%$$&

!) 7%% :+,($% )&,%,# & $!% 7)) &'

)(,&)"

% )$$%:% $ (&((")%

,,%  !: $& 7% )"++,% &' $!% (&

/ ;!(! ) +% )% :))7,%  ,;/ 

/ $!")/ $!% ):% (

&$ 7% $!% 7)) '& :+,($& &'

6 -%

(&"

)%, !) $% $% $!$ $!% +%$$& !) &$! $&

& ;$! $!% (&

/ ;!(! !) 7%% ,,% % ,# %(&% &: $!% %!(,% 6 -%

(&"

)%, !) '"

"% $!$ $!% % ) &$ %% &$ &' % (%/ ,7,% ;$! $!% + &)%("$& / $& )!&; (&:+,($# &' $!% $!% &''% (% 

 66 -%

(&"

)%, !)  "% $!$ &$! ) $& 7% %(&% &:

$!% +%$$& 6 -%

(&"

)%, !) '"

$% $% $!$ $!% +%$$& )

% # 

;,, $& A& 6  $!% 7)) &' $!% '& %:% $&

)"7:))& )/ $ &' $!%  )$ $ +%$$& ) + #% 6 % / ,%

$$% (&"

)%, !) &++&)% $ &'

# 7, $& $!% +%$$& 7#  " $!$ ,,% $& )%   )$ % )% &") 

$"

%6 -%

$$% (&"

)%, !)  "% $!$ !" % @" $$# &' (&

;) %(&% &: (&((")% &' $!% / 

!) 7%%

:%

)(,&)"

% &' $!% (&((")%

C $!% +%$$& 7% )"++,% &' $!% (&

6 -%

$$% (&"

)%, !) '"

"% $!$/  /  $!% + $ ()%/ ) )$,, "

;# 

$!% +%$$& ) #%$ $& 7% 

%)$% 6 % $!%)% ( (":)$ (%)/ (")$&

&' $!% +%$$& ) 

)+% )7,%6 -%

$$% (&"

)%, )"7:$) $!$/  ()%/ $!% +%$$& ) ((&

(%))& &'  # 7,/ $!% % ) ,, ,.%,!&& $!$ !% :# 7)(&

&: $!% + &(%)) &' A")$(% ) ,)& $$%:+$ $&  ',"% (%E  $:$%$!% + &)%("$& ;$ %))%)6 !")/ $!% $ +%$$& ) %& &' :% $ 

) ,7,% $& 7% ):))% =6

!% !%

$!% ,%

(&"

)%, '& , + $%) 

!% % $!

&" ! $!% ,7,%

&' $!% ()%6 <6 ) +% $!% ()% +"$ '& $!    / "+&

%(%

)%( %$  :$& / %!(,% 7%

&6 =0?? ;)  (%+$% C  +,)$( 7 ) (& 1 . &' &  &)$ ;% %(&% C $!%

%

)(,&)% !) :% )  :A$  ! 

$!% &$!% &(("+ $ ) $ :

!6 !% ) (&((")%

&: $% % 

,  !/ 

) 

,

 !/  !) )(,&)"

%/ )+%('(,,# :% ) )"++,% &' $!%

$ ) +% $ $ $& &$% !% % $!$ $!% +%$$& ;) :%

/ $ $!%  $, )$ %/ 

!) :% )"

'(% / )"7)%@"% $,#/ "

(&"

)% &'  / & $!% 7)) &' $!% )(,&)"

% )$$%:% $ &' (& ((")% / ;!& )+%('(,,# $$ 7"$% &,% &' )"++,% &' $!%

!&" ! $!% +%$$& ;) &$ ++ %!%

$ $!% )+&$/ $!% ,,% $& )   )$ !: +% $& ( : , (& )+ (# "

%($&

0? &' $!%  ($/ ;!(!

&%) %(%))$$% +!#)(, +&))%))& &' $!%

!% :$% , (&,,%($% )& '

%%,) + : '(% % (% &'

(&::& $&

A& $ + $(+$& 7%$;%% $!% +%$$&

(& ((")% / ) %',%($% &: $!% )(,&)"

% )$$%:% $6

$!% (& %;

&' $!)
&"

$/ $!% % ($# &' $!% )(,&)"

% )$$%:% $ 

$!% %F$% $ &' $!% &,%:% $ &' $!% +%$$& $!% &''% (%/  % :$$% %@" $!& &" !

/ ;!(! ( 7% %''%($%,# "

$.% ,# $!

&" ! (")$&

6 "(! 

) %))% $, $& $ (% $!% &   / )&"

(% 

%$;& . &' $!% (&

6 $ $!) )$ %/ & :$% , !) 7%% +,(%

$& %:& )$ $% $!$ $!% +%$$& ) (&:+,%$%,# "

%($% ;$! $!% &''% (% 

+&))7,$# &'

%(&% # &' '"

)(&% # &'

( : $ :$% , (

&$ 7% ",% &"$6 866

!% +,% &' $!% +%$$& $!$ $!% (& '%))& , )$$%:% $ &' $!% (&((")% )  :))7,% ) %& &' :% $/ )/ $ $!% )$ % &'

$& &'  # 7,/ $!%
&"

$ ) %@" $& :%$(",&"),# %,"$% $!%  :))7,$# &' % (%/ 7"$ & ,# $& %F: % ;!%$!% :

= '(% :$% , %F)$) (&

%($ ;$! $!% ,,% % &''% (%6

"($% / $!")/ )& ' / 

($%) $!%  &,%:% $ &' $!%  ;%,,& G%

%$;& . %  % $!% ,,% , $ % 

)$ 7"$& &' +)#(!&$ &+( )"7)$ (%)6 $"

% 

$# &' $!% &''% (%/ (&"+,% ;$! $!% :$% , (&,,%($%

/ A")$'# $!% %(%))$# &' (")$& , 

$& "

%, $!% , )+ (# 

$&  $'# &$!% +&$% $, (&(& )+ $& )6 !% ,,% $& )  / ;!% %;%

A"

($& ;$! $!% ,7,% % (%/ )% )% &") 

)"7)$ $$%

(%

) 7&"$ $!% +&))7,% &,% &' $!% +%$$& ,

(&$() %$;& ./ ;!(! (

&$ 7% 7 ")!% ) % $ $!) )(% $ )$ % &' $!% 

!% &''% (% (&::$$% 7# $!% +%$$& )  )% &") &''% (%/ ;!(! !)  %($  % )% :+($ & )&(%$#6 !% :$% , ,7,% &

: '(% 

($%) $!%  &,%:% $ &' $!% +%$$& (&::))& &' $!% ,,% % &''% (%6  $ &'  # 7,/ $ $!) )$ %/ :# !:+% $!%  / + $(", ,#  %; &' $!% %% (")$&

$& )(% $!% )&"

(% &' (&

+&))7,%E+&$% $, , .) ;$! &$!% +% )& )  &,% ,,% ,

" $ ''(.  ($ %)( 7%) )$ $ + &)& ) .%%+ %; $!% :% (% &'

(&$(

" )

+)#(!&$ &+( )"7)$ (%)6 6 "

:& %/ $!%  ) )$,, $  ( "(, )$ %/ 

(")$& , 

&' $!% +%$$& ) (&

%(%)) # $& "

% $!

$!% (&:+,%$% '($) 

$& )(% &,%:% $ &'  # &$!% +% )&

%($% ;$! $!% ()%6 !% +%$$& ) #%$ $& 7% 

%)$%

$ &'

# 7,/ $ $!) )$ %/ :# + %A"

(% $!% & &

< % $!% )% &") %)) &' $!% &''% (%/ $!% )$ % &' 

+&))7,$# &' $:+% ;$! % (% & &7)$ "($ A")$(%/ $!)
&"

$ ) &'

$!% %; $!$ $!% +%$$&

&%) % $!% (& (%))& &' 7, $ $!) A"

($"

%6 ?6

$ ) 7%'$$ $& :% $& % $!$ ;!,% (& +,% '&

$ &'  # 7,/ $!%
&"

$ !) $& %@",7 $% 7%$;%% )'% "

 ",  !$) 

&$%($ )&(%$,  %)$2)56 !%
&"

$ &" !$ $&

%(.& ;$! $!% : $"

% 

$"

% &' $!% &''% (%H $!% &,% $$ 7"$% $& $!% ((")% H $!% %% '

%%  ) ,)& $!% %%+%

; % :+($ &' )"(! ,,% % @"$%) & $!% )&(%$#6  + &'$7,% %'% (% $!) % 

) 7% : % $& $!% ($ +))% 7# $!% 47,% "+ %:%
&"

$ $$,% ) $$% $$% $$% $$% 6  , ! :/ 2??85 8 

8 * ??8 

2
5 6  , ! :/ 2??85 8 

8 * ??8 

2
5 6  , ! :/ 2??85 8 

8 * ??8 

2
5 6  , ! :/ 2??85 8 

8 * ??8 

2
5 1?

1?

1?

1?/ $!% "+ %:%
&"

$ !%, ) "

/ %,% $ ;!% %&'

% ) ) "

* I<6 J% '

(%  $!% )"7:))& &'
 $!$ (")$& , 

) @",$$%,# :& % %,($$& & % $!  )")+%($ ;!& ) ;%,,% )(& (% ;$!  '&"

7,% &

"

%($&  &' $!%
& %6

()% ,.% $!)/ %''%($% 

&'  )")+%($% +% )& ) &' $ %:%

&")  $ % 

)

: # ")%'",  :$& ) 

,)& :$% ,) ;!(!

;&", !% 7%% (%,% 6 "((%))  )"(! 

;&", %,"

% ' $!% )")+%($% +% )& .

&;) $!$ !% ) ;%,, + &$%($%

)",$% 7#  + %

%)$ 7, &

"

$!% $:% !% ) 

& $% 6 K% # &'$%

)"(!

 (&

$& ;&",

"(% $&  :% $",6 !%  ":% $ $!$ $!% (")$&

) '

" !$ ;$! $!% &' $!% +% )& 7% )"7A%($% $& $!



%% :%$!& %%

&$ 7% (&"

(% / '& / )"(!  ":% $ ( 7%  (% 7# ,, ((")% ,, ( : , ()%)6 !%
&"

$ !) $& + %)":% $!$

%)+& )7,% +&,(% &''(% ) ;&",

"($ $!%:)%,%)  %)+& )7,% :

$!$ $!&)% % ")$% ;$! $!% $). &'

)

&''% (%) ;&",

"($ $!%:)%,%) ) &''%

)6L $ $!) )$ %/ $!% % ) & :$% , &

$& !&, $!$ + : '(% ()% ) &$ : % &"$   )$ $!% +%$$& !% :$% , ;!(! !) (&:% &

%,: #  / ++% $& %)$7,)! 

%)& 7,% 7)) '& !) ((")$& !")/ $ ) &$ ++ &+ $% $&

# 7, $& $!% +%$$& / ) $ ;&",

%(%)) ,# (")% :+% :% %''%($%  16 ((&

,#/ $!)
&"

$ ) &' $!% (& &+ & $!$ $!%

&%) % $!% (& (%))& &'  # 7,  $!% '($", :,%" &' $!% ()%  !

6 & %&% / (")$& , 

&' $!% ) %(%)) # '& %''%($%  M $& "

%, $!% $ "$!6

!% +%$$& )/ $!")/ %& &' :% $) 

) !% %7# ):))%

):))%

):))%

):))% 6

&$! ) % 7&% )!,, 7% %%:% $& 7%  %F+ %))&

&' &+ & "+& :% $) &' $!% ()%E 06 %

++,($& 2)5/ '  #/ )!,, ,)& )$

)+&)% &''6 2 -  -  -  -5      (! 1=  (! 1=  (! 1=  (! 1=/ 010< / 010< / 010< / 010< :!

J!%$!% )+%. %)& * %)E J!%$!%

%+& $7,%* %)E