M/S Orris Infrastructure Priavate Limited v. M/S Be Office Automation
! !"#$#%& ' ($))#$% ) $ )*" *)!)#+ !,#-# !. ! # #%!) ($ !
#"!* - #% !$/%.!% &01 ,22,2,,
!
"
# $ % & !
' ( % ) * +++++ ,2,,3 ) 4 % ,- ,.
/,// 0 *1
"2 3 '* * ' 40
)
"2
56678 1, 1-,9 : ; "2 "
2
" " :'3; 0 " 7 2 /,,< 1-
"2 " 9= $ 3 ) 2 8 :3>;
" = 9
2 "2 "
"
// 1, /,,<0* / "
0 1?.
%
" * "
/?.
7 @ 7 "2 3 $ 2 : A3$ B; " 1?.
/?. : ;
7 "
2 @7 " " * * 2 @7
" " 1?.
/?. : ;
8 0 ) 2: ); // 1, /,,< "
"
2 ? *
2 # .-/,,- "2
3$ > 2 2
/= ,19 7 /C ,1 /,11"
9/
2 / "
"
/C ,1 /,110*C
7 "
/= ,19 " C ,=
2 " --/,11 "2 3$ 7 "
" 2
1?. C ,= " "2 " )
" " 7 "
- 9/
2
/C ,1 /,11 $ 8 D
# "
%
"
1?. C ,= " "2 % ) // 1, /,,<
E - " : A" B; " /,1/ -
5 " 5 " /,1/ # 3 ' )
/, /,1C:0*9;
"2 - "
2
2 2
2 "2 "
2 2 2 @5 ( --,1 /,1C
"2 /, /,1C0 *9 7 2 2
,9 1/ /,1C 0*-
" @5 8( 1-,/,1C "2 ., ,1 /,1=
>B" :
'
; " D 2 7 "
1- ,9 /,1="2 ) " * "
7 "2 " 3 ')
8( -- /,1= "2 "2 8 2 * "2
* :
;
2
" & :"; "
2
8 /=FFC<C-/?* :8 $ 2 @ 0 2 0 # % @ 2 $ @> ( 2$;
&
6 :; 2 0 1?.
" CF
9
= 9 " "2 " // 1, /,,<& :1; G
) 2 // 1, /,,<"2 * "
H :
1.
,= /,1=;& :;
1?. C ,= " "2 & :;
'
2/C/,11 & :;
) 2 // 1, /,,<"2 * "
& :; :; "
) 2 // 1, /,,<& :;
I19J
" "2
& :;
"
H 8 2 "2 * G:
; 3 *
"2 " // 1, /,,< 1?. = 9,
" /- ,F
(3 :"; 3 *
B
7
/- ,F 1- -FJ 1?. 1- -FJ
B F F= J
/- ,F (3 :; 3 *
0 F F=J @ ? ? %? ?
?
; 2 8
0
/- ,F
% "
"(3 :; 3
2 " ? ?
%? ?
?
(3 :; 3
:
? 5 7 # ;
%
:@ ? ?
%? ?
?
;
(3 :; 3 5
:
? 5 7 # ; 0 2
% "
? ?
%? ?
?
0 2(5 A3
A (3 :; 3 5
:
? 5 7 # ;
%
F
/C ,1 /,11 " " ? "%"2
2 :; *D * 2?
.=:; "
:
?57 # ;
(3 :;
0 8 /=
:
? 5 7 # ;
" // 1, /,,< "
2 "2 (3 :;
"2
" 2
2 0 2B " 0 > (3 :%; 3
:
? 5 7 # ;
G
H > 2
5
A) > 9= ) B "
%
82B B % "% 0 "2
(3 : ;
2 2 >B" $"
2 H 8
1- ,F /,1F "2
* G/ $ ? 2"
2"2 "2> :
; 3
"2 " // 1, /,,< 1?.
= 9, " /- ,F (3 :"; 3
B
8
/- ,F 1- -FJ 1?. 1- -FJ
B F F=J /- ,F :; 3
0 F F=J
: ? ?
%? ?
?
; 2
0 /- ,F
% "
" (3 :; 3
:
? 5 7 # ;
%
F
/C ,1 /,11 " " ?"%"2
2 .
$
2"2
G:;
1?. ,= " "2 H @
"2 " "
* K
1?.
CF% 9
= 9 " "2 " // 1, /,,<L / K " 2
0 0 1?.
% " .
K /C ,1 /,11 2
' "L K
"
2 "
/C ,1 /,11L = K
@8 1 <=
1<
" "
L K 2
2
" "
DL < K 2
2 2
L >
" "
L - 8 @
"2 " 1/ 1/ /,1F 7 1
"2 B 2 " "2 7 . "2 /C ,1 /,11 2 2 7 C
2 0 1?. C ,= 7 " = D (
2
"2 F < 7 / " 1C1.=<D
0 C19 ,FD
?
7 9/
/C ,1 /,11 0 -
:
; -
0 0 1C1.=< D 7 " "
8 C19 F D
"
% " 8 *
4K 7 9 -
2 8 1/ 1/ /,1F " 3 ' )
.C "
.F :/; " 7 "
2 9/ %2 ,1 /,1< ,- ,/ /,1< 1/ 1/ /,1F 8
19 ,1 /,1< ( "$ 2 8
3
)
D 2 2 B
% "
"2 D2 "2 3
)
/9 ,.
/,1< " 2
"2 K ( -,<= /,1< "2 /9 ,.
/,1< ,< 1/ /,1< /9 ,.
/,1<"
- " " "2 ,- ,9 /,1< % 2
"2 3 ' )
,9 1/ /,1<0*19 "
@5* 8*-/,19 " 3 > 8 0
% 0 1/ 1/ /,1F 0
" "
" "
2
1=1 "2 0 %
1.
,/ /,1- 0*/1 "
"2 8( 1.=F/,1- # 3 ' )
,- ,.
/,// 0
9/
/ ) >
2 2 1C1.=<D "2 " $ CC "
% =,.F= C- D
% /1C 9= D
@ *'3 * G:; '3 CC
/C. 3>
%
=,.F= C- D $
1/,F / 1.,/$3= & :; '3
% /1C 9= D
& :; '3 / 3> & :; '3
8 1./,,,,,?* 3> 4K @
& :; '3 D = "0 0 & :; '3 19=
%"
2 3>
& :;'3 0 2
3>B 2 H " # 2 0 "2 0 "2 8
D " 0
0 "
A B
7 G H 2
" " =C $ 2 199/ : A$ B; " G H G 0
H$ A B 2
0 8
2 2 8
"2 1=,,D % "11.- -,D "2
0 9/
2 " 2 /,11 " $ 2 "
2 =
K
- " "2 ,.
1, /,1/ "
"
/C ,1 /,11 " " % "2 " "2 " # "
" .C " D
5 " 2 2 E :; ) // 1, /,,< :; B
2
B :; " "2 B 2 " :;
% " " " 0 8 D 8 " 2
-< 11< 1CF /,/ 2 "
"
"2 " 7 "
"2 3 '
CC 2 3 ' 2
2 2
1/ 1/ /,1F # "
2 3 ' " A " B > 2
2
# 3 ' "
2 2" 4K "
" 2 4K "
"2 3 2
"2
D
" $ " 1/ 1/ /,1F 7 2 ,- ,.
/,//
"2 3 '
6 )
" 2 " "2
,- ,.
/,//
7 "
"2 " D 0 "2 7 "
" 1C1.=<D
0 C19 ,FD
?
9/ 2 2
7 " "2 " 2 " "
$ 0 2
CC
# "
: K*/; "
"2 0 8
" " " G " 2 0 H 7 "
" 2 G
E " "2
2" %
" "0 H 7
0 2 "
" 7 2 "
7 >
3 " "
2
D 9/
2 1/ 1/ /,1F 0 D A B 0 " // 1, /,,<0*/0 "
* A " 2
0 0 1?. ?
% " $ " "
/?. ?
% "
$ @ 7 "2 3$ :>M3; " 1?.
/?.: ;
2 @
2 " "
7 2 @ 7 " " *
* 2 @7 " " 1?.
/?.:
;
1?. "
:"2 ;B 2 /C ,1 /,119/
" " // 1, /,,< C
"
"2 9/ " 2 C ,= " "2
* $ " " /C ,1 /,11 D 2 " N 2 "
0 2 "2 7 0 "2
7 0 0 ? ?
4D 2 """
"2
40 2 2"
2
>B" 29#+$9 %: )*); ) <$ #4#/3 5 2 576 0 "2 2 " " 0
.F " " "
$ 1/ 1/ /,1F 0 *1C "
"2 0 2 %
8 @ 2 " 1/ 1/ /,1F0*1C / 2 "2 "
1?. " 2
7 / " * G/ K " 2
0 0 1?.
%
" H $ 0 G H " " /C ,1 /,11 0 "
3 "
"2 " %"2
C ,=
" "
" % 2 # " " " * G7 2 A B
" 2 0 @
E
" "2
2 " % "
" 0 K/
? "2 > 2
' 5 $ @8 8 B "
"
8 " 1C1.=<D :# %@ 25$ $ >@ 25 2;
H # " 2 11< ? 8K*1* O " 1-</,F D D 1CF ., = D
7 " 2 2 "2 " "
7 2 "2 " " # "
* K*/ D 0
"2 1C1.=<D
"2 *
$ :;
/- ,F9 /
$ :D
;
11<F..
9C .
" @8 <=
" @8:D
;
/,=9=- /1 =
@8 <C--=
@8:D
;
/,=9=.
F,
<
@84K1 C-1= FF
@84K/ 1-=C /, -
@8
2 1=.= -/ $ @8 ) " 1-<CC< 9/ :
#
# CF
!9
CF0/,P9
-/9 ,,
= 9,
#
"
1-<CC< 9/0= /- ,< Q.-.-< 19D
#
"
.-.-< .
,, Q1.1./ .-D
1C1.=<D @
2 "2 B "
" * G3 0 0
0
*0
$ 2 H 7 "
% " 1C1.=< D
0 C19 ,F D
?
" * G$ 9/
/C ,1 /,11 0
$
0 0 1C1.=<D 7 " "
$ " C19 ,F:@ E0;D
"
%
" 2
" * 4K H "2 K*/*
"2 " "
@8 7 2 ,C ,1 /,1F K*/*
/,1, 11C=F=D
/,1/ 1C1.=<D 7 K*/*
:"
;
% 40 K/?1
"
" 2
"2 K*/
" "2 " $ "
A$ @8 " # " B " 1C1.=<D C19 ,F D
7 "
% 40 2 "2 "
D
0 2 -,--1 =1D "2 /,.
/1D
$"
=,.F= C-D
/1C 9=D
"
0 "2 " " "
E " % 2 " "2 > " %
# 40 " * G1= 2
" " "2 '3 3>
" "2 " " 2 0 7 "
E " % 2
" "2 " 2 " %
# "
0 3> 0 1C1.=< D 3> 9/
/C ,1 /,110 -
7 " 3> -
0
"
9/
23> " C19 ,F D
"
% " 7 " 9/
" 3> "
"
$ " "2 3> 2 " 1F 3> 9/
% "
-,--1 =1D " " 3>
% 9/ "
2
% 2 2 '3 "
3>(
2
7 % H " "2 40 > 2 /,1< 2 " "
% " "2 K*/*
"
@8
7 2""2 40 * G1- $ "
@8 '3 @8 "
=!
// @ " % B 1C1.=<D "
@8 "
7 " D 1C1.=<D "
'3%
2 "2 " "
@8 "0 " "
E
2 "
% 2
" "0 H 2
5 0 "
" * > " " "2 ?
2
"
0 $ ? " " "
"2 K*/*
7 0
"2 2 " 0 2
0
1/ 1/ /,1F 7 "
2
$ 2
2 " $ 1C1.=<D
0 / >
2
1/ 1/ /,1F * G$ 9/
/C ,1 /,11 !="!/ #%; 9! .#$4" !.%#%! / ) -!% $9!"4 #- % $9 44;#+!/ #% 9! )!$/%.!% "9$! %#%! / ) -!% $ #% 9! )!$#.!% # 4"-/4!=3$ 9 # $!% # 4!-!% 9!!= !% 5 6 $> 3#$$ #$ #!.%" $! .!
#"# 3)!$/%.!% $9 44
6 ?! !% # 4!. $*"9 ? 4 %"! )! #% 9!) / ) -!% $ $ " C19 ,F :@ E0;D
?!$#.!$ @+#44 $ 4%;@# 9/)/) #% !)#;9 #% 9!/!% )! 3 / ):#%;3 !)) "!3 ) %. 44 9!) )! $ @9#"9 " %% ?!.#+#.!. :-/9 $#$ ..!.A $ A"B / 2 / " 1C1.=< D 2 " 2 2 "2 40
4K 2 19=
%"
2 5
% " "2 2 # 40
0 0
2 2 7 40 "2 2
# " 2 2 2 2
,- ,.
/,//
"2 3 '* * ' 40
)
"2 0 ( " 8 2 B,2,,C ' *.;! $:9 % K %? O?( K
O?(