← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/809/2020allowed

Kailash v. State Of Haryana And ANR

2024-12-19Mr. Justice Sumeet Goel13 pages

  

     

      !&% #'()*+(,-.-)/

      3

   

 8

  

  

   , 4 % $   

 

   ,,(5 $6 7

  ,8($  



 &  99999

!"#$% 

    

 

 

  # 

  



             !"# $ % 

 %   



 

  & '   

       )"#(   

* +

    !" ,#   -  . $ % %  

 

 #%    "  %  /" $ $ %  '  3

                   !" # $ %0

   %  

 

 "  " 

$*$*:+' 

- .%   "  

/"

"

# ( #    (3



   

       

  !"# $ %   "

"

 

  ; %    " #  # " (  (  

 



     

8*$'

 "  %

$  % "     " #  (  (  (  

2  

6"# 



   

  $  (  %  

  

     % 

     #  

(" "   "  '<

, $ : >  ""  % %

 

     .8 8,'

*+='

* %

 #

 

"#

#

   

   % 

?  *$ 

%# # %    '

 

           

  

      

     

   !

! "



  #$% %&''&$($)"      0 "    * 

    

      

                 



& +      "  

  

! " 

  #      

   

    

&* 

     

* 

   #  

          ""



",



        "  

* 



  #&

 *      

      " "  ,



        "

,

  "   

,  -

 



 #

.

&



*  

  #"     

      

 

    

 "         + ,   , 

 

    /& *

  

     





 + ,  





,   

                                

   "

"   

,

 & 

 

-  



  

* 



  #&

0 +  

           

  

*  

  #  

    

                    ,     

       





 ,



        "2     &  

* 

    #         

   

  

2    *,

 .

    3  

 "   

    



"

 



&

 3  

 "       

 ,  "    

"   

&

 3  "

      #   . 4     

  0    '1&'$&$($)&5

&& * ""   



$ 

     *

.

 !"  ,#  $ % 

    %  @



 

 $  .

"   

% +



"

()&'$&$ $($)     "    6  # 7    &$    89         

 &6 "

" & 

,  "     "       +0B+          

 

,

 !       !

!

,  

 ,

    (:&''&$($; "    

&    <

 =  #





 > " #&+ +    

  ,  

    7 &') (( ((( B 

   "        

   &  6       

   6

'$% &#&& !?+

  " 

  & 8,             >*7 @&'%    $)&(:&$(')    6

 ;) ;$; )(1 )A:B+ %(1  *#

  5



       

  &

 

"

 

  

  *   (  .

"    

 & '  

%

     4  



 

 " '

' ;& +    



 #

 898    "

 " 

       "  

   +0B/            

       !

, , 

 > "    #           "     

 "       

         - -  

     

 > " 'C&()&$ $($;  

 & 8        

    "  7    @ @&$   89 8        " 

,   "

"     

"    "

 

 7 &') (( ((( B   > " & 8   

        = > "      

  

5          "

 

  &   "(  

 &  #





  ( /"  A-8 8 /"

    A-8 &   *+ *  #  "    * *:+'

*

 *

-.     

.( %B   "   " 

 "(          /"

      @  ## A-8/"

  

## 

( =    "  "(     .

"  %  #  

  

     (  

   

   

  .

"  + -         "

          

"# #   "#  



: 1 4 .

"   

2 .

.

"   

     %  "



 )"   "    *+

 .

 /"

"

 #  '

"

    

 %! !&

    

 '#(! !&   

       !"!#$ 4

 

 %   # (   

     

2.

"

"  .

"   #   ):$ &#&& ,  

  

   

 

 "6

;$( 

& 8,

      &      0



   

,2      



   

       

,  "   "

,

   2   

  

          "

  &  

 

      0

   ,, ,              , "     2    "  &   

     ,       , , 

     "& 6

):$&#&&

 "  8    ,  

 -

 &* 

 

  

 "  8     +0        8             >*7  6

;(C"  >* >*7

  &8  



    - 

   - 

, 

    "      & 6 0

  

8    

"   ,

   ,

    

 

       &6 0

        

  ,

 &  3    >*7  B     , 

  ,      8   

     

      

 



  

              

&

2   "

 



 +

<&$

 (      "

 

 *+

..$:= 4

$     

 % % " 

   

 " 

+

<&$

%  :   )" " $   % "

 

  

  

  )"#(

  

C "

.

"     "%,#   

  )*     + 

 !"!#

!"!# #,,#- +./  0!

! /  , "     %

"     8       ,                  ,

"     

   ,

     "      

   



    

  0

 

       6

 ):$  &#&&  ,      

 &     



 " , 

 

 

"   "

,

    

       "

,    



   2  "D ,"-   

  -

"

&

 *      



 ,,         " ,  

   

,        "  

 ,

&8

 

  

    , -

&6    "

  ,"

"

-   0  &*    "

     

 2  ,

  8        0

    

 2  , 

 

 

    



  ,

     

  

  

   

   

&  0

 0 

"   6

):$&#&&

   

-

& 

    

  8     

 -

&+

, , 

   

3 6

):$&#&&"    

   -



 , 

      "       ,

-

&.  

   ,  ,      

 

       0 

 

  " , " 

   -! !& 1

 * ,&5  1

2"!- : 4     )" 

 "     + <& &$

 *+ ..$:=  ( (    #"

)"

 "#  

)"  4"$%    "



   

  " # "

" ( 

  $  # "  (    /"         #D#  "

# % "   '

"    ")"     # "(   4   



  #.

" 

%      

$ %      2 $   .

"  % "

#

   



%.

" 

# "

  "

 )"   - -  % 0 "

1;

;   

  # .

" $         

'

$       $   ((  "

E  " "

1;$ #.

" % "  

("  @  "  4



 #.

"   



 "

%   %  

 (  " 4   

     %    "



#.

" % "#  $     

$ % 

1;

(  "     



%.

"  #  "

" -  



)" "

     "#%

 %    (  $       

 "(   % 

   (



 #"#  (@    (

    % 

   

# #  $%      #.

" %

2 

  "  

 )"      

 #  ( $ 

"

$  "

1;   %  "  %$  "#





  %$

  % $  )" 

  "

"



%.

.

" 4 )"



1;  "   0    (" 

  

 # .

" 0 "

$

   "   )" " 

(

# )"  $     %   %$    #"$   

  (   -  % 0    +

 <&$

 

 

 

$% #.

" ( %"

 %

 )"   /"    $  "

" " 

"



 %$    2 

 $    )"    " "    )" 

         " 

 )" 

$  #.

" $  

   

"   + <& $

  *+  ..$  :=       /"     %    

(   $  " ( 

 ( # "

  "   " ( ( )"  $ %   "  )"    A"  ( $)"#(  

  .

"  )3 3)3 + $/3      4,5

  6*  

:*

*0 %  " ' :&  6

 )A:B+         *#  " "    

    'A:;

     " -

,     ,

 

"

 -

0 ,

   

,

 6

)(1  *#

   , " 

   "    B    

     

  " &

   

 ?6    

 

 ,

    

 

  

  6

)A:B+ + *#           

  ,

        E 



2   

  

9      " 2   "    &.



,

    

 , , "

   



      "

             



    



 & 

 



     

0   

 "  " ,          

       "                    

    &F  ,

         & @, 

  

    ,B



   ,       &G                   2

 

    

  

   ,      

     &        , 

 

    

    

 

  &   8    0

 

 

  6

):$ $ &#&&'AC;H    

     

   

  ,"  & :&' *   ,

,   "

    ,   

       ,



      

B    

  " 

 

    

  

          2  

"    

,  >*7 

  & 896   7  +     )

"!"   , 0 

,"

   2

  I           

  

          

      





"   , "    



   

 " 

"    



    

 " &* * 

   -

   

 "   

  -

," "

         

       B   , , 

     

   





 "  - "-

   B&@ 

  "         

"   

H ,  

 

  & :&$ 



   0 

   8    " "  0

       6

 ):$  &#&&

  >*7  

 

  

  896    0!&(# 

 ) "!" & 

    8    6

):$&#&&

'AC;,   "   7#!" &

    

      H

  -

   6

 ):$  &#&&H  



   "  &"

0





   &>       0  0

  

   "  8        -



       

 "  8      

  , & :&;  89 6        )" #!

     ,0  

 



 8   

    "

" 2    

  ,      

 

    >*7  

 

 &* 



    

  -

      

      -

  





   " 

 & +



"H 8   0



   6

):$  &#&&  'AC;H  ,         5     0   

 5  



  & A&  +   ,

      *&  *  >*7  

       

   

          

   

   I   

     " 

    

>*7  

   ,    &

* ,2 H     "

 B   

   



         

 

 &8,

      

"     "

        

& >    

 

     " 





             ,     

  & **& *     

        2 



        

  I

     2       

  

   H 8   

-

 6

):$ &#&&'AC;

 ,"



 

         2 " 

   &

 ***& @ 

,  0

, 

  

"

"  

  

 ," 

      & @ 

      8   "0

 

   6

):$&#&&'AC;

   

   

 &5 

      

  $   (

#

  %  

 

  '"  

  & '%

  # "

 

     ( $

  & '%

      "

"(

 8*  1 %

   (   

(   ( ;

; (

  '"    

  1  " 

(" "   ; 

        A( .

"   - $  #$  "   

  & '%

 



 

(    

/"

    

  1% 

(" "

  ;        

  

" 

( ( 

 

  , (   "

 

( 

   



   



  

 '" "  

      -)" #" $ 

" 

    $

(    

 

- ("    )" 

"   %  "

  #   

$ (  " " $ 

        "  ( 

 

  %$ 

  2 " "  #$ @ @  #          "   )"   4

$   "  ("   @    

    #    # #(      $ "#   "#

 

)" 

     " ( 2   

   

 ## (  A-8 

% "(  

   ( "#  #" 

"



 %   .

"   & # 2

  (   % "  "

    

        '  4 .

" $

  

   

"  *+

..

:= $ 

 "@ "  2  ""    1;

;  ""

" "     ("#  

 % %  .

"  

 $   % "

        

 )"     ( "#

      %

 

      

       !"# $%  '  

 

/"

  #

  <

 #%  )"# #(  $ 

    

   " 

 & '%



  (



  

(" 

%.

"   "#  

4

#



 

(

# 

  # "(  

 #

#

%    ( 

   

       

"

1; 

 

  G$   

  &

'%

      % %   $%     "#   

 "

    (    - %

 $  

% 1; ( "#

   



               !"# $ %   '

  0

  /"

# "  

$* *$ *:+'  

-. 1;

  & '%

  %   

8$$ '% 

   % .

!",#   1.!,;$  % % 

" %

@ (   -   "    

 0.!,$% ( (   B

#  "   $@"- $     

 

 & '%



0  .!,$%  ( ( 6

"

.

(( $%%   "   (

  & '%

   

    "

  "

  D

$  6

" .

(( $%  ( "( .!,$% %$

"   ( 

  B #   "    $@"  

    .!,$% 

" .

(( $%  .

"

"  # 1; #      (   



  )"#(

 & '%

0.!,$%  6

" .

(( $% %

 /"  +-"   !

% 

 :$ * E 

@#   & E 

   &