High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/276/2022allowed

Kuldeep Singh Alias Keepa v. State Of Punjab

2024-05-06Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mr. Justice Lalit Batra28 pages

! ""##

$% "

& ( )

$ * + ,- *%)

""## .*# /

- ) 0 1) &%2 3

5 ) %" 0 6 6&077 )

8%') 0" - ) 9- -%'-

""##

' 9

"% - 3# % !

&/- "

0%3

;

< ,-%'-

) "

(" %"

'% (" (

/ ) 3 ("

) ) 7)

)

%' '% (" (

- ( -

% ""##

(

)

-9

%" )

""## %#

#/)

- '

5 '

! ! ) 0?

0- +%(

# "

@AB "

C ##)

## ' 0-#/) 9-

(

% +%#"

0 '- +"

8' 0 '-)

## ' -"%) &0 ' '

"""/ -%*

/) ( '

6&C 5 :

# """/ -%* '

( ## ' 0-#/

## ' C ##

)

""-) #/ '

(

)

E? ?

()

3 '

% +%#"

0 '- +"

6&C 5 :

% >%

- 9- 3% C

%) 0?

0- +%(

%) 3%

% +%#"

0 '- +"

- -

(

(( ""

-9 +%( ) 0& ) - %

" 9- (

%" '

(

- " 0) '

- -

/ F

) 3%

% " -9 +%( ) 0&

(( ""

! E(

)

9 '

"""/ -%* %

9 ,9

' (

9 "

(

"""/ -%*

( '

"""/ -%*

G *'

- &""/ -%* "%

* '

9 # # '

(" @0+B

@+B

9##

"""/ -%* 9

* " "

/ (( E(

0% 0 '-

)

"" "% 0?70H

0%2

0 '- %

* " "

/ (( % '

)

% +%#"

0 '- +"

(

# '

"""/ -%*

3%-) 3#9

& #

0% #2

-% -

'#/) '

"""/ -%*

(

"# ,9

' ( 9 "

(

9 # '

' ( 9 '- '

() 9- - 9 "%

* '

9##

"""/ -%* 9

* " "

/ ((

# '

(" @0+B

@+B

0% 0 '-

% E(

)

"" "% ?" +%#9 0 '-) 0H

#$$% &'(

("#

) ##

% ' -

((

"% - 3# % !

' 9

="#

% ("# &%2 3 7.'# -)

9- - "#

'% #

(

# 0%3>% #/

)

"%3# "% #

"% 3%

E0I)

9- - .=&J

.=&J7

!)* (( &( +$

&$%# !&($+ ",$ --$ &"

: %#

""##

-%'-

E0I (

# #)

(

) 3

(

"- 3

%'7

E% -()

# %3(

-%'-)

(

# #)

)

E0I (3 H9)

(

E0I

# #) 3 %#/

( # # "%

% H %3(

"% /)

- "% )

9%#

3( ' #/

3# - )

% %3(

"% )

" 3 '

E0I 3%

" ##/ 9-

)

E0I

-) 3%

H %3(

(

# #) " (

#/ %"" '

E0I 3%

%"" '

!)* (( &( +$

&$%"

"$# !&($

%# -9 %3(

9- # "# '

# %" !

)

# 9- # "# '

# ) %"

E ) "

(

9 !)

("9 '

# >%

"%) 3

# -

%30

" 9-

) #

" ( "

! " !## #"" #"!"" #"#" ""

""" !"$!!" #"! """ #"#" " "

" "" " ! "" " !

#"#" " " ! " " ""%" !

# ! "!!" " ! !!% #" !#"! &

'( "" #"#" ""

"""& !% !!"))" ! #" !!" #% "*+!!"! )"

##!" "" #"#"

"" """&" "

"# !

#" " ! #"!

"" #"#" "" " ""&#" %"#" "!

#"!!"! )"

" ! "" #"#" "" """& #" ," ##" !##!

"! ""!## -

#"!" # #!

* " """& "! " # #-

"% %##!" "#"!" "!

""!!# %

+ ( ##" )" ' %##"

./% " 0 1 ","

23'

! 43' !5" 43+ '!

43." !!" ," # # !

"" #"#"

"" """& !

# % )" ' "! # "#"!"!!" & H

9 !) 9-3/

(

" ((

)

) 9- -

( # # %#

#/) %3(

( # #)

E0I

# #/ / ,- )

"% )

( #

>% ) 3

# %3(

.=&17)

" (

" '

' #

' "-

%" )

6 !"!#$%& '( (!"")* + , %-.

"'$!(!)$!'"

/%7 89':

* /#% 0+*. )0;"!#%"! "*',!

/""7 5"#"< "," 42* !

42*!! ," #!

!" < = ++4 1 :'::3;"# #" !"# ! "!## #"#"!"" #"#" " " """ #"!""

#"#" " " "

""%" !

# !!!"% #! ! # ' !,

) , "" #"#"

" " " ""

# ! "*',! ," + '

),!!") " !#"!!"#% " *+! ,""! #!"" #"#" " " " "" "*',!," .

)

("" #"#"

"" """

!% !!"))" !#" !!"#% "*+! ,"! "!!"!##! """ #"#" "" " ""#,; !" ## )" '!"*',! ," #,;'!"% !

!"#!""#! ""

#"#" "" "

',! %##" )" + ! " *', ! ," !!" ) # #

#"! # # # %#"! # "!" ! !7 7#! " # ! !!" "#! % !!")) " ! % *

),, )> !7#!" < %!" "" 7 7#"# " %" !!" % ! <# ! 5" 9 !

1;" 9 7" ! 7" ! = "!!"! " "# > !7#

!&#"

" ((

- ##

(

>% #/

" 3#

3 %

# 9

( " '

" #K

" '

%" /

=" % " #

#$%!

$ " )$ + .$% )/ ",$ !' (- (

** ""$$.

", $'

%" % (- ( +($ 0$% "$*(

- '

'9 - ## ""

(

% !

%3(

- (

" ((

( '

%3"

' "-

/ '

>% (

%##/ ("# -)

((3

" ((

- ##

((

- ## "-/ ##/ (

9 '-

(

F% " "

/ %( )

.$ + !' (- ( ** ""$$ + % (- ( + ($ 0$% "$*(,- %'

" ((

( %"

, 3# 3#9) (#/ 0# 6 6

( L%

" '(

H !

- -

- +'

- - # +'

= +'

&""/ M"

%') "/- "

) ## %3

/ M"

*- :

5 !" !

" 7 7# " > ! 7#% # 7

7##"" !## 4

$##"

# ! ! $# , ( !!?"

'0"!"" #"#" " )# #

! !

?" !!"" ! ! #

+!!?" "%!!

! !"#!""! ) # # '!"" #"#"

"! ### 83@!/""7 5"#"< " = 42*

. <" ! "" #"#"

"! !!

?" )# # + ! ! ""

#"#" " # !"" " %#! )# # * 8 3

*/"" #"#" " "

" "

"" # !!%

"" #"#" " "

"%"!!!

"" "%#!7 "

," 4.: '+! 4.: %! " 7 7#! "! "# !!"

!" #!! !7 "," 4.: '+!

4.: /""7 5"#"< " ," 42* ! 42* # !8:A!!! ! !!"-

"" #"#" " "

" !!! % ##

""" #"#" " "

" ! %! " 7 7# # !!

!7 "," 4.: '+!

4.: /""7 5"#"< " ," 42* ! 42* !"! !! "! "##!### 7 "," 4.: '+!

4.:

" " %! " 7 7# #!! !/""7

5"#"< "," 42* ! 42*

"" !! %! " 7 7#

8 /"" #"#" " "

"%" " "! %"! !!" "

3 7" ! )# # ""! %#### " "%""#% " " #"## < 5@ % !" " ; " " " # "!<5@ 5 "

" " #"! !

7 7#

: ! , 4 , )7

7#> !7# # ! "!! "" !!

" "#"" #!!"!" " "

#"" ! "#7

7# > !7# # ! "

) ),"!" ! " #"" % % ! " ## !7

7##!,;+ "# # % !

"!!" #" "! #""# # 7

' 1

, % "" #"#" " "

""" %! " 7 7# ### " !" %

+ ),, " ) 5)7!

#!"" #"#" ""

" "" # /""

@=# B &1$&"

9 "%%

(" .=&17)

"% -

%3(

% %3(

)

# -

') '

3 '

" ( "

- 61; 5C <D E #< ?0=/ 84 * * .

FC *!/75<," 5<#

5G ,55!< <0<E ,"" E #< " <0<E# " ! +'

/ +' ! +' +: " ':E"!5##> % " 4 *::E"!5## " ! "" , +' %

#H<EIH,EI HE<I ># " !##" " '*: "!### %!!

#! ; "! , !# % # H<EIH,EI HE<I , +' %.##" !# ! !"" #"#"!'*: ## ! ' 2 %" % #HI

! ' 2%

% #HI "! "" # % # J "%+' %!## " #" <0<E!##!

"#"!!#" #% < C) & <79 7/ 8 :* ':

.B & /( ( +",$#$ + $% &1$&"

9 "

&""/ H%*

/ '

9 '-

+' #

- "

(

3%#*) # '

@+B) @0+B)

@+0B 3( '

(3 0%3>% #/)

%" )

08 % /) * !

.=&17)

/ '

5 #

/ '

-%'- *- 0 '- 6! -( #/

9* '

E0I '

# #) -

#/ %

- 9

# %

%(3

)

.'# -

#"-

.=&17)

-%'- * '

##/ ' .=&17) 9-

- M#

#/)

(

" "

- )

* '

(

# #)

-( #/

(

# (3

E0I

6$??01$?>10,K1L,0/1=5F/9,@$D1=/1/E>,=,= L;;

=#/ .+2.;C':

.C1)'E5 ' =!"/ 3'*)> + < J"?0=/ G . 7!="#G

:):8) .

* !"#G << / *

8 ,"" $#" %"!<E,E E< ";" ### #"%! "M % #"# '*: ! %" #% # 3 5#!!"G ,M# 2 0 !" G""" ! #"!#" #! #"!#" % G) "!#" !" "" $ !### ! # "!#"

0" 1;

1; < C),"1; < C), E "1;5J EB

)

( # 9 %

9 "%)

) " (

%" )

3( /

E0I

! ?

##9 '

(

N-

( # -

3 "%%

-%'-

("9(

O 3

N-

( # #) -

' 9

N- -%

( # #)

E0I 9- %""

.=&17)

-% 9 -

%30

" ( )

' 9

3 %

( # #) ?("

#/ ' .=&17) (" '

" (

& /( ( +("

"!"

/- &( "

* (')

" # '

" ((

)

3#/ '

F%) - 3( '

%) %# 3 #

- K 3

"" ' "

/ #

K H9) % %#

3%#*

(

- '

#*-

(

%" ) #/ &""/ H%* 3 '

, >%

/) 3%

&""/ H%* 9 '- '

, 9- -

>% %(

&""/ H%*

%-)

%(3 %"

)

E0I

( ) /

-( .= (

(

3%#* ""

- 3 '

-( #/

H9)

-3/ (

%" ) *

: ) %30

' # '

- F

F%)

) #

## "

) >% /) >%

/) (

* ') *) %(3 %-

/ '

* '

9- -

*) %

' )

) %# )

H9)

("9

) *

%(3

%" - ()

(

""#

2% ##/ ("9 '

"%"

/ '

* ')

%- '

) "- ' "-

P%- %') %3

/ Q

/ '

%- "- ' "-

##9 '

("#

%- %' %3

)

%- '

/ '

/ #

("# 9

#/ 9-

) -

2% ##/ ("9 '

)

- F "#

)

- #/

# ' ?

)

-%'- %30

- '- "

" ( "

)

' '

- '- "

" ( )

9 % !

#/ "

# "

"- ' "-) ## %3

/ ) 3 "

/ #

("# 9 % %30

&+$ $&#$(+ *",$ ) 1$- &( &% &(.$ (" ",$ ) 1$+ *!

"$% 2!$("

&( + .

)

9- -

" (

' "

-9 /

/ ("9(

((

%" )

( # #)

"" 3%#*)

" ((

)

=("

( % '

( #

8%'

* '

#% 3( %"

%()

%30

' 2%

##9

- F

)

("#

%- %' %3

) 3%

- " 0%3>% #/

/) 3%

9 "

("#

(

3%#*

%- %') %3

)

# >%

- ()

#/ 9

)

%30

" * '

("#)

9 % %

- 3( " ( "

H9) /

#%)

# 3

# #

-( #/

(" '

" (

# -

') " ##/ -%

( # # 3( '

9 '

%()

("#)

-%'- # %30

" ( "

#% % '

- H9)

-( #/

-% 3( '

- ' "

%(3

(" )

.'# -

#"-

- 3 - 3( '

# 3#

# #)

-%'- - '

6 #/

' '

" ( )

9 "

("#) 3%

# (

/ "

9%# %#

"% 3 '

-%'- "%

( # 3%

-%'-

-( #/

# #)

)

) #/ %

9 "

# #!"" * '

# ("#)

"- 3 "/- "

)

%' ?

8%'

E0I %

" ( "

' %

9%# 3 '

## >%

? N -%

# #)

3 '

"- 3 %3

%' ??

=#% '

# #) /

' 3 '

# ,- -%

)

#) 3( " ( ?

"" "

-( #/

' 9

% "

"% 3( =("

(

# "% '

( #

8%' %#

#/)

" (

-( #/

) "

# #)

" ( ) 3%

%32

( #

-( #/

3( '

"% ??? ,-% -%

"" 3

3 '

/ %#

#/)

-3/

? . 3

( '

-%'- "%

( # )

3# "%("

-( #/

& ,-%

"" %

"%("

% - 5 .("- F '#/

%" )

8%') 3(

" (

%""

' %

3 '

# #)

E0I 9- - 3%

' 9

% "

6&0

)

- 3

,- ) #/

9 '

)

# #) 3( %32

- #/ 9%#

' ,-

3 %#/ 3( " ( =("

( "% )

E0I

# =("

( # # >% #/)

' '

" ( )

9 "

("#) 3%

"- ) %#

"" 3

)

# (

* '

-) 3

% '

9 '

) 3

# #/

=#% '

" 3 #

(" ' 3 '

# #) %"

## '

-( #/

H9)

' '

- '- "

" ( )

#/)

=("

( #

%" ) 3%

("#

9 '

(

3%#*)

) 9- - - (

)

- 3

# ?

"- )

- #/

9%# 3(

" ( )

' %

-9 H9

9 '

- 3

-%)

( # -

E0I 3 '

3 "

? . 3

- (

% >%

.=" R "

( #

-%'-

"" %

"%("

% -)

-( #/

- (

",$ $ ( &(+ %

&'",$ ) 1$ &+$ $&#$( . -9 )

-( #/

9- -

9%# 3()

/ 3

(

3 '

# #) /

3( '

" ( ) 9-%"

9%# 3( / % # )

#) -%

(

3 '

-() " %%#/)

- ""

) 9%# /

3( %3

'#/ % 3#

"/- "

("#

,- )

%30

%) - % '

&) 3 %

? . )

-%'-

% # ) 3 9* 3#) 3%

%32

9 '

(

3%#*)

"" 3

' 3 '

3/7

"" 3

-%'-

-9

## '

- "% '

" 3#

("#

)

("#

(

3%#*) 3%

3 %#/

)

- #/

%" ) % '

%30

9%# 3( # ) 9%#

3( % -9 ! H9)

- %'' )

9 '

("#)

(

3%#* -

- % '

2 '

"( ,- ) 9- #/

"" 3

' 3 '

)

%30

9%#

%##

"# /) -9 H9)

"" 3

' 3 '

) ( %# #/

( ""

# %# '

#% )

%= (

"/- "

)

%' ? >%#)

( #

E0I ,- )

% )

( "%

E0I

# -

' 9

,$$++$#"( +-!

- ( 1$ &"$ $"

&" ",$* &% "$ +(!)3$#"

&4 + $#"

&563 +",$#"

"%" "

3 '

%30

# >%

%##

3 '

%##

#' #

9%# 3(

%##/

) =#%

? . 3 =#%

& !

? .

3 '

## )

)

3 '

3 "

9 ) 5

&) #

E0I

)

9- -

3# "%("

' % %30

9%# /

( # ) 3%

#/ 9-

" #/

- '

("#

(

3%#* 3 9-

/ '

- ?

/ '

"" /)

)

9- -

- '- "

" (

') "

- " ##/

-9

("#)

' 3 '

-) "%

" 3# '

"%")

' '

- '- "

" (

/) 9%# 3( %

9%# ( # )

# %32

# 3)

(

3( '

(

/) ( %(

-9 - ?

/ '

#/ /)

( '

)

-%'- -

"" '

E0I >% #/)

- )

9%# 2/

("#

/ )

9%#

# %#

#' #

- =#% '

? . 3 =#% '

3( '

("# #/ #

- 9%# /)

' 3 '

9%#

( #

E0I 3 '

" ( )

') -9

/ '

"" /)

- %

"" 3

3 '

(

- -

"" '

-9

"" "

E0I ,-%) #

3( " ( >% #/)

"%) 3

( # ("#)

)

E0I H9)

3 : ? >%)

'%(

#) " ( 3( 2 )

)

'#/

" '

(%#

- #/

%" ) #%

("#) " (

' ,- )

=("

( " '

E0I =("

( "% ')

E0I

( # # .("- F '#/)

#/ %

("9 "#

)

- (

) -

/ '

/) ((

- % '

' 3 '

3 %

-%'- - " ##/

-9 % '

"" 3

-%'- - "% '

( " 3# '

)

("9 "#

)

' 3 '

# 0%3>% #/)

- () -

- 3 '

E0I %#

#/)

% =#% '

? . 3

&) 9%# 3(

%##/ 3#

# ) 3 9%# '

%##

#' #

9 ()

3 '

H9)

)

? . 3

&) (

%##/

!**

& +-

&# -$( 5

? 3

9 % !

)

) #/ 3

' 3 '

' 9 "

?? ( "%

3( " ( ) 3%

9%# 3( #/ 9-

9 '

"" 3

- )

-%'-

" ##/

## '

- "% '

("9 "#

' 3 '

??? ?

E0I

-9

E0I

/ %(

( "%

3( " ( )

) #

' %

3( "

?$ H9)

9 '

* '

"" 3

' 3 '

)

# #) /

)

E0I 3%

( #

3 (" " ( )

" '

' %

?("

#/) 9-

)

3 !

? .

)

&) (

5 '

H() 1(

&%2 3)

)

H() 1(

3 '

- = ( - -

)

- 5

? >%)

- (

"" #)

)

##9 ("%'

) 9) %" >%

8%' >% -)

)

""##

' 9

- ( " #)

) % 3

-9

##)

) - '

% /)

)

-9 #

( " #

'#/ ""

/) "

-9 %

- () 3%

3#9)

-9 - "" /)

>% )

) /

=" /

# (

9:956964 7 8 ",$(, ,$",$ (-$ ;

&'< $ ( &$%3 $(< 7 & 8"