High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/1618/1998disposed of

(O&M) Union Of India v. Gurmeet

2019-12-16Mrs. Justice Rekha Mittal9 pages

!"! ##

$ %& '($)*)+# ($(,%#++'

!"# $#% &'(") *)(*+&" ) *)$"

# "

&#+%!,( !

-*')" $#%!,(

-.&" )%!,( !

/*&" )%!,( #( 01( 2'! 33333 $(,%#++'- 4! ))$!'5! 6"'! ((!" )5

! /#"!$"))!"' !

! ( 01( " "

! "

"! "()7* " )$ ! ( ",),! !1*!"( " (")"

5 (% (

8 +

9*+ $"!$ &#9"!#":) ")!'')"(

(+' * -;)8#((* ! # #.*),"!4"0+00) )!#"

5-")$5&

" $,! .*),"!4 !<5$ ,))" +$ 6)#" )!# "

5 ," ;

!0!"

" )!# "

5 -")$5 &

"% !(! $ " # '( (+" * ' #))!$#")$"

" #$#) " # ("(*) " )!# "

5 -")$5 &

"% # $ 0!)5 $*!!*) 0+0>')".*),"!4!"!" #"! * $!"("! !'')"( " (+' "*!&( =?@?"@%?"""@!=?""@ #-")$5( %

?"# A A@ /# '')) 2'! B -")$5 !+"" ")! $"

+ "" ')"+"501( * $!"("! $"

#" '("( -")$5 &

" #! ((*! ! *(# '')"( "" +" "0)+"

$!+"

.*),"! 4 !"! " 0+0 0) * "! # '("( -")$5 &

"% )!#/#!(!#!(+') !#"1*5!#!(+*

#-")$5&

"$# #+"#'((*!!*(#"

$ * $!"("! $"

#+" &( "; /#

= -")$5 #! ("! # ' )5 ! " " ! 0)"

> !*' #>"

! #"!

"/#!(!#!)!5 (+* #>"

!!*(# #'')"( ( +" "# ()"+*!&( "; )) #+ "),+ '')"( "$!"!$"

#'5 !"+") #+$"

#( /#'! 2'')"( ")!')"( ""

" # !

8 " # ()"+ '')"( " ! # $"

+ $ ( , ! /#-")$5)"+/"0*)%#!" #(#%#!" # ?"# A #/"0*)A@ +! #"*%! #* C# # #!(!$ "))' "+ 0+00) D C# # # * $! "("! " 7* " ((*! $"

#'("( ")$5

"D = C# # # '')"( " # )5 !'! !(! # #!'! D ; / $# +* (+' "% "

5% " '')"( )! (, + D < -)" /#/"0*)%","$ "!" "* ;%" )" # + ")(!%(('

!()"+ 2'')"( ! #$$!!-)8#% 0#!05 9*+ !8#")4 "7*)#/#-")$5!+"" "$))$! !5 "+ +8'5+ ")" $#"(# #'')"( $))$!" # E'*+ + #!

! ")))" "

;

/#)*0+""+!05(*) " # !(! #! )!5 (+') ! #" 1*5 ! (! # >"

'" ')

+ )!#% ( 0#! 5

#!(!$' $"

#+" &( "? @ ( $# ! # ()"+ ( 0 +" "! *! # ',"" &( "=!; #"'*'%(*)# ! ! ""

" ' "&( "? @!&( "<; !)$"

#>#"0"

"!*! '! "(8 ")$5,

#! #1*5"

"(8 ""*! '("

"!'"!% >'" " *(# '"! " ,#+ )5 *! !(! * "!"1*""0+00)

(+" * #'+" )!#"

5-")$5&

"$#")#$#"" * "(8#$ #" $! 1*5 #" "!(% # /"0*) # $ )5 (!!

"!" "*!" ,* *) ' # ()"+ 2'! % ( 5%#*'' #$! #0 *! ((*(" 7* 8')(;=

0* #$!$'! =

" '')"( ")! =

/# $ +!+ " -")$5(("! ?+' "@-*)%

?"# A #-*)A@ (+ " ( $ ,+0

,"! "( " !

"*! 05 "" 5 -")$5 $#05 (+' ! # ' $"(! +- -;)8# " * # *! "( # !5 '" # $! (+' " 7* ! # ' $ -; )8#% 2( 01( " !!"

")(+' " -)8#$"

#" %( "!05

#"* *'' #"( "%##)"!*'1*! +

< 4A0) # &*'+ * "#$% &'' () '%' '*%"+

,%.%/-0! "1"2&)3"1"' %//"%() '%' '*%"+

,- ,%.%/-4 - (")+! 1*! + #"*

'%' '*%"()5$1%$%'*&15%'6$+ ,4- ,%.%/-

! 578$")$$"'*5$"12"() '%' '*%"+ ,0- ,%.%/-4 *) # '')) % " ')5% $*)! * ( 01( "$ ")!< ! #+0!05)"+"

" ((!" (*)%&#/*&" )%!,( (*!''( 0#) < !+!7* ))$" + "+ ")#"'$

5!*0+"

*+ " * # *! "( #(01( "#,0 ")!+*(#) #= !5 + ("'

"( ( *) #" # '') ! ( 01( # ")!'')"( (! " !)5" ")" ( 01( "% ( # " # ))$" !!"

")(+' "05 " #-*)!1*! + 4A0)

#&*'+* " "#$%&''9):")&?*'@ *) ' # ( 01( 2'! $*)! * #$ "("*!05 #"* $"

# ! ( *) !

#" #'')%!+"

% # % #( 01( "( 0"! 00!05)"+"

" #) ",%"

" *! #"* ">(" 1*"!"( "*!!;-*)== %('1*! + * # #,0'!05 #/"0*)% , "

( 01( " #, 0 ")! 05 2()"+ #" '*'% ( # 0 +! 1*! + 4A0) &*'+* "''";"/()5#"#& 28"<"'*#$&1)+ 54!=>)%'6$()52#&>"8"%+ 50

#,#!(*) #' "%'*! #''08 !(! "*!"'* !'"

" #( .*),"!4 2()"+ $0 "!' ")$5 +$ 6)#" )!# "

5 ! !0!! " -")$5 &

"% )!#"

5;=

#!(!(*)!), #")$5 '("( 20*!5 # )!# "

5 -")$5 &

" ! $ " '( #"" * "(8#$ " #" #*% * * ((*( 0+00) #''!! #!(!* "!"1*" ',!

) # $"

>+"! 05 # -")$5 !+"" "'!*(!') )!#"

5-")$5&

"!'"(

0) *) # !"'* ((*( " 7* 8 ')( $"

# 0*!5 )!# "

5 -")$5 &

"! #"

#$" #') /#/"0*)%$#")!("!" "*##)!%! #* F/# (*) ")$5 !+"" " # *! # 0+0 0) 8 ')( * "! # ")$5

"! >" !/#""

$ $"

"0*")!" 0* )5" #("(*) " #

" $ * # *! #0+00) !"! 8')($"

#")$50*!50* #()"+ (+' "(0 ))$!)5$# #"("! 8')($"

#")$5

"0*")!" *) #'')"( %#$,% *!

&( "; #-")$5(

$#, * $! "("! 8 ')( $"

# ")$5

'+"%(+' "(0))$! #' $#

* ""1*"!"/#(*) )

*"#!+'#$" #)( "$# #0+00)

8 ')( /#" )( " " $"

# '("( ")$5

" ! " # ("(*) " C% # % ("!

#* $! "("! 8')( $"

# '("( ")$5

"!"(,! (+' "*!&( ; #-")$5( G &( " ? @ ! " A' A + ' ,))" $"

#,)"!' "(8 &( "=?(@! "A* $!"("! A ), > ( # +! ))$ FH $!"("! + #"!*) " "" " %# * %055'"5 "(5" ' " $"

" #))% ()8+ , " 08"

"( 5 ')

+ " 5 # ')( $"

'("( ")$5

"F &"( # * $! "("! " # ' ( ((*! $"

#'("( -")$5&

"%(,!*!&( "=?(@

# ( % "

" !"

"(*) (('

( " # '')) '! 2()"+ " (+' " 0(* # !(! #!)!5(!>"

'" #')

+, #* ##! (!

#'("( #-")$5&

" *) # ")! '" * 5',"" " 5 '

!0!" "( 0 ' , "

# " $"

# '("( # -")$5 &

" ! 0(+,"( "+ * $!"("! ! "!"&( "=?(@

( #","$ #+

%( ""!05 " +"

"*% #*%* 0) /# /"0*) $!! - )8# ! " # E'*+"

'5+ $ +!$"

#" !5 + #!

! *) # '')) # !"'* # !

'" #$! #-")$5(("! ?+' "@-*)%

$" ($#05(+' "$"(! +- -;)8# $# #(">+"!" #)" # 1*! + 4A0) #&*'+ * " "#$%&''9):")&?*'@! "1"2&)3"1"' %//"%9):")& ?*'@% $ (+' " -; )8# $"

# " /# 7* " ("! " "% $# # '! (' !!"

")(+' ","

(01( " ")! $"

# '("0! '"! )"+"

" /8" " ("! # " "+ ! '! 05 #" * + < % #"(' +(()*" (01( "$

")! 05! '"! '("0! " # ! ",") (!* H!"'* !)5% # ( " 0,) (") ) ") " ! '(!" 0 #/"0*)*++5" */#',""!)" $"

# (+' "","

)"0)( *( " '*' " * !!

" 0) ( 05'" " ,"( (#"()("! "*) %"" # "#" *0+"" ,"

#! ")!5(01( "%

#$!(0+!"

"!">(" 1*"!"( "*!!;-*) == 05 '" 1*! + * # #, 0 '! 05 /"0*)*) # !"'* #!

'" #$!%'! $ (+' * -;)8#4#) !"'* #*("

")"!!$054A0)

# &*'+ * " "#$% &''9) :")& ?*'@ /# 0" % '! #))0 !!"

")+* -)8#%'50)$"

# " # E'*+ + #!

$! ")))"I "%

0'"! #'?@" + #$! ,"$ $# #0!"(*!#"0 % #'') !"+"!!(01( "))$!" "! + ! ( + , =;- J69*) "K C# #'8" 2!

52 C# #' 0)