High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-AS/121/2023disposed of

Pfizer Crop Science v. Gurpal

2025-11-27Mr. Justice Surya Partap Singh3 pages

"#$#% & '(()

*& +, *(

!"#"

$ %&'

(& # )"'

)) *****

( ( - .

# )"'

# (") # )"'

"& +", (& ) % &

, " # !-,. &( '/-" )$ " '&. ) " '

""- - '"& 01 23 &( ,&"

4) -. '$ 11 5#" ( ( & 6 '78$ 9#4:$ '&. ) " (") 4: # )"'

9 "." # ''- '/-" 3 # )"." /-"& "", (& '&" "& " # &'", " 9## , " !-,. &( '/-" 4: #

&- &( ) ;-"'"

," $ < ) " '&. ) " '

$ 9"# , & '&..""& &( &((' -"# 4) - '"& 01 23 &( '$ '

4 " # " ' &( '&. ) " - # &%"& &

'"& 0=3 &( # >

3 0 # "- " & )&, 6

!"##

" $ # ?&@4) - . &- -#&" "%): #) # '&. ) " " &'-"& - '"& 01 &( # '$ /- )"(" 6%"'".7 - '"& 359 8 &( # $ 4", # & 9#& -(( (" '"

) )& - & "#&&- &(

'#/- &/-):$ -'# '&. ) " " ") & --

, " '/-" ) - # &%"& & '"& 0=3 &( # 9"#&- # /-". &( +", '"

) ) % - '"& 0=1528 &( # # ) '&-) (& # )"'

)) # -4." # #

)"'

)) $ 9#& " %"'".$ 9&-) )"+ & A'" # & "& % ") 4) & " 4(& # "& &- 2 & ", ,.

!-"' &" & '# ,-" 4:

# "'" ) # &'- ) -) .- % & &4-' # '&- &( !-"'$ #" &- . " & "

& "' # # ) 4 & -#&" "%): ""- - # &%"& & '"& 0=3 &( ".") %"9 # 4 + 4: #" ?",# &- " '

3=BB 3B1$ ") 6

"# <-.

;-, ) <"#&7 C '&')-"&$ #" &- " -: 4&- & # .&"D '& ", &%""& " .

# 4 % # " &( !-"'$ -", # .#& &( " ( '""("' '# #(&$ " %"9 &( # !-,. 4: # ?&74) - . &- "

# ( ' # # )"'

"& (& ) % & ) " ",$ ) "& ;-,$ < ) " "' & # )$

) (") - '"& 0=3 &( # - # . &

& "

&- (& " " & )

0 E # '&' )) &- # )) &' & '" # A ""&-):$ 9"#&- 4", ". 4:

: ) : " (")", # )$ " %"9 &( # ), ) &""& &9 ') "(" 4: # ?&74) - . &- = # ,": " "' & ." #" & )&, 9"# # '& :

&( # '&. ) 4&&+ - # "

&- '&$ "( '"%$ & # ) "& ;-, '&' 1 " & &( ''&",):

'(() F## +", & G F## & 4)