High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/11924/2019allowed

Rajbir Singh v. State Of Punjab

2021-09-06Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan7 pages

! "#

" $ %& '( & ) !* & '( & "'+ & "! & '( "&

, & '-& ! !. -& '( &

+#. /0 ! ( 1

!"#$

* " # "

* . 23 4 4 5 ! " 6 4& 7 & 5&

3 / " 5& 55& 676& 66&

3 ) . 1 " 7& 4

'+" ' & 7 "

. *

0 0 9 6 &

) " ) #""$ :%

0!; 9#

* /1

* )" ..

"# )

5 3

# . . (.* "

# .

## " !#& " ) !"

)" ""!

+ 5

( " <#. )

& )(& *

)" .;."

" * .

& )

) )" #""

4 5 /'<! 1$ &'()*+)*,-),'./ 0120!113454#64(31##"71'8("99#43"24'7(.'!.4#47: 201"617;1;<!42912424'7469#1";47:9"!241("7; .'! 9#"347: 31!2"47 ;'386172( '7 !13'!; "!1 "##'<1;(8=>1322'>8(21?31924'7(

%)*%/ ((81 7'2431 '. 6'24'7 !128!7"=#1 '7 @,/ 1(9'7;172'(2')@@"7; <"451; (1!5431 "( ! 54742 5"(204

87>"= "33192( 7'2431 '7 =10"#. '. !1(9'7;172 '(2')! 4A"( 47:0;5'3"21'7=10"#.'.

!1(9'7;172'@! 1;4;5'3"21'7=10"#.

'.!1(9'7;172'("7;"7;! "22"7"

;5'3"21'7=10"#.'.!1(9'7;172'@"(24.' '201!!1(9'7;172(.201"##1:"24'7((2"21;47201 912424'7 "!1 2!81 42 4( 47;11; " (1!4'8( 6"221! '<151!<420'82201=171.42'."!19#B.!'6201 !1(9'7;172(<1;'7'2<4(02'1?9!1(("7B541<'7 20161!42('.2013"(1"2204((2":11?31922'(2"21 20"22016"221!!1C84!1((1!4'8(3'7(4;1!"24'701 #1"!71;3'87(1#"991"!47:'7=10"#.'.!1(9'7;172 '(2')(2"21(20"2201<'!A4("29!1(172=147: ;'71'7"7";0'3="(4(=B"3'664((4'7":172"7; 201("61<4##=1(8=>1322'"7B.8!201!;134(4'7'. 1(9'7;172 '( 2' ) '! '. 204( '8!2 2 4( 201!1.'17'27131(("!B 2' 3'7(4;1!"7B 4721!46 !1#41.":"47(22019!45"21!1(9'7;172("2204((2":1 =1.'1 201B 0"51 "7 '99'!28742B '. .4#47: "7 "..4;"542%47%!19#B . 201 912424'71!

(8..1!( "7B ;"6":1'7"33'872'.201;1#"B424("#<"B("2 #4=1!2B 2' ";'92 9!'311;47:( ":"47(2 201 9"!241( 3'731!71;.'"99!'9!4"21!1#41.(29!1(1727' !4:02( "!1=147: 3!1"21;47."5'8!'."7B9"!2B 473#8;47: 201 ("4; 3'664((4'7 ":172 <0' 4( 3"!!B47: '7 <'!A '7#B '7 "7 "; 0'3 ="(4( '7(4;1!47: 201 7"28!1 '. 201 6"221! "## 201 !1(9'7;172( (0"## .4#1 2014! "..4;"542(%47%!19#B <42047217;"B( '.2014!!1314547: 7'2431 '.204( 912424'7 01 912424'71! <"( =B " 7'2431 ;"21; */ ;4!1321; 2' 1?9#"47 04( 9'(424'7 =B "991"!47:91!('7"##B=1.'12014(2!432"7":1!

"2 '7 */ 01 7'2431 (2"21; 20"2 ."4#47: <0430 42 <'8#; =1 9!1(861;20"2201912424'71!<"(7'24721!1(21;47 3"!!B47: '82 201 <'!A "( 91! 201 21!6( "7; 3'7;424'7('.201":!1161728!4'8(#B201

6 4698:71; '!;1! =#"3A#4(247: 201 912424'71! <"( 9"((1;'7*/411517=1.'!1201;"21'.201 01"!47:!547425"(204 87>"=2';"B 9!';831;"3'!!4:17;86<0430(2"21;20"220!'8:0 "2B9':!"9043"#1!!'!201'!;1!4(;"21;*/ 47(21";'.*/'7(4;1!47:201."32("7; 34!386(2"731('.2013"(1201'!;1!47('."!"(42 =#"3A#4(2(201912424'71!4((2"B1;.'!"##98!9'(1( 24##20171?2;"2120"22016"221!4(2"A1789.'! 01"!47:'9B;"(2487;1!201(4:7"28!1('.201 1730 13!12"!B

;D% "E4.;"!$041.8(2431

;D% 5711(0047:"7$8;:1F %

& *

* )"

! ) ) ;

)

)" #""$ &'87(1#.'!201912424'71!4721!"#4"(8=642(20"2 54;13'668743"24'7;"21;+*/ 771?8!1

%*$201912424'71!<"(91!64221;2'3"!!B'7;"B 2';"B<'!A24##201"<"!;'.71<3'72!"3287;1! 201 ("61 21!6( "7; 3'7;424'7( '7 "33'872 '. #424:"24'7917;47:"7;201!14((2"B'!;1!.!'6201 91? '8!2 2 4( .8!201! (8=64221; 20"2 201 5"#4;42B '. 201 ="7A :8!"7211 0"( "#(' =117 1?217;1; .!'6 ,// 2' */@ '7 201 ("61 21!6( "7; 3'7;424'7( 771?8!1 %*$

1(8#2"72#B 201 ";%0'3 217;1! 771?8!1 %$ <04300"(7'<=1174((81;0"(=117C81(24'71; '2431 '. 6'24'7 ! '"=4" ;;424'7"# 87>"="33192(7'2431'7=10"#.'.!1(9'7;172 '(*,"7;2'+'9B=1(899#41;;8!47:201 3'8!(1'.;"B'24312'87(1!51;!1(9'7;172(=1 4((81;.'!)/=B<"B'.;"(249!'31((

;D% "7;0"<"#4"$8;:1

;D% 78947;1! 47:0!1<"#$8;:1F %

+ ( ##. = 7

5 > = 6777

# ( ?! "! *

* " "# !""" 0 " ##. )"

# " * #""

)

5$ &04(4("7"99#43"24'76";1=B201912424'71!<420 "9!"B1!2'3'66"7;201'..434"#!1(9'7;172(2' 9!'54;1";1C8"219'#431.'!31.'!2!"7(9'!2"24'7'. .'';%:!"47(.!'6201:';'<7('.!1(9'7;172(' 2' + (428"21; 47 4(2!432 "!7 "!"7 2' "224

"4#01";4(2!432"!7"!"7.'!<0430420"(" 5"#4; 3'72!"32 01 "##1:"24'7 6";1 47 201 "99#43"24'7 4( 20"2 ;1(9421 0"547: 6";1 "## 201 "!!"7:16172( .'! 2!"7(9'!2"24'7 '. .'';%:!"47( =13"8(1'.2014##1:"#4721!.1!1731'.31!2"4791'9#1 0"547: 9'#4243"# 9"2!'7":1 201 2!"7(9'!2"24'7 3'8#; 7'2 =1 3"!!41; '82 "7; ;1(9421 !1C81(2( ";1C8"21 9'#431 .'!31 <"( 7'2 6";1 "5"4#"=#1

0172016"221!<"(2"A1789B1(21!;"B#1"!71; ;;424'7"#;5'3"21171!"# 87>"=<"(!1C84!1;

=B8(2'(11A47(2!8324'7(47204(!1:"!;';"B'7 201 ="(4( '. 201 47(2!8324'7( !131451; .!'6 ;;424'7"# 1982B '664((4'71! "7; 174'!

891!47217;172 '. '#431 "!7 "!"7 #1"!71;

;;424'7"#;5'3"21171!"# 87>"=(2"21(20"2 ";1C8"21 9'#431 .'!31 (0"## =1 9!'54;1; 2' (".1:8"!;2012!"7(9'!2"24'7=B201912424'71!.!'6 201:';'<7('.!1(9'7;172('2'+(428"21;47 4(2!432"!7"!"72' "224 "4#01";4(2!432"!7 "!"79!'54;1;47.'!6"24'74(9!'54;1;14201!2' 1982B'664((4'71!'! 174'! 891!47217;172'.

'#431 "!7 "!"7 <420 !1(9132 2' 201 2!"7(9'!2"24'7=B201 '';'!9'!"24'7'.7;4" 33'!;47:#B <1 ;4(9'(1 '. 201 "99#43"24'7 47 "33'!;"731<420201(2"2161726";1=1.'!18(=B #1"!71;;;424'7"#;5'3"21171!"# 87>"=

;D% G!4(07"8!"!4$041.8(2431

;D% !87 "##4$8;:1F %

" )" #""

(* < * 4 #"

23 )" "

) 67 #"

" ) + 7

"& ) " +" )

+ & ) ."

" !" 3 "!+

" # " #. "

." +#. 23& ( #" & .

) 0

.& ! )

7 3"#

.& 8 &'+ "

;

(

3"#

.& 8 & '+ " "

30 ! "!#("

. /3("

1& '+ " /!.1 ) )

++" /31& '+ " /!.1

/31&0 0 3 "

& )" "# ..* +

30 ).. * !

#!.* + " "!+ #

" "@23 ).. .*

## (.

30 %

30 " * !

+* " 7 #"

" (## "

+ " ( " *

#!# " %

( .(+

#" 23 !

# . . (.* ) ) !#"

" # .. " 23& !" + ) / +#. 1 )" ! "!"

( ! "

. !# %

+#. ) ..

" !" ) . "+#. " # # ( *

5 =

, 8& '( & """

* 8"

!. -& ) #" & #

+#.

" # .. " 23& " "# ..*

. #"

" .! ) # .

."& A9@3"#

" B!+ A !; & ( "!

!" %

+#.

! 4 3 " + !

#!".

23&

..* "C %"

5 3 + +& "

30 " "

3"#

.& 8 & '+ " +".

## (.

30&

).. ;& # "

30 6 *

+ "

?! * 30 9 "

& ."

+ . "!

!" #"

. " "! *

30 A )(& ".. ("

" ) .. !#

".. * " " # ( ! 65 /1 =

6 3 + "+ +" " 65 5C %

"!+ #!"!

6 & # " ("

* ("

% !".& "

! "

+ '3 8. & "

"#!

!. # " "

* ("

3 ()

(& " # " ..

) + .

# ( 6 " + "

" (" ! 65 /1

$ )@ "74#