High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/3147/2002allowed

Lalchi And ORS. v. Harmail Singh And ORS.

2019-02-28Mr. Justice Harsimran Singh Sethi6 pages

!""#$%$&'() **+ , -

**, ./,

*, , - , , ' 0*

,,1* !"#

# %# $%& ' ' ()#* +++++ ,1*2

* , - $$# #* *. / # 0& 0# 0 /& "

1#2& &# 0 "&! &)(& & # / ! &"( # #""&

# & ##( 3 - "

#&/$&&0# &/& ( #"

#&/# #

#& $! #""& # #5$ #" ( # # & &!& *(*. &! " ("0## ,- 6# "( #$$

# " # # $ #/ 1+ 1#5& &#&* "# 0 "# 0# #*( # / *( $ 0& ( "#& "# # .# & *(# *(##( 0 "# 1#2&&#

0# "&! # &)(&##( 0

& 3 - 6# "( " #& "&"(/#" &" *( &! & #$$# #" " 78(

&/&# "

#&/$&&9"$ #0# :;+#""(

&#*& &.& #

.((#&#* ,:- # "( $ "

# 4&*(# 5&#""(<=>9+ & *.1+ * 1#2&&#& "# &0 &0#$"& &"#

./& # # #5 " (" $ *( # # ## ?( %$ # " (" # * 0 0 & # 0 *(0# 0& 0# $1#2&&#& # *(# & $"

0# (

&)(&# #& "&"(/#" # 4&*(# ## $#)(/$&( #/!&*(0# && .(& . &"# #*( &!"( $&* .#&"&$# ##$#0( # & "( #" ("** #/ ("

#" #$## #& "&"(/#" 0# "## "#(& $# &! # " (" *( 0 /#

. # /# &#. $( " *! ,@- < #! "& (*/&& # "( $#& - $ #//# *.1+ #&"#& & $ ( %"& 77 " ("0#&& ## )#" &!# &#5& " ("$ *( " ("#!# & #& $($ # & * 0 0# && # # )#" # 0#& $" # &; &* & *(0 *( # .$$ # & $"

0# (#& &)(&!(#

.(""(/*& #/# # 0 #.

,3- /& $&&!# *. # (* " (" *(0#& # *( /0 "# 0# # $$# *(# 0#&# &&& # 0& &!%#/ &!=1+

" # &! # " (" &/

#!& $$ "# / $& # & *(&

&/ *( # $$ < #"&0#&"(/*($ " (" *( #!* # # *(# #!( #/0#$ &

&/ *( # $$ # $#0#&# #/ 0 . # *( # $$ & & #. ("

#/ &! *( # " (" *( * 9#/& (*&0# (. "# #!0#& *( $# # *(*( !& "" 0 # *(0 &0#&

&/&< "&"(/#"<0(

" ("# &! *(#0

# "# 0 8(#

. &&#/("

# " (" & ( 0# $$& $$# *(;$# & $ #

*(&

&/ *( # $$ ?& " (" *(0#&&& *(# )#" &!&# *& # *(" " ("& # *( 0#&# ( # . $## & *(4 #& (.0# &"

# *. " (" *(0# " (" *(9#/& 4 ## !& "& #0#""( 9#/&#& " (" *( =( # "

#&/# # & )("/$#&4 "# 0##(5&

#*(0 * & ( $ & / 0& # 0 /& "

'"#

1#2& &# & 3 $ & &"#& &( ( &&/(/1#" A 3 !#$& /&&/(/0#$#.#* #(5&

#*(0# A::$/ "$. & &"#& ( .& *. # "(

#&#5" # "$.

# ! # "( $ 0 &$( # /&&/(/ 0# $#.#* # (5&

05 "" & &"/ "# &#5# A::$/ ( 3;+ $/%&" "# 0# # .# ## 0#

/$ . #$$###$ @ &! "&& BC* %($/ 7( & D

E #* & &"/ "# /&( #9 "/$ &*#5 & #""( 0# (( $$" 0 "/$(& "/$#& $#.#* %" . # $ $###$ @ !&&& "&& BC* %($/7(&

# (/ ;+ & $#.#* #""( $(# "&(/0 :;+&$#.#* #""( (# 9$# &5 #/( #""( # %&" "# * & ( $ # ("&0( */# F ;

&"/ "# 0# &$# 9$%&" "# 0## /& . : .# # # $ $###$ "&& BC* %($/ 7( & D

C /( &$ & D 3C 0( * #$$ &"#* ,A- %&" #""& 5 $ #"

# "# /#& # /& & $&# &#(76( &### & # # 0 #. 3 / 9$ /( #! * &"(

#/ "# ( !& "& " . /#5&#( &/##(/ ;+&#0# #""( / &"# 9$6&50&& "&& BC* %($/7(& D

!" C

## & #0# = ;+ #""( $#& # (

& 0 "# # 0

# "

#&/# (

0 "# ! *0 # # # #""& &

# # , - 78( . "/$#&$#.#* 05(#( + & <"/# = 3 && (($$" F E #* & &"/ "# G =

;+ &&& 4# &"/+= 3H=

G= :

;+ &! ' ("&F ;

# &"/G=@G= 3A;+ ! ( &$ &G 3 !& = 3A9 9 3G= 3 ;+ !&& 6 $(# "&(/ ;+ !&&& (# 9$ :;+ &9 6 # :;+ 9 &"# 9$ ;+ 9& #&# (

& ;+ 9&& 4# 2)(2;+ , - %&" $ # "# 0 8(#

. & "/$#&$#.#* & &#* *#$$& & #& ::#""( "&*(. &" "# #0

# &! # " (" *( "" & . # ##& # "/$#&

A3 ;+ #$$

# # & #0# "/$#&

;+ :# # .$#& #"/$#&#""(

&#*& &.G AA ;+# 0& &F@E$#(/0&

" # "

#&/$&&&

# $#./ - /&#9 &#*& &.& #. (($$"

* (" 0 /#5&$#./ "/$#&&#"" #"0& "&& & D

"" & . #$$# & 334"5 #0# # $# *. # 4&*(# 6( &##&65$$"5 9# #*! ,1*

"789 8:(2) ! "# $#5&;# ; $#* ;