High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/813/1995disposed of

(O&M) Jugraj Singh v. State Of Punjab & Another

2025-11-26Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja6 pages

!"# !"# !"# !"# " " " "

"0.,"

",755-' ",755-' ",755-' ",755-'$ $ $ $

$$ $$ $$ $$

% & & & & % % % % 11,220-.

11,220-.

11,220-. !" !" !" !" ,1-6,-.

,1-6,-.

,1-6,-. $

% & & & & % % % %

11,220-.

11,220-. !" " " " ,1-6,-.

,1-6,-.

! %

& & & & % % % %

11,220-.

11,220-. !" !" !" !" ,1-6,-.

,1-6,-.

' +,,-.' + + + (!) % *% (!) % *% (!) % *% (!) % *%

5.,/&,+80 6>70., ./,011,220-.D20-6;-,+ ./0+/8,6 " :-E0= FFFF +02 +02 +02 +02 *% *% *% *% &56 6, ./5 788- +6,+ ./, 0 0+,8,-.5-,6 011,02 0+, =, ,5-@ 6,756,6 0 ./, 08, /0>, 0+5,- :. 78 88- 079:55.5-D;0+6 5->2> >5-@ 56,-.570207.0 0-69:,.5-20;+./,0< <,=+,>5.?

07.0+,=,5-@.0< <,- +8

3$4 !? ;0? 1+,,-. 011,02 7/02 22,-@, /0 =,,- 2056 . ./, ;

;0+6 60.,6 10,6=?./,2,0+-,6662"

"5.+57. :6@, !0+-020/,+,5-0 .,+ .=,+,,++,60 0./,A,,+,-7, :+.B ;/,+ ,=?,,+,-7,,.5.5-52,6:- -6,+ %,7.5- ./ /, )0-6 79:55.5- 7.

C C + /+. A./, C 7.B 0.

5-.0-7,./,2 20-6;-,+;010+.2?022;,6 ;/52,@+0-.5-@./,8./,=,-,5.

. ,-/0-7,6 80+<, ,. >02:, G

$ DI 1,+ 0 07+, 9:0 ./, 079:5+,6 20-6 =,5 56, :-6,+./, C7. 0;0+6.0.:. +?=,-,5.D5-.,+,.01+>56,6:

!+ 5,2? .0.5-@ 5- ./, 1+,,-. 7 70, 8, 20-6 ;-,6 =? 011,220-.D20-6 ;-,+5.:0.,6;5./5-./,+,>,- -:,,.0.,>5220@,!0+-020 0.5 %,</;0-0-6% 0-@/,+0 708,.=,079:5+,6> >56,.5570.5-60.,6$

0-6$ 5:,6:-6,+%,7.5-C ./, C7.+,1,7.5>,2?+ 1:=257 1:+1, -08,2? + ./, ,H.,-5- % 0-@/,+0 =?, 10 22;,6 =? 0- ;0+6 10,6 =? ./, )0-6 79:55.5- 2 22,7.+ + /+. A./, ) B - C $ ;/ 0,,6./,80+<,.>02:,./ /,079:5+,620-6G DI 1,+ 07+,+ /0/5D ,/+520-60-6 DI1,+07 7+,+@05+8:8<5-20-6 3C4 @ @@+5,>,6./,+, ./,011,220-. I20-6;-,+5-><,6,,+, -7, :-6,+%,7.5-

./, C7.

;/57/708, .=,10+.2?022;,6=?./,2,0+- -,6 ,,+,-7, :+ +.>56,5.0;0+660.,6 ;/52,@+0-.5-@./,8,-/07,6 781,-0.5-G G

$ DI1,+07+,9:0./, 079:5+,620-6=,56,0;0+65-@ @022 ./,+.0.:.+?= =,-,5.D5-.,+,.5-./,5+0>:+:- -6,+./, C7. "5 I0.55,6;5././,;0+610, ,6=?./,2,0+-,6,,+,-7, :+.

7,20-6;-,+ ./,1+,,-.011, ,02;,+,1+,,++,60../,5-.0-7 34 81 1:@-5-@ 0+,056 ;0 0+6 2,0+-,6 7:-,2 + 011,220-.D20-6 6;-,+ :=85. ./0. ./, 2,0+ +-,6 ,,+,-7, :+. ;,-. ;+ -@ /0>5-@ 6570+6, ,6 ./, 02, 5-.0-7, 1+>,6 - +,7+6 =? ./, 011,220-.

I 20-6;-,+) ,0+-,67:-,2:=85../0../, 079:55.5-5-./,1+,,-.70,;

;0 70++5,6:.+.

./,1:=2571:+1,-08,2?+.

/,,H.,-5-%0-@/,+0=?,1 10

0-6 ./, 079:5+, ,6 20-6 +8,6 10+. +,>,-:

:, ,.0., >5220@, !0+-020 0.5 %,</;0-0-6%0 0-@/,+0 3 4 ),0 0+-,67:-,202:=85../0..

./,02,5-.0-7,HIC.H I 1+6:7,6 - +,7+6 =? ./, 011,220-.I 20-6;-,+ 1,+.05-,6 . 0+,8,-.5-,6 +,>,-:,,.0.,>5220@,%0-@/ /,+00-6!0+-020-2?0-6./: 08, 7:26 -.

. /0>, =,,- 6570+6,6 8,+,2? - ./, @+:-6 ./0. 7810+0.

.5>, 270.5-./, 20-6+85-@10+../,02,6 6,,6;,+,-.5-./,>575-5.?0 ./, 079:5+,6 20- -6 , :+./,+ 15-. :. ./0. .

./, 02, 6,,6 ./:@/ 1,+.05-,6 6 . 8022 10+7,2 20-6 ./, 08, 7:26 /0>, =,,- +,25,6 :1- =? ./, 2,0+- -,6 ,,+,-7, :+.

.=?0112?5-@011+1+50.,6,6:7 7.5-.;0+680225J,./,0 0+,0 :7/02,.+0 0-07.5-0-6077+65-@2?

./, 80+<,.>02:,./,079:5+,620 ;0.=,,-/0- -7,6 34 - ./,./,+/0-6 2,0+-,6%.0.,7 :-,2:=85../0.0;,22I+,0- -,6 0-6 E:.55,6 ;0+6 /06 =,,- 10,6 =? ./ /, 2,0+-,6 ,,+,-7, :+. :1 1- 011+,750.5-.

./,12,065-@0-6./,,>56,-7,0 0>0520=2,-+,7+6;/57/ ./:7 022 + - 5-.,+,+, ,-7, ),0+-,6 %.0., 7:-,2 02 2 15-. :. ./0. ./, 02, 6, ,,6 HIC . H I ;,+, +5@/.2? 6570+6,6 =,5-@ @ +,20.,6 . 802210+7,2 20 0-6 ./: /, 1+0? + 658502 ./, 011,02 1+,,++,6 0. ./, 5-.0-7, 011,220-.D20-6 6;-,+ / /0>, /,0+6 2,0+-,6 7:-,2 + ./, 10+.5, 0-6 @-, ./+:@/ 101,+=<0;

;,220+,7+6./,70, 5-6:=.0-7,5-./,:=855 - 806,-=,/02 ./,011,220-.D20-6;-,+ 3 4 - ./, 1+,,-. 70, ./, 20-6 1 1,+.05-5-@ . ./, +,>,-:, ,.0., , >5220@,!0+-020 00.5%,</;0-0-6%0-@/,+0;, ,+,079:5+,6+./,1:=2571:+1 1,

-08,2?+./,, ,H.,-5-%0-@/,+0=?,10 -:11+../,5+72058.;0 0+6 ,-/0-7,8,-. 80+<,.>02:,./,079:5+,62 20-6 ./,011,220-.I20-6;-, + 1+6:7,6 - + +,7+6 02, 6,,6 HIC . HI ./, 6,.052 ./,+, 0+, /,+,:-6,+'I &5 &5 &5 &5 5220@, 5220@, 5220@, 5220@, +,0 +,0 +,0 +,0

-56,+0.5-

-56,+0.5- - "0., "0., "0., "0., H,7:.5- H,7:.5- H,7:.5- H,7:.5- H/5=5. H/5=5. H/5=5. H/5=5. %0 !0 !0 0-@/,+0

*I DI 0+-020

*I$ $DI 0+-020 DI

$ IC $ $ I

I 34 /, ,0+,8,-.5-,602,6,,6;, ,+,6570+6,68,+,2?+./,+,0 - ./0. ./, 7810 0+0.5>, 270.5- ./, 20-6 7 781+5,6 5- 0+,8,-.5-,6 02, .+0-07.5-0-6 6./0.079:5+,620-6;0-. 1+>,6-+,7+6!,56,./, 056 02,.+0-07.5- ;,+,+,20.,6.802210+7,2 20-6-./,/:8=2,15-5- - ./5 :+.

./,0 0+,056+,0-5-@+,7+6,6=? ./,2,0+-,6,,+,-7, :+.5 -. :.05-0=2,5-20 0;05-./,1+,,-.70,079:

:55.5-/0=,,-70++5,6:. 20-6+85-@10 0+.+,>,-:,,.0.,>5220@,!

!0+-0200.5%,</;0-0-6%0-@/ /,+0 0-6./,02,5- .0-7,HIC.HI1+>, ,6=?./,011,220-.I20-6;-, + 021,+.05-,6.

./,08,+,>,-:,,.0., ,>56,-7,/0=,,-15-.,6:.

.. /;0-?<5-6 65,+,-7,.;0+6-0.:+,0- -61.,-.50265,+,-.10+7,2 20-6+85-@10 0+../,08,+,>,-:,,.0., ./,>5220@,!0+-0200.5%,</;

;0- 0-6%0-@/,+0 4 :

:+./,+8+, 5- ./, 70, 079 9:55.5- 20-6 +85-@ 10+. +,>,-:,,.0., ./,02,6,,61,+.05-5-@../, ,08,+,>,-:,,.0.,-,,6. =, +,25,6:1-0./ /,+,5-5@-5570-.6510+5.?5- -1.,-.5020-6270.5-0206>0-.

0@, 0..07/,6../,2 0-6+85-@10+.-,788- -+,>,-:,,.0.,>5JI0I>5J./,20

+85-@10+. 0+,0270.,665,+,-.2?5-./, :+=0-0+,077+65-@2?

./, 02, ,H,8120+ HI IC 1,+.05-5-@ . ./, +,>,-:, , .0., >5220@, %0-@/,+0 + 20 8,0:+5-@ * *0-02;0+,9:5+,6.=,+,25,6:1 1-+0,8,-.80+<,.>02 2:, /:@/ 5. 1,+.0 05-,6 . *0-02 =,56, =,5- -@ 1. -.5570.5- =? 028. 8-./0-6 6 60? 0-011+1+50.,6,6:7.5-G GK1,+0--:8-./,=0,1+ +57, 1,+ 07+, 6,+5>,6 6 +8 HIC -,,6 . =, 01 1125,6 + 6,.,+85-0.5- 80+ +<,. >02:, 1,+.05-5-@ @ . ./, 1+,,-. 079:55.5- ;/ /57/ 78, . $C $ $$ 1,+ 07+,%5-7,./, 02,5-.0-7,HIC1,+.05-. 802210+7,220-68,0:+5-@ @ *0-02 ./,+,+, , 06,6:7.5-GK-,,6.= ,01125,60-6./,>02:,./: 78 8, .$ $ $CDI I1,+07+,

4 -.

./,@5>,-07.5-7,./,079:55.

.5-5-./,70,5-/0-6/0= ,,- 70++5,6:.+.

./,1:=2571:+1, -08,2?

./,,H.,-5-%0-@/,+0=?,1 10 0-60:7/./, +,1-6,-.D%.0.,/0-.:, +,62.;0+6:.525J0.5-20 +,>,-5-7:++,6 67.+1+>565-@0665.

.5-025-+0.+:7.:+0208,-5.5,0 ./: -7:.-,,6 6.=,01125,6.;0+6./,6,>, ,218,-.7. $4 77 7+65-@2?

./, 80+<,. >02:, + ./, 20-6 :-6,+ 079:55.5- - 5 0,,6 G $ $ $CDI 1,+ 07+, - 0665.5 - ./, 20-6;-,+ /022 02 =, ,-.5.2,6+0;0 +6022./,+.0.:.+?=,-,5. 0-65-.,+,.01+>56,6:-6,+ 1+>55-./, , C7.08,-6,6:1..60 0.,/,20-6;-,+/02202 =, ,-.5.2,6+20.

.5:8G K=,56,0;0+65- -.,+,../,+,:1-0;,22

- -,9:,-.2?

5- >5,; ./, 657 7:5-806, /,+,5- 0=>, 022 011,02 1+,,++, ,6 0. ./, 5-.0-7, 011,220-. I20-6;-,+ 0+, /,+,=? 10+ +.2? 022;,65-./,0 +,056.,+8

C4 L/ /,+,>,+ ./, 20-6;-,+ /0D/ /0>, :-+.:-0.,2? ,H15+,6 5- 011,02D7+I =E,7.5-0.,+525-@./,+, 0-6./,2,@02/,5+/0>,-.= ,,- 5812,06,6 ./,?

? /022 =, 0. 25=,+.? . ,,< ,H, ,7:.5- ./, 1+,,-. 6,755- =? 8>5-@011+1+ +50.,0112570.5-=,+,./,2,0 0+-,6H,7:.5-@ :+. 4 22 1,-65-@0112570.5- 50-?

/02202.0-6651,6 *% *% *% *%

>,8=,+ >,8=,+ >,8=,+ >,8=,+$ $ $ $ $ .5< $$ $$ $$ $$ L/ L/ /,./,+1,0<5-@D+,0-,6 #, /,./,++,1+.0=2, #, D D