Bhagwant Singh v. Rehra Ram
! !"#$#%& ' (
)* +,- .+
!"# $% !& '! ) *$% !& '!(!%!+, - &.!/( 0 11111 - .+/01 2 ( " 3 ('% 30 4#* &/!'&!/( %% #% %% %26272888( % 30" %!!&&#%."
#/#3- "$ # $! &&!-!'# -# - #%30 *5 #*# /!! #&-"
&&#%
2 , 73#''
&!'& !296+288:$ ;&"
*5 #*< *% 3!-770 =$5 &!/#*3 &4!#!-!
3#&0&" '-(("0#*/#"4 !
#0$ ""4 &% #!' #*$ (!;79,2+>6$3#*%# 30(!% !2 /# $*"#* %& "/ '!/ "5 # <
=#%$& / ""!' -%% %-&4 * #3#&0&"!' &"
-"$3#&0&" %&"
'""!/ ""%!
% &"
&# %/-"#("#!-# -#!
#!-( !'3!%0
&&!-!'# -#-''%# &&#%$&"
'#"% (##!
-% &#!2??!'!!#&"&3'!" %!!&&#% ."
#/#3- "$ # $4#*&!/( #!'!# -#-''%30#/ ' ((&# #* #%&"%30( #$" %%
"-/(;-/&!/( #!!'+6$666,;! ""&!- "!*5##@ 27A( -/'!/% !''#"#*!'(##!#"" #!%#
%!55"% !#"0 % ""0"# 3"$5#(#/ 0"# 3#"#0! #-!#%/#'0!5 , + %&!-"'! *-% &!/( %% 30" "#*!"0# %#&!#5#"% (#&#("'!%/##* -&!/( #! 5 -3/#% " % #3- %30 %#*!"0"-/(;-/&!/( #! ( $!
(&#'#&&!/( 3* %!5 %/%#& "D($( -''#*$ % ! &!C-# " D( #&-% 30 !
&&!-!'# -#- #%# &&#% %&!-" "!-3/#% ! /!- 3 %% !5 % "! !' /## !' "#'$ #!D($ * %(&# "%#*!-%$# -*% &!/( %%30" "% !
3 -# 3"0 &% ! ! - * !' '
# % 3" #!! 9 %&!-"'!(!%!+-((!% %!' " "$&!%% % %3( % ' (!( !!-* ((&# #!!' #%&!&!% %'!$%#%!5
0#'&30#.!- ,-, , >
%" %&!-"'!( # %(-%&!/("
3 &!%%-&!#% #!!''#%#*&!%%30" "$ "0!#-!'*"#*& %'
#*!'"# 3#"#0$ '#%! ! 4 %#'' #5!5 $&!#- ##*## "( # ! /!'C- -/!'&!/( #! /#$ '!$-% 4 -% ? # -0& $ /!-!'&!/( !3
"- %#
&&!% &5#(#&#("&!*#%# $5#!E3" -(/.!- &"
#'#% %!'
#!( "0'!(&-# 0 %!;(&-# 0% *$#&"-%#* /%#& "D($"!!'#&!/%-#* /$'--"!!' #* & �$ #!$( %-''#* %"!!' /##C- -/ ##& $'!$5 ;D /# #!30&!#%#* -!'
# -#$ %- #! !' !(# "# #! % ! %#* &#&-/ & '"&%#(&# &!% :(- "!'&!% " ;&"
*5 #*- #%/-"#("*# !-# -#$ # #%'!/%#&!;* (!< D 9= #%(! &!%!#&#%5!-%!#* /(! "*#! %'!-"
& %5!-%!#*( # "*#!$"!5 "#($-(("#($ %&# %%##!!$&"
-''%% *-/' &- &&!/( #%30%*"!
#*
-"#!$ "!*5#&3 "!%/ $ 5#&-"%#%!5# %-&!&#!-'! ((!D#/ "0'# % 0 F-$ (#/!0!' -3% #*< ;>=$ %!'#$ -*0!9$ %!>$ $! 4$ %'!//%#& "&!%< D
7= %%#& *&#'#& < D >=$&"
/ #% %/#% #%!!( # $! 4'!/2>6+288:!786+288:$#$'!
(#!%!'29% 0-#*#(#!%$5 %&!
# "0-%
( -( ##!!' -! -*! % " -*! '$&"
C-#%! ##!(# "!:;G!&& #!'!'!""!5;-( /
'-&!/!&!% &"
&!#-%!-'''!/(# #$&- &$ %'-&#! ""#/# #!$#&"-%#*%#''#&-"0# 5 ""!5#*$ 5#& "0 ''&% # 3#"#0 ! & 0 !- # !/
!& %% 0;!;% 0 &# ## G "!-*H; 0(!%#%! 03!0' &- %!
'!/ "%# 3#"#0&#'#& C- #'0#*(/ %# 3#"#0 3("
&%! &!%$ &-/-"
# ''& !' # -# ( "0 % # -0 # !"
#*&3 "!%/ $(!"!*%(#!%!'-&!&#!-$ % % " -/ & !3%#* %%.!#%#* &"
5 0!-* !'770 $* *%#(0#& ""0%/ %#*5!4-& *#&-"- 3!-$ &!/& #&$ %% #0;"
% &# ##$## #% / #%-% / %5 #& &# %'!/5!4'! -3 # (#!%$30-''#*3!(0#& %&!!/#& %#( 8 F-/!$&"
%(!% %#&-%-3 # D(%#-!# /I!5 $!%!&-/ 0 #%&#'!/!'
3#""!&#( 3(!%-&%!&!%!"$##5"""% #& # !"
#*#!-# -#$#&(!!'!' & % 0D(/ ! "5 03(!#3" -!'# -#- #%30&"
$# !(# #!# #*/%#& "&# $! 4$C-#/ !' ( % '!""!5;-( ##$ &!% !' (-& !' /%#&# ! %#"0
#"
3"#!(# "$(&# ""#C-#%%#&# %30% "# -#$ #!D($ % *$ ""3!!-'!/&!%
%& !3!
"!!4% #3 &4%!($ %!' &!!"#% %-/!'
+6$666,;30" "-% "" % !35!""0
# % ! &!//- 5# D !'# -#$ %- #! !'
/$ % &#&-/ &!'& 26!!
$ #%&!&!% 3"# 5 * *%# *#&-"- ""
3!-$ &!/& #&$ %% #0;"
% &# ##
%$!5#*!# -#- #%# &&#%$/ #%-% /
% 5 %% #& 3" !' 5!4#* '! &!#% 3" (#!%
3&!'#&%!&-/ 0(!!'!'#&!/$/!"0 #*!' ₹ &"
3"03 %! !#! "3 # 7$666,;$3#* (
#"#*#&!/!' -4#""%"
3!- "
#/.!C-"0$ "!!' #*%-#*(#!%!' / %&-( #!$5#&
!%#&"0'!/ &&#%$% !3%-"0 &&!-%'!5#" %/##* -&!/( " '!?!(#!% 22F-/!$/ # "!&!%&" "0#%#& -''%/-"#("#!-# -#$#&"-%#* % -/ #'!/!'&3 !%/ %#*#'#& % "# -#"!-*!'!/ "%# 3#"#0&#'#&
3(!%-&%$ -$D$ %/-"#("#�!'# -#$&!-("%5# (!"!*%&!
0(#!%$-/# 3"0-** &"
5!-"%
%-%&!#% 3"( #$-''#*$ %'-&#! ""#/# #!$ "0
''&#*#5!4& � %% 0;!;% 0"#'$#&"-%#* !0/!'
!/ /## 27 #5!''!*!#*%#&-#!$ %
#*%-* %! - %*
#0!'# -#<# !"
#* %$'
&$ % 5=$(#!%!'
!(# #!<29% 0=$(!"!*%&!-!' / %&-( #!$ -" "!!' #*$ 5"" D(!5 % $ (&# "%#$ % #!$ "!*5#( #$-''#*$#&! #&$
%"!!' /##%-%30&"
$#.!-#!'&!#%%
!(##! &!/( %%30" "##
%5 &/&!/( #!#$'!$ % ( '!""!5#* 3"
₹ !&$$!$$!4 !!'#&!/%-#* /<?/!=
5&
6 %#& "D(
5& #!
5& (&# "%#
5& %
5& !!' /##
5&
%-''#*
5 1 ₹77/
5& 2+ #5!' 3!
$ "#( "0 ""!5%#/(-*% % %26272888#/!%#'#%!D &!/( #!( 3"! ₹
# &%'!/ +6$666,;! ₹ 77/
5& &% /!- ""
& 0# !':A( -/'!/% !''#"#*!'&"
(##! #"" #! D&( '! /!%#'#& #! !' C- -/ !'
#!$ ""!'#%#*&!%%30" "$#&"-%#* !5#* %!*"#*&$"# 3#"#0 %/!%!'%#3-/$ ""
''#/% 29 #& / # & 3 %&#%%$ (%#* /#&""
!-
(("#& #!<=$#' 0$ % "!%#(!%!' - .+
' (