H.C. Kalra v. Subhash Chander And ANR.

  
      
  

Reserved on : 04.04.2022 Pronounced on :20.04.2022 H.C. Kalra .....Appellant

Versus

Subhash Chander and another .....Respondents CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE 

   .

Present:

M 

 !"

# $% & $'!()*& +!

),* --*.. ) **** 

    & 
 

             

          ! "

# "

 $

      "$   #"    "##     %"  &  "#   "

'( &&)#"" '(*+         , "#""#  " -  " .#  # "#    #""    

   "  --/ "!    #   !"!  "!"0    "   !#"#

  " " #"  1 ""# " 

   0#    #"

  !

!#!"! !"0  2

 0 "

"#3  "


      ( -"     "!"  ""   -""

  "  #  "'

     ,   "45 46#" "#7 /$"

   "# 8 
  , !  0 0 #    "
 #     "$  ""!  "  "  "     ,     "45   455  "  "

76 /$3-   "!   #"   " ,!  0 07  ##

""! ""#" #"  "#   ,   "45&5 5#" "#7 /$9 -   # #    "#7: /$"   ,   "45 #" "#7: /$  " ""! """#"8""# ' -!



  !   "

 " "  "#7 /$("    ,   "46:

6#""#7 /$  !"'

'

'. 0 .      !    "#

#"

7

, 

 ""   ,  -  ""  "# , """   ("   ,   "46:& 54#"  "#7 /$  ! '

'

'. 0 .     !  

/ # -""#

 
  ,"  "! 

""  0! 0;+# $0 % 0#++%(%* )  $ ((!# ) $!

1 )2 
 # " 64! -      "#  " "#  "$ " 0  "

 %"&"# '( !  


  #

  

""#    8  - " "

""#      ,9 "8  9 "#% . 0"# 2    <" "- "# ""#!# 9 "

8  %   "   .   "#2  " . 0

      <=7  %#"3%. 0      

<:  "9 #"'

'

'. 0       <4" "- "

"#, ""0  "  > "  "  "  "#    -     -   "

-   -     

      

     

   "

 "  "- 

 #"

   

    -      "$8  "       ## -    !  !   8     "$      "  "      "# 7 /$   "! "  - ' !  ""   "

"# 

 !! 

  38 5"!   "# ""#7 /$    "-  "-   "#  "$  
 

   ## -/ ,"!    "   

0 

 


#



-  !       

      ?   "

   "   #  "#   

$ "

         -         "###"#  #  "

     "-!   -   

   "  "#  "   "  !   

        "$  ' #   8" "#  ,    "#   "$  "  ,!" 

      " %"& !%"5"#  '( #!"

""


  !"

#

"  "

 ! " "#"##



 %"&"# '( ?  "   "

  ,,"!    "# $8

 ' -    " #"

   ""        

     !

  
 " "     "  "            %"    2   !     "# "# ""!  ""# 74 /$#"

 "@4A "          -!"

0 , 

0   

"

   9#   !   "

         -  ""!   " "# 7 /$ #" 

 
! "" "" "#"  "$  " -  ,  "#  '!     

   

0  ,'!  ""     

$ "

      "   -  -  #      "#  7 /$

!!   #!""' "

"  #    "#76 /$ -   "$   5!  " 
    "  ""#7 /$  "

-  ""#%      "#7: /$ ""! B '  "#

"# ,""#7 /$!   " -

 
   "#

$ "

 !   '"    "#

 !    ,! -

 #"  ,"#

   #

,   "46:& 54 38   !"   0!  3-"

     "$8  "   8  !

" "   ""!"#7 /$"  

  

/ ## -" !"    

   "$8  "  % ,  "

"# 

 !    38 5!"

" "#C"8  ""#  "

"# ## -/ 

 38 ! -   "# ""# 7 /$  "-  "- "#  "$  !

  #"#

     

0     

         "  #" 0"!

     ""#, '!  

 "  " " 

   "     !"

  -  

  8  "#  

 #"

 
 

" "#  "$

    #  "#     "$      

   0

0 , 

0  

     
"- "#  

"#7 /$" "     #  "# - ""!    ","
  " %"& !%"5"#  '(    "(  " , "  8"#    0 "

 #  "   " - "! #! "  0"#

    #! #> " ""# "   ""  

   "#



#"

  $8 

#

 "

 ' !"

  #"

 "

    

-   ","  !  "      ,,"  

 "!  

 "#   3-  "    #      "#   

$ "

   



 #  "

 -

-    ""#7 /$   (# ""  !   

$

"

 ""# ""   " !   "" "  "   "$  


    "," !   1! !

8"#"

  "     - "

"  = "- " -  """!8"#  ","  "

  " ""
   

 !  "

 "" "-8"#  " "!"

"  -   
   ,""##   "

"- "" "-   ## --   "  " "#"  "-"0 "

 " %"& !%"5"# '( && %  " " 0 "

8"#  "

  " """ "- 

"   "

  "     "  "    

 

  " 8"#  2$8   "  "-

 " "-  

- '!

$    " !"

" ,"# ""#
#"

"!    # "#

  " ""  ""#- "#  ""D$ ) +


  " 

"



- "# ""#7 /$    ) +
    "  !  "  "  8   

 

""#  "  " -   !

    

)+
" "#

    "

"  "# "   "! -   "  "" ""# " #    

     ( -"    !#     !" -  2

  "

   " !"  "" ) +
 " "# ## -/!  " -

8 ! " "- 

$ "

  )+
 !  ""   ""#7 /$ "   " !8   "$   ""! "- "#  "$

     "    #         0/ ## - 0"!

 "#7 /$! !"  $

0

 )#+ 3-"#    "   " -  0

  ##"-  " "#

""#  "  !" )+
   - ""!   "          #

         

0  

"  , -   )+
"- 8

 " "!  "!     0"  !"

#    "       "#

#   "" 



"

 )+
    

             "$       ,     "45 

46  !"2  " . 0#" "#7 /$  # ,   "45  !"2  " . 0" 455#" "#76 /$."  , ,0 "     " -  "-  "# "   !"  "'

  

  !"

" -  ,#"

"

"#"   !  " )+
 "#    ""#7 /$!   "#   "

"

,

  "46:  !"'

'

'. 0  " -  " 6   , "#   "46:&  !" '

'

'. 0 "54!   #  "#"  !"   "'!"

 

 , ,"!"

  "     "$ " ,  #  ,$ ""0   "

"#" !" ' 

"

 "#  

0,   "- "

    

0,  



 
0""#    #" "-

'#  "

"#              

            ' " ""###"    $

 ""#  - " " "  !  " 




 "!"

"

"#! " "  !

 " "! " "    " "

 

 ""#-  """     - "###" " " #
 

 "  

 -" "#  April 20, 2022 (VINOD S. BHARDWAJ) 0**1

 <  0/ " D/ "

<7 "

D/ "