High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/25320/2013disposed of

Reebok India Company v. State Of Punjab & ANR

2021-08-06Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan10 pages

!"#$%&!'(&#) *%*%!#+ ,+-.-

*&*!/.#0& &#$&#!*1+ -(!#$#*- 2222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222 3

&4$%-1 &0 1&+'& *%*%!#+ ,+-.-

*&*!/.#0& &#$&#!*1+ -(!#$#*- &*!/$5%-%!#673 6 89

, :

! "#$! %&'( # ) * #

$%&'( #*

% +, -# &

$%&'( #*

." &

$/%0$+ 20+* $%&'( *& 3(,*

1#( 44444444 , :; 5# (,,&#

& * 1'& *

#6 +# ,78$# '$# 2(' ($# ( 1 " 2,# * <3=7%# 3 6 # ** ( 6 "#*(& "1 #

+9+ * .

$&+ "#*&(6 #** $# '$#

9+ &(+ #

** ( * # # &6 &'

( "+, #, (

$ # & # , ( $ # (# :& ;

$ **&& 6 <#, ( 1 2+*& 6 ## ((&(

# "

&%#5&-- 6 #* 9+ # "78

& &

= >

$" &+&!( >

$> ; &

-#8 ( ! 6 -

$ / ( -

$ + 1

" #

# +19+*(& " "#, 8 +1, & # * 12 8& ,* 6

,* 6" &+&#,* %($?

; & * # %& & 0+* < & (+ $ ** "* 128&

,* 6$+1, # *

#78$" & # ((,*

3*& !

' 1$ &# # + " * *+,* # , &6 3

! &# '

( *

( & "# &* *+,* 8# ,# (1$

$ * .

"& # !# ** (#& (,*

& &+(&# , % !

"312 8& ,* &+# 2&# , ' ,+

< 2#

#(,* #(,* 6 2 " + *

(* +

% ,#$* .

( , (,*

@ ( & & &+( "# ,16# ",

& ( +

* # ,$#+$# &+(&(,*

, 2 ', #(,* 6 .

&, && < 2# ( #1* &!+1# &! "#,$# " "/ (

**'

& ( "#*( &:(+ " ## (,*

A*+(#

+,$#(,*

' ,+ < 2#* .

#*( ! "# ( ' "# & ,+$* .

+& # ,# (,* + & 1+ 6 #(,*

& 2&# , #(+( & &( *# ,#(,* &#(,*

* ,+ < 2# (+(

&( & "& & &16 * .

"& # !#

$ ",

:(+&1 #(,*

$1#

# ,3-#

$ &!+1# &! "#,$ " "/ (128&

,* 6

$ # (,*

( '&

** ,127 (# +&# " +* .

"& # & ##(,*

2&# ,# # & ( # **'

# " "/ ($# +&# # 9+ , # (,*" **'

&+# &# (,*

#+ &, , ,+,(2 ' > < 2# & # $ &(2# & **

#+"# , # & "

# B##(,*

&1( $* .

> !# +&# ,# #

('# 6&+ &(2 8 +# & #78# (,*

1 & ,+

&! &- 2$-

&*,#

< 2##

*($ # '$

$ ?

$#( '& # #6 " " , & # ", B # #

$ # * 78

" &# * .

$ ( '

( ## *128& ,* 6$# (,, &#((# "

& +& 8 # ( "# #* $ &16128&

,* 6$ *& " (

& # * & & &

& " + (1

#* " "/ (128& ,* 6$

6&$' &&& &

< & (+ +#+1, # #78# 1 " & 128& ,* 6#+"# " "/ (

#+ 6*( ( ,$#$#

+ *(& " #* " "/ ( #*

#* .

##% !

" ((+

(# " &, *** +&$ * ',, & #78 8 +#+1, &# # * " "/ ( , 6C (/ ' &D &

' *

"1 #(,*

&* .

&, &( #(,*

# +# E $ # '+$

' +&'16## " "/ (#(,* 6 < & (+ +#+1, #

$( +& + #&"

& "# #(,* & 78

??& &

$+&!( > ;$> $>$>==% &

- # 8

" & ( ! !( > $ 0+"

!+1# &! "#,, " "/ ( &) #+-# ,# * " ( &# $#* 3(,* 6# & 2'# , ",#(,* &#* ( ' & 8 %+"+$

$ # * 3(,* 6 3 -#

$ # , # (,*

$ ( + # 1+ +&# 1+ ,& &*&16#(,* 6$# '$ &* + ( ,$ * 6

" ' 16 # (,*

&$ #$#7 (#

, &

C'# $

(

" ' ?

# #

& , &

& *#, &(& #

",$#* 3(,* 6# &* & < 2#$

# (# 9+ '

#,#@ #*& (+ 6 &* 8 +# +1, & #

$ *& 3(,*

' (('6 < 2#

" # FG 5#

# ( # &(2 > < 2#

5#(,* 6"

' * 6# (;

8 +# +1, & #

$ *&

3(,*

' (,*

* .

# (##

(# " '

& # ,

# # " "/ ($ , 6!+1# &! "#,$ #' (

, &

8 +#+1, &# '*&

3(,*

+& (

(

, "# , # * 3(,* 6 & # ,

(& 16 # * 3(,* 6

; < & (+ +#+1, # " #78$' *

" '! !+* & ($ -

# #, *+ 6( '

+ &$#$( , &+$# '$#*78

" & < & (+ +#+1, # * .

"& #

& &

1'& #&& &

;

# , ,# '& 1 #* < & (+ $#+$* 69+ # "#789+

* 3(,* 6 # "+& # # , # + & , ( "+ ( # '

!+1# &! "#,$

# " "/ (#* 3(,* &($

(,, &16# ,$# '$## 1 6& ((+& # ( &#* " "/ (# &+19+ 6$ #$#( 1# &

# , #1( , " "

/ (#(,* 6

8 +#+1, &# 1 *+

#78 + & # #

, & , " "/ ( !+1# & ! "# , & * .

"& # !# $ , ,* 6#(,* 6 < & (+ +# "+# ' #* " '16#/ (%6$# ( " "/ ($

# (#

, " "/ (!+1# &! "#,$ # 6& ((+& # ( #* " "/ ( & ,+(#

8 +# +1, & # # , #

* #* (6#* 3(,* & *

" '*& 3(,*

(#' , & (& $# '$# ' "

&&$# ,

, & &

&16#, # ", < & (+ # &

+1, # # 1# &16D@1 !+*,+# # " "&(6 # 1+ ( ( ('#*+ 6( '

& *+ ( ,

( # # #,& ( '

,(+, " < & (+ #

& !"#$% &$ # ,

' # 1 216D@1 !+*,+ < & (+ +#+1, # 1 *+

#78$(+&!( >

$> ; &

-#8 , & + #* " "/ ( # &

& * # $# *&(#

&6, &# &#

2 " # ,6 ( # '

& ( ((+&3* .

< &(+ $ ** "* .

6+1, # ( ( ( '

& *+ &#&( ,

216#* &

2 16#(,* 6$#$#* ( 1# &

6+(# , 7 (# # ## #1,+(# * # 8* 6$ &! (+ $ &16 &(+ #(,*

$+1, # #78# 1" & (&+( "

&+9+ 6 &2 "#* #/ (%6# (

, &+ # " "/ (#128& ,* 6

&* .

< &(+ $ ** "*& 3(,*

$ +1, # #* # '1+"##(( ((&

+," '16* .

# #( *(+#7 (# 3128& ,* 6#(,*

$ #(,*

# * & < 2# ( #.

"#(,* 6 8 +#+1, &# !+1# &! "# , &) #+-# #,* 6#(,* &$#$ #78

" & #* 3(,* 6 < &(+ *& 3(,*

$#1 # ',, & #78$+# "+# #1 #

+, " ' 16 * .

"& # !# & #$ # (,*

# *

< 2#(+( $ &( & ',#(2 8 +#+1, &# &#(2$ &(2

" '#(,*

16* .

&$#$(+&!( > ; &>

** 6, &+ 8

"+&# *++ ( ",$ # (#

#* #7 (#

&(,*

$'# * &

1+* 6, &16#(,* 6 8* 6 "+, &1#

* .

!# $ & (+ *& 3(,*

# +# +1, &# (# & (

# , #78 & # ##

+&#(,*

& ( + &(+, &2 < 2# ( #*' & "7 (# # (,* 6 8* 6$ & (+ # "+&# # & '

? *& 3(,*

$# &

# (#

" '16#* 3(,* 6#(,*

(#' , & (& $ # '$ # ,

"& 16 # (,*

& &# #* " "/ ( &

$ # (# ,+(# #, # &

", %# " &(+ #* $8 &, #* &16* .

%*+

#78# # # & (

# ,(,, " +& .

# & +*( &(+,$ # (# ( 1,& #&(+, + ,* (# (# ( # , & *+&16 &! (+

&(+ #(,*

C'# $

&* ( *

# # " * $ &+&!( > $#+

2 #&(' &(# ((+&$ #$ # ## , 1 *+

#78$#( , &+ %((& "

6$ # * & 16 * .

"& #

!# $1 "

$ & , & D '$8 &, #* $ &16128&

,* 6

$ , &#:# #78$ ,# ((+&## " "/ (3128&

,* 6 " ' &# ((+& 6& 3128&

,* 6#+"# " "/ ( &$#$ # 1(

6" ' ,$*(+ ( 1 &$#+"# #78$# (,*

# '

## " "/ (

!+1# &! "#,$&+ " #+$#7 (#

& #' ( ,H#

& &

$# ,

, & %((& "

6$ # * 1 "

& *& & ,*+"&&& &

$' & # (#1

+& #* " "/ ( C (/ ' & &$ #169+ #& D '$

1*#(,*

*++# ( 378 3128& ,* 6#+"# ## " "

/ ($ !+1# &! "#,$16,' " *** ** ( 1#

+$ *, 1 +&#< , %( % *#(*6 # & 1 *

(& # # ((&( 73 , :