Madan Lal v. State Of Haryana





    
 


















 




















 

 !"!

#$%&'& (( 



















&&

!!

# ) * )"+"

,    &&&

"- # #  $  .( & ,
,
,




 


 






 
 

  



 
!
 


"#   $$$$ ,
,

/& %
 






&'(
)*

 (+(,



 

 
- #




 
./0 *+,+1
 
+(2+(+(&



,2&
,234(5
,2'4&5 )* 
#
 
6 

7 " 
*   ( %

./0
 "

-



 
  
 "




 

   
8   6 
"- #
4 
! 


865


 "
 


 9 :

 



   

 


                         


     
      

               

   



  

!

   
 


   

"#$#


      
     

% 

   
 
  #&!&#!#  #  
        '

     

  $!     '          (  (    %   

)      $         '

           '

       (   

  

   (               
        * 



%

(

%  ( 

((         


         

    

       (


 
 


        

  

     


 

  



  



 

   

             



  (     
 


      
 
   




  



    

         
  + 

                     








 


 


  
   


  

%
 
 

  

 

 
        



     

%      % %  
 
 
'



        
  




 
  

    

   
 (    



 
  
 (      

  %      
     





   
  

%  



    


  


 
   *    %
 





%
#

 

  
        


        
     

   
   
   
   
    
 
 




 


    


  


        
        (   (
     
    #!# #,

!,$&!!
   %

 

       
        
 

  

%


 

 (#!# #, 




 


% &!

#$$  +
    
  

  

 





!,$&+
   






 
* 

  

         


     

 
  

 

% + % 

 ,$,+
 

#$!

#,


% 




% 
  











 



  %  

    

 
 
 

   
 
  

%     
  





  

 

          
   
 

        
   

               '

    




 

% 



     

  
 (        

  
 %






 
""!&!+
  
 

          

  
       %   

 #!#,#  


&!$#!#,  




   
 +

  

  
      


    ,         

  
    
  !

!$#!#,  !!&#!#,  


 !!+


 

    %
*  
 

 

 

*
 










  %         
       

 
    
  

  
  

      
          

* 
 ! 

  
  %
         






 
 

   



   

      

    
 
 

  

    


   

 

 
       

  
  


 
  

  

 "

   

  
 * 
  
    

              







 

     (     
(       


    
  
 
  
    


   


  
   
 
  

 
  






 

 

  
    


      
 
+


 


 % 
    
        

 

 
   
         

   

    

   %
  
   

 
   
   % 


            #!#      (    

         (    


   

- , %

 



 
- # -

6 


#

; 
7 " 
*  
  "

-
"


 
('+((+(1 & % 

 



#


+<+,(+(1 
6 
 


 





-
 !
 


#"
4= 
9,5
>
+'+&(+(1



  
-

 #


86
 

 
-
#
  # "# 


""

0(
# 

"
 

- 
-


%





 
01+
# 


 
" 





"


 
+<+,(+(1


  
%

 


?-#
"
6 


"




 (,+3(+(1
 - 




02+
# 


0

 6 
@ 







(2+'(+(1
-

?-#

"
6 





6 





 
- #


"
 



 


1 8

"


 "


 

+1+A(+(1
- 
6 

"




  ##
 



6 


 #

 
9 
- #

"





#

#   




     

    !"""    #$#%      #& $'

#$#%   ()*

 + 

,  

   "$-.!/#$#%





#-

!

 

02++++++B9


 


" 
   
%
"


 

"

 #
 
 
3 %
# 
 #




 
 
 
-
 ##
"# 



 

  


./0


C 





  


   
8  
6 
 


! 
./0

- 






"#

 


#
 
(A22(+(&
4= 
9,5
%
 
"#



 

- 
 #

"

!  "



*,
%
 #
" 


#
 


-
/
 


 
-

"
 

"##  



 

 


#

 

 
- # < >


 

# 
 
 #
#
 

#
 
+<+&(+(1

 





 "

B


@ #

6" 

23+A(+(&

 


 


 
%



#


02A1

/

#


 





 


 
 !

 
0(
# !

"


6 
 
 ./0
 
-
!

- 
/



 
=
 

 
-

!



 "

01+
# !



 
 !
 



#
- 

 

"
 
 "##


" 
 


 

-
""
/
  
 #
 


##
#
- 


 " 




- 



"


 

 

./01232405
 -#



 


-
 ! 

# #
# 

  #
 



  #
C 
%



#





 
- # ' /
 
 

# 
 #


 
A %
D-#
"
6 


 

0 



1
0 ,1 #$## 2 3 4-$
#  
"#
- 
  #
 



C 
-
#  #

-

 

 
 
- #

%


 "



6 
 

 
- #
# 

 


"

 
 
 

 
%
# 
=  

"

 
-#




:

6127856/952: .;0<65=;9687>52/<5=4;9<:5> 2..52/0<?  3;/  5:.;<=5<6  ;  6@26  4@2/?5:@556  @2: 2>/52=7855<30>5= 6A0>>859<320/6;./5:915;<;9/.2/6

6@266@5 <B5:60?260<?33045/=;5:<;6/5C90/55:.;<=5<6 ;3;/49:6;=02>0<65//;?260;<3;/6@5.9/.;:5;339/6@5/ 0<B5:60?260;< 56@262:061275B5<2::910<?06242:5A@5/5 5:.;<=5<6;0:<;6/5C90/5=3;/49:6;=02>0<65//;?260;< A52/5:260:305=6@266@50?@ ;9/6;9?@6<;66;@2B5 ?/2<65==0:4/560;<2/7/5>053;32<6040.26;/7820> 52/5=52>0<?A06@212665/A@5/50<6@5;/0?0<2> 4;1.>20<2<6 2..5>>2<6 @5/50< @2: 4;15 853;/56@0:

;9/6./270<?6@266@52<6040.26;/7820>?/2<65=876@5 0?@ ;9/66;6@52449:5=:@;9>=8542<45>>5=
;.96060< ;6@5/A;/=:6@54;1.>20<2<6:27:6@266@50?@ ;9/6 A/;<?>75D5/40:5=06:=0:4/560;<A@0>5?/2<60<?2<6040.26;/7 820>6;6@52449:5=0<2B5/7:5/0;9:4/015>0E5  2<= 6@5/53;/56@5;/=5/.2::5=876@50?@ ;9/6?/2<60<?

2<6040.26;/7820>6;6@52449:5=:@;9>=85C92:@5=2<=:56 2:0=550**60 3 2 00 06 2

     7 *6 0*  6            6    

0     3                  06*     36   *6   6 2 

6  3    3   8 *6   0*6 0* 3        0*676  0    0       

 6      28     

  6   *6   0           *  6   



         0                      

6 8 3   2* 

0    6       9322        7   

  6*    6  *6 2+ 
  #


 

 " 


 
 # 
 







 

"   
 
 

#

="

#
02'+




86 E



 !
 

 #
 

" 

0( # !

"
- 



./0


!

- 

 




 

 

"#


"

 

#"
#
 
(A22(+(&
4= 
9,5
. 
   #
 

C 



 


"

 #

 B





 #


.6/


 -
##

"

##
-


86



  ./01232405
 -#


 


-
 !


# # # 

  #
 




 # C 
22 /



"
 
/


"
 


%

 "
 
" 2(

 

- 
"


 -

#
 
 



- #



% #
6 






 


"




- 



#
-
 # 
-

 
- 
"


  0,
,

1   %&'& 
, 3 )"- 4!#56) "

# $ "6