High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/1850/1998disposed of

Surjit Kaur v. Ram Pal Etc.

2018-10-22Mr. Justice Satpal5 pages

!"!# "$%#%& ' !( )*+, $-"*+"!#"!$.%+ //%00"!$' 1%+'*'

"2 "0"!#$.+'

%'/!#%!$'

+%'%!$( 3+ ) 004#5&"$%+$.%"//%00"!$' 3+ %%/"6)*+ 4#5&"$%++%'/!#%!$

. '"//%"0."'7%%! 0%#78$.%"//%00"!$'&0" 2"!$''%%6 !9 %!."!&%2%!$ $.% &2/%!'"$ ! ":"+#%# $ $.%2 78 $.% 0%"+!%# 3$+ && #%!$0" 2'+ 7*!"04."!# 9"+.;<+ 7*!"0=+'.+$>5 #%":"+##"$%#

!"&&*!$#%"$. +5" +) !9. !"2$+5%. &0%"&& #%!$ ! +'' 7,%&$ !' ."5% 7%%! /+%%++%# 78 2"&."0

"#:"8'+"!'/+$+/+"$ ! .%&0" 2"!$'4:."+%$.%/"+%!$'48*!9%+7+$.%+"!#' '$%+ $.%#%&%"'%#4 0%#"/%$ $ !*!#%+)%&$ !??$.%3$+1%. &0%'&$4 '%%6 !9 &2/%!'"$ ! ! "&&*!$ #%"$. +5" + ) !9. #*% $ !,*+ %' +%&% 5%# ! " 2$+ 5%. &0% "&& #%!$ :. &. $6 /0"&% !

:"'+%9 '$%+%#*!#%+)%&$ !'@"!#

"$ 0 &%)$"$ ! !#*'$+ "0 +%"4."!# 9"+."9" !'$+%'/!#%!$ $:"'/0%"#%#$."$$.%#%&%"'%# "$ $.% $ 2% . ' #%"$. :"' " $+*&6 #+ 5%+ : $. 3' ."+"$ 3$+' ."!# 9"+. ' 2!$.08 !&2% :"' '$"$%# $ 7% ' A

% :"' A 8%"+'0#"$$.%$ 2%"&& #%!$ 2/%!'"$ !:"'$.*'/+"8%#+

;B3> .%0%"+!%#+ 7*!"0!&!' #%+"$ !$.%"&$'"!#%5 #%!&% !+%&+#.%0#$."$$.%"&& #%!$ !C*%'$ !$6/0"&%#*%$$.%+"'."!# !%90 9%!$ #+ 5 !9 %!# !9 5%. &0% 78 $' #+ 5%+ .%+% ' ! # '/*$% +%9"+# !9$.%"75%'" # !# !9$.%0%"+!%#+ 7*!"0!$. ' ''*%4:. &. ."'"$$" !%# !"0 $8 D%"+!%#+ 7*!"0*+$.%+"''%''%#$.%"9%$.%#%&%"'%#"' A8%"+'"$$.%$ 2%. '#%"$."!# !&2%$.%#%&%"'%#"' ' A

/%+2!$."$$."$$ 2% %#*&$ ! E:"'%%&$%#$:"+#'$.%/%+'!"0 %F/%!'%' "' .% :"' " 7"&.%0+ %/%!#%!&8 $.% &0" 2"!$' ."' 7%%! "''%''%#+"7*$$:8%"+'G '

/%+2!$."!#$.%+%"$%+ '

/%+2!$.+ ' ?

/%+"!!*2!$.%9+*!#$."$$.%#%&%"'%#:*0# $.%! ."5% 9$ 2"++ %# .*'4 $.% &2/%!'"$ ! ' 44

:"' ":"+#%#$$.%&0" 2"!$'"0!9: $. !$%+%'$GE/%+"!!*2+2$.%#"$% 0 !9&0" 2/%$ $ !$ 00+%"0 '"$ ! D%"+!%#&*!'%0+$.%"//%00"!$''*72 $'$."$#%/%!#%!&8."' :+!9087%%!&"0&*0"$%#78$.%0%"+!%#+ 7*!"0 3+%5%+4*$*+%/+'/%&$' !%%#$7%"+#%#47%' #%'&2/%!'"$ ! !$%+2'$.%,*#92%!$$.% !=70% )*/+%2% *+$ ! 3"92" %!%+"0 !'*+"!&% 2/"!8 D$# 1' "!* "2"0 "'.*.+* "2"!#$.%+'4 ! 5 0//%"0 #%& #%#! 4'.*0#"0'7%"+#%# D%"+!%#&*!'%0+ +%*$%'$.%"75%'" #"+9*2%!$'"!# '*72 $'$."$ !"!8&"'%%F&%''&2/%!'"$ !."'7%%!"+#%# 3+%5%+4 "//%00"!$' "!#A&"!!$7%$+%"$%#$7%#%/%!#%!$'$.%#%&%"'%# .%+%+%4$.%+% '!C*%'$ !0''#%/%!#%!&8C*"$.%+%'/!#%!$'

"//%00"!$' $ '*+$.%+'*72 $$%#$."$$.%"&& #%!$# #!$$"6%/0"&%#*%$

;B3> $.%!%90 9%!&%$.%#+ 5%+$.%%!# !97*' $ '4$.*'4/+"8%#$."$$.% "//%"07%# '2 ''%#"!#$.%&+''7,%&$ !'7%"00:%#

."5% .%"+# 0%"+!%# &*!'%0 + $.% /"+$ %' "!# ."5% 9!% $.+*9.$.% 0%: $.$.% +"70%"'' '$"!&% .% #%&%"'%# :"' !505%# ! " 2$+ 5%. &0% "&& #%!$ :. &. $6 /0"&% !

;F > :"' +%9 '$%+%# ! $.% '"2% #"8

'$ 2+$%2 ! $.% 7#8 $.% #%&%"'%# :"' &!#*&$%# '$ 2+$%2 +%/+$ ;F > ' "5" 0"70% ! +%&+#4 :. &. /+5%' $."$ +5" + ) !9. # %# #*%$$.% !,*+ %''*%+%#78. 2 !$.%'" #"&& #%!$ D%"+!%#+ 7*!"0."' +%%++%#$$.%$%'$ 2!8 "2 "04$.%#+ 5%+$.%7*'4+%'/!#%!$ 4 :. &.:"'*!#$7% !&!$+"# &$ !$$.%5%+' !/*$+$. !. '+%/08 $ ' '/%& &"008 7'%+5%# 78 $.% 0%"+!%# + 7*!"0 $."$ ! &*!$%+ 5%+' ! "' '*9.$$7%/+,%&$%# !$.%$%'$ 2!8 "2/"04:"''%$+$. !$.%+%/08

$ ' $+ $% $ !$% $."$ &0" 2"!$' ! $.% /+%'%!$ /+&%%# !9' "+% +%C* +%# $ /+5% $.% + &"'% ! $.% 7"' ' $.% /+7"7 0 $ %' "!# /+%/!#%+"!&% %5 #%!&%"!#!$7%8!#"!8+%"'!"70%#*7$ .%&0" 2"!$'."5% !#%%# '*&&%%#%# ! /+5 !9 $."$ $.% "&& #%!$ ! C*%'$ ! :"' &"*'%# #*% $ $.% +"'."!#!%90 9%!$#+ 5 !9$.%%!# !97*'78+%'/!#%!$ "2 "0

!&2%$.%#%&%"'%#:"'"''%''%#"$ ' A

/ 2 $.*9. $ :"' &0" 2%# $ 7% ' A

/ 2 D%"+!%# &*!'%0 + $.% "//%00"!$ ' *!"70%$/ !$*$"!8%5 #%!&%!+%&+#$ !# &"$%$."$$.%#%&%"'%#:"' %"+! !9 "!8$. !9 2+% $."! ' A

/ 2 "' "''%''%# 78 $.% 0%"+!%# + 7*!"0 .*'4 $.% '" # !# !9 ' */.%0# D%"+!%# + 7*!"0 ."'4 .:%5%+4 %++%# ! "++ 5 !9 "$ $.% 0'' #%/%!#%!&8 "' ' 44

.%+% ' ! ,*'$ &"$ !5"+ "!&%"$%+"/%+ #$:8%"+' !&2%$.%#%&%"'%# "$%+ " #%#*&$ ! E ' "''%''%# "' '

/%+ 2!$. *$*+%

;B3>A /+'/%&$'"$$.%+"$%A E."5%$7%"+#%# !$%+2'$.%9* #%0 !%' 0" ##:!78$.%!=70%)*/+%2%*+$ !"$ !"0 !'*+"!&%2/"!8D$# 1' +"!"8)%$. "!#$.%+'4 @;A> ; 5 0>

3*0$ /0 %+@."' $7%"//0 %# !5 %:$.%,*#92%!$!=70%)*/+%2%*+$ !)2$ )"+0" 1%+2" "!# $.%+' 1' %0. +"!'/+$ +/+"$ ! "!# "!$.%+4

D'' #%/%!#%!&8 ' $.*' "''%''%# "$ '

4A4@ 0" 2"!$' "!# A4 :. "+% $.% 8*!9%+ 7+$.%+ "!# ' '$%+ $.% #%&%"'%# +5" +) !9.4"+%!$/+5%#$7%#%/%!#%!$!$.%#%&%"'%# //%00"!$'&0" 2"!$' "!# "+% %!$ $0%# $ 0'' #%/%!#%!&8 0" 2"!$' "!#A:*0#4.:%5%+4+%2" !%!$ $0%#$0''%'$"$%"!# 0''&!'+$ *2 !$%+2'$.%,*#92%!$!=70%)*/+%2%*+$ !$.% &"'%3"92"%!%+"0 !'*+"!&%2/"!8D$# ;'*/+"> -%%/ !9 !5 %: $.% "&$ $."$ $.% "&& #%!$ ! C*%'$ ! $6 /0"&% ! $.% 8%"+ 4 "00 $.% &0" 2"!$'"+%%!$ $0%#$ '

%"&.$:"+#'0''&!'+$ *27%' #%' "'*2 '

%"&.!"&&*!$0''%'$"$%"!#*!%+"0%F/%!'%' //%00"!$' "+%4 $.*'4 %!$ $0%# $ &2/%!'"$ !4 :. &. ' +% :+6%#"'*!#%+(

!&2% A

/ 2 % 44

/%+"!!*2 $"0 !&2%"$%+"## $ !"$$.%+"$% A E!"&&*!$*$*+%/+'/%&$' 4

H ;4

FA E> IA

!&2%"$%+#%#*&$ ! E! "&&*!$/%+'!"0%F/%!'%' J 4?

;A > I 4?

A $"0#%/%!#%!&8"$%+"//08 !9" 2*0$ /0 %+@ ; 4?

@>I 4A4@ D''%'$"$%

? *!%+"0%F/%!'%'

;B3> @ D''&!'+$ *2$&0" 2"!$' 4

$AG

%"&. ;

FAI4

! "#$ .% "2*!$ &2/%!'"$ ! "0+%"#8 ":"+#%# $ $.% "//%00"!$&0" 2"!$4 !%%#0%'' $ '"84 '."00 '$"!# #%#*&$%# +2 $.% "2*!$ &"0&*0"$%# "' "75% //%00"!$' '."00 7% %!$ $0%# $ !$%+%'$ "$ $.% +"$% @ E /%+ "!!*2 ! $.% %!."!&%# "2*!$ +2 $.% #"$% 0 !9 $.% /%$ $ !$ 00+%"0 K"$ ! L $.$.%"75%'" #2# &"$ ! !$.%":"+##"$%# 4 /+%'%!$"//%"0"':%00"'$.%&+''7,%&$ !'"+%# '/'%# %

& ' &$7%+4

'.:"+ L.%$.%+'/%"6 !9+%"'!%#( %' L.%$.%++%/+$"70%( %'