High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/27323/2010dismissed

Kanta Devi & ANR v. State Of Punjab & ORS

2015-01-20Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan4 pages

!"#"$%&%'( ) * '! "+% '# '!,"- "!%!%'"-& ."-&/& 0! !" /'1 2 '#!,"-& "&3'#"'!& ( 45 0* 5 0

-"&"'!( -.%+"60"!,%7#+$ !"7-!,"3"!%!%'"-& -%6,%8*,3- 7"3/!9 /'1 2 -0 :%- !,-"7#+$ !"7-7 -0/:""!"870! '#%';/'&"87 --"&3'#"'!) -/-$, - '0%';,7#+$ !"7 --"&3'#"'!&<! =

>,"!,"-!," "3-!"-&8$ 8'"?&3 3"-: 92" 88?"#!&"" !,"1/#;:"'!@ 2"-""--"#!!," "3-!"--'! >,"!,"-!,"1/#;:"'!&,/8#2"-"3-!"#%'!,"#%;"&!@ * 5 07

5 '!,"3-"&"'!3"!%!%'7!,"3"!%!%'"-&, +"&/;,!!," #%-"$!%'&!,%&/-!-"'!-/&!%';!,"$ &"-"; -#%';$/&!#% 8 #" !,!,"#"$" &"#%"8 !"0 '#""3*/: -!"'!- 8/-" / '+"&!%; !%' '#/-!,"-#%-"$!%'!$'$8/#"!,"%'+"&!%; !%' "A3"#%!%/&89%' '%:3 -!% 8 '#!%:"2/'#: ''"- !%&&! !"#!, !0 '#""3*/: -? & --"&!"#29!," 38%$"/'#"-0"$!%' !," -$!%$-/;& '# &9$,!-3%$

0/2&! '$"& $!7 B<) %' &,-! 4!,"$!4 %' BB # !"# ) B7-";%&!"-"# ! 8%$"0! !%'-%'# 7%&!-%$! /3' ; -7 - 88";"#896""3%';%',%&3&&"&&%';- :&: $6 '!,"& :" # 97 '!,"- # !"#) B? &-";%&!"-"#/'#"- 0"$!%')!,"-:&$!7 B)B ! 8%$"0! !%'-%'# 7%&!-%$!

/3' ; -7-6""3%';%',%&3&&"&&%''"&3-%'; $!%+ !"#6'%" &3"-!,"$ &",%&!-9;%+"'29!,"8" -'"#$/'&"8- !,"3"!%!%'"-&7!,"& %#0 '#""3*/: -? &3-#/$"#2"-"!," 8" -'"#/#%$% 8 ;%&!- !" &!8 &&7 /3' ; -7') B '# ? &-": '#"#!1/#%$% 8$/&!#9!%88C '#!,"-" !"-7,"? & &"'!!1 %8 ?"+"-70 '#""3*/: -, ##"+"83"#&:":"#%$ 8 3-28": '= B7 !<(C 7,"? &! 6"'!%+%8&3%! 87

3 -7 '# -: !,"-"7 ? & -""--"# ! 7 , '#%; -, '

B7,"? &2-/;,!2 $6-: 7, '#%; -,7!1 %8 '

< B7 ," ? & ; %' ! 6"' ! 7 , '#%; -,7 & 3"- #%-"$!%'&!,"#$!- '#? &-""A :%'"# ! 7, '#%; -, ,"-" !"-7,"? &2-/;,!2 $6!1 %8 'B B7 !=( 7 !,"," 8!,0 '#""3*/: - ; %'#"!"-%- !"# '#,"? &! 6"' !%+%8&3%! 87 3 -7-:?,"-" ! (%" B7,"

? &&"'!! 7, '#%; -, 0 '#""3*/: -"A3%-"#%' 7 , '#%; -,7' B%!&"8 !

( !%&&! !"#!, !%!%& $ &"$/&!#% 8#" !,

"&3'#"'!& !)%'!,"%--"389&! !"#!, ! $!&

, +"2""':%&&! !"#!? &&! !"#!, !!,"#"$" &"#? &3 !%"'! $/!"#% 2"!%$ '#,"? &&: $6 ##%$!"#"? &-""--"#! !," 7, '#%; -,7!?%$"-:= B! B ,"

#"$" &"#? &;"!!%';!,"%'&/8%'%'1"$!%'!!,""A!"'!C/'%! '# =/'%!%' # 9,"&'%'8 ?!,"3"!%!%'"- &?"88 &!,"3"!%!%'"-,"-&"8+%&%!"#!,"%&!-%$! %87 3 -7+%#""'!-9 &)< '# # !"#= B '#< B ""--%';!,"

#"$" &"#!!,"%+%8&3%! 87 3 -7 '#!!," 7, '#%; -,7 ? &'!#"'%"# ,"#"! %8& #:%&&%'%'!,"+ -%/&,&3%! 8& ? & 8&:"'!%'"# !? &&! !"#!, !!,"-"? &'-8"!," 38%$"%'!,"#" !,!,"#"$" &"# , +"," -#8" -'"#$/'&"8-!,"3 -!%"& '#, +" 8&$ -"/889;'"!,-/;,!,"%8" ," $!& & ' -- !"#29!,"8" -'"#$/'&"8-!," 3"!%!%'"-&%!&"8&,?!, !#"$" &"#-": %'"#%'38%$"$/&!#9'89 ' ) B " ? & -": '#"# ! !," 1/#%$% 8 $/&!#9 ' ) B!%88C ,"#"$" &"#&/"-"#:"#%$ 83-28":

'= B%!&"8 '#,"? &! 6"'! 7, '#%; -,,"'7 '< B7,"? & ; %'! 6"'! 7, '#%; -, '#!,"'

2-/;,!2 $6!1 %8 ,"-" !"-7,%&," 8!, ; %'#"!"-%- !"#' B B !=( '#,"? &&"'!!%+%8&3%! 87 3 -7 '# -:!,"-"7,"? &&"'!! 7, '#%; -,7?,"-",""A3%-"#'

B !

( ,"-"3-!!," 7, '#%; -,7'%8"

&,?&!, !%!%& ' !/- 8#" !,,"#"$" &"#&/"-"# -"- $!-9

C &,$6' $$/'!-"&3%- !-9 %8/-""? &&/"-%';-: $/!" 3/8:' -9"#": ' !," 8 &! # !"7 !," 38%$" , # 8& 3-#/$"# !," /!3&9-"3-!!,"#"$" &"#,"3&!:-!":? &$'#/$!"# ! %+%8&3%! 87 /3' ; -7%'?,%$,%!%&&! !"#!, !!,"!/2"-$/8&%& ? & #"!"$!"#7 8" #%'; ! -"&3%- !-9 %8/-"7 & 3"-''"A/-"

5" -'"#$/'&"8-!,"3"!%!%'"-&, & -;/"#!, !!," -"3-! -"; -#%'; !/2"-$/8&%&%& '"?!,%'; ?"+"-7!," $! -": %'&!, !&:"!%:"!/2"-$/8&%&%&'!#"!"$!"# ! !,"%'%!% 8 &! ;","-"%&'!,%';'%8"!&,?!, !!,"$ /&"#" !,%'

7 , '#%; -, '# ,%& !-" !:"'! %' 7 , '#%; -,7 ? & : '%3/8 !"#," $!-": %'&!, !!,"#"$" &"#? &'!"'19%'; ;# ," 8!, '# ," ? & ! 6"' ! 7 , '#%; -,7 !,-%$" '# /8!%: !"89 ," #%"# %' !," , '#& #$!-& ! 7 , '#%; -, 0:""----"; -#%';!,"!%:"#" !,%'!,"-"389%8"#29!,"0! !" : 92" !,"-"72/! !,"!%:" #" !,%& 33 -"'! -:!," $ &" &/:: -97&/2:%!!"#29 7, '#%; -,!2"%';&7 :!,"

+%"?!, !%!%&'! $ &"$/&!#% 8#" !, $$-#%';897!,"3"!%!%'%&#%&:%&&"#

* 5 0 ) &16&