High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/22609/2015allowed

Sunil v. State Of Haryana

2015-12-24Mr. Justice Krishna Murari5 pages

!"#"$% ! &' ()*

+,$"- . ""$ ( /# + (0 $ . #1$2 $ % 34 ++

( # $% ('5"- 6#5(7 (27!

(5 1 ""$ ( (+ 6#5"*22-* (0 $ ( ,( 7

$ *27!

(5 !&1- $ 5"#"## !$21 ""$"- 2'0+,$"-(8( $( 8,- ('

"- 2,("$85 1 $2 $!05 ("

-5 "(#1 ""$9 #2"#&"## 2$ !' ( * ) :5 $!$($ 2 #95 ( 5 !5 $8 2!"(!,&# $! #( 8( $ ( 8,- ( '

"-* !,$# - 5 # #,'&" 2 5 5 (-" ( 1 ""$ 9 2"#&"## 2 $ 5 8(,$2 5 5 1 ""$ ( 9 & &' ( ,$- 9,-

## &'-095"!55 2!

,# 2"$;,(0$5( 1 (#$# $22 5$ 1 (#$

,$# -(5 1 ""$ (5 -##,'&" 25 5 1 ""$ ( 2' $2 !- ( 2"$$! $ (5(,85"$7 #"8 "$!$2,! 2,$2 (5 #,1 (7"#"$+

-9 - $25 ' ( ' "$82 !- ( 2"$$! $'0+

-9 -*5 9 -#2 !- ( 2"$$! $'0+ * 5"$$ !' ( * (!$#"2 ( "$5 ( 1(#+ 5"$2 2 !' ( * $2 + 2 -2 2 (!5<* < $2"$2"$8 "/"(+"$85*+ =>?*

-9 -* +"$85*+ -"! 5 2,$25 1 ""$ ("$$! $5 $ #1( # $ 2$ (!5@* < $25 $ & 5 1 ""$ (9 #6 1"$ !-,&$* #"$$! $',5 1 ""$ (9 "$ (( # 2$ '(, (0 * ) (5 ("& ( $!5*

$!56,- ,(5 ("$7 #"8 25 & (

$2 #,'&" 2 "# ( 1( (( 0"$8 5 1 ""$ ( $ !!,# 2 ( 1( ,$2 ( + !"$ A< =@? ( 9 # #,'&" 2 $ 0*

$2 5 1 ""$ ( 9 # ( & $2 2 ;,2"!"

- !,#20 +"6 $2 ( #5 9 (

"$ 6 1 "$ !-,&$ "$ 5 #,11- & $ (0 !5 $ 2 2 1("- @* )"#1 ("$ $& $"$5 ( 5 5 "(#!5 $"#' "$8(" 2,$2 ( 5 "- + /# /"6( & !* 59 7 (* 5 #,11- & $ (0 !5 $ #,'&" 2 "$#5 1 ""$ ($1("-* )5 #' $(2 ( 2' (" 2 # 1 -0 # + /# +,$"- 7"2 (2 ( 5 ("

- ,( 2

'(, (0 *

# 5 !!,# 2 "$ !

# + /# /"6( & ! ( "$ !,#20 $2- (8 $,&' (9"$ ## ## $2 B &"$ 2 ($ 2 !,$# - ( 5 1 ""$ ( 5 # #,'&" 2 5 5 1 ""$ (5 #$' $ ("', 2 $0"$;,(0 $25 5 5 #' $ (( "8$ 2

$ !!,# 2 ( 5 5 7"$8 ' $ 2 !- ( 2 "$$! $ 5 "&

1( # $ "$!5 $"$!

# + /#/"6( & ! $2$ !!,$2, - 7 (#"$C, 5"&*5 !

$' 8( $ 25 !$! ##"$'

"- (" !#5 !

# ( 5 AA2 2 0* # ( 8"# ( 2 5 "$# $! D $+"$85 -- 8"$85 $ 0 ',<1&5"#$ 15 96 #55 "9"5

5,- ( #,- 95"!5

5,- 5 2 8"7 $ #- 1 $2 1,$!5 6 #5* 5 ( ( * 5 !&1- $5 28$ 5 5,# /"6( &9"55 !&1- "$

5,- /"6( & - $$0 2 $25( $ 25 5 9,-2 !5 - ##$(& 6"$8

!&1- "$ $5 # & 2 0 ',<1&95"- 5 !&1- $ $2 5"##$5"#5 &*5"#$ 15 9 ("$! $25 ( ;9 ( #""$8 5 "& 1 ""$ ( -$89"5 52* +,( $2 ( $2 $#( ; #$# #5( 5 $2

5,-#$/"6( &!

& 5 ( (& 29"59 1$# $2# ( 2 ',#"$8 5 & :5 $ 5 0 9 ( -2 #1 ',#"$8* 5( 0,$8 '0#* $ & -0* +,$"-* 5 #5 $2 +"6 $2 ( !

& $ &(!0!- $ 5 #1 $ 5 "( B5( "$* +,( $2 ( "( 2 #5 5 #$ 5 !&1- $ 9"5 5"# !,$(0& 2 1"#-5 #55"$5 ( 5 25"#5 & $#

;

-#"( 2 #5 ("$! 9"55"#!,$(0& 2 1"#-5""$85"&$5 - $295 ( #5 1 ""$ ( -#"( 2 #5(&5"#!,$(0& 2 1"#- 95"!5 5" $ 5 - 5 !&1- $ $2 95 ( # $$1 ""$ (

5,-8 7 # ("

'-95""$85 !&1- $$5 '

5,- -#

-- 8 2-0"( 2(&5"#!,$(0& 2 1"#- 5 !&1- $95"!52"2 $ 5" 5"& 95 ( # /"6( & 8 7 '- '-9 5 5 2 5 ( ;

(528 7 # ("

'-9$5 5 25 ( ;+"6 -#"( 2 5

!&1- $9"5 $"$ $"$6"--5"&+,$"-*$$ 11-"!

$ -#"( 2 & $0#5#9"5 $"$ $"$6"--',5 05 2$ ((9 #!

1 5 ( ( )E '0#1 - 2#$ # $2'("!6#5 ( (+,$"-* 5 #5 $2+"6 #!

1 2 $ 5 "( &(!0!- 95"- "("$8 9"5 5 "( ( #1 !"7 9 1$# 95 ( #!&1- $ -$89"55 ( ;* ("$! $25"#5 &9 ( 6 $ 5#1"

-"$ 1("7 7 5"!- 5"#5 $ B1"( 2$ 5 9 0 ' ( ( !5"$8

-9 -

""$ (+,$"-* #1 (5 -- 8 "$#"$5 5 2!& $ 5 &(!0!- - ($ $25 -- 8 2-01 $ 2"( ',5 !&1- $ (05 2$ ((9 #!

1 #& $"$ 25 ( "$' ( *5 ("

- "$#5 1 ""$ (5 ' $(2 ( 2' 5 -2# 1 -07"2 (2 (2 '(, (0 *

5 1 ""$ (9 #2 !- ( 2"$$! $"$5 "(#!

# 11-"!

"$9 #"- 2 '0 1(# !,"$ "$ 5 "(# !

# #,&&$ 5"& $ 22""$ - !!,# 2 ,$2 (+ !"$< ( ',$5 '

#"#5 "$7 #"8 "$ $(,# 2 5 !("& '( $!5* #,11- & $ (0!5 $,$2 (+ !"$ A<=@?( 5 ' $ "- 2* $ 5 '

#"# "$7-7 & $ 5 1 ""$ ( & &' ( ,$- 9,- ## &'-0 (2"#&"## -5 "(#1 ""$$ !' (* )* 5 &#5 & ("

-9"$ ## #5 7 ' $ B &"$ 2"$5 "(#!5 $ $ 5 '

#"# 5 # & $ & 2 '0 D $ +"$85 :

22""$ -

!!,# 2 ( #5 $2 +"6 $2 ( 5 2 ' $ #,&&$ 2 "$ 5 !

# + /# +,$"-,$2 (+ !"$< ( 5 #,&&$"$8(2 (5 #' $!5 -- $8 2 '0 ( #5 $ 5 8(,$2 5 5 5 7"$8 ' $ ,$2 "$$! $ 9"! * 5

"$' $ ("', 25 # & (- '05 !&1- $'0 ("$8"$5 ,( $7" 9 5 ! 5 5 1 ""$ (5 #$' $ ("', 2 $0 #1 !""!"$;,(0 $25 5 7"$8 (("7 2$5 #1$5 &(!0!- - ($* 5 !

$' 8( $ 25 !$! ##"$'

"- 5"## 8 6"$8 "$ !$#"2 ( "$ 5 1 ("2 2 $"$ #, ( 2 '0 5 1 ""$ (F& "$# (9"$ ##5 7"$8 -( 20' $ B &"$ 2F!5 $! #

&1 ("$8 9"5 5 7"2 $! ( ( & F 2, - 7 (#"$ C, 5 1 ""$ ( 7"$8 -( 20 !(11 2 ,1 ( 8 (2"$8 5"# "$7-7 & $ $ !!,$ 5 7"$8 ' $ 2 !- ( 2 "$$! $ &( 5 $ 9 "& #F 1 ""$ "# --9 2

""$ ( "# (2 ( 2 ' ( - # 2 $ '

"- $ 5"# ,($"#5"$8 '

"- '$2#E #,( 0'$2#5 # "# !"$5 ("

-,( ! &' ()*

=+? # $;