High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/22713/2014allowed

Manav Arora v. Ut Of Chandigarh & ORS

2018-10-15Mr. Justice Harsimran Singh Sethi10 pages

!" # $% &'()(( *+ ,, -".-"( # $% &'()(( *+

# $#/)("! (+ 012%+"## &'3()( /4/)(-%"! +-

53( 664%)6( %+++( 7 6 6 6 % + % / (6# %8%()9:*-

)%/ ,; <":## / / ()( 8%+ ))(%

667+!! 9(= !3 (! =6

! "

#$%$& $'()*$%+,$*$%+ -*(

: ( ((9:*7)) ( +-7((<<7(+: )((6)(%)( 6+63"(6 /76>7((+

()( +3(%)() %"%:)( () 63%6 ?<7+ 3( 6+'( 6+)! )7)()

6)( %)( =( (7)!!: %()() () 7)!( +7() (7)() )6+) )7)(),)67)!(+(+: (9:*((+(%)(( 6+7"%

( 6++( :%()((63(+7 "%

6( 3%)(3 "%(%)(( 6+7% )) % 73:)(( 6+)7((63 7"%

6(%)(7((+@ 63)(+(%6(6:%()(

(6((+ ( 6+@7( (+3 =((3(+% %

( 3!)(6

( 6+7=+3

=( ( 3(+(+(%)(7% %'(+)+%+(7 )!) ! ((%

$#/)( %++) (( + ()%(9:*3 7(%3 :)%((6)=+

( ( %+ 7 "%

: (( 3)(9:*=+ "%((9:*6 +63( )% =4% * ()+ %+ 4%)6$.$%/((-%,**)0$$$%+ -*('() -$-( !1)%2$3$%+ -*( ""45 65.%$6478:%( (!3( %( =(( ( + 7 ++ ( 73 ( ) 67(!( 6+(+ ( + ?!))%(3) +!"A%#?

()%6%8%()(9:*: )%((73 7(!(+<(% (+:67376: ( ( + 9:* 7 )(3 ) ( % ()( 7% (! ( 4% ( + )B7!02%+ %&'3 (+%( ( 7=!)% / ((6# % )( + ))!"

:(!(( %(+7(( )(%)((+)( (7 , '(+%(6)76> 7( +C! " ( %)( ( 6+ 63 "(6/

()((( %+ 7"%

'(%)(( 6+6 7(((%

%:=(#(!! (%"% ;

(5(+ ! "% +3 % 66 (

7(60)% 7!"C+ "(6%)(( 6+7( (%"(6/6=) ++ =)!963$ # "

"%)((% (+((+ 7 ( (=( ( ((! )%6 (7! ( 7 % ( ! 6) '(

+C(% ()(%() ) ) (6 ( 7 % ) 6 %6 ( %) +3 ( 6!%3(3 ! +73 5%(%)(( 6+)( %6 % 8%39:*

6 )()(

'( 9:*(! =+)(+ %!"((% (+")( 6 3 ((+ )(9:*+) -"(7-6"+ ,, ))%6673(6 6)!('(%)(( 6+ "%7(((% % 6 =%=(#(!!!

(37((<7:(9:* ( 663 ( 6) ( %)( 7 %

))73+(%'((%()6 %()(39:*)(+763-" (7-6"'( %66 73 ()( ( ( % ()(7%(!4% (6'()%6 ( ( 6 ! ( ( 6+(6( (7(++37((73(%)( 7 )((6 ((76 736! =()D!( (%3 6%+7( ( (

, "(6/((( ))(+( 63()6((% (!%( ((7 63()+ 6 ?633 =(66! ++((% !"( +3%7"%37((7( 3= 6+)((% 63<77(+ (733(= (!% =() ( % 6 6 ( )% "(6 / 7 ( %%:!7(+ ) 6)(+((% %(9:*( % (6*%388# !

#6 " )

! "

# ( + + 3!"7(7( (() 8%(69:*%"3 (6 (%)! + )673) (+<<7C+ ,, : )((7(+ 7=(6)(+ "%"3<66%(7!) %("%7() %! 7 %%%)(6: !)"%% ( 6+( '()%6((7 ) ! ++"%))%6( = ( ((!=+ )'(()

! ( (7 ((( 6+( %)((3% ( 6+%)((3

3 : (6 %+"%'(( 3(! 66"%+ )%(9:* ()( 3% 74% "

6 6%+() (/%+6%$.$%/((- %,**)0$$$%+ -*('()-$-( !1)%2$3$%+ -*( ""45 5.%$64787((+7)9:* 7)E())6736+++ 73 '(+ )78%(()((E( %7%(!4% (6 ; ")%6( 3( %(!

(+ )

:3 (( 66%( 4% : 3+ ) %+/ ( 6# %7( (% <

# $

"% !&'

'(/%+6%* -$'(%9$-(*0$)&-$-( ! 11%(:$%5 "

647

( 7( / (6# %7( < F (

) *++"& &"#

&( !

! !

" % !& ,

,- ,

.*//00)""12/*//0)"""/1*3 ) *++ " "

& 5!

- 6&7& ) 8& !

)"" &19+ 9/ F9/&:

&6#

&' ,

,- , .*//0 0 )""12/*//0)"""/1*3 4

;

) *++" "&(

! ) *++

$ !

" % !&(

) *++ #

"% !

& ,

# " % !

! ) *++ " "& ;

"% !&( 7

#&GG

'( % ++) ( ( & '3 ()(3 (% 6( ( (2!6(!7( 7* -$'(%9$-(*0$) $(5)/$6%(9:* %)!"7% ! 3(+! / (6# %7( ( 3+% +++!(2!6

9 ( <

7(9:*-

)%/ , ; <":## // ()( 8% + ) ) (%

$ % $& ' &

' ( - 3( 7 "

; 5

6 H((+=)? I )

" $