← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/5737/2023dismissed

M/S A1 Papers Pvt. Ltd. v. Union Bank Of India And ORS.

2023-03-20Mr. Justice Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia,Ms. Justice Harpreet Kaur Jeewan7 pages



         

!"# $ $  



   

 

 



 %# &'% $ ($($('  &'%($ (

)

 

    ! "

    ! "

#$%  &&&&& $($(*" +*,*-*.$ /*- '

(( )  

 (  

 

++,++-

' 

 .  

 $/ + 

0  

%"

"

  1"( 

2 3

"

!+44+ +546+4++  7

%6

  

 4+45+4++ 7

%5 +

 .  7

%6*()  *

/$4/+4++.$4!+/!9,!--$:-* ) / ;

!

"

 

< (3

   

   <3  "

 =

 )

 

 3 )

  (

 

""

3  ""  *

 (*   "

<("

)

   *  +649+4+$  7

 %+  ((*    <3    +:4$+4++ 7

%/!

) *

(*(* "0 *"1!2" *34$(*05*,*0!" !"6!0+ /4.  7( $8

" (  ( * 

  "

 (  ) 

"

) 

(  (3")

(*

( *

(



%  >+- .



""

  

"

 '

 ?)  '

 "  )

  (<( 3  

 

8 "

  12  "

" @



 ++,  ) 

 *

 

 

 . "

 

)

  <  

 "(  

 ;



 

?) '

*((

"

"

"

.

*

)

" !"

" ".   +: 

" ""

!*

" "

 ?)  '

 *     (( @    @"

((  . )"



 

$/6

"

 +9

(

(((*  

. )



  "



"

(!

" 

. 3A 6  "!" *"1 !2 " * *"  *"!0+ / 34$ *"

+*"*" (898 +.  (.

?) '

  

 <3 

 3  .  $4 (    ((.

 (B



(( % "

)

)< 

<(=

 "3 

"

)< 

8 <(!

   

 $/ +  $/ 6 

0  

%"

"

  1"(

2 3

"

!+44+

3. <

B  <3

8 <(

(  (3!

?) '

<

 "

!* 

. < Page No.2

 ((.

8



( <

( < 

 7 '

! *

   *

(

 *  @ "  

 ?) '



 <3 )

 "

   (

3* (<(



$-

  $-



% >$- (" ) .



 C $3

"()<

!))

<33



<% 6 $/ <3

 

 "

   

  "

 

 '

!$D.3.  (" ()*

"



! .3 <

"

< !E

<( @ 

.



3

3 .

 * "

.



<

  





.3<

"

<  .)

 (" <3

<





<

E   27 ( C1

. (  < !   

<3 "(

".." 



<

<3

"

 )""



 <@ 

( (3"



 

  )   ".."  



<

(( (

"()<

 .    ("

<( 

<% E  $   ("  

 <%  $  (( <  ( 

<(*



("((.  @ C 

" "

!* ((3  

!  F <*



(" F  "

 <    3 

 "

   <  "(    . )  ""    "(.

 )

.

< ) Page No.3

 + 8

<(  (( "

3

.



<% 6 $/ <3

"

 

""



"

( .

  / !

<(! 

7.)

"

" ".

"

"

"

<3

 

!".

""(

3

.



  <%  6    $/!  <3

"

 ""



 "

 

(  .

! 

B



.) 

  !



<

 

))

! .3!<3

!C   "(

"  3     .



<% 6 $/

<3

"

 (F <

    

 

  .)   

 

 <

  "

 

 ))

! *  .    ("  

 <%  $! 

 "  .3 F "  "

 

 

    .3 "

   3

( 3 

"  <3

 

 "

 

 <% 6 $/  6!

<( "(

"

<3

"



<% 6 $/!""



"

(  .

!  *

) 3

"    3 

 (* 

.

 < )  

 "

  (( < (

"     .

 .



  "  

 <%  6  $/



  6;

C Page No.4

3

! (" 

<% $! "(.3 "3 ( 

( )

 



<(!

7.)

"

"

"

"

<3

 



(  "

 "(.  ((! 

    

  3

@

7.

(   "3!C   7 

 

. F  <  "

   ,5 

 8 



3"

!$::+6$::+F  ""

..

)) F  "



"

  (   . <3

  

 <  +  $/

"

F 

<( 

"3

)

   ( 

( )

 "(.

  

 

 ((

<%"(  <%"( < <%"( " <%"( "( !

 *

) 3

"

3"  3

(*

.

< )

<(.3  "

 

    

.    ""  *



"

 5 3  ("  .  

 <%  $  (( < (

<3

<( (3 <(   *

7 33 .

 "

 ("   

<(.3! . .

.







 <

 )!!

(

  "3

 ("  *

<(!  (( 

7"

   .

  .

    .)  "

 (" . 

<% $  , 

  ("         <3

<( *



    .

  " <% 5!3 

 (" .3 .  (" !"

..3<

"

< ! Page No.5

  ((  8 <(   

<(  (

 (" ) 

<( 

  (( <( .3!  "

  (" ! .   

 

 (

) (" <3

<(  - 

  

*  

 "

<(  ((!     .3 < !  

 (" ""



= = 1"( "

!$99/ 5$$99/

( .

A 5  )*"5*-*- '*- +*"  (* + : *"  !0+ /4 34$ (0*0  !2 %*+*/*4+0/* *"  !0+ /4.    ( 7.

 ?)  '

 .

"

)

$6

  

) 

*(

3* (<( ?*

!

 

  

   %B *  *   

  $4

  <()

  "

<(8

)

*

@ 

(  (3

.

*

 7'

8

 7'



(

?) '

*((3@   "()

"  @ 



++,  ++- 

 '    

  ( * . *

" +4!444% , %;4" !" !/< :0$'0 $*" *"!0+ /34$(0*0 !2

00*/ /* 4+ 0+/!8<+ 40/ 0 %*<40/*0  +*=*9*  *"  *"!0+ /. 7 (7.* ( 

()

@).

1(( "

 (( < ?)  '

  7 '

(

  <

 " "

<( 

 $- $ 

Page No.6

    <



( : $:+

3

2  ( !+44+ -  "

 " ". ! "

   ""  (

3 (<(

!*

! 

(

     "

"

%  3 *  @  

 

++,++-

' !

) *

)  ) 

 < 

3)

 .

 <3



"



"

< 

(* :

!"" )(3!. *

(<

 ( (

3""

(* $($('   

)

 $ $      ;

)



G # ;

<( G # Page No.7