Balprit Singh v. Sham Lal Etc.
1-
!"# $%&%!'())
!"# $%&%!'())
!"# $%&%!'())
*+,
!"# $%&%!'())
( -.
) /
.
! "
#! "
$ %&
' ! "
%
(& $ ) * +
,,,
.0) . -" $ $ .
$ "
$ # /" .
" # " .
*0 2111! # "" (3! %
$
$ 41%23'
45& -" 6 -782-
-2- *000 "
$ '9 %
$
$ 4# $ & #5&!
#
$ " $ :!70!000/- # 3
$ "
-" 6 -78*-*000
$
#
$" $ 2!;0!000/-# 3
$" -" -
6 -780-*000
$" $ *+!070/-. "" $' $$ # - " - 6 -;<1-*000 '
# $ " $ ;0!000/- # 3
$ " #$
*
= ' 9 - "
$$ '
" "" "
*8 0:
211+"" $
# ) 2.
3 80< ) -0<(-12*:
:
"
# # - " > $"
"-'
$ # "
$"" !
$"
$"" $
$ #
-"
"
! " $
$$"
#
"
-3- " $#
;
3
.
$. "
"
$ # "
$
'9
?"
8!0+:/-
= "
2/: *!+00/-
2* 3 $?" :!<8!000/- %*!+00@2*@2*& 6 ;!+00/- 3 " .
:!70!000/- +
" $ -"
" $.
- ● ?" . " #
"
# 3
.
.8:# $
$ "" .
##. 7!:00/-.
$ $02 211+
3 # "
."
!
" # 8!0+1/-
# # "
7!:00/-
. # "
● 6 .
$ "# 6
@
:0A $
#"
.
-48: # $
$ "" . '
●
# 342*5.
!
.
8:#
$""
$4285
● = "
. $ .
2/:
$ 2/8
. #8
."
●
$"
$ !$
$$ " "" "
.
. .#B5 (
<
#! " ! - " # @ C-2 !.
..
( $? 3@ ( C-2 " #
$
3
.
#.
$ 02 211+ "#.
$
211+.$@ 7!:00/-
B.
!C-2 "
# "" "
.
# " ! .
. " 02 211+ "" #!
3 " 8!0+:/-
$
"
?$ "
$ 3 "
. .#"
$ 02 211+
#
$ #" " "
?"
= *8 0:
211+!.
"
-5- .#"
$ 02 211+.
"#. 7!:00/-
3
$ !
# " $
7!:00/- ?$
"
$$
" $ -"
3 "
2/: . $ "#.
"
. $ # .
$
2/8
$2/: )$ .
" # 3 = .8:#
$"" .$ %!'
4'&31 '$ !56 '7. #)8&)
'
7/ 9% '# 1&)!*02<%2+&((! -" .
" $ .
"" $
"# = . #
.
( D
$ :0A . $
.$$"
.8:# "" #.
9
.
8:# ! $4285. "
$42*5. # 3 - " 2;!000/- "
. $$ " ! <!;00/- "
. $
$
$$ "#
"" #!
. " # - " - ?"
7!:00/-
7!:00/-
= "
2/8
%7:00-*0<;& +!**;/- 6 :0A %+**;E27+<& 7!01*/-
-6-
3 $
"# 7!01*@28@2* 2:!;1!8;+/- $
<!;00/- 6 <!;00/- 6" ( ) 2F* 2;!000/-@* :0!000/- "
( ) :
2;!000/-@* :0!000/- ( . #3 :!70!000/- ( . 28!:8!8;+/- G
$ " 28!:8!8;+/- %. &- :!70!000/-% . # 3& 20!;8!8;+/-
" $ ' - -"
" $.
- ● 3 "
$$"
#.
;0A% .$ #$20A&
● 6 .
$ "" # 6
@
80A$
# "
' - -" .28# $
$ ""
● 3 #
-"
$4275
#
3
● ( $$$ $ !$$" $
-7- $ "
.
-"
● (
" !
$$ $$" .$ $'#! $
H !
"
" !
" !
#"
$"
$' - -" . # "
G@ -21 $
3
( " .
#
. # 3! .
3 #
"
$= D ..
C-8! $ .
G@ -1! #"
$"
G@ -21 "G@ -28 G@ -2<
2*
3 #
-" $$ 20A #
"
$ # " !
$"
# >
# # "
" " ! .
"$ "" #
#
-"
2:
? : '#1 ;35 1 1%6 9% 1&) 8&) 9 1% '
'&31 '$ !56 '7. #) '1)!*0*+%2&=) 2*!B5 (
" $"
"
. .
80A$ ?" $28 # "
! $42;5.
B5 ( /5 )
-8- / 8 15 1&)8&) 49%1 '&6!1 !16!1 %!' '1)!*02<%2+& ((+70 " $4275$ $2; *0# *2 *;# ? %12 4 '#'! 9 18&)9 '# 1&)!6
) :807$*008 " 0:
0* *0*+!
$"
$ $$ .
#
(
?
.
$
$ # 3" $ #
"
"# .
% /5 )/ 8 15 1&)8&) 49%1 '&6!1 !16!1 %!'
'1)%&!
" $"
!.
. $ $# $
! "
$ ## $" ?
.
. $42;5" $"
.
22 28! $42*5" $"
.
0+ 20# $20" $"
.
0: 0; $415 " $"
$0 0:#
. $$
$ "#$ /
?
.
$42;5 " "
$22
28#
$ ! $42;5
$ "" # ? !"
.2:
# ! $ 42;5 .
$
$
$ "" # "" #! $42;5 $ "" $ "" # $
' "
"
!
-" .
$
!
.
$
#
>
. !
$ ! " 2!887/-
-9- -" ""
+!070/- !G@ -28 G@ -2< "" #! -"
$ 2*!000/- . " !
"
!
)
$ "
> " "" $ $$
@
$ *0!000/- B.
-" $$ .
$ $$
-" ##$28# 20A #. $
#"
$ "
'# $ $$
"" #! " @
$ # $ # $ .
-" $ ! $ ;0!000/-. . $$ $
)" $$" .
$ " -" .28# .
$"" "
.
> $
2;
-" $. -.
" - ?" 2!887/- % . & 2!887/- 6 80A %2887E;<1& *!0*</- 20A6"
# 20A$ *!0*</- *0:/-
2;
2;
3 $ *0:@2;@2* :+!;80/-
-10-
"" # $$ *0!000/- %. #
3& *0!000/-
" !
"
+070/- %. #
3& 2*!000/- $$ $ ;0!000/- ( . # 3 *+!070/- ( . 2!27!;80/- G
$" 2!27!;80/- %. &I *+!070/- %. # 3& 1*!8+0/-
2+
3
$."
"
$ #"
$
?" 2!000/-
2* 3 $ "# 2!88!000/- % 2!000@2*@2*& 6 G@ +!000/- 3 " . 2!;0!000/- 2<
" $ -"
$ " $.
- ● ?" . " #
"
# 3
.
.:1# $
-11-
$ "" . -
3
"
. # .
$""
● 6 .
$ "# 6
@
80A $
#"
. :1# $
$""
●
# 342*5.
!
.
:1#
$""
$42;5
● = "
. $
@
$2/:
. # .
●
$"
$ !$
$$ " "" "
.
. .#B5 (
# " . .$ !
"
. $#" " #
.$ "
# .
$ $$#
" "
!.
.
"
$#"
.$ $ $ ;%1 %/%'<9 '#'1)8&) 1% '
4'&31 '$ !56 '7. #) *0*2%2& (%( &8<7
.:1# $ . -
. $ .
"" .
# 2!887/-
B "
!
-12- "
2!887/-
.
#:1#
$"" !
"
!80A$
.
$
"$
B5 (
$ %!'
4'&31 '$ !56 '7. #)8&)
'
7/ 9% '# 1&)%&
$" .!
"
! .$
/ 8 15 1&)8&) 49%1 '&6!1 !16!1 %!'
'1)%&!2/: "
. "
9
. $
:1# $42;5. "
6
!
" .
"
4$" 5 ' $$"
-" . <!;00 . $
<!;00/- . $
-"
.
$
. 2;!000/-
"
. $ "
"" # . " . - "
?" 2!887/-
% . & 2!887/- 6 80A %2887E;<1& *!0*</- = "
2/: %*0*<-+<+& 2!:;2/-
2;
2;
3 $
"# 2!:;2@2*@2;
*!8:!270/- 6 G@ <!;00/- $
<!;00/- $ " " 2F* 2;!000@* :0!000/-
-13- ( . #3 2!;0!000/- ( . *!77!270/- G $ " *!77!270/-% . &I 2!;0!000/-% . # 3& 2!:7!270/-
*+, *0
" $ ' - -"
" $.
- ● 3 "
$ $"
#
$ *;A #
● 6 .
$ "" # 6
@
80A$
# "
' - " .28# $
$""
● 3 #
.
' -" 28 # $42;5
#
3
● ( $$$ $ !$$" $ $ "
.
-"
● G $" $ "
$$ $$"
.$ $'#! $ H !.
-14- *2
"
" !
" !
# "
$"
$ -" .
. # "
G@ -27 #" ! $
3
( " .
#
. # 3!.
3 # "
$= D ..
C-8! $ G@ -7! #"
$"
G@ -27 "G@ -7!G@ -22!G@ -2* G@-2:
**
3 #
-" $$ *;A #
"
$ # " !
$"
# >
# # "
" $$"
$
!
.
"$ "" # #
-"
*:
? . $ : '#1 ;35 1 1%6 9% 1&) 8&) 9 1% '
4'&31 '$ !56 '7. #) '1)%&!/5 )/ 8 15
1&)8&) 49%1 '&6!1 !16!1 %!' '1) %&! %12 4 '# '! 9 18&)9 '# 1&)%&! .
. $"
? !"
.2:# !
$42;5.
$
$
$ "" # "" #! $42;5 $"" $ "" #$
' "
"
! -"
.
$
!
. $
#
> . !
-15-
$ ! " 2!887/- -" ""
22!0<7/- !
G@ -7!G@--22!G@--2* G@--2:
"" #! -"
$ 27!000/- . " !
"
!
*8
B.
-" $ $ .
$ $$
-" #$28# *;A #. $
#"
$ "
'# $ $$
"" #! " @
$ # $# $.
-" $ ! $ <;!000/-. . $$ $ )" $$" .
$ " -" .28 # .
$"" "
.
> $
*;
-" $. -.
" - ?" 2!887/- % . & 2!887/- 6 80A %2887E;<1& *!0*</- *;A6"
# *;A$ *!0*</- ;0</-
2;
2;
3 $
"" # ;0<@2;@2* 12!*+0/- $$ *0!000/-
-16-
" !
"
22!0<7- %. # 3& 27!000/- $$ $ <;!000/- ( . # 3 ;0!000/- ( . *!08!*+0/- G
$" *!08!*+0/- %. &I ;0!000/- %. # 3& 2!;8!*+0/- *+
?
$ ! %&-" %&
" .
< ;A
$
$ $$"
H
#$ #" .
*<
"" #.
*7
" %&!$#!/ $"" #
"#$
"
$ $"
. ))