High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/22742/2015allowed

Sarabjit Singh @ Sarabjot Singh And ORS v. State Of Punjab & ANR

2015-09-23Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal17 pages

!"#"$%&'

( ) *+"("$,-.( )*+("$,- $/- )# ""$ )# 0# ( 1$+ * $/ $- ) #2$/ $# %

! "#

$% &'%(!)* + # % )* ,

&'%(!) '

%#%-).-( *

/

!"

# $%& '!

(! () (!)

*(+ *'

%,

)

+ )' )-

.

,/

1 2

1 3 #

..

"

, $%&

4 ,.1

3

, 3 , ,1/ ,

( /

/

4%

5

0 3 1

.

/ %89:

3 .

;

- ('

(!)

13 5

3 ,

<

$ , 1/

0 1 . .

/ ..

5

:

1 = 3 3 .

:

.

; *( ('

(!)

+*( .

1 3 5

3 > ?

1 3

<

7

, 7 1

.

1/

.

,1/

&

/ .1/ .

3 3

1 /

3 . . 011 /1 3

:/ ./1 .

.

. 3 .

@A / 3 /

B % 311 . / C % 1

/ 3

<

11

1D1 .

.

3

11 3

.1 > 5

1

:

/ .. = 3 .

3

11

;

. .

$%& *"

11 $%& .1

D 3

11

- ('

(!)

1 3 5

3 ,

<

. .

5

>

1 = 3 3 .

'"

; *( ('

(!)

+*( . 3 .1

5

3

> ?

<

/ .1/ .

. ./1 3

.

<

11

1 .

.1 ,.1

1 >

1

/ )"

2

1 %

/ 0 3 :/

1 11 1 1 : . , 11 E"

: =

3 3 >

'F

, , # . .

311

..

3

.

.

# 1 : >G 1

=

. %'

-! "0

/ 123'!'42 & ) 0

" ) )% / 11+'! '564

7 ) 8 0

')- $ !" )% 122'!'431 .. / '(-

/ $ . - 0

0& )%' 9

)'' )% /+66,:+; :

;356:;

: 1 ..

. 113 .

4

" " # $

" %

" " "

! "

"

"

! "

"

!

" "%

" ! &

' "

!

!

! "

( %

# )*

+

(, ( # )*

+

# -.!

+ # "

, "

# !

/ 0 1

"

! !

" "

! "

"

"

! "

" ' !!!

"

'

' "

"

"

2

" ! ! !

" !

"

"

+

!

! 3 +"

$11 0 7'

$-)%-)( )%

<')& # )% )/ +662:,; :

; 6=+ 3

'F

, , 1 > 3 #

:

3

1. .

.

1 3

1. >3 3

= / 1/

3 .

: /

3

3 >

'F

, , : 3

'F

, ,

=

F"

%

& ) 0

" ) )% / 11+ '! ' 564 3 >

'F

, , 3

>G 1

= 3 .

1 % 1 3 1

=

/ 3 1/

/

1 . .

.

1 = 1 3 3 1

=

11 >G 1

=

11 3 3 1

=

1

7 8

!

!

!

" %

"

" !

%

8

!

!

" !

"

&9 :

"

"

# 7;<071

2

# 7;;01 - 8

!

&9!

! !!

"

!

%

) 8

&9

:

" 5 :

!

"

2 !

# 7;;01 ; 8

!

&9 !

"

< 8

" 0

1

=

"

8

!

"

!

=

"

! %

!

3

-"

% = 3

'F

, , .

# 3 1/

# 3 31.1/

. 1/ 1 1

.. 1 1 . 1

1 .

. %

.

1 3 3

11/

.

..

% - )-)(0

<')& # )% )+6+:4;

:

;=4, >G 1

. / .

113 .

4 ; ! !

!!

> '

&9 !

!

!

# -?

"

:@0 1 0

1

"

'

!

& 9!

" ! ! "

! "

! !

"

% !

"

" ' ! !A " #

" #

" "!

!

% + !!

"

%

"

@ "

'

B

" 5!

"

'

" !!!

!

% !

!"

" "

"

"

!

"'

!

!

!

" !

%

!

! "'

!

! !

!

! !

"

!

! !

!

!

' 01 !

'

3 !("

: >G 1

. 3 - )-)(0

<')& # )% )+6+:4; :

;

=4,/ .-!"'& &0

)-)-"'(%!-)- /

/ )%-( )% /+6+:5;3+1

*(+ %, : >G 1

= 31 1/ - )-)( H I 1

113 .

4.

1

. 31

.

:

1

>G 1

= 3

1

. 4 .

1 1 .

- ) -)( H I : >G 1

= # . 31 .

3 3

/ =. /

/ :

113

.

./

./

3 % . 3

*(+ %,

113

.

$%&

1 3 # 3 # !!"

: # .

*(+ %, . 1

>G 1

. -)%-)( )% 0

<')& # )% )/+64:+; :

;43+

>G 1

= .

1 .

*(+ %,

/

4.

1

> 31

# . 1.

3 = 3

'F

, , $113 1 3 3 *!

.4 -7

!

"

" ' ! !

# )* ! '

!

> 01 + # )* !

!

# -? , # )*

'

!

!

!

"

01 8

!

'

> 1

" 8

!

01 # !

"

% !

" #

" #

"

!!

% + !!

" +

# %

" ' ! "

!

!

! 0C1 D

" 5!

"

" !!

!

"

'

! ! 0C1 8

" !

%

!

! " '

0C1 D # -?+

"

"

!

"

! "

! # -? + &9 !

# -?+ %

# -?+ & " "

"

=

"

2

" !

" D

"

"

!

% ! ! '

!

!

!

!

" " !

!" ! !

"

0C1 8

# )* !

"

!

!!

"

!!

!

!

"

! '

=

$ %

!

"

"

"

! ! =!

!

D

! !

!

! !

"

!

# )*

"! ! # -? + !!

#

"

" "

!

! !

!

!

'

" "

# -?+

"

!

'

" ! 3 "

% %" < % 0

. 8 )%

+64:4; :

;+6+ >G 1

=

*(+ %,

/

3 3 1 3 -)%-)( )% 0

<')& # )% /+64:+; :

;43+ 3

- )-)(0

<')& # )% )/ +6+:4; :

;=4,

%

3 = -)%-)( )% H I

1133

3

. !*"

% 11

3 . J1 = 3 > = . 3 1/

1

31

31 1 1/ ;

*(+ %, 11 /

11/

D/

. . > 31

.1/

*(+ %, . $%& % 11

3

*(+ %,

$%& %

/3 .3 1

/

. 3 / 1

/ 3 . .

. 1

1 3 = .

3 1/

1

. % # .

*(+ %, 113

/

1 4

HI J 31 .

D/

13 3 1/ 3

HI 1 3

1 11/

=

=

/ HI

3

.

1.

1/

3 1 *(+ %,

HI .

/ .

.

3

, 1 1

1 . 3 1

1/

11

. 1 3 = 1 3 3 1/ 3

.

1

3 1 4 1

*(+ %,

.

.. !'"

%

/

1 ;1/ 1 /

!

/ :

3 J1

1/ 1 3 -)%-)( )%

H I 1

3 ..

.

1/ 1

1

1

3 .

/ : . !

.

/ 1

1 .

!)"

. .. 3

/

1

: 31 1 .

31

113 !E"

,#1/

113 &1 1/ $%& '!

(! () (!)

*(+ *'

%,

)

+ )' )-

.

,/ 1 2

1 3 #

#

.

*

(!)

(5 %