High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/480/2023disposed of

Haryana Public Service Commission And ANR. v. Suresh Kumar And ANR.

2025-09-16Justice (To Be Nominated),Mr. Justice Rohit Kapoor8 pages

!"# $

%&%%%'' ()%

%%%%*+ * - ./01*%23 45,1 -6.573*5 -* - ./01*%23 45,1* -547

*

!

" #$ -6.573*5 -*#2%

"' %

&

'$ &

" ( ) *+

, , -. -/ /-/0

& 1, &2 & 2'//3-'/-3

& '"

&

'

4'

' 4 (

, + 6 7

$

,

& 8

9 :

9&

";

,

& ) 7&! *

(+ % 9

:

< /0 - /-= %

,

- / /-= > & ) 7&! *

" ;

& % ,,

&

,2 & 2'//3-'/-3 52

: , & ) 7&! *

(+ 5

/- /-=

&

& >

) 7&! * & ? - /-3&&

>

& --@

&

,

%

&

& 2 , : &

, ) 7&! *

5

&

&

"

8

&

&, A 8 &,

2 && B'

!"

"!#" $$%&

"'(

%% !#& !"

%%)!(!*(!# $(#&!"("

%

!'&( "+ "#,#!"

!(,!

%!

!(#

!#-.//-./0 1""!2(! 304 ! $!

"!(

$!&'& %%+ 5!# $(#&! !6)7!& " !( '&

!89 !'

(!

"

!$!

"!( /..: "#& $$!#$!(")!& !'

& ! $$%!# '( 6 89 " -;//-./09 &

'(

(#!# )+ ! !

#

!( ' &% %&5 %! !"

(+#&

"''&!(1 49 "!

(9 " (" '(

(#!# (& %! !"

(+ #&

" ''&!( 149 (5!

( 9 " <.//-./0

% !2$% "!#)+ !$!

"!()!'(! &( "+

!!" .//--./0 ! (!* ! &!( '&

!

!# )+ & $!

!"

( + ! $!

"!( " /=./-./> 1""!2(!3//4

",!

' ),!9 !$!

"!(

" "+

! $$%!#'( !(!* !6)7!& " !( '&

!8'(

!& $!

!"

( +9 9 !(!"'

% " !$ ( ' $!

"!( ! $!

" #$!# ' #(!& " (+ )%& !(,&! "9 & %% !$!

"!('( "

!(,!

"#&"#!(& "##

(!" !( ,?3 3,? !(& "##

!@

A

&

&

&

& 5

,

&

,

,

&,

%

,

,

0- -C /-/0 & ,

,!, 1,B' "

!"#9 "

!(

% 9

$(

#,!( ! !"

#

!# /=.--./=9 (!$"#!"

/ & $!

!# '( !%!& " ! $ '

('!( 1&" &4 %%!!

#(!49

9 ! * %'!# (

!" !2 "

" "#

!,!"& %%!#'("

!(,!

"#&( "+' #& !"

9) & "##

(!

(!7!& !#9 !'

%!# )

" 6)7!& " !( '&

!8'( ! $%+!(

(!#

! %!

("!# "%! A#!9 " (!'!(!"&! %!

!( #

!#,! )!(-.9-./013049)!(,!#

( !9 '( !'( !9,#! #%!

!(9(!*(!#(!$"#!"

/ )

" '( $$"

" ( +9'

%" &9!

%#" )!"

!(,!

!#"#9"&!! !#

!%+ $$%!# '( ! " -;//-./09 &

(!%!

!# " /=./-./>9 !(!

"! !( "+#!% +9"(!&%#)! #

)! (! " $(" & ! &&(#"%+9

$$!%% " )!!" #(!& !# "

!(,!

(!$"#!"

/ "#&"#!(& "##

(! B!(!

9 ! !(

$$%&

" '( 9 #

!# /<.<-./=9 )

!# )+ (!$"#!"

/ !%'9 (!*(!#

%% ! & "##

!9 ! $%+!# " C,!(" !"

D)%& !& ( "#!(

5"9 ) '( !( ! $%+!(149

!'"

!(,!

!(!'(!9!)

(!$"#!"

/

&"& ' # (!*(! !"

!

(%+ " /<.<-./= "#9 ! %!

!( #

!# ,! )!( -.9 -./0 1)#4

7 !*!% !(!

E( !(9 !!%!& "$(&! #

%(!

#+)!!"& ((!# "#"!9"

+ (

59

$$"

!# "

!"%+, "&+

#,!( !#9$((

'%"' !$!

"9" )!"&!' !!%!& !# "##

!9 ! (!%!' $( +!# '( " ,! )!!" ( !# " &&"

' ""37"#!( ' "!&!

(+ $ ( ! "

"+& !9 !!%!& %

" !,!"*!

"!#" ( $!

""#9&"#!(

"' !& "##

(!'(!$"#!"

/9

!9 %# ,! !( ( '&

"D (!$!(&" "# %# ,

! "& + ' ! !"

(! !%!& "D $$"

!"

$(&! &!" $$%&

"'(&"#"

"'#!% +

!%% " " $$!

%9(!

("

)%!)+/>.>-.-< &!(!F

+9 !%% %% #7("!# #

!9 $!(

" ' ! $"!# (#!( "# 7# !"

#

!# .;.--.-<9 (!"#!(!# )+ %!

("!# "%!A#!9 %%(!

"

+!#@

&

#

&

,

2

%

& 1,

, ' D & ) 7&! *

5

%

, : &

& B 14 (!+ (5" !

&!("#&

"!$ ( !"

G 14 (! + ! $%+!# " C, D)%& !& ( "#!(

5"G ' ! "#+ (!"(!% (!(,&! !",!#!

% "# ,!

) '( !! $%+!(

!'"

!(,!

4 5 : ( +

: (

+

,

% 5 -C - /- % & &

6 #

" $ %

% 6 #

$

9&

" ;

: , ) 7&! *

&

%

, &

6 #

" $

)* % : & ) 7&! * &

A 1,

,2

&

& --@

2 &

--@

& ! < : %,

: & ) 7&! *

&

< :

& ,) 7&! * 5

& ) 7&! *

&

/- /-= 8 < : !

--@

, &

& %

&

, "

/-= <

,

<

%

& ,

%

&

%

&

&

? 5

& & &

5

&, "&! & &

++% 5,

, &

&

&

& :

!"

## $ "

$ %&'%()%*+ + B!

!($!

5"D(!

"!# F ! D B!

!(!$(

)%! F ! D