← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1520/1995allowed

Bant Singh (Through Lrs) v. Darshan Singh (Through Lrs) Etc.

2018-05-16Mrs. Justice Anita Chaudhry9 pages

 

     

 

  !!"# !$  %%&&  '"# "! !!"# !$ (!" % ( 

) !  %%&&  '"# "! ! (!" % (       

 *" 

"*# + (&, "(-.!

") (% !!,(-

"!%%&&  



"#)!/ , "(-.!

")0!",(-

"!%%&&  



"$" , "(-.!

" " ,(-

"!"% (  

 2!/#( ) 

(

!&& (((!!%%&"" # )# (!/#( )  %(32!&"

(4"%%&&5#"&))  %%&& !- &(.%"%%&  

!(" "% 32.2 % %"

")  ! ")  &&(( 6

 .!"%& ()#"  3 ! ( 3.$!!#/)7!#/ !,.!. !- !&(" (!. !(&%"((!),.!.

" %"%"2 (%#8! !%&

!!9#( 

 ") && -#" !%&

 6

 "&&  (" , ,

: ("-(,;

,

:"

) 2 8 #"!"%&((!!&((.39#(

 ;

%2)     3&   &   ("     ,

:  <!"  "  - (  !#   ! ) !"   " / !3"!" &!!#/)7!#/ !, .!"( ; (!# !,#&( ! (0"%& ! "    ! " / !!#/) 7!#/ !((   8 &&2( &( %"." ) ( 2 9# ! ") && "% "

) 232!#/)5# "&&  .")(32 (  "" !!#/)7!#/ !

.=( %%( (.!& %-2!!#)3)%" ."=

3& =%%" .!! ") &&!3 %" (>.-",&"

( %%"!-"&-(!(%# ( )     !  

  .  ""((  32  !  &"

(  "&  5#"  





#) (#3  !." )  &(32(   !! ") && " ( 3"((#)  $"

("&5#" "%%" !-( -&3&

! &""((  ( !! ") &&(" ( &"(2

; 9 !#)3)"=(%%" (,!" ",!# &(32!%&

 ."("(3()(*&

 &(! "%%&$"

(4" %%&&5#"!! "-"! "(/#( )  ((" %(32!&"

("&5#" ! ("(%  !5#", &&. #3 & ?#  &." !%"       

    

                    

  

       

   

  

 

 

         

   

             

    

"(# ?# &.," )" .#&(3

"23 (,!#/)..

" & ()#"  3 ! ( 3.3 !& !" && (;3 ! (3. #(-&& # ,<!& ("$#(! >. !-

5&8!" "  3"!"" / !

!#/) 6 ,!#/)9#(" "(@&& -#"

 ; ,    !8! &&  !>"( !& .!+"

& !,. 3"!" &.  ,)% (.!</ ! !" &.   -&& /& .!!",.!." #&&2 ")() "#=-&& 3#

) "3&2= .2!#/)&!#/ !,.!. (3#A 2"!

6 )!3! ) !B(   &( ( )%& ((A  !*,$#(! .!%2>,(", $#(! ,%2 .!!C9@6<!)%& .&( ( 5#" !" (!## (" ;

6,;

:;68*5  A  ,.! !#/)&!#/ !&33 .    !  #(2    </   !     !"  " "(  @&&  (( A  . 9#( -#" ) ! (!.  8 #"!"&& (!( !(&( (") & %"(   (  ( !. " "",! =!#/)!!# ! !" &.</ !,.!. = .

! " !,.!%")(=%.! !#/)7 !#/ ! #" !%"( # &.

#&%-2 !#/)7 !#/  !,!#)3 )%"  ."3 ( 32"! !  ! " !,!%&

, .!!! ") &&!3

" (       %&(  !    .  (   ,  .!  !( =( %%(!#/)8 2,!#/)&& (!-3

"-"(  32  !  %&  .!"    )%")  .  ""-(    3.

(      (    (  !#/  )   *#"#     !   "( &) ," "(@&&(( A

 .9#(3?#! ! "%"%"2 ?#&!" -#" !#/ )  ((         "  -  (2    !  9#    ! " "(@&&  ("&",!#/)."( -&& #  .!  " (" !?#  &.

 

 

 

 

              

 

 

       

    



 

   

 

 



 

                  

        

   

             

    

!%" ,"( !/#( ) %(32! &"

(4"%%&&5#"( !.!!&"

(5#"!(& .!!"  - 32!&"

("&5#" ( ""&%%"& ((# &2,"-"(!/#( ) !&"

("&5#"$"

( 4"%%&&5#"!%(/#( ) .)/" "# (D !#/) -&&!"

  !"2 (((  - 2!  ( (#" !& ) (! 3&!(! !#/)7!#/ !. !- &- (

 ."( ( !#/)7!#/ !. -""-(32 ( D%&

" "?#"((& ").!" !!("" ( (%(!"

) 2       5"#&(#)  !%"  ") && 9#(32!#/)7!#/ !5%2 ! ") && C9* 8 .%  "3(   /#(&)%%%"

 :3"&=! ") &&%"-! ") && &!# !! (." 3#  &2% 3. !& !3

"(#( ")%3) !8% >.-",.! &=

%  !&& ( ") &&, 3&!(32 ( (#3!!% !3 "(#(("&&2 #")%&

! ") && :;"(%" !  /#(&)%%%" 

%8?#%%" ! "& ! (% !-"&%%( !%" !  /#(&)%%%"% 3. !&   (%  "&2(

" ! ! "% <! (")  "

%#"! )%%%"( 3"!#)3)%" !#/)7 !#/ !,&!# ! ")&&2!)%- ("( ! #""

!#)3)%"  !%#"!" !%" ,.!!%#"!(! )%%%"&& #"!",)"&-(  !" "( !"3, .!!(!! ") &&.9#()"&@!

  !. .(".

!(

"  !% %   (.! % ,!( (! >.-",#3?# &2 .!        !     .  (".

,    &"  %"    !  " 9)  ,!()(!!"(

"  % 3. & 3#((  - 2" 9%2 !)23(#(&  !=!" #)3"("% & (C- !"  "" 3#!("% !& (!3  - .! " -& 

! ") &&.!"%3. !& ("("&&2 ! ( ! "%  #"!""(# ! (% .!"  =!"  #)3"  !  3  )  (  &&  #"!",  !  "3  .!  ! %%"(*@;!()(!-&& #  "#3<!& *2&.!"(#) ""3( (" "(#3 "" *2&>.-", " !3  - .!2&() ,.!(( " .(2E!"-&)"&9#! ") &&<!

A "3.! %%"(& .!!" ",. # (!!" "

! 3 %"%"&2)  (>(! "2 6((

 ,.!!!3 (&( (!" ";6% ."& 3& = .!!!&)."#

&(((#)=> #"!"()(!

! (% !." ! ") &&""  &2

:;"(%  (")  .3& = $"

(4"%%&&5#"!&)"(!-(  $"

(  4"  %%&&  5#"  !  3(     "  /#( )     ! )   !.!" !# ("

F@!-"!"

( ")! "#&#"& & (!#( -!),)23"!" &#( - !"2" " E!E !#/)7!#/ !G $"

(4"%%&&5#")"! .%&!-  "%"(!-( ""(!  !!()(!!#/ )7!#/ ! -"#( -%" !"

 ! %!. 3#. - -"2!  !"28 ! ("(%  ! 5#",#!  ( &"&2)"( !/#( )  !#/)7!#/ !.%%"9)&2A 2"  , .! .#&  (!. !( %"(( !)>9#(  " "(@&& -#"  6  C-   #)( "!= " #) !!#/)7!#/ !.

2(.! "  !3. . %!.(

&&!#/)7!#/ !   9#(#3?# @&&

A

 3?#! ! "& ( ?#&!" 

 8 !#/)7!#/ !!(9#(  ") &&

6

 !".  "!)9#" "(@&&

-#" A

 &&  #"!",    " #&  "(    !  "9)   

"! !  !%&

,.!!%%"( -(  !!!"%&

! " !!( !"- #""( -(!-&& >.-",! " !! %%( !.  39 " #&"( !"9)  "! !%&

, %%" !!  (( !5#" ( &)"!! "-&>( !-) %#"!!& (H!& !,! !")"  &. !& 3 9) ( !-(  $"

(4"%%&&5#"!&""( ""(

 ( !!%&

. "?#"(%"-#" "

) 2 ! ("(%  !.!"&&  "! !#)3)"== 3& =%%"!-3 )#(,. #)3

!%&

%"-%2) !# "

) 2 ,;

,

: 2" 8()(32"! !!!( )  3 =#  && #"!",!&&  !%&

!!#/) 7  !#/   !  .  )% (  32  (      (   .!

 ") &&.9#(>.-", !"%"    !-3 ( 2.!" "!#)3)%" " #" !-3 3 ( && #"!",&"

(4"%%&&5#"! #"!"""(

9)  !@&& !) "2(#) !#/)

7!#/ ! #<!% .!! (((")   %" &  . &2!.!!"! ") %"-(" I -. !(# )(3-,!5#"!) ! &# !%&

!- &(%"-! 2 ") && . "( .! ".&& (-& !$!!#/ !"

2"

) 2.%(!) > ,  3!  !  ?#   "   ."(   -#"    ! %%&&  @!& (!/#( )  (("%(32! &"

(4"%%&&5#",! &"

("&5#"""(  #&" (%%&"&&.( 

 





   @!!"%= : ( J: @!!"%"3&  J: