High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1754/1995dismissed

Dalip Kaur v. Sukhbir Singh

2015-02-05Mr. Justice J.C. Verma11 pages

!"#

$%&'%()*+) ',-.'&% ///-- ,,'!0 %2&2 &34$%!54'! 04 %2 ///

!02 66666

!0"# 7%'%!'8!544&,,'%* 9

%04 ,,'!0 7%%9! 0'* 9 % 7%

-'35!40%* 9

%04 !02

2-&0 !042

5&,'%

! -- ',- %0'!202&

22!0 20'0 '% 9!54:2!

; ! '!080',-.'&%* '-- ,,'!04 !*2220 %'% 9!54

*<4 '2-,'!02 &34$%!54*4&-!

%!54'! '54$%!542!2'%24'!!54 <4'% !024 !*'% 2!204 &!

'% 9!54 '% 9!54 != >?'0'&24 %' '!!&' <'2'$'

,%'!

<'24'9!5,'! !9,,'5 '!5',.','!'2< ,,'2!'&24 %' '!!&' + 4 '% 0< 80!5@,,2*!

'0 >?-%-&!

$(04 -,'!02*% !024 !*'! 04 04 % '0 +? >?2 0&- $(04 ! '!0*'-- ,,'!04 ! !04 $'22@,, '0 >?*04

-,'!024' ,'8 ,9 20$ <!

%2!-22 22!04 ,'! , 0 $('% 9!54

<4 '204 ! '!0*'-- ,,'!04 !* ,'8

,&29 <!

%24-'! -22 22!-&%2&'!00@,, '0 +? >?!4 '9&% = ' B& %9', ,'8204 -'%0 2*04 ,< &%04'

%'8 ,,<!522& 2"

@4 %'% 9!54

&0 '9', @,,! >?!'9&%04 -,'!02C

+ @4 %04 -,'!02'% !00, !B&!

0!'2 -%'( %C

= @4 % 04 -,'!02 4'9 !0 2 %9 !0

0! &!B'$-

2 0*202

0C @4 %2&02!08'!0'!'$, !04 -% !0%8C # @4 %04 -,'!024'9 !, &220'! '! '&2 '

0!0, 2&0C # @4 %04 2&0!04 -% !0%82!08'!0'!'$,

!' 0!',22& ' !5'2#<'2',2%'8 $(04

,< &%0,'0 %!*<4 4% ' 2'2&!

# @4 %'% 9!54

&0 '9', @,, +? >?!'9&% ! '!080',- .'&%C

0 %%

-0%','2< ,,'2 &8 !0'%(

*04 ,<

&%0

22& 2'! +!'9&%04 -,'!02'!

2&09 B& 58 !0'!

'0 +=+

22& 2=*#'! # 4' !0$

!-% %'%5&8 !02*4

*!! !52< 59 !!04

2' 22& 222& #<4 44' $

!%'8 ' 0!',,(*<'2!0

!2 $(04 ,< &%0'! !! !52< 0&%!

! ? 4 %20'-- ,,'0 &%0

!504 ',80',-.'&% 03&- '

4'! %(8'00 %%'2 $(04 ,,'!0'! 9 ' 0',

B& 58 !0'!

'%8!5! !5204 ,< &%0 '2',2

!522& #'5'!2004 ,,'!0* 2822 4 %'-- ', !042

5&,'%

! -- ',*2&$20'!0',D& 20!2,'<

!5 %8!'0!$(042&%0'% '2&!

@4 % ' @,, '! $ 0% 0 4'9 $

! -%9

<04&0-% & !5'!(04 '00 20!5<0!

2'! !

2 %$ ',!

+ @4 %'! !5$(04 ,< %'-- ,,'0 &%0 '!$

0'3 !'2'2&$200&0 %04 0%', &%0!'$2

'!( 22& '! ! !5% 0&%!

$(04 0%', &%0'0',,C > %5&8 !02 < ' 9'!

$( 04 &!2 , % 04 -'%0 %%!5004 %%9', ,'82

&!2 ,%04 ,,'!04'2&%5 04'004 @,,!'9&% '-- ,,'!0# ! '!0 <4 4 20 -%9 '2 - % ,'<* <'2 2 '%

<4 '2&!-%9 @,,!'9&%04 -,'!02<'2% &-! '&2!5'

5% '0 -% B&

,,'!0# ! '!00 2 ,'8 04'0 04 2 %$

'!!0$ 0'3 !0$ '2'!'00 20!5<0!

22'! !'$2

A'8!'0!

'00 20!5<0!

2*@,, '0 >?:A ;!'9&%04 -,'!02

8'!2&!-%9 02 !0 04'004 @,, '0 +? >?:A;!

'9&%04 ! '!0*'-- ,,'!04 !*<'20$ !2 $(04 &%02 $ ,<<4 4<'25!% <04&0'!(-,'&2$, '! , 5',,(9', % '2!20 2&%04 %&%5 04'022& #<4 4<'2%'8 $(04 ,< &%0 ' 0!',,($&0 !0 !5'5 '00 !0!04 2' &%0'! 2 D& ,,( 8'!

&!'!2< '&2!5-% B&

,,'!002&%5 04'0 04&5404 2'8 <'2'!2< $(04 %20'-- ,,'0 &%0$&004'0 &%2 2 !0- %822$, !,'< ) &!2 ,%04 !0 20!5% !024'2&%5 04'0@,, '0

>?:A ;-%-&!

$(04 !02#-,'!02<'2&,,(-%9

% '!

<04,'<'! 04&2*<'20$ '

&-!02 ,'8 04'0 @,, '0 +? >? :A; 2 0 &- $( 04 '-- ,,'!0# ! '!0 4'2

&%% !0,($

!4 , $(04 &%02$ ,<0$ 24%& <042&2- &2

&820'!

2'! 2!0'9', @,,04

'! 04&2*<'2%540,( 5!% $(04 &%02$ ,< %'( %% 2822',0422

! '-- ',4'2 $

!8'

$(04 !02 % 8$'%3!5&-!04 %9', ,'8204 -'%0 2D&'04

2&$20'!0', D& 20!2 ,'< !

!5 %8!'0! $( 042 &%0* 0 2 <%04<4, 00'3 !0'

&!004 '

02'$&0<4 404 2! 2-&0 '% 9!54 '2'$'

,%!= >?2'04 %4' 04%

$%04 %2* !'8 ,(* %0'8!54*-',!54'! '%24'!!54 %0'8!54*'04 04

'2',204 ,,'!0# ! '!0<'24'!5 0 '04 <4 '2 -', !54* &!

<'2 2 !0

0 ,

8-%2!8 !0024'-- !'8&% ' B& '5'!2004 8 +

'% 9!544' 42$%04 %*!'8 ,(*',<!

!54'! 220 %80',-.'&%4 204 ,,'!0# ! '!0 !04

4'%5 8&% %*<4 !'04 %04

' 800 ,(<'24'!5 0

'04! ?'! 42&!

-',!54<'22 !00B',0&!

%5,

8-%2!8 !0! ?*04 <'2!!

0,3'0 %04

'2',242 $%04 %',<!

%!54'! 220 %80',-.'&%4 (< $%&540&- $('%24'!!54*04% $%04 %'04 %04

80',-.'&% <'2 ',2 8'%% $( '%24'! !54* &!

0 !,( 8'0 %!',&!

.&! '!!5404

'%!5'2 @$&0 42!,($%04 %',<!

%!54'-- '%!5'2 @>4'9 &,,(2&--%0

-,'!02*% !024 ! = < 5$(!0 20'0 2&

22!

'% 9!54* ',<!

%!54:

@>;*$ !542% ',$%04 %<'205 0E24'% 42

20'0 '242!'0&%',4 % -20!',<!

%!54:

@>; ,!

204

!0% 8'00 %'! , '9 2!8'!!

% &$004'0'% 9!54

42220 %80',-.'&%< !0!,(,3 '0 %$('%24'!!54*42 &!

$&04 <'2',22&20'!

'! 2&--%0 !42,,!

22'24 <'2 2& %!5%8$%!

402 F'! 04

2-%9 0$ !0!&!5!-22 22!

04 !02#-,'!02<4'% 2!2'%24'!!54!24%0*04

<'25% '0 80!',!9 !08'

$(&!

'%24'!!54'! 422!2 !'% 9!54

*<4<'2!'0&%',,(4'9!5'00'

!0<04',, 8'! 04&2* 04 <'2 !04!5 &!!'0&%', ! '% 9 !54

<,,!5'<'(42 !0% 20'0 042'

0!'0 &2!2 2!2'%24'!

!54<4'% !02#-,'!02

'04 ,,'!0# ! '!004'004 @,, '0 >?

:A ;4'2!0$

!-%9 !0 %82,'<<4 !2 %&0!2 !04 , 5', -

20',*',2',2 &$0*0-%9 '@,,!' 0!004

* 208!('!'00 20!5<0!

222% D&% !0 %82

0!?>04

! '!9

0*>+:%24%0*04 0;<4 4-%92!%% ' (

2'-- '2$ ,<"

! " # $%$&'()* +&',$*(#$-')#$+./012(.$ 1(($3($+ 1+&',$*()3#$-')#$+./012(.$1(($3($+4)(35100 *(.$'3$+13$6)+$*&$'*()0*$1(($3()*72)(*$331(0$13(513 .$$*&100$+ #(5$8'#83$ 8#6)*7)(3$%$&'()*4) (5$#$.$ 1*1(($3()*72)(*$3310)6$41*+3'.9$&(((5$8#&$33 (5$ '#(1*+&181.0$ 7)6)*7$6)+$*&$ :

#6)+$+(51()(35100*(.$*$&$331#/(&1001*1(($3()*7 2)(*$33)*8# (5$$%$&'()* 1*/+&',$*(4*(.$)*71 2)004 25)&5 513 .$$* #$7)3($#$+ )* 1&&#+1*&$ 2)(5 (5$ 8#6)3)*3 (5$*+)1*$7)3(#1()*&(4 ;"< ;"=4 '*0$33)(3$%$&'()*./(5$8$#3*./25,)(8'#8#(3(516$ .$$*$%$&'($+)338$&) )&100/+$*)$+>G 0404 @,,2*!

-%-&!

$(04 -,'!02'! 04 04 %2 0&-$(04

! '!0'% &!% 520 ? !' 0!004 2 %$ *04 '% 0<'00 20!5<0!

204

@,, '0 >?:A ;!

!5,(*!

0<'00 20!5<0!

9HF'8$ % '% '%'!544' <4 '204 %'00 20!5<0!

22B'$ !54 <'2 822!5 '! <'2 &!4 '% 2 <4 '$&02 < ',2 &!3!<!04'22&

!0,( 8 !

04'004 < 04% '02%8 0 %%%202<4 44' 8'

B'$!540,

%804 9,,'5 , '9!5 $ 4! 42!<4 '$&02 %$ 'B!

%!54'-- '%!5'2 @4'259 ! 0',

208!(!0!,(2 %$!504 @,,$&0',202

&0!$(04

20'0%'% 9!54'! ',2'00 20'0!$(04 '00 20!5<0!

2 '%'

!54'! B'$!54%8',,(*0 208!('2 %$ 2!00'3 !0$ '0 -'%<04'!'00 20!5<0!

22$&0!042 *0 208!(04 2 %$ 22

0', '! %-09 04'002!, 229', '! , 5',,(25! '!004'!

04'00 208!('!'00 20!5<0!

2202*04&2*2& 4' <4

208!( 2 %$ 'B!

% !54 :

@; 2 ! D&', 0!52 '!

'00 20!5<0!

22 > '%'20 208!(',<!

%!54:

@;2!'00 20!5 <0!

22F'8$ % '% '%'!54:2!

;2 !

*4 4'2',2 59 ! 8-, * %-09 '! -!0 '

&!020'0!504'042'04 '%'

!54*'00 20!5<0!

22@,,A 4' !++ > 4'2

5% ',,(8 !0!

04'04 &2 02

42'04 %25!!5'! <%0!5 '! 04&2* &, !0(4225!'0&% 2'2',2<%0!5'! 4' !0 42 25!'0&% 2!@,,A 004220'5 *% -% & 0!

0!?

22'%(*<4 42'-- '2$ ,<"

# 25$#$ * 1(($3()*7 2)(*$33 '*+ * 3'&5 1(($3()*72)(*$33&1*.$ '*+4#) (5$+&',$*(8'#8#(3( 516$.$$*$%$&'($+)*(5$*)($+?)*7+,4)(,'3(.$8#6$+ (51((5$1(($3(1()* *$1(($3()*72)(*$331(0$13()3)*5)3 51*+2#)()*741*+(51((5$3)7*1('#$ (5$8$#3*$%$&'()*7(5$ +&',$*()3)*(5$51*+2#)()*7 (51(8$#3*G 9

',<!

% !54 :

@; $ !5 ! 0&!

<04 D&% !0204 -%92!2

0!?

0',2-%9 204 @,, :A ;!' 0!00 208!(-,'!0&34$%!54:

@+;'! 42 '04 %'%24'!!54:

@=;*04 2&!'22', 0 208!(',<!

!54:

@;2!'00 20!5<0!

22F'8$ % '% '%'!54'2',2* .&! '!!54*8'0 %!',&!

'2 @'! ',<!

%!54 :

@>;*$%04 %04

*<4 42 !'5'!2042<!!0 20 +) '% '2 @,, '0 +? >? :A; -%-&!

! '!080',-.'&%2 !

*02& %2%88'!(2&2- &2

&820'!

222& #4' 2-

',,($

!%'8 !-, ' !52 ! '!0!042 &!07 ,($

'&2 0%', &%04'2!0'!2<

042 22& #* <4 4 <'2 ' 0!',,( %'8 * 2 !0 90'0

" -%

!52 %$ % ,< &%0%$ % %20'-- ,,'0 &%0 '2 0 <'2 '5%

&-! $ 0<

! 04 -'%0 2 '0 04 08 %'8!5 ' 0!',22& #04'0!

<'2% D&% 0$ , ' 0!',,( $('!(04 -'%0 2*'! 04&2!,(! !52< 0$ 59 !!22& # <4 404 0%', &%04' 800 059 + 004220'5 *02'--%-%'0 0% %0 &, + % %JF <4 4&,,('&04%H 204 ,,'0 &%00,,04 9 <04&0 %%!504 8'00 %004 ,< &%0' &, + % %JF % ' (%

2% -% &

'2$ ,<"

@ 5$#$$6)+$*&$*#$&#+3'

)&)$*(488$001($'#(,1/ +$($#,)*$&13$ )*100/A@5$#$(5$$6)+$*&$'8*(5$#$&#+)3 3'

)&)$*(($*1.0$(5$88$001($'#((8#*'*&$9'+7,$*(4 (5$88$001($'#(,1/41 ($##$3$((0)*7(5$)33'$34) *$&$331#/4

)*100/+$($#,)*$(5$3')(4*(2)(53(1*+)*7(51((5$9'+7,$*(

(5$ '#( #, 253$ +$&#$$ (5$ 188$10 )3 8#$ $##$+ 513 8#&$$+$+2500/'8*3,$7#'*+(5$#(51*(51(*25)&5 88$001($'#(8#&$$+3G ++ 4 %20'-- ,,'0 &%04'2&,,( 2 &22

'00 ! !5 &820'!

2!'!2< %!522& #02!0 20!50 !0 04'004&5480',-.'&%:@;4'28 !0!

04'004 @,, '0

+? >?:A;<'2

&0 !4 %'9&%$('% 9!54

* %$%04 %*'224 &2 02 %9 48$&0042-, '4 %K22!00 !'$, <'!54:@+;'! &%

-!54:@=;'% '00 20!5<0!

2 042@,, '0 +? >?:A; += $'% ,304 @,, '0 +? >?:A;% ',204'004

!0 !0204 !4'9 $

!' B&20 $(8'!-&,'0!'! !'%%<!5 <!

2-'

$(<%0!5 ,2 ,('004 ! 04 <%0!504 @,,4

&820'!

22 %$!504 @,,!042<'('% '%,(% ',!504'004

-'- %4' ',% ' ($

!25!

$,'!3$(0225!'0%('! !0 !0204

< !

%-%'0 ,'0 %! +

'% %!52 %9

$( ! '!080 ',-.'&%:@;2'24,,<'24 %20'! 04'024 <'2!-22 22!04

,'! 4 28'%% !9,,'5 '!5',.','!4 2!04!5!%

% % !4

04'0

'% 9!54<'2,9!5<0442220 %9 42 '04

%0 A J24<204'04 !9,,'5 '&24 %' '!!&' 42'

002 ,24'00 %2 !0% ! '!080',-.'&% + 4 2',2!0%&04!'22 %0!80',-.'&%04'024

<'2!-22 22!04 ,'! '224 $ !58'%% !9,,'5 '!5',.','!

'! ,'! $ !5, !9,,'5 '&24 %' '!!&''! '!5',.','!*24

&, !04'9 8'!'5 2'8

-0$(, '9!54 %8'0%8!',48 @4 ! !%!0 <042& 4 &820'!

2*80',-.'&%0<20

!0% 20%('! 0% 0 A-,'!04'004

&2 0920429,,'5 !

% %0 ,,

0 '0!!04 '0!'% %(8!04<4 42!0!,( &!$ 9'$, $&02&!'

-0'$, '2< ,, '04

%0 A J24<204'0 !9,,'5 '&24 %' '!!&'4 2!

<%0404 !'8

04'080',-.'&% %, 04 %8'0%8!',48 08'!'5 20'0

$%04 %'% 9!54 +? @4 ! %22# A'8!'0!80',-.'&%$

'8 ,2 %'!

8% 2 %&0!H!5*04 '0<'2 8-, ,(&004 $'54 0%&044'

'%,( %5 7'00 %24' $

! '% 80',-.'&% !

04'0 !0% ,05'0!%84 %2 4' $

!-%- ,, '! 2-!2% $( -',!544 %&!

42'2-

022&20'!

'! 2&--%0 %804

<%00 !20'0 !0, !$ 4',80',-.'&%<4 4225!

$( 8%3!542!-',!54<44' !-< %'00%!

( !%8 80',-.'&%(!<*0204&2* !004'0-',!54*&!

-,'!02<'2 !0 20!504 -%A(,05'0!04%&5480',-.'&% '

; 80',-.'&%04'0'% 9!54<'2,9!5<044 %'! &2 0$

%9 $( 4 % !0 ! '!(-,'

! 04 %

0',2 04 @,, '0

+? >?:A; +

'04 %*<4 ! 8-'%'09 '!',(2204 2-

09 204

!02#-,'!02'! 04'004 !0 20!5 ! '!0*'-- ,,'!04 !* 28'

*0$

8 2D&0 '%04'004 <'2! 4'!

0 $ !04 4&2 ,,'!0# ! '!0'! 04 <'2!

'2!%4 02 %9 4 %$%04 %'% 9!544 %20'-- ,,'0 &%0<'2%540!

0&%!!5! !52!22& '5'!2004 ,,'!0'! !'9&%04

!02#-,'!02 +> '9!5 $

! 2&

!0,( %!

* 04 '-- ,,'!0# ! '!0 400!54'% *04 9', 0('! , 5',0(04 @,, '0 >?:A ;!

'9&%04 !02#-,'!024'2&%5 04'004 <'2!

'2!

<0404

0 2!4 %042% ',220 %'! 42% ',$%04 %',<!

!54!42@,,!-%

042 &2!2 04 !02#-,'!02 + 9 %('

020$ 0'3 !'! 20$ '--%

!04 8, &!

<4 400'3 2-,'

@04&0 8-, 0',2$ !5'9','$, *!! !52 !'!(22& '% -22$, 80',-.'&%<'24'--,(8'%% !9,,'5

'!5',.','!'! 4' 4'% ,(, 0<04'!( !!

0!<0404 2&0,'! % '% 9 !54

<4 <'2 2& %!5 %8 $%!

402 '! $ !5 $'

,%!

!0!&&22&--%0'! 20% !504<4 4<'2$ !5-%9

$(04 -,'!02'! 04 %'04 %<4< ' ,('9','$,

4 ! '!0#'-- ,,'!0 <'2 < ,,#2 00, ! 4 % , D& ,,(* 4 2!4 %0'!

$(04

24&, !0%'2 '!( ( #$%<28,'%,(* 2!4 %0'!

',<!

%!54*$%04 %04

$(48',2 !02-%!5'!(2&%-%2 $

'&2 !0!,(04'04 <'2< ,,#2 00, $&0<'2 ',2!04 3!<, 04'004 -,'!02'! 04 %'04 %< 2 %9!504

<04&,, 90!'! % 2-!2$,0(!24%0*8 ,($

'&2 @,, >?:A ;5!% 280',-.'&%'! $%04 %',<!

!54$(04

*04 2!04!5<%!5!0 '04 %*',<!

%!54 :

@>;4'22&--%0 '&2 -,'!02'! !004 ! '!0# '-- ,,'!0 =)

%804 00',0('

02'! &820'!

2'2 2 &22 '%, %* 04'2$

8 2&

!0,( !004'0@,, '0 >?:A ;!'9&% 04 -,'!02*% !024 !*2&,,(-%9 '! !'$2

! !50%', &%0!22& #*2&$200&0!! !5$(04 %20 '-- ,,'0 &%0*2&,,(9', '! , 5',0404 2&$20'!0',D& 20!2 ,'<'% 04&2

!'9&%04 !02#-,'!02 = D& ,,(*!5%&! 0!0 % <0404 !

&%% !0! !52$( &%02$ ,<28'

&022& 4*'%8!504 8-&5!

B& 58 !02 '!

204 0%','2',204 %20-- ,,'0 &%0*042'-- ',*$ !5

9 '!(8 %0*2 2822

0$ %'<!

L'5&00M @4

-%0 %2, ',-'- %28'($ ',,< 02

B& 58 !0C 2 + @4 %0$ %%

-%0 %2%!0C = @4 %04 B& 58 !024&, $ -%0 !04 5 20C 2