Makhan Singh v. Piara Singh And ORS.
RSA No: 19251995 (O&M) 1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
(102) RSA No: 19251995 (O&M)
Reserved on: 18.03.2026
Pronounced on:30.03.2026 Uploaded on: 02.04.2026
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VIRINDER AGGARWAL !" #$ %
' "$%
(
)"$%
(
"$%
( * + ,,,,, VIRINDER AGGARWAL, J -
.
(($ / "
--01-223 4
5 & (
6 & & & 6 / "
-+07-212 5
(
((&
Background Facts * 6 (($ $" " ( $
(
((
& (
/ 9(" (
RSA No: 19251995 (O&M) 2 - ((& ( "
:
&( #" & '* 7& $
%$
( ((; < ( ( " /
* =("
("(
( ( ((
(& > :
&
(" ""
(" ( " !
Uttam Singh (common ancestor) ↓ Ram Singh ↓ Piara Singh (defendant No.1) ↓ Avtar Singh (defendant No.8) ↓ Makhan Singh (plaintiff) ? ( ( $ &
(($
$ <
?
( ( $ (( "
& &
" '-$ ) $
"
&
(
$ ( $& :
&(
(( $ $
$ $
RSA No: 19251995 (O&M) 3
< /
" + @
&
$&( /
&
" & /
:
&$
$ % 9& "
# $ & ( &
"
"
(
(
&? " $ &
'- &( "
" $
(%( '* 7& %$( $
( &
(( (
:
&
( &
" & "
( / $"
% $ ( ( (($ " '-$ & " 9 5 ? ( / $ &
&
" 6
"
(
& (
/ (
(( (
$%
(
" ( $& %
"%
((
/ "
? $"(
& ( 3 ? ( ( $ 5
("
(& *+*-217!6
RSA No: 19251995 (O&M) 4
! ! "!
# #
$ %
!& '
$ (
)* (
$ "
5
("
(& 71-21=!6 + ! &
# #
$ 7 5 $
"
(
& "
%
$
& 6 ( ?
: '--$
5
/ 9 ("
( '-
) $ % 9&$
" ((%
"
A-B) A*4 & /
$"
($
(" 6 ( @
" $
RSA No: 19251995 (O&M) 5 #" C8 6-* 6-7 5 ( % "& (
& $
& % %
&
$&/66"(( <
! "#$%
+( 9
$-237$ " %
9& & $
= 5 : '*(
C8 6E 6*&
A3 "
6 8"
& " (
&
("
F A
( (%
( < $ % 6 ((; &
&
/ ("
&
& (%( ((
1 / "
5 $
(
# $ # 4
( ( 5
" & 4 $
# (
( (#
& % " 9 &$ % "
&
$ '-
RSA No: 19251995 (O&M) 6 "
%
-2=> "
"
/ 5 "
& 5
((
& (
$ &
/ :
%
%
"
*10=-2236
( ( / "
& ( ((;( %
'16& & % % "
C8 - * 9;
9 5 -217 % G H$ 4
( ( $ " (( 6
"
"
&
&
'
& () *++ , -&.
/
& (+ * + &0
&
/ &
&& 1 & )..!
+ ( % ((;" (
A3"
& (
? $ 4
(( & " && 2
" (
# $ 6 ((( @ "$
&
$(& & $ $ CONTENTIONS
RSA No: 19251995 (O&M) 7 -0 ( . ((%
/ "
--01-223 4
5 (( (" %
(&(
$ %
(9&$&
(
:
& 4
""
("
" & 6 ( (
5 & " & &
( (:
& "
(
" (
9
$-237$ % & ( % ((
(
+ ($ "
%(
% ((
"
%
$
$/ (" (
$ # (#
$
% 9&
( " %
9& &
% $" " %
& < $
$ $ % %
("
" ( % &
A*$ A> A3 % &
" (& $& "
($&
< (%
" ( 5
4I / "
9;
!
"&% $ ( 9& 4
RSA No: 19251995 (O&M) 8
" ""
(%
-2=>"
"
/ 5 "
& 5
$& G
"H 6 (
9&& " ( % -- ( (
( (
4
/
& ((
" $
$ " ) ( &
%
( % $
'1 ( ( &
" ((&
$
%
&
( ( (
--5 5 "
C
(
" & / &
12* 3*!4& ++5 % 9; 5 - % 1.. 6
4..,3* )+5 < !
"
(( ( '
/ (
:
& "
<
C8 6- C8 6*& % (
(
A3 " ( "
6 8"
RSA No: 19251995 (O&M) 9
&
" (
&
("
"
("
%
( <
< (
& "
C8 - *@ 9&$ &
%
( 6
$ 5 -*
$ ( . %
/ "
4
--01-223
"
( (
& (
(
:
& $ # (
( ( #
$ % "
% " # (# 9&@
"$
& '- .
" ( %
&
$&
$&
"
$
(
( " ((
" ( &
/
(& ((;( $ % '1$
&
% "
C8 - * $
RSA No: 19251995 (O&M) 10
&
&
9;
9 5 -217 %
( ( / "
C8J- C8J-+%
( 4
% (
?
( $ ( $ 6
"
(
:
& "
&
C8 6- C8 6* &
( %
(
" 8 (
$&
%
& 4
%
$ %
$ " ( $ &
(
OBSERVATIONS AND FINDINGS -> :% ( " /
& $ %
$ (
&
( 8"
" &
" / "
(( (" (" / (
(
5 -+ (
$ &
(& / 9 $
+-( / 5
$-2-1
-005 5
" / "
5 ( 676 &
* & 89 &6 & ,:5
+ $(& / "
RSA No: 19251995 (O&M) 11
(/& ;&;&
*89*6 & , :5 ! & & & 897 & ,:5:::
;: && ( / "
$ < (& < ("
0. &..;1 2 -3 %
< ! (
" &%6K6% 9&$ %
< ((
"
&
" (
)
/ 9(" $($&
((
'-
) %
**01-210*--0-210 C8 6-E C8 6*(%( '* 7 %
( (( $
5
("
(
( '- (
!
&
("
""
@
" " F
" ( A- B)$" ( ( " (( A* 4 & /
$ (F
#" (
% C8 6-* C8 6-7$& (
RSA No: 19251995 (O&M) 12
/ "
& ((
6 8" ( ( 5
( ( ( $ " %
"
% $ %
" $6 (
-7
6 "
8
( " # (
(
( #
$ &
(
& D)
(
&
& :
$& $ & 6 (& "$ (
9&$" &
( % &
%
" (
<
$% $ (" %
(" $ ""
:
$ ; %
(
"
(%
A*
I/ $ A> & A3
" (
& (
"%
(& $
"
%
$("
"
(
$ "
(: "
(
($ ( ""
(:
< &
" "
F " % "
((
$
RSA No: 19251995 (O&M) 13 "
-=?
" < (($
% 9 &$ " (
% ((
(
+( 9
$-237
+
8 %
$
(9&$
" &$ (
%(
% ((
("
%
4 I ( 5 " % 5 (C
-2=75# 5%-2> $ 6-237$ "
%
9& "
(
/ (" "
% F
( ($ (
$ & "
<
$ ) ; & (
(
(
(
-1 5 (
(
& <
((;%
6 < ( ( 4
$ & $ ""
(&
" 8
" "
( "
(" (
$ (6 %
$
"
( ( % &
% (( "&
RSA No: 19251995 (O&M) 14 ( $ ( 4I
" $ (
5 ;( 4
%
(
%
; ! & -2
4
" & "
/ 5 "
& 5
"
"
$-2=>
/
'-*(-2=>"
(
G "H:
$ &
(
9& " "
"
"
"( "F
(
" (($ ?
( %
"
( %
< $
( (
" % 9&@ &$ (( $
$ ((
)
&
-2=> "
"
$ "
" $ 6 ((& ( ( " $
4
"
"
1/ & 0;
RSA No: 19251995 (O&M) 15 *0@ 9&$ ) (/ 9(" "
&
% (" (
("
&
"
$ ( ( (
$ & (
" ( 8
(
" ( <
(
(
$ %
( 6
% %
<
'* 7 ( $
C8 6-E C8 6* / &
"
(
"
" &
: %
A3"
& " (
& $ & "$
"L
?
A*E A>
'
$
(&
& & % *- 5
&
(
&
((;% (
9& 4
$% & "
"
"
(
&
($ 8"
(
"
:
( ( / "$
RSA No: 19251995 (O&M) 16
""
"
% / "
9
$ &% 5 ; (
(
* &; &3 &. & *
;.; ** < ( &
(( $" " ( ( /
/
% ( ( $%
'1$ % "
:
( 9&
<
$
$ " ) &
%
( $
("
((;
C
(
" $ ( ( "
(
&
&
"
"
*> :
( & ( % !
●5% '*>-(-21- ( (M
$& & "
? = -05
RSA No: 19251995 (O&M) 17 (
( / "
●5% '*>> ( -21- (
& D
(
$& &" $& <
" & (
" (" /
"
( (( "& "
% (
&
( ( (
-- 5"
(
6 ( /
--5 56"
"
$ "
"
$(
"
$"
(
6
( (
<
" ) &
6
& % ( 6(
/ &
12* 3*!4& ++5 $&
% 9; - 1.. 6
4..3* )+5
(( " & ( ( %
$
(
/ "
RSA No: 19251995 (O&M) 18 *+. 4
( % (&
((
"
( " (
&
/ L G H&
( ; ($ &
"
% 9& %
'
() *++ -&.
/
(+ * + "
$ "$
5 ; ( /
$ (
" (
$ ((; "((
( *3 ( ( / "
5 &
(
( %
( 4
$ & ( $"
(&
% "$ "
( / $ (
8" < (
" / "
4
( $(( (" (" *7:% &( ( $ allowed
/ "
--01-223 4
5
/ "
-+07-212
5
RSA No: 19251995 (O&M) 19 *=
"
$ $( $ ( 30.03.2026 (VIRINDER AGGARWAL) JUDGE , -
.
/ 0 ,
- &/ 0