← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/1117/1997disposed of

(O&M) State Of Punjab v. Bhupinder Pal Singh & ORS

2019-02-28Mr. Justice A.B. Chaudhari9 pages



   



 

 !!

"#  $ %&'(&&( 

       

 

  

 )%  *+)  ,,,-+       

   ! "#

 ,, ."$ /0 "1 $    

             %&'''('))(

%&*+,-

*+,,'))'

 # -./

#'1).23#34    #5   6'6.'))'  7

   

   7      "       #   1666689# (*-6689# 7/

#0  5# 6*6(')1, +  

    7 #5  * $        #     :;+       6)61')1-'  ',  # ;#  <1666689 # #   #   $ #

 # .# 0    '16)')1-  7

  '6)    "! #0    #  # =/5   " 

# 1*6    # 

5&5 +     # ,+.-6689 ;>9'?   + $ #5 " 

   # #      #



# #  * 6$ ,$7 8# $ $ 9 $7 *'2 + : @ "

   #   "  7  7 ;  # 

 +   

# 7

#  7# 

  "  # #" 

7A"  # # 6$ ,$7 0#;!1/    

  $"  

 

9 B''   # 7#   #  "   #   #    

              $ " 7 # 

  #   

"7 ## " # # # 

C  

      " # " 

#

 #2   4



"    ##     

   35 3  C       #      # "  

 7     " #    C  7  

  # /

5#     "  #0   

   #   ";   #    7   "  '*$ # #  "        7'),,

   #

 " 

    #          #       # #   

 $7   # #

  7'),, #

; 72'..+4  +6)' 7')(-

     7   :# #  "   7 

7

5"  "

C

& A C  "                #  

#

#  .   #       

A#

*1')(.$ ##  #      ''.*D #"#          '66D#     

  $ # #0      # ##   #

;  7 "

C

  7   #7'),,#   

                    

  #  $7   "           #   

 #  7# $ 7

  "7     "    #0   7  #

       ;# 

 7 ;     C  #    #    #

5:5 '66D  ''.*D"#            "        7  @  > ##   # 

  7 # " 0 #7#    #0     7 

7# 

# # # #7  



        5   7          

$   #  

 75   7;0     7 

#



7

 

" 

7     '+C  "  

   





# # #"/

5  

 ##  ## #  

 "   "C # #     #     # "     " 7        " #    7   #  $           #  E .    #  #         5    

  #5   

  " #  #            #    

 # '1#$  # '1    >9- 

      

#7"  #  @ " ##  #  "  #

   

  7     # " # #"  

 

*

"  ,$7    

#  8#  

 , 

   ;6</ 

;7

""

/+ =;$#$ $/$7 $ "

/  $"*'

:4 $"  

 

9 B'6 $  #      " #     

   

 $

# #  7" # #   # ##    #  #0   #  # #         #  7       7    "     # " ##

 #    "       "  

   

  " 7  "#  # 

# 7 0    "

 #  # #  #  #  # #  #  =/5 C



#      " #

#    #

###  

7F#  

         # #     #    # 7    

   

       # # # "7   " > 

   #              C

A   9   #       #   

     ##   # #  7#  #  # 

 #0  /

     #

 7  " #         # "

" 

# "  

7 # G 

''$   "# ## C#   #    " # 

# # 

9

9 2'4>=/5  "    

"

" 

 # #   " #  ,6D  " 

 #0   2*4>" 

    "

=/5   #  #

7

   

        #           " # .6D

 " 

#0   2+4>" 

   #   -#

#

 =/5 #    '6D  " " #  7 H - 5 # # #7  7   6'6.')1(      " #; *-D" 

 #0   

7  7

#      # #  $#   

# 7#  7

 7



   " # #"   #   

" ## " #

# " 7    # #7" #

 

 7##" 

 $#  #     # 

55 , $A"  # ## 6$ ,$7

0#;!1 ;5  #*, 

> " 8#  #>9* 3',;!

?

;

&( 

  

      #  #    7 #  #   #0  "   

9 H>  

#  ;   #   7 #

+24#  

 #   7 # 99

 #0       "

7        #    

    7 "  $ #0  #0  

## "

 

   

      

      #0   

"

; #0  

  ##"7  $    #      #    /

#C #  

7     #    

     #  

#

 # " 

3  9 " 3  7$

  #   

"  

             "   

      #  "  ###   75#   " 

 #  

 7#

        #   7     #         7#0     #7#

  7   5#    #  



5'5



 7 ##   #0  3

3 7 



              

   

# " /

5# "    "   

 7 

"     7;:;# " :

   @#    A"   5

  

  A" %I#5

@

## #  # "   



E (   7  5        

#   "   :"  " # 7    # 



  "7# " #

  

7 #   " " *-D C  ;#

7 7  7

"  # "       # #

7 7 # 

 " #

 # 1 ##  # 

5  A#? &24 "!

 $!

     #

A#?

&24& 7   

 #   

# ### #    #

55

"

   

 #   " # )  #  A# ?

&24 *-6+*6') 0,,-+1



 &'/&(    >  8  =8& >  =8&