← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaITA/113/2000dismissed

Madan Lal Baasi v. Commissioner Of Income Tax

2020-02-13Mr. Justice Ajay Tewari,Mr. Justice Avneesh Jhingan11 pages

     

!" #"$%&%'( 

  



    

  

         () * + , ) * +-+  ...

  !"   #$% & '(  

  $ )   * &  % &   %  *        ...

,/  0 1 +     ,  *     

,    * 

 *- &,(

& * &!"

+ ./ // ++01"

2 0 5631"

7 7 3331"

5 7 3331" * ,   8   && 9: 9#:   ,*      

 

8  ;9:

9*:

9: 9$:  ,  

8   &, &!"

 

        

       



  

     



 

 

!

"

 ! #  % !

  %  &'  

    

()*'''+,

  

!

-  . 

 



 



       

  !

      

    



()*'''+,

  

!

-  . 

 %   %

 #

  0  #

 



/ /  

! 

/  !



   

     

()*'''+,

 

!

 

  

 

  

"

 



/

 

  

!

 

 

   

    

()*'''+,

 

!

-  . 

  



/

 0 "

 

 

   

    

()+1&231,

 

!

 . 

 



 



       

  !

      

     

, 4  %   ! 5 



, +'

0#

 



 

    

()411111,

 

!

    



 



 



       

  !

     6 

    

()411111,

 

 

 



 



       

  !

     " 

    

()*+211,

1   

     +)*)&+ , 21 7

# 

 



 



       

  !

    8 &                ./ // ++01"   

0 5631"            <

*)&    7 3331"           * 1  &   

  7 3331"&    * *  ,    &             8  , &   =  *      

./ // ++01"&   

& !"

1)   

!   



 

  

)

% 

   ) #

 

!

!  

 

   

! )

 

5

!

  

  

         



      





/  



  

 / 9):)3

7

0 /

 

; )

% 

 



) <)() 

 







 ) 1) =     8  

  



 

 

  

"



   



 ;  )





> &    

7/

0 /

 ()31 

 

    

*

:)'

 ? 

)

$

 >

!   

 



0 /







/

 

 ;

  

/

@  



  /  

 9 )) 7   

  

 

  

9 )3) 4 > 6



 /  

!

9 )1

  0 /

  >

  /  ) 27    



 

 

  9 )'

  

 

()'1

 

/

  

()31  9 )3 2) >



7

0 /

>

/

 @ A



  

()*



  

()'1 



 

9)2* +1) A



  ()31





  9 )+4) 4A

 

9 )+2

 (

 

< :)&14 

/

 

"

 ()'2111,

&))&+  >

   !  

 



" ) 2= 

 

 B )0  0



 9 )++ +*) +D   



 

 !

 

= ) &&+ 9 )+3 E)

  0)0)C



C   &&'

)) 

"

  



)) 1) %"



  

 

 

 0)0)C



 5     







 

)

     

 



/    

 0)0FC

;)

=   0)0)C

     /   8)

  

  

  

!

  

  

! 

)

$

 



 

0)0)C

 

   9 )* 



  

  

)3

  ! 

 0)0)C



/ "

   

  

5  8) 1)4    ;  

 



 

!

 !

 ()4+

"

 

A

   !



 ()'1     !

 !  ()31 

 

 

   

  

    

 



 

     



>

  ()31   !

 ?

!







   )

% 



/



()31  

/

   

 

   

  ) =  

 !  "







()'1

  #$%

  #$%   





()31    

  )



  

 / 

  /



  / 

 ! ! 

  %

)

% 

! ; ) 1)2

 "

   !



   

 /

       0)0)C



! 

 

  

!

> / ! !  "



 /  

()*'''+,

   . )8    0 5631"         

& !"

)   

!     



 

 



)

% E) #   

  

  

/ !

 6

!

 

 

  >  

 

  )

D!





  



 ) % >  



5

6    

 6 

 



)

$



    /

  

 /

 

  /

 ! )

  



!

7

766

 ()21111, 

>

    !



  , 4  !



   )

 / 

/ 

  

!

>     

()21111,  

 

/ 

  /

" .  

   

 



" )





 

/ 

   

/



()*'**+,

 

 

"

 

!

>)

% ) 

  

  /



 ! 





!

/  

()+1&231,

>

  . )8 =  *        7 3331"       &   

& !"

$

 0

>





 / 

         

"  ()'*11, >

     ?  /

      

" )

% #$%



   "

 ! 

 /

    

" ()4 ")





  ; 



" 

  

   

  /

>   

/ 

 





 "  5 )

  



  0  7    

 %









  /

/    

)

/  /! 

 / "

 >  

 / 

"



/ )

 /    

/

 

/ 

%



"



)

 /  

>

 

   )8 .

=*  7 3331"* *

 &   

& !"

) <

  

  )

 



   





"

/ (6

   





 





 )

/   /

 "



    



 



 

 )

    /

()4  

  

!      /  



5





 !

;

)

    

"

 

  

 

;

 

  /

 ) ) $

 /  

()4

 

!

   

)8

     

      8               & ,(

 *- ,  ,                *         

  

  , ,  &   * ,     ,     " *    $ (    ;8   & 

 ( ,   8  

&          



 +2     ,    *

 

     ( 

        ,   

-+ 

  "607 08 /

6  $ = # *1   > 1; =, !

> 1;