High Court of Punjab and HaryanaITA/134/2000allowed

M/S Gita Forging Pvt. Ltd. v. Commissioner Of Incoem Tax

2020-02-05Mr. Justice Ajay Tewari,Mr. Justice Avneesh Jhingan6 pages

!""#$%& ''(( ) +, $(- .'

! " !#! $%&%'(

$)* +((,)-./0,(% $(1%,22%)),'(

$,3%&14,(01-!%'+$!(,'.+'56'&%),'.

&$+.1+,&7+'.%$!,'.16-6'+$!(,'.+'56'&%) $(1% $%/%'6% /001232! 3 8(1+&099'$.%$- 6$,22%,)&:%,$+'5&

,'.

,'.<

,$%:%+'5.+&2&%. ,&&+9+),$ +&&6%+&+'/)/%.$(1%&,*% 0'/%'+%'0%- ,0(& $9

1,/%:%%'(,*%'))7+'5&6:&(,'(+,)=6%&(+'& ),71,/%:%%'

0),+9%.

>?+@ "1%(1%$+'(1% ,0(&,'.0+$069&(,'0%& (1%0,&%-(1% $.%$&''%A6$%B,'.B ,$%)%5,))8&6&(,+',:)%C ?++@ "1%(1%$+'(1% ,0(&,'.0+$069&(,'0%& (1%0,&%-'

0$$%0(+'(%$2$%(,(+' !%0(+'D (1%'09%,A 0( $.%(%$9+'5(1%:*2$ +(-(1%,22%)),'(1,.(1%

2(+'(,.2((1%.%2$%0+,(+'$,(%&2$%&0$+:%.+'(1% '09% ,A 6)%&- <E +' 2$% %$%'0% ( (1% $,(%& 2$%&0$+:%. +' !01%.6)% F# (1% 92,'+%& 0(- <DEC ?+++@ "1%(1%$+'(1% ,0(&,'.0+$069&(,'0%& (1%0,&%-(1% .%2$%0+,(+' $26$2&%& !%0(+'D (1%'09% ,A0(1,.(:%7$*%.6(,&2%$!01%.6)%# 92,'+%&0($,&2%$(1%'09%,A6)%&-,'. '09%,A0(CG 1%$%)%/,'( ,0(&,$%(1,((1%,&&%&&%% +)%.$%(6$' $(1% ,&&%&&9%'(8%,$<< B<&17+'5'+)+'09%1%0,&%7,&(,*%'62 $ &0$6(+'81%,&&%&&9%'(6'.%$!%0(+'D (1%'09%,A0(-<E ?

$&1$(-(1%<E0(@7,& $,9%.' <<,(,'+'09%

- HB1%.%2$%0+,(+'7,&,))7%.:6(')8,&2%$(1%2$/+&+'&

(1% 92,'+%& 0(- <DE ?

$ &1$(- (1% <DE 0(@ 1% 22%)),(% 6(1$+(8/+.%$.%$.,(%.

<< ,))7%.(1%,22%,),'.$%9,'.%.(1% 9,((%$:,0*((1%&&%&&+'5

+0%$($%B0926(%(1%+'09%:8,))7+'5 .%2$%0+,(+' $(1%7$+((%'.7'/,)6%9%(1.,'.,)&:82$/+.+'5 .%2$%0+,(+'2%$(,+'+'5((1%%,$)+%$8%,$&1%$%/%'6%2$% %$$%.,',22%,) :% $%(1%$+:6',)-(1%&,9%7,&,))7%.'E

(7,&1%).(1,( (1%+&&6%(1,(.%2$%0+,(+'+&(:%2$/+.%.,&2%$(1%2$/+&+'& <DE0(+&0'0)6.%.+' ,/6$ (1%$%/%'6%-(1%$.%$ (1%22%)),(% 6(1$+(87,&&%(,&+.%-1%'0%(1%2$%&%'(,22%,) 1%+&&6% +',',$$7092,&&+&71%(1%$71+)%0926(+'5 +'09%6'.%$!%0(+'D (1%<E0(-(1%.%2$%0+,(+'+& (:% ,))7%.')8,&(1%2$/+&+'& (1%<DE0(,'.'(,&2%$(1%'09%

,A6)%&-<E ?

$&1$(-(1%6)%&@ %,$'%.06'&%) $(1%,22%)),'(,$56%.(1,((1%9,((%$+& 0/%$%. +' ,/6$ (1% ,&&%&&%% :8 , .%0+&+' (1+& 6$( +'

+,)14((((#$%& #

'(1%, $%&,+.36.59%'(-(1+&6$( ))7+'5(1%.%0+&+'

(1%!62$%9%6$(+' '(( &)* #

. .+&B,5$%%.7+(1(1%/+%7(,*%':84%$,),+516$(+'*) + 7-'#$%& #

8#9% ,'. ,.18,$,.%&1 +516$(+'*)/.(("((& #::5%

.8:

#$%1).+'5(1,(.%2$%0+,(+'06).'(:%0,)06),(%.,&2%$(1%2$/+&+'& (1%6)%& ' '(( &; #'% (1%2%A6$(.%,)( 7+(1(1% ))7+'5=6%&(+'

>,' ,' 71+)%,&&%&&+'5 , 092,'8 $+'09%B(,A 6'.%$&D (1%0(=6%&(+'(1%0$$%0('%&& I ,H02$%2,$%.:8(1%,&&%&&%%B092,'8,'.0%$(+ +%.:8 (1% &(,(6($8 ,6.+($& (1% 092,'8 ,& 1,/+'5 :%%'

2$%2,$%.+',00$.,'0%7+(1(1%$%=6+$%9%'(& ,$(&,'.

!01#((1%92,'+%&0(CG 1%!62$%9%6$(0'&+.%$%.!%0(+'D (1%<E0(- %A,9+'%. (1%:3%0(& +'($.60+'5 (1% &,+. 2$/+&+'-0'&+.%$%. (1% :6.5%(&2%%01,'.1%).,&6'.%$ >D7% +'. +( .+

+06)( ( ,0%2( (1% ,$569%'( (1% %/%'6%(1,(+(+&&(+))2%'((1%($%B&0$6(+'+&%(1+& ,006'(,'.&,(+& 81+9&%) (1,((1%&%,006'(&1,/%:%%'

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

(1,(-7%.'((1+'* (1,((1%&,+.&6:B&%0(+'%927%$&(1%,6(1$+(86'.%$(1% 0((2$:%+'((1%,006'(&,00%2(%.:8(1%,6(1$+(+%& 6'.%$ (1% 92,'+%& 0( (1% &(,(6(% 9,'.,(%& (1,( +'09%2$%2,$%.+',00$.,'0%7+(1(1%92,'+%&0(&1,)) :%.%%9%.

+( &16). :% (1,( +'09% 71+01 +& ,00%2(,:)% ( (1% ,6(1$+(+%&6'.%$(1%92,'+%&0(1%$%0,''(:%(7 +'09%&'% $(1%26$2&% 92,'+%&0(,'.,'(1%$

$(1%26$2&% +'09%B(,A:(19,+'(,+'%.6'.%$(1% &,9%0( (1%)%5+&),(6$%+'(%'.%.(1%($%,&&%&&(1% 092,'8&+'09%-(1%'+(76).1,/%&(,(%.+'&D(1,( >+'09% (1%092,'8,&,00%2(%.:8(1%'(1% ,:&%'0% (1%&,9%,'.'(1%),'56,5% &D-+(7+))

D 1,/%(1%).(1,(/+%7(,*%':8(1%$+:6',)+&0$$%0(,'. (1%+516$(1,&%$$%.+'$%/%$&+'5(1%&,+./+%7 $+:6',) 1%$% $%-7%,$% (1%2+'+'-(1%71+)%0926(+'5 (1%+'09%6'.%$&D1,&')8(1%27%$ %A,9+'+'5 71%(1%$(1%:*& ,006'(,$%0%$(+ +%.:8(1%,6(1$+(+%& 6'.%$ (1% 92,'+%& 0( ,& 1,/+'5 :%%' 2$2%$)8 9,+'(,+'%.+',00$.,'0%7+(1(1%92,'+%&0(1% (1%$%, (%$1,&(1%)+9+(%.27%$ 9,*+'5+'0$%,&%&,'.

$%.60(+'&,&2$/+.%. $+'(1%A2),',(+'((1%&,+.

&%0(+'26(+(.+

%$%'()8-(1%.%&'(1,/%(1% 36$+&.+0(+'(5:%1+'.(1%'%(2$ +(&17'+'(1%I ,H0 %A0%2(((1%%A(%'(2$/+.%.+'(1%A2),',(+'(&DG 1% !62$%9% 6$( +' ( ( + * & ) +<, #

71+)%.%,)+'57+(1(1% =6%&(+'

>"1%(1%$ +' $%&2%0( , 092,'8 0'&+&(%'()8 01,$5+'5 .%2$%0+,(+'+'+(&:*& ,006'(,((1%$,(%&2$%&0$+:%.+'(1%'09%B(,A 6)%&-(1%'09%B(,A

+0%$1,&36$+&.+0(+'6'.%$&%0(+'D '09%B(,A 0(- <E- ( $%7$* '%( 2$ +(& :8 &6:&(+(6(+'5 (1% $,(%& 2$%&0$+:%.+'!01%.6)%F#((1%92,'+%&0(-<DECG,))7%.(1% ,22%,) (1%,&&%&&%%,'.&%(,&+.%(1%/+%7(,*%':84%$,),+516$( %,$'%.06'&%) $(1%$%/%'6%7,&'(,:)%(.+&26(%(1% ,:/%.+&06&&%.)%5,)2&+(+'-17%/%$-2),0%.$%)+,'0%',.%0+&+'

(1+&6$(+'J;

DBB *++ +,

&-) 7=(1"&+ .%0+.%.'

,'.,$56%.

(1,(+(1,&:%%'1%).(1,((1%&&%&&+'5

+0%$+&%'(+()%.(,.36&((1%2$ +(

E 71%$%1% +'.&(1,((1%2$ +(+&'(.%(%$9+'%.,&2%$!01%.6)%#((1% <DE0( 1%$%)+,'0%'(1%, $%&,+.36.59%'(+& '1%)2((1% $%/%'6%1%36.59%'( (1%!62$%9%6$(+''(( & ; #'%7,& 6'.(:%'(,22)+0,:)%+'(1% ,0(& (1,(0,&%1%+&&6% $%),(%.(2$ +(,'.)&&'(:%+'5.%(%$9+'%.+',00$.,'0%7+(1,$( ,'.,$( !01%.6)%#((1%<DE0(7,&(1%:'% 0'(%'(+'

71%$%,&+'(1%2$%&%'(0,&%-(1%0'($/%$&8+&,&(71%(1%$.%2$%0+,(+' 0,':%0),+9%.,&2%$(1%6)%&$1,&(:%$%&($+0(%.,&2%$!01%.6)%#( (1%<DE0( '/+%7 (1%.%0+&+' (1+&6$(+'14((((#$% &;#'% (1%=6%&(+'+&,'&7%$%.+' ,/6$ (1%,&&%&&%%1% 9,((%$+&$%9,'.%.:,0*((1%&&%&&+'5

+0%$(0926(%(1%+'09% 6'.%$!%0(+'D (1%<E0(+',00$.,'0%7+(1),7 1%2,$(+%&(1$651(1%+$06'&%),$%.+$%0(%.(,22%,$:% $% (1%&&%&&+'5

+0%$'D

1%,22%,)&,$%.+&2&%. ,00$.+'5)8 #/001232!% #3>04.% 3?!03?!0 %:$6,$8 D-

9* "1%(1%$&2%,*+'5H$%,&'%.

%&H "1%(1%$$%2$(,:)%

%&H