Smt. Mohinder Kaur v. Commissioner Of Income Tax

  

  
 

  

    !! " # 
$%# &

 

'  

  !
 "
  !
#!
 $%&%'( 

$)* +((,)-./0,(% $(1%,22%)),'(

$,3%&14,(01-!%'+$!(,'.+'56'&%),'.

&$+.1+,&7+'.%$!,'.16-6'+$!(,'.+'56'&%) $ (1%$%&2'.%'(&  ())*+*
,%+ 8(1+&099'$.%$-(7,22%,)&:%,$+'5
& ;,'. 

,$%:%+'5.+&2&%. ,&&+9+),$+&&6%+&+'/)/%.1%,22%,)& ,$%  $  (1%  ,&&%&&9%'(  8%,$&   ;

<

 ,'.  

<    $  (1%  &,*%  

0'/%'+%'0%- ,0(& $9


1,/%:%%'(,*%'))7+'5 &6:&(,'(+,)=6%&(+'& ),71,/%:%%'0),+9%.

>?+@ "1%(1%$+'(1% ,0(&,'.0+$069&(,'0%& (1%0,&%-(1% $.%$&  ''%A6$%&  <-  <  ,'.  <  ,$%  )%5,))8

  &6&(,+',:)%B ?++@ "1%(1%$+'(1% ,0(&,'.0+$069&(,'0%& (1%0,&%-(1% ,..+(+' & -C -D EF<0,':%)%5,))8&6&(,+'%.-:,&%.

' $%3%0(+'  :*&   ,006'(  :6( (1%$%:%+'5 ' .+&0$%2,'08  +'  (1%  .069%'(&  2$.60%.  :% $%  (1% &&%&&+'56(1$+(8,'.(1%&,9%1,/+'5:%%',00%2(%. ,&0$$%0(B ?+++@ "1%(1%$+'(1% ,0(&,'.0+$069&(,'0%& (1%0,&%-(1% $%&2'.%'(&7%$%)%5,))836&(+ +%.+'9,*+'5(1%,..+(+'

 & -C -D EF<',006'( +'09% $9&,)%

 )+=6$'9%$%2$%&692(+'&,'.&6$9+&%&7+(16( (1%$%  :%+'5  ,'8  +'.%2%'.%'(  %/+.%'0%  '  $%0$.  ( 0$$:$,(%(1%&,9%B ?+/@ "1%(1%$+'(1% ,0(&,'.0+$069&(,'0%& (1%0,&%-(1% ,..+(+' & - C-D EF<+&)%5,))8&6&(,+'%.+'/+%7

(1%.%0+&+' (1%)%,$'%.$+:6',)+'(1%0,&%& F& '+)469,$5$,,'.92,'8$%2$(%.+'
 CDGF1,'.+F ,'.+'(1%0,&% !96((5$,H $%2$(%.+'
CDCF1,'.+F BI 1% ,0(&'%0%&&,$8 $,.36.+0,(+',$%(1,((1%$%(6$' $(1% ,&&%&&9%'(8%,$

< 7,& +)%..%0),$+'5+'09% 
- -;;

F<1% 0,&%7,&(,*%'62 $&0$6(+'8,'.(1%&&%&&+'5

+0%$0'&+.%$+'5(1,(' &,)%$%5+&(%$-&(0*$%5+&(%$-&,)%/601%$&7%$%9,+'(,+'%.,'.(1%$%7,&' :$%,*,5%0),+9%.:8(1%,&&%&&%%-$%3%0(%.(1%:*& ,006'(:%+'5'( /%$+ +,:)%,'.9,.%,..+(+'/+.%$.%$.,(%. 

 1%.+&26(%+'(1%2$%&%'(,22%,)+&7+(1$%5,$.(J%&(+9,(%.

  2$ +('(1%&,)% 
'.+,' ,.%$%+5' +=6$?

$&1$(-
 @1% ,&&%&&%%1,.9,.%&,)%&((1%(6'% 
- -DC-C F<,'.0),+9%.)&&%& 1%&&%&&+'5

+0%$0'&+.%$%.(1% ,0((1,((1%,&&%&&%%7,&+')+=6$ :6&+'%&&&+'0%)'5,'.(1%$%,$%'$%,&'&5+/%' $(1%)&&+'06$$%.,'.

(1%$%, (%$9,.%,..+(+' 1%22%)),(%6(1$+(8.+&9+&&%.(1%,22%,)'

 

 1%,22%,):% $%(1%$+:6',)9%((1%&,9% ,(%' CG

-1%'0%(1% 2$%&%'(,22%,) %,$'%.06'&%) $(1%,22%)),'(,$56%.(1,(,0%$(+ +0,(% $9 (1%A0+&%6(1$+(+%&7+(1$%5,$. (&,)%,'. 26$01,&% )+=6$7,& 2$.60%.:% $%(1%&&%&&+'5

+0%$,'.(1%$%7,&'00,&+'(.6:( (1%&,9%,'.(%&(+9,(%2$ +( J'&,)% 
  1%0'(%'(+'$,+&%.),0*&9%$+(1%0%$(+ +0,(%2$.60%.7,& 7+(1$%5,$.()+ (+'5 =6(, 
 ,'.(1%&,)%(1%$% 
(7,&')87+(1 $%5,$.(=6,'(+(,(+/% +56$%,'.'( (1%&,)% +56$%1%&&%&&+'5 

+0%$1,.,00%2(%.(1%&,)% +56$%&17':8(1%,&&%&&%%:6(+'(1% ,:&%'0% ,'8$%)+,:)%%/+.%'0%,'.(1%:*& ,006'(:%+'5'(7$(1 $%)+,'0%-$%3%0(%.(1%)&&%&0),+9%.'&,)% 
 '&+.%$+'5(1% /,$+6&,&2%0(&-J2$ +(7,&%&(+9,(%.'(1%&,)% +56$%&17':8(1% ,&&%&&%%
'(1%,:&%'0% ,'8&%$+6&01,))%'5%((1%$%3%0(+' :*&  ,006'(-(1%%&(+9,(+' 2$ +(+&'(6'$%,&',:)%$,$:+($,$81%$% 7,&'%+(1%$,'8&,)%$%5+&(%$9,+'(,+'%.'$(1%$%7%$%&,)%:+))&1% ,6(1$+(+%&1,.,22$%0+,(%.(1% ,0(6,),&2%0(,'.%/+.%'0%:% $%(1%9 +'(%$ %$%'0%+&0,))%. $+'(1%%&(+9,(%.2$ +( J'&,)% 
 

G =6%&(+' ),79601)%&&&6:&(,'(+,)=6%&(+' ),7,$+&%& 1%,22%,)&,$%.+&9+&&%. -())*+*
,.

-+/)0'
.

+1,)+1,)

;

9* "1%(1%$&2%,*+'5F$%,&'%.

%&F "1%(1%$$%2$(,:)%

%&F