← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2012/1995dismissed

(O&M) Smt. Kaushalya v. Jai Singh

2018-03-20Mr. Justice Arun Monga10 pages





          !

 " !#$   #%

%&%%% !# #''() * + &,%-./0 %%%11// 2 . &3 %%% 14 %

%&%%% ! 5#''() * + &,%-./0)44 .36% + %%%11// 2 .  7 %%% 14  !"#$%&' ()%)(*$



%%&%4"48"

 11//911/%

% ."& 48:

%,"48"

  14911/% ;;;;; )(*$+&       ,  //  41    :  3./  &4 11/9 3% !# 4 ! 5#''(% &% !#  3. 444 $%<%#'$' 4 48/&.%(#$#'$=/4 >&32 .&,%-./0?)  //4>&.%#?+4

&% ! 5#''( 3.7.43,44 148/ &.  %=$(    #'$=  /4    > 7  2 .  -./0  ) 



4>&.% ?+%.: 4 490 /.

4 11//49 6: 11//.

9044:  /4,4847.43,44 44=%5%#''(%



14@1/&3.4&.%# /,3 11  ,3 ,//44 (%#%#'$= 1 /4,.

3#AB/#=, /.//4,.

355B/'

, / 4  '"(!!C@3 1 ,0 '"!!!C@%://341./4:448

1/%4 D.4 3 /44: D4#(%A%#'$=41/4/:09 404://3 1  ,3 ,//"9. D.3 , //"44,/./.4 .4 D.,% &.% :.490 14@1/ 7

/,311  ,3 ,//44 (%#%#'$=

1/4,.

3#AB/#(, /.//4,.

3 55B/', / 4  '"(!!C@3 1  ,0'"!!!C@%4 D.4 3 /44 :D4 (%A%#'$=41/4/:09 404://3 1  ,3 ,//"9. D.3 , //"44,/./.4 .4 D.,% 9"11//@4411 44/4 :

,44.90403D. 3 ,//%":4&,% :):44 4 1 490-./0+44303 ,//4 3 ,//: 3449 44.,",./:. 4 %&,% :  :   // " ,1/ 4  4114 /40%&49. 3 ,1 /0#'$#%, ,

,

: 6/"//34:": 39.

4,/0,,9

44:,/490B3.4.483" , , 1 4 . ,"::./83/4 44":383   1" "  1.

133/4/4. 1 4 0  ("!!!C@"

1144 .,9,1  11 "9. #!C# 40 &B " 39  ,4, ,, . 4D./3.4"94 .,9,1  ,11 4:/4 ,1/ ,/ /":./4914("!!!C@%44,B:9. 3 ,///34/0D.490 8.

&3

39 4 7% / 04/4. 7.  : 1 1%8444907,94  1.

1 33 ,//":: 48 4 D1/4 %&8 44//1 1 0%  ,48 ,:   8 490/3

1/4 /.

"91/431 "

 ,4//:3.9. @ >   

  

  

        

      

       

 

      !"##     

 $

%   

   !"## &      

      '   

  !"#(      

      

)   

    %!"#(     

         !"#(

-

* '

 '$ +#+!"#( ,     )  

%     !"#( ) -  ,   .%  '

     

    !"#(  '     



 ' '    '

/

'$0  

  % 2 .

'.0  



+

34 !"#( 

    9    ."    1/  D,4    //:3 : @ &.%# &.%

E@# , ,: 6/

E@# , ,: 6/

E@ &./&3 ,&3

E@ &./&3 ,&3

E@5 270-.,  .34:

3 4 3 

D1 

E@5 270-.,  .34:

3 4 3 

D1 

E@= &31/

E@=  39 &3 ,   1/  /  4 4    84  //:3 4., @ &.%# &.% D% # 3 ,44 (%#%$= D% # 3 ,44 (%#%$= D%

,94 0 #'<'@$!

D%

,94 0 #'$=@$( D% E5C D% E5C=  1  3

44:

3D1 % D% E5C#  1     3 

  4 4:

3D1 % D% E5C(D% E5C< 38 D% E5C    D% E5C=  3 1 / 3,.,9,1 % D% E5C(D% E5C< 38       4"  44 D,4  &   ,"   -1 E@#"&., &3/ B& &%%.148E@ "

,  B/ B&  %6%4848E@54 / 11 4E@=%44/4 484//:3 4., @



&.%# &.% D%# 101/8/&.%##A #'$=% D%# 101/8/&.%##A #'$=% D% 101/8/&.%##( #'$=% D% 101/8/&.%##( #'$=% D%5 10:

,8/ &.%##A#'$=% D%5 10:

,8/ &.%##A#'$=% D%=  10    1/0    7. 11/% D%=  10    1/0    7. 11/% D%( 1048&,% :% D%( 1048&,% :% D%A 10:

,8/ &.%##(#'$=% D%A 10:

,8/ &.%##(#'$=% D%<  10    1/0    7. 11/% D%<  10    1/0    7. 11/% D%$ 1048&,% :% D%$ 1048&,% :% D%FC# 10,.%=!=% D%FC# 10,.%='=% D%FC 10 44#(%A%$= 8/&.%##(#'$=% D%FC 10 44 %$%$= 8/&.%##A#'$=% D%FC5 10 44#A%$%$=% D%FC5 10 44#(%A%$= 8/&.%##(#'$= D%FC( 10 44 %$%$=% D%FC= 10 44#A%$%$=%  /.

"984"4 4. 411//49 6: 11//.

/,: ,%

%%&%4"/ 4./ 11 39/ 11//@449.9,4&34 7 : ./41:)*7+% .4491/04.1 &,% :% : , / 4, :"1 ./ /0, , E@#9.%.

 9/:  8  ,,4  //3/0    /43      D.     3 ,//91 84": &,% :":  /4":1 /0"41144 ./40" "."

  9.

4    1     D.    3 ,  :  8/0  .1   1/":0/44 3% E@#, ,4 E@ &./ &381 84D.3 ,//4&.9

.

4 "4E  "::4141 "49 4.4"."48  :/9/94 :% :.

 .9,4:: /./ 1/434:, ,"&,% :4 /8//41//3 .4" ",9 ::  /9/%.

3140."&,% :  44" "./4D, /%&/4 48

 4%&/,4,9 .

 ,:./4 9  44"9../494%.:,9/ 1 1 8   ./ 8/

4.

4" "  / . 1 ,7." /11  ,: ,4%3 4&#A)#+)+&1 /:  :3%        4"    3 4     A  ./  =   

3 43 3 049 "891 84/% 9".

9/:./484 4/ 8."9.

4  0 /.4 & !&1 /%.11      "  /4  .1    7.43,  4 4  90    G9/ &.1 ,.

& /0& 0 12 

34//4

(0 6/ 786 +,, 595 2//:  4 :  0339/B11 491 74" 9 :./4899: 8/

1% :   0/4 4139/1 1/:./49/  1.

14 3 4" /4.1 444.//4. & 854/0  #0 7; 5 4/)

/5

# 8$2 /+  595 2//,-+ <0/0

=//05<4//>  1 /  =/  /05<  

 20/+ )  .:  6  2  ?:? 

:

4.//1 ./ .4./.4 .449 84".:/9/94,4%       4" 

% .  "  / 4  &  ./ 490

%," 1 3 14@1/.9,4  39 &3411 49/ 7 E@=: &.94 %:/9. 7&344// B:/43D.: 3 43 ,// 1 /4498%11//@44/41 8 3 4     A  ./  =   "   "    4:

3  D1    .9,4    1             .,9  ,1      3 ,//: &,% :":4381,.,9 ,1 ":: B4.

3.

1 43%//"

 :, .4"0./484 ,/1 43%-./0 3 4@4.3 @@/:&,% :4" @D,"4,4  : 44"   4 D.4   E//    .4 413,4"

 "1/. 3 ,1 /0: .3%//" :. 3 ,,4",4/  4: H. 499 .3

 4"1 ./ /0 % 4:  ,:, ,:B% :.

 .9,4,  4, , : 43:&,% :4 14,%11//@44   9  1 ,4    B    1/    4  4  ://3"   "   3 ,//4944%.11 " /4.1 7.43, 4 490.

 &  5 04/$80;5

@6

20/+  595 ,

$0

4/(80

+ ,

595 - :090.

4" ",."  490 /.

"./4894144".". 34 .

 4,/11/%

?

8 4/ 4./ 1 "11 4 11 9B"  4.

9/:48:   4, .9,

%44  9.,0 @ + -./0":11 4:9D"4,4 &,% ::44:.4413,44 4D.4E// 8.

% 0B :

  ,    //0  11        :   .

44.

3 @D,"' 5 '6 31 8411//@449 3

 4844  ,4/  4"  

. 9/      :  . 3   ,  1 /0  4"

 ":,1114 .,9,1 I +  1 D% E5C#4:

3D1 ",/0"

270-.,  .391 84": 3 //0 4.,9,1 38.

8@@8 3 ,//: &,% :I 4+ 3 ,// 4 : .,9 , B411 89.490.347.,% :"%%", ,4&./&3"414/4  @D,"89 4%  "

4441 841/901.3 1H. @D,&31/% :.334 .31H.:,0 .

0: 38%:4,.: 384,:.4% @D,"



:  4    ,  , .4    0      8/   &,% :I + 11//@4491 ,4B 1/    4  4  ://3  9.    44   D.      3 ,    //%     ,4 9 8,4 84 , 444.//4 .7.43,4.1 I + 4,4/0"   7  :  &.94       ,0  4

39 &3: 044/B:/434     &3  4  D.4    3 ,    //  : &,% : 1.

3/44 9498" "

 444.//4. & 854/0  #0 7; 5"/

// +90B341 8 5 ./# *      :./4    9  11/9/%    :./4  8  9 11/9/444B1/ 44 ://3":"4498"91 ,4 9B8:4/3 ,//I 3+  41. 444.//4. 7.43,.1 "9., 0  .44, 1 491/04.1&,% :"

3  1 84      /43     ,/  1 43%

 10:  40: 9 44: 43.4 &#$  %9,0 1 "   D,  4.," 8/@4   .          3 4     :"  ./3   /3%   0" 14@1/49



.494/31.

.3, " ".: /4#<%$%#'$= 349 : #(%A%#'$=%       ,0    '"!!!C@    /  9 84%:83 //04  3 ,:  '"(!!C@% .1,09843",8: 7.43,44 .

9/:4// 0  "

,./0.9/H./:  , ,4  1

84%3 .4   ,4.%

.//0"11/ 4,4% .

3.

 3"

%4  : ,  .@H.84 44#%##%#'''" "

,../49144/: : ., 11/"9.//41,.4:.  4  4 :0%   14@1/     3 4  :  ,  ,   419//4 %  020+?

  )(*$

6/0 &'=>% *020/85 A/

 B/A

*020 2< B/A