High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/853/2003disposed of

Nahar Singh v. State Of Haryana And ORS.

2024-09-03Mr. Justice Aman Chaudhary6 pages

#$%&'(#&)*+*',- . /. 0 1$2$34*,52 ...&%*%*',&3 6&3+7+ 4%$%&'(8$39$,$$,: %2&3+ ...;&+<',:&,%+ => ?@=A B = " ! CCCCC 3&+&,%-

3.;.D. $E*FG43.H:I')$%&J*%2

3.4$K3$% $E*FGH:I')$%&('3%2&<&%*%*',&3.

3.#7+29$,%4$2$3$,GHHLG8$39$,$. CCCCC

= " !M A . N2& <&%*%*',&3 *+ $553*&I&: O9 %2& $)%*', J2&3&O9 2*+ :$%& '( 3&*,+%$%&K&,% 2$+ ,'% O&&, )',+*:&3&: (3'K %2$% '( :*+K*++$EG *% O&*,5G . .// $E',5J*%2 :&,*$E '( )',+&P7&,%*$E O&,&(*%+. Q73%2&3 <3$9&3 2$+ O&&, K$:& ('3 P7$+2*,5 %2& '3:&3 :$%&: .. G &,:'3+&: ', .. G J2&3&O9 3&)'I&39 2$+O&&,'3:&3&:. . N2& ($)%7$E K$%3*R $+ &K&35&+ *+ %2$% %2& <&%*%*',&3G J'3F*,5 $+ H++*+%$,%

47ON3&$+739G J$+ *,*%*$EE9 :*+K*++&: ', . .// :7& %' 2*+ )',I*)%*',. S<', 2$I*,5 O&&, $)P7*%%&: I*:& T7:5K&,% :$%&:

0. .//UG J$+ 2'J&I&3 3&*,+%$%&: J*%2 *KK&:*$%& &((&)% I*:& '3:&3 :$%&: V..//UW..//UG E$%&3 3&I*+&: %' O& (3'K . .//UG J2*)2 J$+ +7O+&P7&,%E9 )2$,5&: %' O& J.&.( ..//UG O9 %2& *K<75,&: '3:&3 :$%&: .. W .. G 2&,)& 3&)'I&39 '( &R)&++ +$E$39 J$+ '3:&3&: %' O& &((&)%&: *, *,+%$EEK&,%+. N2*+ '73% I*:& *,%&3*K '3:&3:$%&: . . G+%$9&:%2&+$K&. . 1'%$OE9G %2& <&%*%*',&3G I*:& '3:&3 :$%&: U. . VG 2$+ +*,)& O&&, <3'K'%&: %' %2& <'+% '( 4&)%*',

((*)&3

&$3E*&3 4&,*'3 H7:*%'3 J.&.(. . ./VG 2'J&I&3G ',E9 ', %&K<'3$39 O$+*+G <&,:*,5 '7%)'K& '( %2& 3&I*+*', <&%*%*', $,:

! " # $

% &

### '(# #')))* + *,##- # (# . + % * / 0 1# 1# + 2 ,2 0 * 3# 4* 4* , 5! * % ! % *2 6 7&-- &89, 80948,:&:9 98: 1#

' ;2 !*

* 2* ! * * *

! /6

% % !

;2 ! !*

< * 2 ! %

! *

' ;2 !

! " * *

+ * ;2 !

%2 !

* 2* ! * ! #

* ;2 !

%2 ! !! 6 2 !

# 2 !

1##

( %

! #

! "

" !

" "

" # $

% $! ! " &

" !"

! "

$ $ " ' !

% $! ! "( ))) ))) ))) *+*,-* - .+/-% ,-.,-0

1 / -23 / ,,.-%*&

/ / ,,.-%* / 2//,*4 / .,54&

/ .+/-% .,4,-4 - +-.,/ 2 32 / 6.-%1 //,6,-46,.,4,-4 - 7(( 2 ! " % $!

! " 8 $ $ $

" ! ! & 8

8 " " 8

" 8

8 7(

! 8

9 "&

( 2 9 !

$ "

! 8

; " ! !

" 9 (< ( 2 !"

= >?@ABC== D@EFBG== D@GC?H= = I@J?K== LGEM== NOM== I?GPB== Q?K= = R== S= T ;

! " :

$ 2 & UVW7&

$ !

" 8 ) & ! !

" &

) !

! " $

U U*W

!" # $%

! !!!

" &" '"

!& !

(( !

)!"&# *+,+ !

& (( !

-&# *+

!& !

(( * !

-&# *++, !

& (( !

# *++( ' !

! !

! !!!

! '" !

! ! !

& !

(( !

-&# *+ ! !

(( * !

-&# *++, & !

0&# *+,( 1 ! !

!& !

& !

# &! !

! ! ! !

" & & &

( 1 !#

!& ' !

# !

" !

& ! & & &

( 1 " 2 0 ' / ' -"!

3 !

4' !

(5 6( 1 -"!

3 7 89:;<77 =>?@A77 BCD77 =E;EF77 GH77 8;IJ;?;7 K7 !

! ! !

&# !

# ,# # 0!

% 4!

L & !

( M!! ! !

N ,( ,(O PQPRO !" # $%

N ,( !

N ' # !

# N ,( !

N !

( 1 N S !" ' !

N ,( !

N # ! !"# !

S ' # & !

!"# !

!" " !

* *N0/ *(

## ## $ ! %#! # & '

( )

+( % , -./012,, 3456/, , 7.8,, 3919:,, ;<,, =12>151, ?

# " # @

A B # * '#

#(*

# C A #(D* "

# *

@#(

* EF''A

# $ ! * " #

'' ! " ' #A

(

#! * "# @ H

I # "

# !'# @@ J

#@ @

'' # A ! @ @ A '# ! H #A

'#AK !' # A L# ( #

A !

'# #!

#!'# K ( L # , 3194./,, MNO12,, P;:Q,, 7.8,, 3919:,, ;<,, =12>151,, 15R, , 15;9/:2, , S, * " TF U VT !* # 'A!

# #! #

#( ' '#

' #

#* A ( @ # H

@ *

@#(

* E ("

$@ ( V#( W *

## ?

#@A H

' #

'A "

'# #!

' '# " L #'

'# ! #

' # ###

# ! X YXYYY

XUXX U

# # #

' # '

# XY? V? ? X VL Y X XVL X U TF X* ? X VT U? X* X X

$ %&''% &())))

+ ") !& %!! ! ) % (', )) %, !) &! !! ") & ' !) %!! -) !! ' " .'

/ ''% '(' ) " &,

' (%)!, ')() "

'%&%!( '), &%") ) ))

) 0 ) )') ! !

'1%! ) % ) )&!, !"

#$%&, ) & 3454627849:84;<=2 >9:?@2 ABCADCEAEF2 / /"G) H IGJ ! H IGJ