M/S Gopal Mills v. The Commissioner Of Income Tax

  

 
 

  

 

     
!"#  $ 

   
!
   
" 
 #$%$&'



#() *''+(,-./+'$ #'0$+11$((+&'

#23&+( 0+#4+, $&*# '+&-*&53&%$( #'0$ #$.$&3$  %&&'()(
") 0$+%%$%%$$*%*&+11$+(3&-$# $/'*&  '0$
&/4$ +7/',869 #%0#', '0$/'

:+5+*&%''0$#-$#-+'$- ;

1+%%$- <='0$
&/4$+711$((+'$#*<3&+(,0+&-*5+#09 #%0#', '0$#*<3&+( :

+((>*&5'0$+11$+( '0$#$.$&3$((>*&5%3<%'+&'*+(?3$%'*&% (+> 0+.$<$$&/(+*4$-*&'0$+11$+(

@9+:

!0$'0$#*&'0$ +/'%+&-/*#/34%'+&/$% '0$/+%$ #-$#%&&$73#$%A+&-AB+#$($5+((=%3%'+*&+<($C 9<:

!0$'0$#*&'0$ +/'%+&-/*#/34%'+&/$% '0$/+%$,'0$
&/4$+711$((+'$#*<3&+(>+%#*50'*&%3%'+*&*&5 '0$#$D$/'*& '0$<)% +//3&'% '0$+%%$%%$$A +11$((+&','0$%+4$<$*&5<+%$-&4$#$1#$%341'*&%

 +&-  /&D$/'3#$%  >0*/0  /+&&'  #4  '0$  <+%*%  # +-D3-*/+'*&C 9/:

!0$'0$#*&'0$ +/'%+&-/*#/34%'+&/$% '0$/+%$,'0$ +--*'*& %E, , FGA&+//3&' #+'$*% ($5+((=  %3%'+*&+<($  *&  +%  43/0  +%  '0$  +43&' %3##$&-$#$->+%&+//3&' '0$$7/$%%%'/)>0*/0 %'-/#$-*'$-*&'0$'#+-*&5+//3&'+&-'03%>+%'<$ '+)$&*&'/&%*-$#+'*& #+##*.*&5+''0$5#%%1# *'

#+'$C 9-:

!0$'0$#*&'0$ +/'%+&-/*#/34%'+&/$% '0$/+%$,'0$
&/4$+711$((+'$#*<3&+(>+%#*50'*&%3%'+*&*&5 '0$#$D$/'*& '0$<)% +//3&'>0$&'0$#$>+%& -*%/#$1+&/=*&'0$<)% +//3&'%3<%$?3$&'''0$ %$+#/0+&-%$*H3#$1$#+'*&%C 9$:

!0$'0$#*&'0$ +/'%+&-/*#/34%'+&/$% '0$/+%$,'0$ - 
  >+%  #*50'  *&  %3%'+*&*&5  '0$  +--*'*&  

%E, , FGA<3'&'*&/(3-*&5'0$+43&'%3##$&-$#$- *&'0$'#+-*&5+//3&' #/+(/3(+'*& (%%+&-1# *'

#+'$CI 0$+11$+(>+%+-4*''$-&(=>*'0#$5+#-'?3$%'*&9/: 0$ +/'%&$/$%%+#= #+-D3-*/+'*& '0$1#$%$&'+11$+(+#$ '0+''0$+%%$%%4$&'=$+#*&.(.$-*%88 A80$+%%$%%$$ *($-#$'3#& -$/(+#*&5  *&/4$  
, B,E66GA  %$+#/0  >+%  /&-3/'$-  &  <3%*&$%% 1#$4*%$%&F8F8,$7/$%%%'/)>#'0


GA>+% 3&-+&-*'

>+%&'$-'0+'.+#*3%<)% +//3&'>$#$&'>#*''$&31'-+'$0$ +%%$%%$$ +*($-'$71(+*&'0$%3#/$ *&.$%'4$&'<3' #+D$%0234+#

B 1+#'&$#%3##$&-$#$-+%34 


GA 0$%%$%%*&5

*/$#>0*($

#+4*&5  +%%$%%4$&'  /&%*-$#$-  .+#*3%  +%1$/'%  *&/(3-*&5  '0+'  0*50 /&%341'*& $($/'#*/*'= #1$#?3*&'+(1#-3/'*&+&-'0$ +/''0+' +'$>#)$-3'' J+%/41+#$-'  8J #'0$+%%$%%4$&'=$+# 8FFAF8, J #'0$+%%$%%4$&'=$+#8F8A8 +&-BJ #'0$+%%$%%4$&'

=$+#88A8 +&-#$D$/'$-'0$<)% +//3&'0$*&/4$>+%+%%$%%$- +11(=*&5#+'$ J+%%0>&*&'0$1#$.*3%=$+#0$+%%$%%4$&'>+%

*&+(*%$-.*-$#-$#-+'$- B88B/+(/3(+'*&5'0$''+(+%%$%%+<($*&/4$ +% 
F,BB,F EGA0$44*%%*&$# 
&/4$+7911$+(%:9 #%0#',


 :+((>$-'0$+11$+(& 8688B+&--$($'$-+--*'*& 
E, , FGA 4+-$&'0$<+%*% $%'*4+'$-5#%%1# *' J0$#$.$&3$1#$ $##$-+& +11$+(<$ #$'0$#*<3&+(0$#*<3&+(%$'+%*-$'0$#-$# '0$
+&- +((>$-'0$+11$+(& ;

,0$&/$'0$1#$%$&'+11$+( $+#&$-/3&%$( #'0$+%%$%%$$+#53$-'0+'>0*($4+)*&5 +--*'*& 
E, , FGA&+//3&' #+'$,'0$+43&'%3##$&-$#$- >#'0


GA%03(-0+.$<$$&/&%*-$#$- #/+(/3(+'*&5'0$5#%% 1# *' 0$  /&'$&'*&  #+*%$-  *%  &'  >$((  3&-$-  0$  <)%  

+//3&' '0$+11$((+&'>$#$#$D$/'$-0$5#%%1# *'+%1$#'0$1#$.*3% =$+#>+%/&%*-$#$-<='0$%%$%%*&5

*/$#0$%+4$/+&&'<$%+*-' <$$7/$%%*.$#+#<*'#+#=0$#*<3&+(#*50'(=/+4$''0$/&/(3%*&'0+' %3##$&-$#$-  +43&'   


GA  >+%  &  +//3&'    3&A$71(+*&$- *&.$%'4$&'*&'0$%'/)
'#$1#$%$&'$-3&+//3&'$-'#+&%+/'*&+&--$% &'#$1#$%$&''0$1# *' 3&+//3&'$-'#+&%+/'*& 13#/0+%$+&-%+($ 0$#$>+%&/&.*&/*&5#$+%&13' #'0<='0$+%%$%%$$D3%'* =*&5'0$(> +'$

 0$#$*%+&'0$#+%1$/' '0$4+''$#0$%%$%%*&5

*/$# >0*($  *&+(*%*&5  '0$  +%%$%%4$&'  /&%*-$#$-  '0$  1# *'  +43&'*&5  '
B, 6,;

EGA+%/.$#$-3&-$#'0$%3###$&-$#$-+43&' 


GA+&- '0$#$+ '$#4+-$'0$+--*'*& 0$/&/(3%*&+##*.$-+'<='0$#*<3&+(*%1(+3%*<($+&-/+((%

#&*&'$# $#$&/$?3$%'*& (+>43/0($%%+%3<%'+&'*+(?3$%'*&

(+>+#*%$% 0$+11$+(*%-*%4*%%$- *%&&'()(
+ *),&-$
+ ).

&).

&



4) !0$'0$#%1$+)*&5G#$+%&$-

$%G !0$'0$##$1#'+<($

$%G