High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2027/1995allowed

Swaran Singh And Others v. Sardul Singh And Others

2026-01-30Mr. Justice Virinder Aggarwal11 pages

!

""## $ % %#

&&& " ''''

( $)

+

& ,) * +

""##&

& %"

-& . * +

/#

+

" & ''''

&

# &

%#

""#

01 2 % ""##4"# ## , &&

# # 6% ,

23 .

#

,

3& .

# * , 8&9& * " # %26% 7#* . . * % ""##4"# )

#

#& && ""##

,"% %

2 % 2#

, ##3 %2# %##3

%* ) ""

"

%

""## & &

/ #3 *

+

# * % +# % "#""##* 0

#

#

%#% # # % +## &

"# #

" +%

;

+ 3 *

2# & * <*

3

&=& =&

%

+

* # # * # #3 "%

## #% # #

#

+%

"#""## #, # % # *

" 3&

"##3 "# "%# #

* ?%#3* "#""## 2, #

# "3, ,3 & * < *

# % # & "#""## %

"# %#

@& * #

:

-% 6

@ 5

* #,

,#+ # #

%

#

)

# "

+

#

3 #%> ,& %* 3 2 > " 9&& A8 , @&& % *

#

%2 6% . . *

# # &

"##3 +

* , % %*

#

# 3 * 9&& A8 2 % %##3 2 & "#""##* 2

# *

,"#

* ?%#3*

2% &

%

"# :

-% 6

@ 5

"# #

%* # *

# % * ,#3 @&

,"# %&

,* "#""## 9&& A8 2 %#

+ * ## #* 2

&

"#

% ?%2#

"#""##* 2

# % # *

#

# "3, & * < *

# % # * #

3

#

3 ,3 % # &1 9&

@& *

"" %& "

,

# * 2# @& *

2# (% B% * @&

"+ "# * 3 ?% "

# + % +# % 9&& A8 * ?%#3* "#

+ ##

* # &

%

"#

# 2

,

2 #,

* 3 +*

# #%> ,& 25

2

#,

"##3

& # ) "# 2 " #3 +#%

"% " % & ##

, # + , , "#

##3 & 9&&

,

* " % +*

# =& C" ,"

+ %# %3 "#

##

+# + " * # # , ""

"

3##D , + 3 *

"% " 3, ##3 5% * ,

%

, & ;

"# "

# "% #, "#

((& &

;

"# #

# , "3, & <

3

,% #, E

((& 9&

;

, 9&& A8 " &@&&% &

A

%##3 2

"#&E

((& =&

;

# ,2#

(&

;

%# 6 @ 5

,& :

-%

+ 2, # "% #%> ,E

(& 8&

;

,E

((&

&

;

" #3 +#%

"% " %

((& & ;

"#

3 % #

((& A&

#&

/ "

%##

"" %3 # +

,

%& C" %#

# .

# !"#$"##%!

%& ""##4"#

""# 2 F ""## *

*

>,

%2, , #

# !"#$"##%! ""#&

+ %

% 2# ""## + +) ""## %

& 8& ""## + % ""# 2 * ##

%

,

# 2# C" 2

%

* ""#

,##3 ,

%#

%#3 %

" *

"" %

%# & ""#

3 %2, + # %#

" & 8&&

!

"!

#

$

%

%

!

&

%

'

() A&

" ""#*

# " #

(%52 G 3* ""#

""# %

= (%52 * A %

7(7&

, , %"

,

, ! "

# $

%

"& $& #3

#

# ,* ?% #

?% , & # %#

""## %2, # 2#

#%

&

% 2#

% , ""#2# # +& # #

%% %% " #, 2 & H, ,, #3 ,

,3 "

* 3 3 ,"% , & &

3* # %#

" * + ## #3

,3

# 2#

#3 #%

"

& # ?%

&=& =

+ 3 * 23 2,

,2# &=& =& 33

) , &=& =*

&=& A=&

# && A * 2

#, ,2#& H %#

# '! ( )*!&+

) (

,- ./ * 0# ( )* /1 ,

2 3 4 5 3 ""# , &

&

#

% %* #%

#+ +* "%& ,

>%

+ 3 *

&=& =& # ?%

,

#,

,, ,

,

,

,3 & &&

GI2# "> *

#

)* # ( 6 $ 5* # "& (

"

9 ,*

#+

"%*

!

*

"!

! ! & * GI2# "> *

#

#+ # "#* # "

"

@&

# ""

! $ " %

! & # ! ' 9& * %#) %

,

%"

*

%% %%

" ,

2 " * ?%

>%

> , + 3 & * ,

2,

,2# ,, #3 "%# ,*

, ,

+

,"* % #,

,, , #3 ,& 9&& 8 .

( " 3 #3

#+

#% ?%* +

(

)

"

!

+ ! ! * + ,! ! " - + ,!

"! + ,

.

=& 7#%

2 8 .

( " 3 #3

#+

& C

#%* > , ,%

%& ,* "3,

,3 / , ,% %### & :

, %%### * 2,

,2#& F

*

,3 2 ,*

& ,# #3*

# "3

,3

,*

%&

#3

2 ?%##3 # +#3& =&&

*

> , 2,

,2# 2 "%# *

% > , 2,

,2# ,, #3 "3,

,3& # 2 ,

,-

% > , # ,

%#

, ,

2

,& =&& %

" I %#

,

& &'(")*&+,-#

%"

* + 8

* B% ,

%"

* %""

" I "& (

"

,

/ 0 1 ! & 0 1 2 % 3

#

" ""#2# & #3*

# F ""## * 2,

,2# , &=& = #,

#

&=& A=* % &

" ,3

"

,& && ,3

"

* % %2*

""##

#" #%> ,& %,*

,2#* ""# ""## &../0%!& , # 2# > 3 # # ""##"# )

" %

2

#,* &

,, 3* ""##"# #

# " ,3*

## " &

" < +

" # ""##"# ,, #3 % "3,& 8& +

5% "# , ## "

,##% ""#* 3* " ,"#& @ %

?%

1 &+,&3 /,/) Whether reasoned / speaking?

Yes / No Whether reportable?

Yes / No