High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/746/2003allowed

Jai Pal & ANR. v. State Of Haryana

2019-07-04Mr Justice Rajiv Sharma,Mr. Justice Harinder Singh Sidhu10 pages

! "## !"

$ #% &

!' %%&& ! ( )! !* + %

#$%& '()*+#,-./0+ $1/234$#%$ '()*+#,-./0+$#/'5+#3/'643/54, , !

, ' ( ' +- " !-!' %%&& ! . /

%)# /'0 (-

#!# & " !. &- * +

$1/234$#%$7 1'# %% &## !#!(! / # !!'2( /3 ! !

! 4 -

5+&

#!# &)# $( /- 6 &-# )# 7-# 8'#"' ""( $ #% &

3 9 &8"' / 8#!'

!# !' "%( #' 5&(

)"!#

8#!' )"!# :, 1'+ 8 " #"! !'(

! " !(

/&##3%# 3 !

!% +# -; "'

(&!% +3 !# !(!'(

/#/(#3%# 3 !

#<3 !' 1'" !'%"(!# -# (!'&&-#!' !' 3 3 & / !'"3%& # !!!'"!!' ! 7 ! 5(!

, -8'#&'8 #!!# /# !'#'(#!( ! #&& /

&#- ""( 39 &

$ #% &# !'##&& /" 3!!' '('# , & &# = ( 1'+ > '# ! ""3% +!'3 " !"'# /#'3#? 3( , & &# = ( ""3% !'3 !! ># / 5 /

@(#%3 !!" !"'#' :

!' #/'!=

, & &# = ( !!( @(##83 3 $ #% & $ #% &!& !'8#= , & &# = (!' != (8 " !"'# / #'# ? 3( 3%& #

!A !' & > 5(!= (3 !' ""( 39 & *!& !' != ('

!( 3? 3( %# !!'3 ! 5(! , - 3' 6#'

# !!'##&& / " 3 ! !' '( !' "3%& #

!& !' ! = ( 8 &+# / ( " "#( # !' % / & / ! #&& / 6 3 &%( 1' "3%& #

!-'# & - $# 9 &

8# )3! , ' # "' !'%!

(

(&+# /( " "#(!' B!'8 "3# /(!'#3(!'

'8 3&&# /&#@( !!' !!#3!'

8 8 # / &+(

8 *#!(-'#!

5 /8&+# / ! 3 #!

" 1'+ 5(/'! = ( # ! "!!&&+ ! !' '( 1' !-'8 ! > !, * -:

#-8'!' "! '#3! . & *%#! &- 6 & = ( !' # ! / #/'! ; "" /!!'"3%& #

!- ""( $ #, &

3, & = (!" (3<"#&#@( !3#<# /3%# ( (5!

"# &#@( :!8 &! ! !' ! 5(!4 + %#!'! ""( 39 &'

&&& &&/ !# !' 5(!'#' # / 3&! '#5!' '(A (/'! 1'3 !!8 "3%3# 3 9 &8 5 # //( / / # !'#3 (!!'## "# ! 1' 5 +8 !%!3!3< 3# !# 1'"&!'!' 8 & ! > !%# =#" 8 & !"'3#" &< 3# !#

!#/ !# 8 "3%&!

"' && 8 %(!(% !"3%&!# && !'" &3 &#!# 1'%"(!# < 3# (358#!

# (%%! !'" 1'! !3 !!' ""( 8 &" (

)"!#

, 1'+ !'" !'%"(!# 1'8#!

8 < 3# " 1' ""( 8" #"!

! " - !#"

5 * "-!'% ! %% & 9 "( & %% # / 5' & !' %%&& ! '3 !&+ /( !' !!'%"(!# ' #& !%#!" 9

"( & %% # /!')! !'3 !&+ /( !' !!'%"(!# ' % #!" 5+

5& (5!

(%%! !'2( /3 !

!'& !# &(! 0' ' & "( &!'% !#

/ !'(/'

!'2( /3 !

" +" (&&+ ,0 >' .# ' '

("! !' %!3!3 < 3# !# !'5 + ( "" /!'#3-!'%5 5&

( !# 5!8 !'

%!3!38 8#!'# '( "" /! ,0 >' .# ' - !' " ( !' 8 * &/ !

*+ " 5 3%(

.(%# "!#"# %!'%!'3#" & C< 3# :

'#"< 3# !# -' !' !!'" /!# !' / !' 8 (!# "!#"# %# 1'#/# !' "!#"# 8 !% ! 5'#35+!'%&#" !!'!#3># / '#%# # / /" ( !' 1'&& &"'&3 !# 8

3#&&#/ 3%" ! ,07 6(& #%)# /'< 3# (-8' '8

3#!! . &*%#! &-6 & 1'% !# ! !

# !'. &*%#! &-6 & ,0' 3 !' ! 7 '# , & &# = (8 % !# !''( 39 &

$ #% &-# !'##&& /- " 3!'#'( ! 5(! , 1'+(33 '# ( " !"'# /#' "" /&+'# ""3% !'3 *8-# !'

#/'!= ( !!( !'#'( <! +-' !)3! , '8# '# (!!'!(58&& ""( $ #% &! @(# 5(!= ( ""( $ #% &!& '!' !''(5

(8 !#&&" !"'# /#'# !' ? 3( # !!' 3!#3-''

!'# & !!''( ""( 39 &! @(# 5(!'# ( ""( 39 &# 3

'#3!' != ('

!( !'#'(%#!!'3 ! 5(! , !' 3 +- 3'" 3!!'#'(

3 !' !'#

= (8 &+# /( " "#(# !'"33 % !' # !' #&& /6 3 &%( 1' !-'-'# &

)3! , '8 !!!'

B!'8 "3# /3'#3(!' 1'+!>'#3!!''%#! &# ! "!!&&+ *8 !. &*%#! &-6 & * !'

#/'!#!& ! 5(! 1'8 &&/ !# / # !'# ( !' !''

3&! !' (/'! '(-5!' ""( 39 & *8- % "' + !8 " !'#&& /

!'3 !!8 % !"' (% 5(!4 + %#!!'# "# ! *# 8 >#&& 5+!' ""( ""( ! 3#!+5+ 3# #!# /%# &#@(!'#3 :

'#"< 3# !# -' !' !'# (8 &## /% !&+ 3'#3!'& !4+ *# (8 # /# 3

2 " !!!'3'# & *# ( ""3%

!' ""( " !"'# /#'%#!!'# "# ! *# (( ! " !"'!' #' '# % & " (3%!# :

!' % "' + !- '(-

4 ""( 39 &

$!' 38% ! 1'% "' + !8 "

!3%& ! 5(!4 , ,0)3! , '##!'8# 8 )'

!' ! 7 -''(5

, & &# = (8 % !# !''( ! 5(! , -5!'!' ""( $ #% &

39 &" 3!!'# '( 1'+ (33 ' '(5

= ( " !"'# / #' 3 !' ? 3( # *'(5

!' ""3% !'3 !! ># /'#5 / ,0' 3 #' !'# & 8 :

!' #/'!''(5

!!( ! !''( <! +# 35 +# 3 ' !'# & 8!' !

""( $ #% &8 % ! !'#!(58&& * !'# & 8'

> ' !/!!'!(58&&$ #% &! @(# 5(!''(5

, & &# = ( )'8 !! ""( $ #% & ! 5(! *!& !' !' '(5

(8 !#&&" !"'# /#' 1' '" 35 ">!''( *8- ! 5(! , !' 3 +- 3'!'##&& / " 3!!'#'(

3 !' !''(5

8 &+# /# !'"33

% !'#&& /6 3 &%( 1' 3#&+3358 !!!'%! 1'+

!#" !' != (8 &+# /# !' *8 8 # / (

B!'8 "3# /(!3'#3(!' *8 !% ># /

8 ( " "#( *8 ! > !'%#! & 1'8 &&/ !# / # !' '(5

(!' !''

3&! !' (/'! '(-5!' ""( 39 & *'(5

8 >#&& 5+!' ""( (!!'# 3#!+ 5+ 3# #!# /%# &#@(!'#3 :

'"< 3# !# -'

!' !!' ""( ( !"3!'#'(

1'+'

##!# /!3 1'+83 # ! # /3 # /!# )' ! !!

!' % "' + ! ,0):)(5' ''

!' ! '

8 !!. &*%#! &-6 & *" !'! !3 !-C< ,.- ,0' 3 !'5 #8'#"'B:-C< ,.;-8 " 5 + 8 !%!3!3< 3# !# *" !'! !3 !!' & !8#!

,0 :

%"!.(&D )# /' !' !' # !/ !

""( 39 & *3 #"&(! !3 !!!'"!!' !

# !' 2, &# !' #&& /

&#- ? 3( -'

""( $ #% &8#!'!'#"33 ! !# 3#< (% "!#"# # !' &#@( = , & = , & ( ! "!#"# #"&(! !3 !#C< ,9 * &# !/ ! ""(

$ #% & *3 #"&(! !3 !-C< ,-!!'"!!' !' & / 8#!' ""( 39 &>%!" " & "!#"# # !' 2 , &#&& /

&# ? 3( #

"(& /!!' 3"

* " !' ! !3 ! 8#!

(

)"!# , 1' !-!'+8 !!!' #? 3( !'!' ""(

' # /" " & !'# "!#"# 5!!& "" /!'3#" &C< 3# %!-C< ,;-" ! ! <'#5#! -

/ %#!#!!' &/ ! '+ " 5

"3%(

/(%# "!#"#

!'+& &"'&!#3 !

3/% " !# <'#5#! ! !<'#5#! / %#!#!! &# &+ 1'" ( !' "" /!,0 >'.# ' 8 * &/ ! *+ 5 3%(

.(%# "!#"# %!'%!

'3#" &C< 3# ! 7

3#'

8 % (" 0

4 0 3''

!' !'> 8!'"3%& #

!' ""( * " 3!!''(,0, '#

,0 ' 3 !# 3 5(!!'# "# !# @(!# (- -8 &"'&#" * !> 8 +!'# / 5(!!'" 1'%&#"'

" '#! !3 !

0$!' 3 !' !'> 8= ( ,0 ' 3 = (8 &"'&#" # "# !# !'##&& /!>%& " / /3&!# /!' #" 39 & , "' + !8 "

!'#/

,"#&+!'%"(!# " #!' ! 7 = , & &# = (8 " && 5+ ""( 39 &

$ #% &" !"'# /#' *

!!( <! +)3! , '8#= ( @(# 5(!' '(5

(3 ""( $ #% &-8'!& !' !'8 !#&&" !"'# /#'

!'? 3( # )'" 35 ">!''( 1' !- 3'

3 !' != (8 &+# /( " "#(# !'"33 % !' #

!' #&& / 6 3 &%( 1' "3%& #

! % !+ !> '#3 ! !' '%#! &# ! "!!&&+ *8 !. &*%#! &-6 & *

1'8 &&/ !# / # != (!' !''

3&! !' (/'! '(-5!' ""( 39 & % "' + !8 " !'# / !'#&& /8'!'3 !!8 % !"' (% 5(!4 + %# !!'# "# ! = (8 >#&& 5+!' ""( ""( ! 3#!+5+

3# #!# /%# &#@(!'#3 7 "" /!,0' 3 - 7 ""( !> 8 + '# , & &# = (!" !"'#'3#? 3( ( !

!( !'#'( * !'# (/'!# & 8)3! , '!!'!(58&& ""( $ #% &! @(# 5(!= (-8'!& '!' !''(5

7 = (8 !#&&#'# /# ? 3( # !!' 3!#3-''

!'# & !!''( ""( 39 &! @(# 5(!'# ( ""( 39 &# 3 '#3!' != ('

!( !'#'(%#! !'3 )#3#& &+,0)3! , '# !' !''

/ ! !'!(58&&$ #% &! @(# 5(!''(5

, & &# = ( ""( $ #% &!& !' !''(5

(8 !#&&" !"'# /#'# # ? 3(

'" 35 ">!''( :!# !5&# 5&!' != , & &# = (8 " !"'# /#'!'(/'(!!' #/'! :!' "3# !'! !3 !,0' 3 !' !!'+ !

!+!! "= (# !' #/'!#!& 1'+ ! @(#3!' 3#&# !' ""( % 8'!'!'+'

!( ! ,0' 3 &

3#!! !' ! #!'' +5 +'

!' ""(

'# ( 8'#&! ># /!' # >!/!' * & 3#!! !' !'# ( ""3% !' ""( " !"'# /#'%#!!'# "# ! "" / !,0' 3

,0)3! , '#-8' !'# "# ! 5(!

3&! !# (/'! '( 8 ! > %& "- % "' + ! 8 " *8- " !'% "' + !8 % (" # " 1'%"(!# ' #& !%!'3!## !'#" 5 +' !' # ># /8#!'!' ""( 1' "

("! ,0 ' 3 "3%& #

!- !' !'

,0)3! , '#-8#!' -#( (( & "" / ! ,0 )3! , ' #- ' 8 ! ! ""( $ #% &

! 5(! *!& !' !''(5

(8 !#&& " !"'# /#' 1' '" 35 ">!''( :!# !5&# 5&!' !

8 " !"'# / #' (# / #/'! # " ' '

7 ! 5(! , %0 3''

-'> 8!'"3%& #

!' ""( * 8 !!!''(!'"3%& #

!% !+!# 3 5(!!'# "# !# @(!# ( 8 &"'&#" * !

> 8 +!'# / 5(!!'" 1'%&#"'

!" '#! !3 !

1'" !'%"(!# #!' ! 3''

!& ,0' 3 5(!= (&+# / !'"33 % / )#3#& &+- % 0 $!' 3- = ( 8

&"'&#" # "# !# !'##&& /!>%& "/ /3&!# / !' #" 39 & % "' + !8 " !'#/

:!' &"3# !'! !3 !,0' 3 !' !'#

= (8 # /% !&+3'#3!'& !4+ *8 # /# 3 2 " !!!'3'# & 4 "" /!!'B:-$ #% &'

&&& &&/ !# / # !

= ( / / 3#5' # / 8#!' !' (/'! '# 5!' '( *8-# !'! !3 !3 5+,0' 3

,0)3! , ' #-#!' "3 " !' != ('

3#5' 8#!'!' (/'! '(-5!' ""( 39 &

1'" !'%"(!# # &!' ! (/'! '(- 5!' ""( 39 &-8 3&! 5+ ( C '( 8 !"#! 8#!

!%!'# "!

1'" #5 "#"(3!

!# &# " 1'"' # # !

"3%&! 1'%&#"' !" +# "!#"# (5!

" 7 1' %"(!# ' #& ! % !' " / # ! !' %%&& !5+

5& (5! "" /&+-!' %% &# &&8

!'2( /3 ! !

! 4 ! # 1'

%%&& ! "@(#!! !'"' / 3 / # !!'3 1' %%&& ! 5 #& 1'#5 #&5

#"' / 2#)' 3 $( /

* #

)# /')# '( $( / 0'!'% ># /;

?; 0'!'%! 5& ?;