High Court of Punjab and HaryanaMRC/1/2021dismissed

State Of Haryana v. Sanjeev Kaushik

2024-01-30Mr. Justice Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia,Ms. Justice Lapita Banerji37 pages

!""# ! $% " &"&"&'% $%&" &%

! " ! #$%$&'&% # $($&&)$&'&%

*#+! " #$%$&'&% # $($&&)$&'&%

(! "

+! " "+ ,,,,, "&"&( )(*(+ (," - *+ #$%$&'&% " + . * # $($&&)$&'&% .

"" * *+ " " .

/*! 0 . %&1%2 ') &'&%! .

$"". * " " " )'& 3# 03 4 %25 %2 ') &'%6 " )'&! &'% 3# * " ! ( "

0 . - "" * " " " "

. * +" ! " " ! " " ! - # ! ! "++ ". +" + * + ! + *" )''3# -7" * . +!! "" * ! ." " &883# - " 9" *" &'%3# "! + " " " "++ " . + ." *+ 1 %2 ') &'&%! * " " "+ " +

"" +"++.

* +. " + !. "!+ *7 + & # !"" * ! *" " "+ " . "

"" ! * . * "! +" 7 + " " + " " + 3 ! "" * ! * " " "+ " "+ +

" . ! !. .. * !

" " +" !. * + !! * +* *" "+ " +7 +

3 * " * +

"! ++ * + 3" " "+ . . $.

! + ! "" * ! .+ + " .7"! * " " "+ "!"- # 3!"" * ! *" +* . ! " "+ " " "" .

)-( ./(+0(.1 ) - 03 :;7 < = * . + > +. "

4 25%!" &)$ * + ++ * = "! + ! *%5 . $ $ * #(( * " 0 0 4 ))&)! >"$#! 0 #

!0 . -"". * . *.

! ++ !"" + " ++ * * + . ! " +"+ * *"+ .

+ + *" """ ?

" ! + "+ + * * + + * -" * *+ ""* +* **+"

* " :-< "+ . + " " + - "".

""!. + * . " . + ?

" * + !"+ " " " !"! . + .

"" * .

" * " ! !+ *" . * "" @ -" . * " A )' ! ". ".

4 ! ":-<+ 3 *! 3 +. * * # B! # # . !. *!B"+ -03"" * *%8 %' 3 *+ ="

"?" !> !0 .! "!" . .

- ++ "" *

+ C%%!3 *! " "" +# ++ 4 ))&)!#>"! 0#

!0 ." " * "" *."" " - + . " "+ * . C " !. "

* " "

- 0B + +! "+ - *" """ ":;7 <

* "+ !" """ ".

* " (( - " + .

> +. " * 03 =" :;7 B<. + " " * + + + !" " % %5

-"+. *.

& '' . "+ ++

(3 -1

- - # + + " )5@:%<:.<# # * "+" "

+" %2 ') &'%6 " " "++ ". +" " "

* 7" "7" " )'' 3# - . * "

" 4 @ ! "" * +." ! !. " &'% 3#* "= +" * -- # ! ! "+ " " " " "+ " ++ *" " .

7 # &)(1( )

)( &(1 ( 53" &.(. - ()(1(3).1(, 67# # & 8! . + . " " "+ " "+

. * " " "

" """ . " " . " . 7" -

" + * " "+ "! " +. ! . "" " " ! $ D< "

$ E <." * " ="++ . E < && % &'%6 "

! . * .. " "" !"" -03 * "+. * .

""$. + " %A@ # # !

" ." + E < %'

) &'%6!" * #$))&)! % 0 ! 0 #

! 0 . "%& ) &'%6 $C5 * " :<$ 4 ! %A1%2 ) &'%6 "" " * E <##-* *%A ) &'%6 "" + *.%% &' + %2 ) &'%6!"+ +

" . % '' + %A1%2 ) &'%6 .%% '' + E <" " 4 +;7 - " %2 ) &'%6 . %% )' + ! " .

"" + +. 856&8&2@86! " C5$ ""* " " *$C5.

" E < %2 ) &'%6C5$ .

"" * 9 + *""E

<"" " %2 ) &'%6 .

$ .%% )'1@5 + E 7<.% '' + %2 ) &'%6 + * . *" *! . $ "

+ * . ""E 7<"" + ". . . # E 7< * * "" . 7 %A ) &'%6 &'

) &'%6E 7< ! ""

7 "+

7 " *. " %'A; " " F (.

9-( .13

" * " * 0 0 4 ))&)! >"$#! 0#

!0 .! + . " + ". %2 ') &'%6 . *" 3 + " ". + &''% + "! ! + . && '% &'') - " 7+ ( G+- C$%6 "+ + + "" " *+

- . 7"! ++ " "

+ " .

" && '5 &'%6 " %A%# # + !C$&6 ! * +." " . * * "+ . *! + " "

%2 ') &'%6 . %& )' ! "! . "+ ! " - """+ *+* - * ". "! 3 " $7+ ! ++ * + "* -! ++ ! ! C$5 + " * + * $+ 9 ! * *H

* " + ! "! * + - ""+ + ". *.

4 +! . + %'

') &'%6 ?

"" ! . *" * + ! * . "!" "@$5+ .

+ + C$%&!> +!"+ . "! * * ! + + "" "+ *. ".

"= !"* . *! 7 +. . "! * * 4 ))&)! ! >"$#! 0#

!0 . " +" * " *+ "" " . % )' " " " +

! + . " + * +.) )' .

%% + + C$%)! +! "! * +! "" + " * "+ + + "+ * **" " ++ * + +! * . = "4 "+ + " - !* "" + ! + + . + ." "+0 . 3+ " = " * %6 ') &'%6 :;7 /< .

* *?" !3 *! " + . " ! .

"+ " " * + - !" . - #

"+" "

43: .! %&

! * * "" " * *+ " " . *. $ $:. < -

" """" +++. *+ + !"." "" * * "" *. + + +++. ++ -". + + + !" " " * # * *03 * + * %)

03 4 %'' * &@ '% &'%6 :;7 G< " )@A 3# " * " ! " $2! 0 . * *

#(! ( > && '% &'%6 . 6 ''

* * + " +!." + ! ! + * . * * " ! *@% %5 %@ C$%2 3 + !3 * *?" 03! "+* *03 %6 '& &'%6 "" + * "" * . *+ 0 . -"++ :

$ <. B*

# !".

+ $ %

7 . ". ( * " * + " %A@# #! + " .

!/ 3#!0 . + !+ . " " %A@ # # ! " . * "

$>I# !" " :;7 <. %5

" " * " .

? "" " + * . " + . " " %A@# # . # - * * * . "" + *+ . H . " +4 @A'!" $2! ! " *" +

-". "! " +. +. %A

+ " " . / 3#%8 '& &'%6:;7 33<* " #%& + *+ H%2

. . . $ $ . " " " + $ $4! + .+ !" + * * + 9 ! . . $ $:4 <! ! * + ! + " .

+ / 3# %8 '& &'%6 :;7 >< *

" " = + . + * " - ! "

+ ! .

+ " && '% &'%6+ * * + * + 9 ! . * " :0< %2

* %8 '& &'%6 :;7 # ;7 ;< * = + . * "+ + " %A@# # > " * + *"

# ! " *. " " "+ + " .

* + !+ " . " * + + * * +.

*+ +

+ ! %8 '& &'%6:;7 0 ;7 < + " "+ .

* ! " !" " " - * 7+ C$&) "+ - "+ ." * " . .

= + ! C$5 ! "+ 1. "!C$%&> + C$%) +! " - "* " + *#$3;+ #(!( + + .

+ * 4 %6&$#! 4* +! 4 ( 0 . - + &% '& &'%6 + " " " $ $ + +J+! " && '% &'%6 +. $ $

+! + ! - > 0! + + + " ! " .

" %6 '& &'%6 -"++ . * " . /* . - ! * + * + 9! "+ *H %6 + + C$%&! > +! . " + + * * + + "

" + " " 4* +!( . ! ! *+

"" * ! + * ++ . * $ $ . * + + + - ! *H " " %'

') &'%6 * " " C$%)

+! "! " * + * 9 ! . ! . + "0 . * + %8 - "+ ! ! . * .

" " - """ . * " . .

+ ." 4

+! . 7+ ! . * "" "" -"+ * .4 856&8&2@86. * .

7+ * C$&5! . ** ! 4 ?" ! 3 ;7 ?" #+ " 0 + + ! * " 4 %6&#! 4* !( )+(3.3

/03.( 3( .):13 (..)3:.

- $ "" %2 ') &'%6 . " ! " + 4 +! " "" +. + " + = !* * + - "+ " " + *.*! " ".* +"+ * + - +. + + * **" * + * ! ! ! ".

" " !. " * + 9 +" " " ":-<+ * *

" "+" !+* . +

- " " ++ " " " " "" " + *+ . *" - / . +

* " + .

+ + " . + *+. 3 " $7+ * . %% %51%% )'

" " . %'$%5 * + . !. + -"+". * ".

"+ " " " " + +. ". &% C$%@! 3 4 + %2 ') &'%6 .%& 55 ! "" +4 + +. = 856&8&2@86 " + + * "++ " = " . . =. + " - * * " + . + * 4 @*4 &5'

-" . .

?/*! +3 " *!" 0#

!0 . -!"+"*+. ""

. 3"+ " +. +"4 +. 4"888'A66'88,. .

!" * " """ " && -4?" * !" ." ++ C$&5 -"+.=

+. 888'A66'88 . * + 4 + "" * . .

. * * " ;7 ! 3 #+ 0 +!"* " +.

4 %6&$#! 4* +! 4 (! " + . " " " " A5>3 ; " "!%62&: K; " "K< :;7 G< . * " - " :;7 G< +. 888'A66'88 + %5 ') &'%6 %8 ') &'%6 . " " . .

4?" + " * . * - " " :;7 L< . + " " " A5>; " " +. . *.

. * " ;7 M! " " " + %5 ') &'%6 &'

') &'%6 * * +.

+. 856&8&2@86! 6)2)8A%'55 856&6A&8') - . " " " )%%# # ! %& '& &'&%! " +

$" " *( G > !C$%%3 *!C$&A3/+

+ C$&5 - *" +. "" *"" " !

" * *

-- # " " * " ! + + ". K!. .

. - # * *" $ D@) ! " "* " C5 %2 ) &'%6 :""<"++ C5 +. * $ " . .

" * .

""C5 " + *"

# +!" $%&!0 . -"" 7 +. "+ C5

@@ *!C&5$4?" ! 3B "$7+ " +. 856&8&2@86 +"" %A ) &'%6 %2 ) &'%6 "" * C$&5 4 ?" ! %A ) &'%6 %2 )6 58! " ! *+. + . ?

%2 ) &'%6.%% )'

&8 ! ." . * 3(@'@%%)''@&%%%A * " G$A8! A%1%6! 0! 0 . %% 5% 5' " .+. +. " * 3( @'@%%)''&556)& * " 551%'! C$5A! 0#

!0 . -" * " +. "" * " " * *+"+ " *. 4 +

@5 ?

%2 ) &'%6 %% %) ! ." . "+ * 3(@'@%%)''@&%%%2 " G$A8! 0! 0 .! %& &) +. "+ * 3(@'@%%)''@&%%%A + 3( * " +. %% )'

&8 C

*! C%@$ 34 + !.%& 55 %2 ) &'%6! " + * + " "# + + +. +. ! ""+ " ! C5 " """ + ."" 0 #

! 0 . * 3( @'@%%)''@&%%%A "" * ! " +. "".%% )' + %2 ) &'%6* .

C&5$4?" !""

!0 .! "+ . "* + . .

" " " +". " " - "" %2 ) &'%6 " * +. + " + " . ##- " * .

" *+ " . " + 3 " * .

C5 * *+ *"" 7+ *+ * +. +.

"" . - " " " .. + +

" &) - " " + """ " . !- # ##-*!" %A ') &'%6&% &2 %@ ! "+ *" * $.* .* *+ * " * + + "+ * . * %% %A &'1&% %2 ') &'%6 -*. +#( :;7 -1%< " . .

+! ##- ;

* ! " " 7+ C$%A! .

* " " " $8 0 . * " "+ 0 #

##- * "+ ! " 4 ))&)!>"$#! 0#

!0 . #( * 3+ B. #(! " %8 ') &'%6!" .

3 * *?" .

H ++ !"" * ! " ":;7 -< " A5>; " " -+#(. #

- # -- # " * + . " ! . * "+ * + + ! =! * "+7 ! . 3 " " "+ "! - # "+" " =

* *++ * ! + * " . 7 .

! " . ) 3.(.0 . - ) + * . 33, 3 - .) (3 ( .) (::++( .( .)-( ./0-.))/3; 9+ < ( ( ;

=-.)

(3 )(4 9; -/ ;1(< 9/:.)+ <! &@

+ ! ! . %5 ("+. !&'%6! + " ! * . . = = " + + +"! " * #$3 + " # ! ( "* " " *+ .

/*! * + * + K ! "+ *H " "!* + * ""+

+ - + + ! " "" "! . * * .

+ 4 %'

') &'%6 " " . " ! " *

" * * " @$5 + +

%2 ') &'%6! " ! " " "" +. ! + " + = ! * * + - "+ * * +. "" "+ .+ * * " $+ . ."+ "! + +* *+.

* * **+" 3 "" "+ "! * * *. + . * . " " + ! * +" ?

* * ! " " "! "+"+ 9 ! + ! + C$%) +!+* . +

-. " " " " " + *+ . * /! . + * + 3 + " + C$%&> +" &5 " $7+ !" + "1"+

* * . 4 %6&$#! 4* !" " ! + - . " . *!. + . * .

+ " .

1 - +> " $6 &$)

+ 3 7+ $ $"!"* " "" +!+> *+ " "" . " " . " * . . * + * " + *= + ++. %'$%5* +

+ !." + + "" "

" " &A C$A # B + " ""+ 3 *!3 +. !# # .

. * *"+ . " + " $. "+ *.

# -"+. ++

+ ++ + "# . !7+ C$2! + * * " 3 * # * *03 &2 C$%'3 +. . *+ "+ " . . * ""+ 3 * * * " " 4 . * 3 " $7+ "+ . ++ * . +. * "+ ** "4

&6 + + C$%% 3 * "" * * " " + " + + ! " 4 ))&)! >"$#! 0 #

!0 . *"! " * "" -" "" *3 +. !# B!# * # . *"+! + . . -0B+. " ". + - = . . . > * . " "" " .

* ! * ;7 4 ;7 41%% (( ;7 41%& * " * * " " " A5$> 3 ; " " - "+"+ .& '' "" ".% %5 ! *. "" * * + . * + ++ "+ "

7 + -0B" ++ " .& )'1) '' * +. 0B+ " " - &8 - " " " )%%# # ##-#+ .

C$%A " *+##-* " .

> +!

. " * * + * " ;7 C)'1 * "" ". " +!++;7 "* " ++#B 3 +. )'

+ ! C$%@ 3 4 + ! 3 " * # + * * " *" +4 !. + .4 856&8&2@86 " + 4 ))&)!" 0 0#

"++" = ". . " . + * 4 @ -". .

?/* +3 " *!"! 0#

!0 . )% C$&' +!* !

* + (* ( 4* ! 0 . ++ .

" " * ;7 4;7 41%% (( ;7 41%& " " ;7 41%) " A5> ; " " . &N ) ! .)'+ * " ". * * .

)& C$&2 *! B"+! . !* * " + " + . ++ ":# < - . * !" . " .

" " *

- + ". * + )) - *. C$&6 7+ ! """ "+ +* . * * " . !" )@ -"+"+ * "+. ". *" . * " * + " ! "" . *.

*+ - + " "" "+ " " " + . * .

. * . " . * 3. "" . - 7 " * " ." + * . +" + " + "* + * .. * "

" * * + +$H *+ * . -" "+ "" * * "+ * * + * . 7 + ! + 7 * * . $ $ ! . + + + "" * +

+ + $ $ * *0( + !

" ! * ". + "+ K . + + +. + *

+"+ * 0 . + !+ . 3 " +" "K+

3 # &'

') &'%6! " * * * + *

" + ;7 M ;7 O + " *";7 "

" + ;7 M&'

') &'%6! * . $ $ + *+ ." + + + *. * *" +. + + ! ( . " ! " + " " " +. + + ! ( )5 -+ ;7 O &) ') &'%6 + + ;7 M! + * * " "" " * " * + . +. +. + "

" * B 4* ( ! ! "+* " -+ " * ;7 ! 4 (.

-.):14 3-& .

8-.)

( 4

7>!

)A -!7 * * ** *+ * " %2 ') &'%6 * @ * +" H * ""! - " %'A 3 ; "" . "7 !" * -. . " !." " . * """ . " + ." "+ " " " . " -" "+ "" " . . *" !!. 7 .

""! "!*" )2 - 7 # 1 0/<) (1.

1<( 53" &.(. - ()(1(3).1(, 8 & 87, " " " . " .

*# " "= - # .

* " + "++ "+ " "

!. "*"* 7 " + "++ . + - * *. .

. ! ! *+ . " ". " " "+ " )6 " " . " *+ &.(. -

(@(3.)( 53")(</1& 9),#&,""

"=. " .

*# !" !" * " *+ ( )( 53"&.(.-(1=( (,#&# &.(.-'3. 9(+53" 1)(00( 0(1,7&7 * + . . + !. .

3 ! 7

+!. +. + - '(A 1?)( 53"&.(.- ..(1(<)( , &>>7 " %'A **+ *# ! " "= * + ! "%2 " .

C *." + "" " )%)# #

7# " " " .. .. " *.* 7 * *" . "++ " + * " " .

+ )8 -+

"" +. "++ . ".

- # . * +. " -7 +. " +" " " . + ; " + * . . "! * *"+ + - . + " " + .

3 " 7 + .

. ! ""

*" *. " +

-! "" "+ "- # "+ * "" " + " * + - +7 +

"". . . +" - ."* " . " ! !" + " . * " " +

+. ! ! " . * * * " .

- # * *" ) 43.

9(.

-( ./0)(4 9; /+=:14 ! @'

- "+ " * .

" -" . * " ;7 # + ." $ " " * . + * $> - " +

$#"" +* :;7 4;7 41%%< - . " " * ! >

$;! " " ;7 0! .

#B *3 +. 3 * - " " ;7 !".

+ - *" &% 5"+ . %%"+ " %'

5"+!". - . " ;7 !" .

+ - = " +

++ ! ;7 B " " * + + . " "?" !>!0 .! . + + . "" .

* " @% - " 7+ C$&8

>! " " ?" ! " + "+ " * 2 " &'

'@ &'%6 * +"7+ ;7 O ;7 O1%

* ! ;7 & *;7 A!.

! ;7 A. ." !;7 A" . + ! " .

" .! " ;7 2! * ;7 2.! . "!;7 2" . * !;7 2 > " ;7 5! " ! . " ;7 )! !;7 @!- ;7 @.! * -.* " ! . ! * . $ !"." +;7 O13! .* " " - (4 + ! " = " @& C$)' ( G > " ?" ! 0 .! + " . ! ;7 )'1> && ') &'%6 + .* """ ." .

" ". " +" "" " - " + * && ') &'%6! ;7 )'1 " . " " * ! ! " "+ *+ -". .

7+ * !

. 7+ .

* " " )%%# # " """ *. ++. " . ! " + ** " . + * * " +.

3?+ . @) C$&@( +

! "?" !#! 0 .!" "+ +!;7 / + 7+ * *" " + * *" . " " " " . + +* " +! C$%) +!. K. -+ + " +. +" . + * " . " " - " $ D% ;

((;# 3- -;(0?

>?(L ;

(

-#;;-?0>?(L 3434-?4; 4(

34?034#33?4?4;

( 4(>?(L#?34#3(;

& #; -3?4 %# O '

5# ?4 B?C; B3 3 - 3(; ) 03; #G-

?0 3P; % 5# O '

5# # --;;( ?4 3 - #;; @ # B ;

?4 3 - 3;- B ; 3?4 #G- C?G4( 34(B; ;( )# O %# ?4 3 - (;B-?3( ; 3?4 #G- C?G4( 5# O %# ?4 3 - B?C; B -; B ;#-

> 3?4 %# O %# ?4 3 - ?GB(; #; -3?4 %# O '

5# ?4 B;0- 34 034 ; (3/ 3O #G- C?G4( %# O '

5# O'

5# ?4 # --;;( ?4 B;0- # GB 4(340 # GB ;

@@ ! * " " + *" * !" + + " " " - * 7+ * . ! + ! 4 + !. " " 7+ +

! . " 7+ - " ++* "! " . + + + 7+ ! " " ! " @5 -+ 3 * *?" !C$%% " ++

" * . * . ! " *. . +!" " ! + -! " "" * .

" ** !C$&' + " +" .

7+ * ! ".

" * ;7 4 ;7 41%% * + 3 * * ?" C$%A !##-;

* . 7+ * * * * " "

- ##-*"+ + #(!;7 -1% -##-*. + . * " +" . ". * " .

" "

+" *" " " . " . + " " ! ". + * # 7+ + " " "+ @2 - "+ " + . 7+ " . .

7 # "" + ." "+ "

. "!.. ."""

- # ." . + + . "!" " " .. - "+ " . * + . * " * ". ".

- # !* " "!+ . " "" " "+ "!+ " 7 " + " !. " . .

" !". ##-* - "+* *+ * . " - 7# 93)& 9)53"()(;1& 9)( .)13,> & 6B + " " . * + " " + . + "

@6 - + " " 7+ .

! " * ." * " $ 7+ .

"" "! *. 7+ $ $"! $ "

* * *"+ * * * +

" "* " + "+!"."+" * . *." "+ !" " + " + ! +" * " "! "+" + -"* " 7+ %6 %& &'%6! * + 8# 8+ " * " ++ + " $7+ !. *. ".

" ++ ; * ++" + * *+ " *.+ "! * . @8 3. " " + +. ') %& &'%6:;7 ($A<!" * * "!. *"+ * + " " ** . ! + ++ *+ 7+ $ $" " " - ! " . + " !

- 7# + * " *+ "

. " ." "+ " (*( ?/0(1C / ..(+53"&.(.- ..(1 1( 3)( ( .)1, B>&#7" "+ "" " "" " "" *"

" "+ " *"""++ " + ! 7# (../ (@( 53"&.(.-(0 +( /,6#&>> " ! " . 7 .

" " " " "

3 " " * +*. . ++ . +. . . + "++ "

+ ! ! .

. * " + .. D/( ./0- / 3)0 .!

5% ! " " "+ " " " . " + " ! ! "" "* " + " . . + "" ." *+ ( )) & 9)( .)1343"&.(.- / @(;,67&#>! $/*> " "7+ """ " ""++ ! "! + 7 + . ! * =! ." * "++ +

! "K "K. " -# *%2 5 " 5 * * 7+ *" K + 5&

$/*> "! &*(0=&)1(

( ( (43"&.(.

- ?(1 (.(<(, 7 & >8>! 7 # " * " # .

". + * ! 7# . " .

# * "" !/* *"" " . + " + + . " " . + 5) ( )(1( 43" 3: .1 - +

, 6 > & >8!

" " *2 %' . .! "". " +.

*# +.

$/*> " 7# - ** * +* *" "+ ". + "* 7 + " + " + " .

"+ * " " "* K "K 5@ ) "( ( C;

/+( 43"&.(.- )(1,6 8&B7#! * " )5@:)<# # * + " "* K "K! . " + * + +

""++ ." 3 # " " + + ! " " +" ."* * " " 7"

-! "". .

7# * " )5@:)< # # . *

% )( &)1 4(3 43" &.(. - ))(..

39(1), 1 (+ 7! $/* > " "++ + + * " " " )A)!)AA!)2A:&<:<!)22!&'% )'& " )2A 3# " A?#? " 3 "!"+"

" *. +. * -". " "+ " " " "" * * " + 3 " *+ &) " + " " "++ " . " " + ! ! . . * + . " * " + 5A (::/ 43" &.(. - ..(1 1( 3), & ! $/*> " 7# ! *+ + * ! "+ " " " . .

"++ + + . $+ + . " + + )' * "!+ " 3 ?(3) (.) & 9) C?(++/ & 9)43" ) &.(.- )(1<)( , >&>! + %@ * !

. + * "&A *

" " "+ "! " " MRC-12021 " * * " * + + " + CRA-D-223-2021 .

" * " " + + + + "&"&'% % ""#

C *1 L C . L