High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/292/1999disposed of

New India Ass. Co. v. Swaran Singh And Others

2019-05-16Mr. Justice Fateh Deep Singh8 pages

! "

# $% &'()#*+*, -) )./ ,, (

""#$""##%&' "(

)*& !

" +,-# !

". /. 0

". /. 1 0

)./ ,, (0/#0

( ""# ##2

3-,( ""#- "& 4!- ! ""#&"",(

! &# ""#$""## &"# -

,)-,(&#"" ""###-5

3## ""#2# & ,2 6(# #"#

11) ( 7 -## " ""# # 8& #- !#! )& 9-!

#( . '&# ""##-&# #( ""# ," # 2 7,&#&. 1"2 !2#" 2 !(2& & "( #( 2 #,#( - # '&# ""## & "(-&#2& & "(: ;# '#

<#/=>10 #' '#

=2#7"

<"&-: ,(;# '

"",('&&,"#="# +2!

2!#"!## & " #' #!(. 3 -& &+2- &+2 42&-! 7,&#2#(,()2 #',

=2#7"

<"&

#(,&&# (2& 7"

4 &2&2###

. 3 3 -& ="#+2 -# ,(&(<#& & 2

7,&#&. 1#,#, '&# # -&## ! 2 - !( & & "( & &, 9-! & "( #( " " # - 6 !2&, ,(&# & "( #!: " -

##-

7&"!&-.- 4 & ' "( ; " . 1 4-"#,(". 1 ="#+2 " . !

2,&- #2!#!2# 7"!"# ": =>*#+2 ## '& +@+<) #+<&2 *"&# 9 !2# ="#+2- # #222 8& =>1;# '#

<#""(#.

1 !2#

="#+2--&<"&! # . 3 3 - - &"

72& + *"& ! #&# "

- # ' '#

=2# 7"

<"& - - : ,(;#'

!2#!(. 3 - & ,( =2# 7"

<"& !& ="#+2 ! (!2#-& !& &+2 4-&&, ,(# &# " . 1 !2 # ( ---,( 7"

<# ,(=>1 -!2# " . &##(: 2 A:

=$1 #' 4 ( 2& # &# ". 1 #' '# 2##( :

- 7"

- & # & +2 - # - ;# '# =>1 : -!2 #-&<"& 9" ( ;2&(- &!2# 4, =2# 7"

<"& - #( &( - - # & !2# ! !2#

="#+2-!"&

# #222 # 7,&# 4 , !2# # ,"# #' '#

, !2 #

="#+2- !2# +

*"& ! #&# " # &"

! 4 &##6

&), 9( 92 '& # -"#2 !2#2 -,( "&( -&# &!# ( &"#(!# (&("! &## 6 # # - 2 !2 # !##( - -## , !#!2# , #-#-&( + *"& !&, "# ="#+2 ". -#2

2!2#! -- -##, !#!2# ,& "( 4!2! ( &2 &#2& ,(#'&# " 6& &,! ,"! ="#+2 ". -#2

2!2# 7 "" #-#-+!B/&"0## ,""#,# "

! 9B,#+&" '& 4 , - &##6+ !B - ##2 - ""! - 2 !2 # - !##(

- "#(,

$%& !'

4!2&2"( #' """,(;#'

2 *#+2 />0 ## '&*"&#-: "!2# ="#+2!#,# # #228& 77,&# " - ,=2#7"

<"&-#(&(- -#&!2# !2# ="#+2- !"& # #222 # 7,&# & #, !2# #,"# #' '# ,!2# ="#+2- 77,&# # "" &2 ,#2 & "(,##",( !-!#

! - ,&" #( &&,#2"&"( #&""#( "&# ,# & "(

(! ;2&( 4 : , )&2 9B,#+&" '&

() #

*+,$- +.

42!& , "& "( !2 # ,( 2 ,:& 7

2&22! &( &"#!2#-2##(& !& ="# +2,("&#;2&( -&,(

=2#7"

<"& 4!-

2 7,&# :

)&#&(#,#,) + #' '#

=2#7"

<"& , ,( &( 9 (,) #(,& -- 2

&(#! - ##. 3 -& &+2

#& (2& 7"

7 !&,(!&& # ' '#

=2#7"

<"& 7 2 #' '#

=2#7"

<"&,&"&"#-

#& &"&2#!2#-## & ( # ' #( , # # "&",&,(;2&( <"&-&##( & !& ="#+2 & -# # -&#& #",(="#+2 7, !& !# " ="#+2""-,: (,( -( : "&&#(#,&#" ,(

9-! : #-

"#" -&,(7"&( <#& , !2#-111

9 &22!2#-& <"&-#( - <# 9 (

2 # ,# -

<#-""(#. 111

1 !2# ="#+2--& <"&!+ . 3 3 --&"

4 ""="#+2 -#-&,( &(<"& ##(-#!2# 7,&## & "("!8& !2# 4!- ,! 4 & "(="#+2-#2!#!2# &2&#( !#2 &"#( &2 &+ /0 D# 33 7,2 & "(#!2 !( 2& "( "# 4!- -,&,! ""# "#(##-& "(##!2 !( 2& "( "# 2 )./ ,, (3 +!4)

6 , >" 2$ E$. >",# E$.