M/S Happy Forgings P.Ltd.Ludhiana v. Commissioner Central Excise Chd.

   
   
 

 !

"#$ %$&'(')* +,

-


           

     
 * ./ 0
0 / ./ 0
 00  1$($)#* 1 $$2"342#"5%6&"#$ 1#7$2$#'#')$1 1)(748")
721"5%6&"#$ 1#7$1$(2)%$)#(  "9$(7')%": 7$;1'$6")&$ #7$2$#'#')$1'(#7"##74;7'#<"($)#'#:$%# =$)$ 8%6"#&1$%'#)241&7"($ #1">&"(#');4($%')#7$21&$((

8")4 "&#41$ #')>2<%$15')#$18(  &'1&4:"1

?-@ %"#$%

-57<$6$15#7$("8$<"(<1);:>%$)'$%#'# 7$  (4=8'((')  '(  #7"#  ')  &#=$1?6$8=$15  ,5  #7$ 2$#'#')$1241&7"($%#1">&"(#');"(&"2'#":;%()#$18( #7$"

1$("'% &'1&4:"15'#<"($)#'#:$%#8%6"#&1$%'#"(2$14:$A,B #7$
$)#1":

C&'($4:$(5  

1(71#5.#7$4:$(.!7$%$2"1#8$)#'((4$%(7< &"4($)#'&$) A D212(');#%$)>#7$8%6"#&1$%'#E'%$1%$1 %"#$%+  D5(('(#")#
88'((')$15
$)#1":C&'($5/4%7'")"%$)'$% 8%6"#&1$%'###7$2$#'#')$1<$6$15')"22$":5#7$1%$12"(($%=>#7$ (('(#")#
88'((')$1<"( ($# "('%$=>#7$
88'((')$1 22$":(!5

 
$)#1":C&'($
4(#8(5
7")%';"17) +D 5<7':$1$:>');42) ")$"1:'$1%$&'(') #7$
4(#8(5C&'($:%
)#1:!22$::"#$ 1'=4)":5$< $:7'

1(71#5.#7$1'=4)":.!)#7$'((4$7$%$2"1#8$)# 21$ $11$%"22$":=$ 1$#7$1'=4)":5<7'&7<"("::<$%6'%$1%$1%"#$%

A+

7$2$#'#')$1"##7"#(#";$&4:%)#1$ $1##7$&'1&4:"1'((4$% =>#7$%$2"1#8$)#$)#'#:');'###7$=$)$ 8%6"#&1$%'#)241&7"($

#1">&"(#');88$%'"#$:>51$&#'

'&"#')"22:'&"#')<"( ':$%5<7'&7<"( 1$9$&#$%6'%$1%$1%"#$%D

=>#7$1'=4)":7:%');#7"##7$1$'() 8'(#"3$  "22"1$)#  )  1$&1%  $  41#7$1  (4=8'##$%  #7"#  $6$)  1  #7$ (4=($F4$)# 2$1'%5 #7$1'=4)":  "::<$% 8%6"#  &1$%'#  ) #1"> &"(#'); 241&7"($%=>#7$2$#'#')$16'%$1%$1%"#$%,+

5<7':$1$:>');42) &'1&4:"1   

?-@  %"#$% 

-  )&$  #7$  &:"'8   #7$ 2$#'#')$1  '(  (F4"1$:>  &6$1$%  ')  #$18(    #7$  &'1&4:"1  '((4$%  =>  #7$ %$2"1#8$)#5#7$2$#'#')$1(74:%)#=$%$)'$%#7$=$)$ '##7$1$  $1$:> =$&"4($7$7"%)#=$$)"=:$#&'#$#7$&'1&4:"1"##7$1$:$6")##'8$5<7$) #7$"22$":<"(7$"1%5#74;7'#<"(#7$%4#> #7$&4)($:"22$"1'); 1 #7$%$2"1#8$)##7"6$21%4&$%#7$("8$5#7$2$#'#')$1&4:%)#=$ %$)'$%#7$=$)$ '#"%8'(('=:$#'#"#7$15#7$%$2"1#8$)#(74:%)#7"6$ 21$ $11$%  #7$  "22$":  ";"')(#  #7$  1%$1  2"(($%  =>  #7$  '1(#  22$::"#$ 4#71'#>)&$#7$&:"'8 #7$2$#'#')$1<"(')&)()")&$<'#7#7$ &'1&4:"1'((4$%=>#7$%$2"1#8$)# )#7$#7$17")%5:$"1)$%&4)($: 1#7$1$(2)%$)#(%'%)# %'(24#$#7$ "&##7"##7$2$#'#')$1'($)#'#:$%#=$)$ 8%6"#&1$%'#') #$18(     &'1&4:"1   

?-@  %"#$% 

-5  7<$6$15  7$ (4=8'##$%#7"##7$&'1&4:"17"6');)# =$$)=14;7###7$)#'&$ #7$ 1'=4)":"##7$#'8$ 7$"1'); #7$"22$":5#7$=$)$ '#<"()#"%8'(('=:$

+ ##7$2$#'#')$1 $"1%:$"1)$%&4)($: 1#7$2"1#'$(")%2$14($%#7$2"2$1 =3 7$="('& "&#(5<7'&7"1$)#')%'(24#$"1$#7"##7$2$#'#')$1 241&7"($%#1">&"(#');#'($)#'#:$%#8%6"#&1$%'#)#7$%4#>2"'%) 241&7"($#7$1$ ')#$18( 4:$A,B #7$4:$(1$"%<'#7&'1&4:"1

?-@%"#$%

-)'#'"::>5#7$%$2"1#8$)#'((4$%(7< &"4($)#'&$%"#$% A D##7$2$#'#')$1212(');#%$)>#7$8%6"# &1$%'#>2"((');#7$1%$15#7$(('(#")#
88'((')$15
$)#1":C&'($5 /4%7'")"5%$)'$%#7"#=$)$ '###7$2$#'#')$17'(<"(%$(2'#$#7$ "&# #7"##7$%$2"1#8$)#7"%":1$"%>'((4$%#7$&'1&4:"1&:"1' >');#7$2('#') #7"#8%6"#&1$%'#<"("6"':"=:$)#1">&"(#');74;7#7$
88'((')$1

22$":(!5 
$)#1":  C&'($   
4(#8(  "&&$2#$%  #7$  &)#$)#')    #7$ 2$#'#')$15=4#";"')%$(2'#$$C'(#$)&$ #7$&'1&4:"1 #7$%$2"1#8$)#5#7$ 1%$1<"('824;)$%=>#7$%$2"1#8$)#=$ 1$#7$1'=4)":5<7"&&$2#$% #7$"22$": ':$%=>#7$%$2"1#8$)# )&$'#'()#')%'(24#$#7"##7$ 2$#'#')$1'($)#'#:$%##7$=$)$ #7$8%6"#&1$%'#)#7$$:';'=:$ &"2'#":;%(5)"8$:>5#1">&"(#');')#7$21$($)#&"($5"(<"(&:"1' '$%$6$) =>  #7$  %$2"1#8$)#  =>  '((4');   &'1&4:"1   

?-@  %"#$%

-5#7$%$)'":#7$1$ ##7$2$#'#')$1'(##"::>'::$;":6$)' #7$ 2$#'#')$17"% "':$%#1$ $1##7$&'1&4:"1"##7$#'8$ 7$"1'); #7$ "22$":=$ 1$#7$1'=4)":5') "&#5'#<"(#7$%4#> #7$%$2"1#8$)#'#($:

# 7"6$#"3$)&"1$ #7$&'1&4:"1")%)#')%4:;$")>2"1#>')4))$&$(("1> :'#';"#')5"($6$)#7$ "&#((4;;$(##7"#6$1>')'#'"#') #7$21&$$%');( ";"')(##7$2$#'#')$1#%$)>#7$=$)$ 8%6"#&1$%'#<"("

#$1#7$ &'1&4:"17"%":1$"%>=$$)'((4$%5<7'&7$)#'#:$%#7$2$#'#')$1##7$=$)$ '#  8%6"#&1$%'#6$)'

#7"#<"((5(#'::<7$)#7$8"##$1<"(";"')

  =14;7###7$)#'&$ #7$1'=4)":=>#7$2$#'#')$1=> ':');1$&#'

'&"#') "22:'&"#')5)$&$(("1>1$&#'

'&"#')(74:%7"6$=$$)8"%$=>#7$1'=4)": ')#7$ "&#(")%&'1&48(#")&$( #7$&"($#'(":(" "&##7"#$6$) 1#7$ (4=($F4$)#2$1'%5#7$2$#'#')$1<"("::<$%8%6"#&1$%'#)#7$("8$ ;%()#7$="('( #7$&:"1'

'&"#')'((4$%6'%$&'1&4:"1

?-@ %"#$%

- 1#7$"

1$("'%1$"()(5 #7$<1'#2$#'#')'("::<$%7$ 1%$1(2"(($%=>#7$1'=4)":"1$($#"('%$7$2$#'#')$1'(7$:%$)#'#:$%# =$)$ 8%6"#&1$%'#)#1">&"(#');

"9$(7')%":!

4%;$  "1')%$10');70'%74!

4%;$

+,

-

$ $1#$21#$1!